- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The manuscript proposes 1Step-WAM, which transforms multi-step action denoising into a single forward pass, thereby achieving significant inference speedup.
Critical strengths
It is valuable to consider to improve the efficiency of world-action models.
Critical weaknesses
- The authors claim: We find that when the visual observation, language instruction, and robot state are fixed, the target action is nearly invariant to the initial noise used for generation. While the manuscript provides some subsequent verification, the experimental evidence lacks sufficient depth, and the visualizations are not intuitive enough to convincingly support this crucial hypothesis. A more rigorous study and clearer qualitative illustrations are needed to solidify this theoretical foundation.
- The related work section is neither sufficiently comprehensive nor well-organized.
- Chapter 3 is more appropriate for an appendix.
- Figure 2, which is essential for understanding the proposed framework, is overly complex and difficult to interpret.
Questions for authors
please see weaknesses.
4 comments
Response to Reviewer SE19 (2/2)
Concern 2: The Related Work section is neither sufficiently comprehensive nor well-organized.
To address this concern, we have further expanded and reorganized the Related Work section in a more structured form, and incorporating additional representative methods and clarifying their connections to our work.
For world action models. Beyond providing more detailed descriptions of Fast-WAM, GigaWorld-Policy, ImageWAM, and Kairos, we have added discussions of other representative WAMs, including LingBot-VA, DreamZero, and Motus.
For Diffusion Distillation. We have expanded the discussion of diffusion and flow-based policy acceleration methods by including FlowPolicy and Efficient-WAM, alongside existing approaches such as Consistency Policy, OneDP, One-Step Flow Policy, and SnapFlow.
Concern 3: Chapter 3 is more appropriate for an appendix.
We understand the reviewer's concern that the original Chapter 3 contains mathematical derivations that may interrupt the overall presentation.
However, we believe that its core content is important to retain in the main paper, as it establishes the motivation behind our central design choice. Specifically, our goal is to reduce multi-step action denoising in pretrained WAMs to a single forward pass. Chapter 3 provides an explanation for why the denoising trajectory can be approximately linear under a low-variance assumption. This analysis motivates using the first-step velocity as a starting point for estimating the final action, which directly leads to our velocity calibration module. Without this discussion, the motivation for our one-step formulation and the design of the calibration module would be less clear to readers.
To address the reviewer's concern regarding the presentation, we have substantially shortened Chapter 3 by removing intermediate mathematical derivations and retaining only the key empirical observation, theoretical insights, and their implications for our method. The detailed mathematical derivations have been moved to the Appendix. We believe this revision improves the readability of the main paper while preserving the essential motivation and rationale of our approach.
Concern 4: Figure 2 is overly complex and difficult to interpret.
We have therefore redesigned Figure 2 to provide a clearer illustration of the three key components of 1Step-WAM:
- Lightweight Velocity Calibration. We have explicitly illustrated the newly introduced calibration head and its role in correcting the initial velocity prediction. Specifically, the calibration head predicts a velocity residual , which is added to the initial velocity to obtain the calibrated velocity . The resulting one-step endpoint action is then supervised by the multi-step teacher endpoint through an MSE objective. This makes the calibration mechanism and its training objective much easier to understand.
- Bandwidth-Constrained Action Decoding. We have redesigned this component to explicitly illustrate the temporal DCT/iDCT operations and frequency-domain truncation. The revised figure shows the action trajectory, its frequency representation, and the process of retaining the first frequency modes while discarding higher-frequency components. We also include an intuitive frequency-spectrum illustration to explain the underlying motivation: when noise exceeds the corresponding action signal in a frequency mode, retaining that mode may introduce more prediction error than discarding it. This provides a clearer explanation of how bandwidth-constrained decoding suppresses prediction errors while preserving the dominant low-frequency action components.
We sincerely thank the reviewer again for these constructive comments. The additional experiments, expanded Related Work, streamlined theoretical presentation and redesigned Figure 2 have helped us improve the empirical support, clarity, and accessibility of the manuscript.
Responses
Thanks for the detailed answers! My concerns have been resolved, so I'm happy to update my rating.
Thank you so much for your thoughtful feedback and for reconsidering your rating! We truly appreciate your time and constructive suggestions. Your feedback has helped us improve our work, and we are very grateful for your support!
Response to Reviewer SE19 (1/2)
To address this concern, we conduct additional experiments on three representative RoboTwin tasks: Adjust Bottle (grabbing and raising a bottle with a red screw cap), Click Bell (pressing the top of a bell), and Move Playing Card Away (moving playing cards to the side). For each task, we place the target objects at the center of the dual-arm workspace, where both the left and right arms has the same possibility to independently accomplish the task, providing two potential execution modes under identical task configurations. We fix the visual observation, language instruction, and robot state, and independently sample 512 initial noise seeds to generate action trajectories using the original multi-step teacher. This setting allows us to directly investigate whether different initial noises lead to different manipulation strategies under identical conditioning inputs.
Here we report the percentage of trajectories using each arm for each task.The results demonstrate a strong concentration around a dominant execution mode across all three tasks:
To make these findings easier to verify, we have added trajectory visualizations from both front and top-down views in the newly added Appendix 7.2 (Figure 6). By visualizing trajectories generated from 512 independently sampled noise seeds, readers can directly observe how the generated trajectories concentrate around the same manipulation strategy, despite the availability of alternative execution modes. These results provide additional empirical evidence that, under the tested configurations and fixed conditioning inputs, changing the initial noise rarely changes the selected manipulation strategy.
Our observations are also consistent with recent findings in diffusion-based robot policies. In particular, Immiscible Diffusion Policy [1] systematically identifies action-modality collapse in vanilla diffusion policies, showing that they can generate actions concentrated in a single modality even when the training demonstrations are perfectly balanced across multiple modalities. Moreover, under a fixed observation, different initial noise samples often lead to the same execution strategy, indicating that the learned policy can become largely insensitive to initial noise. The authors further demonstrate that this collapse is associated with insufficient preservation of modality-specific noise-to-action mappings, and that explicitly organizing action-noise assignments can substantially recover multimodal action generation. These findings provide complementary evidence that the relationship between initial noise and generated action modalities is not necessarily preserved in learned diffusion policies.
We have incorporated the additional experimental setup, trajectory visualizations, empirical observations, and discussion into the newly added Appendix 7.2 (Mode Collapse Analysis).
[1] Zhang, Xiao, et al. "Immiscible Diffusion Policy: Preserving Multimodal Robot Actions through Label-Free Noise Assignment." arXiv preprint arXiv:2610.09369 (2026).