acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Causal Identification of Endogenous Feedback Amplification in Self-Evolving Agent Skills

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Large language model agents convert execution trajectories into persistent skills, creating an endogenous loop in which the current skill shapes the evidence that drives its subsequent evolution. Following a controlled skill shift, a single evolving run cannot distinguish among static retention, repeated evidence exposure, stochastic drift, and amplification through the skill-to-trajectory-to-skill pathway. We introduce Paired Counterfactual Skill Dynamics (PCSD), a causal framework that identifies this endogenous feedback effect. PCSD synchronizes two branches: a closed-loop branch, in which each updated skill generates evidence for its successor, and an open-loop shadow branch, in which the initially shifted skill is held fixed and always generates evolution evidence, while updated shadow skills are evaluated but cannot influence subsequent trajectories. The paired difference isolates the effect mediated by skill-induced changes in trajectory distributions while holding the initial shift, task stream, update budget, and evolver calls fixed. Information-matched replay distinguishes feedback from equivalent evidence exposure, while a frozen-skill branch estimates generation drift and measurement noise. PCSD also decomposes local loop gain into behavioral and evolution responses. We vary displacement, update intensity, history window, deployment policy, and clean-data anchoring to characterize stability boundaries, hysteresis, recovery, and path dependence. Deterministic probes, paired controls, and explicit rejection criteria enable evaluation across isolated task domains and structurally distinct evolution regimes while separating endogenous amplification from ordinary retention and finite-horizon variation.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
Large Language Model Agents, Skill Evolution, Endogenous Feedback

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 25%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.75 over 4 reviews, above 25% of the others.
Reviewer_32uoOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper try to study endogenous feedback amplification in self-evolving LLM Agents, exploring whether initial skill behavioral biases are recursively reinforced via the “skill-execution-skill update” closed loop and separating this effect from static retention, repeated evidence exposure, and random drift. We propose Paired Counterfactual Skill Dynamics (PCSD), a causal evaluation framework with four paired experimental setups: closed-loop, open-loop, replay, and frozen baselines. Despite its rigorous counterfactual design, the work overclaims on stability, hysteresis and causal mediation, and relies on synthetic canary tasks with limited external validity. Focusing contributions on finite-horizon causal effects would strengthen its argument.

Critical strengths

S1. The research question is well-formulated. The paper targets endogenous feedback amplification in self-evolving Agents and seeks to disentangle static retention of initial skill drift from trajectory-driven progressive reinforcement. The research objective is concrete.

S2. The controlled experimental design is sound. Four arms — Closed-loop, Open-loop, Replay, and Frozen — are deployed to examine the effects of feedback closure, fixed evidence sources, repeated evidence exposure, and static retention, respectively. Compared with a single evolving trajectory, this design facilitates separation of contributions from distinct factors.

S3. Experimental variables are systematically controlled. All arms share identical initial perturbations, task sequences, environment snapshots, and update budgets, mitigating confounding effects from task heterogeneity and computational resource disparities.

Critical weaknesses

W1: (Section 3.3,Lines 294–298; Section 4.4,Lines 428–439) The definition of Local Loop Gain is insufficient to support conclusions on stability. The local empirical loop gain Gt=BtEtG_t=B_tE_t yields Δzt+1≈GtΔzt\Delta z_{t+1}\approx G_t\Delta z_t. A value Gt<1G_t<1 indicates local contraction, whereas Gt>1G_t>1 indicates local amplification along the measured coordinate. Per the definition provided in the paper, Bt=ΔqtΔzt, Et=Δzt+1ΔqtB_t=\frac{\Delta q_t}{\Delta z_t},\ E_t=\frac{\Delta z_{t+1}}{\Delta q_t}, which gives Gt=BtEt=Δzt+1ΔztG_t=B_tE_t=\frac{\Delta z_{t+1}}{\Delta z_t}. If both responses are evaluated using the same finite-difference pair, the Δqt\Delta q_t term in this factorization cancels out directly. This implies that the product alone does not demonstrate independent identification of the behavioral response and evolution response mechanisms. For signed scalar perturbations, the contraction condition should generally be ∣Gt∣<1|G_t|<1, rather than the simple condition Gt<1G_t<1. Since ztz_t is merely a scalar observation of the high-dimensional skill state, one cannot infer the dynamical stability of the full system from this quantity. The authors' conclusions regarding loop gain, local amplification, and the stability boundary require more rigorous definitions and derivations.

W2: The causal identification scope of the Closed–Open comparison suffers from overclaiming (Page 2, Lines 91–99; Page 6, Lines 305–315). This comparison can estimate the aggregate causal effect of the updated skill on subsequent evidence generation. However, as evolution proceeds, the skill states, trajectory distributions, historical evidence, and their interactions with the updater diverge between the two groups. Consequently, the final Closed–Open contrast cannot further disentangle the independent contributions of individual intermediate mechanisms. The authors’ claim that this design can ``isolate the causal pathway'' may exceed the identification bounds supported by the experiment. A more precise statement would be that the method identifies the aggregate effect of the closed-loop feedback mechanism, rather than enabling independent causal identification of its internal mediating pathways.

