- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
Unlike usual superresolution (SR) the proposed method claims to ake care of inhomogeneous (space varying ) blurring also. Hence they try to estimate the local departure in HR restored image and diffusion is controlled accordingly with the help of LoRA.
Critical strengths
It is worthwhile to explore how to take care of space varying blur during image SR. Use of orthogonality is also a good attempt. There is some marginal increase in the SOTA.
Critical weaknesses
I am quite disheartened at the experiments (although there are many) because the data set did not seem to have any space varying blur (at least not noticeable). Then how do claim that you have solved the problem if not experimented on the proper data. Your ablation studies should show the benefit. Currently it does not.
The orthogonality is enforced through a low rank SVD-based approximation at each step of iteration. This is huge amount of computation. Remember SVD is O(N^3) computation. I do not see any attempt to improve or computational comparison for the computation. There are classical techniques like rank-1 update etc which can speed it up.
I do not understand what is zoomed HR image for comparison. If you zoom it up, it will be a low pass one and will be inferior. Your comparison should be with the HR.
Novelty is quite low in terms of the methodology being proposed.
Questions for authors
See above.
Additionally, it will be good to see how does the SR performance degrade with increasing magnification. I do not see any experiment or ablation studies.