W3: In Section 4.3 (Lines 410–414), the paper claims that the independently evaluated skill-state metric mediates 61% (95% CI: 45%–75%) of the branching effect. However, it does not adequately specify the precise definition and measurement of this mediator, the estimation procedure for causal mediation effects, nor the underlying identification assumptions. Given the dynamic dependencies and potential time-varying confounding among skill states, trajectory evidence, and subsequent updates, statistical association alone is insufficient to sustain a definitive causal mediation interpretation. Accordingly, the 61% estimate lacks sufficient methodological grounding; its reproducibility and causal interpretation are questionable, constituting a potential overclaim.

W4: The paper’s Replay comparison only matches task domain, trajectory count, trajectory length, non-Canary outcomes, and marginal Canary frequencies (Page 5, Lines 253–261; Page 16, Lines 816–822), yet it fails to adequately control for the semantic content, joint distribution, temporal ordering, and historical dependence of evidence. Since the LLM Evolver updates skills based on full natural-language trajectories rather than merely Canary occurrence frequencies, the failure of the Replay setup to reproduce closed-loop effects is insufficient to rule out alternative explanations such as differences in evidence structure or temporal sequence. The existing experiments only demonstrate that evidence exposure matched on these limited statistical properties cannot replicate the closed-loop effect, and they do not rigorously establish that the effect arises entirely from the endogenous feedback mechanism.

Questions for authors

My primary concerns are W1–W3.

Reviewer_yNnvOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper asks whether a self-evolving agent can amplify a small change in its skill: the changed skill produces different trajectories, and those trajectories push the next update further in the same direction. To test this, their framework PCSD runs two paired branches from the same shifted skill. In the closed loop, each new skill generates the data for its own next update. In the open loop, the original shifted skill always generates the data. The gap between the two measures the feedback effect. Experiments use three synthetic tasks, a Llama-3.1-8B executor, and a Qwen2.5-14B evolver. The closed loop reaches a 42.1% canary rate vs. 24.7% for the open loop (log-odds effect 0.83), and the gap shrinks with longer history, clean data, and gated updates.

Critical strengths

S1. The paired closed/open-loop design is a simple and clean way to separate "the agent keeps the initial change" from "the agent reinforces the change through its own data." It can be reused for other self-evolving systems.

S2. The controls (replay, frozen skill, shuffled labels, no canary) cover the obvious alternative explanations, at least by design.

Critical weaknesses

W1. Limited realism and unclear significance.

The setting is narrow: three synthetic tasks, small open models (7–8B executors, 14B at most for the evolver), and the authors' own update pipelines. The canary label has no cost, so nothing pushes back against the drift, which makes this the easiest case for amplification. Table 7 suggests the effect grows with stronger evolvers, so results with frontier models, real agent harnesses, and real tasks are needed. The paper does not explain how this differs from known drift effects: feedback loops that amplify bias [1], in-context reward hacking [2], error propagation in agent memory [3], context collapse from repeated rewriting [4], and hallucination snowballing [5]. Because the canary is harmless by design, no real harm is shown. The mitigations (keep longer history, mix in clean data) are already known from model-collapse work [6].

W2. Soundness and reproducibility.

Several numbers disagree across tables and several quantities that the text says are defined in the appendix are missing (Q2). The supplementary code is a small NumPy simulation with no LLM, and its README says it produces "Demo results, not the paper's experimental results." It also differs from the paper's design: the open and replay branches use different evolver settings from the closed branch (src/baseline.py), and replay data is generated from the initial skill instead of being matched to the closed loop (src/pipeline.py). The full parameter sweep would take roughly 160k GPU-hours or more, i.e., over two years on the single 8×A100 node described(Q3).

As a result, I cannot tell whether the reported results support the claims.

References

[1] Taori and Hashimoto. Data Feedback Loops: Model-driven Amplification of Dataset Biases. ICML 2023.

[2] Pan et al. Feedback Loops With Language Models Drive In-Context Reward Hacking. ICML 2024.

[3] Xiong et al. How Memory Management Impacts LLM Agents: An Empirical Study of Experience-Following Behavior. arXiv:2505.16067, 2025.

[4] Zhang et al. Agentic Context Engineering: Evolving Contexts for Self-Improving Language Models. arXiv:2510.04618, 2025.

[5] Zhang et al. How Language Model Hallucinations Can Snowball. ICML 2024.

[6] Gerstgrasser M, Schaeffer R, Dey A, et al. Is model collapse inevitable? breaking the curse of recursion by accumulating real and synthetic data[J]. arXiv preprint arXiv:2404.01413, 2024.

Questions for authors

Q1. How exactly is the replay data built? App. B.2 says it matches the closed loop's canary rate, but the code builds it from the initial skill. Also, answer-only evidence (no rationales) keeps about half the effect (0.41), while replay keeps almost none (0.15). What does replay lack that the closed loop has?

Q2. Can you please explain on some of the inconsistent or missing details? (i) Which history policy, update interval, and edit budget give the main 42.1% result? It does not appear in Table 3. (ii) Replay is 23.5% in Table 1 but 27.4% in Table 5. (iii) "Updated skill not deployed" (Table 5) looks identical to the open loop. What is it? (iv) Which models are "small/medium/large" in Table 7? (v) The hysteresis area, "effective update intensity," the boundary models, the 61% mediation analysis, and the six preregistered hypotheses are not defined. Where is the preregistration?

Q3. Can you release the code that produced Tables 1–10, and explain why the supplementary simulator differs from the paper's design? The sweep in App. B.3 has 1,152 configurations; at 20 seeds and 7–11 GPU-hours each, that is 160k–250k GPU-hours. What was actually run?

Q4. (Suggestion for future work) The paper would be much stronger if it (a) tested frontier models, released skill-evolution systems, and real benchmarks (e.g., τ-bench, SWE-bench); (b) made the drifted behavior slightly costly, so that the verifier pushes back; and (c) showed one case where amplification causes real harm that ordinary drift would not.

Reviewer_ftPbOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

I found the paper very difficult to follow, but as I understood it: the paper asks whether agents which update their own natural language skills can amplify specific behaviors, even if these behaviors have no benefit. To test this hypothesis, they include a canary label that has no semantics, but may be reinforced by the model. They compare learning using a closed loop (where the skill evolves based on the agents trajectories) and an open loop (where a shadow skill is update, but not used to generate trajectories). They demonstrate that the closed loop causes the canary behavior to be reinforced significantly more due to learning from its own trajectories.

Critical strengths

The proposed method causally demonstrates that feedback loops are cause certain behaviours to be reinforced in LLMs, even if they do not have a practical benefit. To my knowledge, this question has not been answered before, and the experimental setup here is original and interesting.

The authors pre-registered their hypothesis, and appear to include enough details to reproduce their results.

Critical weaknesses

I found the presentation of the paper very difficult to follow, and it took me some effort to understand what problem they were even trying to solve. Adding a motivating example might help.

The experiments are on a small set of artificial synthetic tasks. It would be more convincing to show a more realistic setting where this problem happens.

Questions for authors

None

Reviewer_hrnMOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper identifies a loop feedback problem of self-evolving LLM Agents skills. It propose a framework called "Paired Counterfactual Skill Dynamics (PCSD)" to isolate the change in trajectory being affected by skill. The experiments tries to quantitatively analysis the loop feedback effect with the proposed framework.

Critical strengths

This paper identifies a problem that during the self-evolving process of LLM agents, the feedback of evolved skill into next turn of evolution introduces a loop that might amplify existing biases. I think this is an important and interesting research question, and deserves a careful investigation.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The authors claim that they developed a framework to study the dynamics of skills of self-evolving agents. But the main results only compares the difference in "canary rates" with four settings. I am expecting how "canary rates" changes with the varying of some variables (e.g. the turn of self-evolvement, etc...). So I think the experiment design does not match the core claim.

  2. The evaluation dataset is not specified. The main text does not illustrate any the content and number of the dataset the research based on. An introduction of the dataset can be found in the appendix, but still not make clear how the dataset is generated, nor any example of the dataset. So I can not examine whether the experimental setting is appropriate. I am also expecting the use of commonly applied dataset of agentic tasks, e.g. SWE-Bench, not only some generated dataset.

  3. The experimental results are very limited. The main text only show one table and one figure of results, the table and figure seems conveying the same group of results. Some additional experimental results can be find in the appendix, but non of them is linked with the main text. So I can not examine the completeness of the experiment design and experiment results.

  4. The paper is difficult to read. Some of the word and sentence structure is hard to understand. E.g. "endogenous loop", I can not find exact match on google search engine of this word. The author noted that AI tools are only used for improve the writing, it seems this process lead to many AI-like words and sentences.

Questions for authors

None

Comments on the paper

2 comments
Reviewer_yNnvOpenReview ↗

Concern about changes to the submission record after review

I reviewed the 41-page manuscript “Causal Identification of Endogenous Feedback Amplification in Self-Evolving Agent Skills.” When I checked the forum on November 18, I found that the submission had been withdrawn, the title had been shortened to “Causal Identification of,” and the abstract consisted of just three words: “Large language model.” The PDF now contains a single page stating “The content is current not available.”

All four reviews remain public, including questions about how the reported experimental results were obtained. Readers following those reviews can no longer examine the manuscript through the forum’s PDF link.

After noticing these changes, I then checked all 18 withdrawn submissions I found that list the same two co-authors. In 15 of the 18, the PDF contained only the same one-sentence notice. The other three still linked to full-length manuscripts. I ask the Program Chairs to preserve the version histories and investigate when these files changed, who made the changes, and whether this pattern violated conference policy.

We thank the reviewer for the careful examination and constructive comments. We appreciate the concerns raised in the manuscript and will carefully address them in the future version. We reviewed the ICLR policies ( https://iclr.cc/Conferences/2026/AuthorGuide ) but could not find any provision that specifically restricts revisions to, or replacement of, a submission. Therefore, it may be premature to conclude that the changes themselves violated an explicit conference rule. Nevertheless, we fully respect the Program Chairs' decision.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.