- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Gradient Descent Quantum Lyapunov Control (GD-QLC) which is a feedback based QLC method. Standard QLC methods like FALQON require deep circuits for smaller time steps , but when the circuit is shortened with larger time steps it can become unstable. To address this the author proposes a greedy layerwise training variant of QLC. Each layer’s control parameter is initialized at zero and updated with L gradient descent steps, before it is frozen and the next layer is added. They show GD-QLC makes the energy non-increasing with a sufficiently small step size (Theorem 1) and that the inner loop converges to a stationary point under noisy gradients (Theorem 2). Empirically GD-QLC converges with fewer layers than FALQON like methods including under finite shots and simulated hardware noise.
Critical strengths
The benchmark results are strong. GD-QLC reaches better approximation ratios than FALQON often with much fewer layers and it also matches or exceeds SO-FALQON / FOCQS. It is more robust to the time step where the other methods begin to become unstable at larger values such as = 0.3. The shot experiment looks particularly strong where GD-QLC remains much more stable. This suggests the method is more suitable in NISQ.
I also thought the study of GD-QLC as a warm start for QAOA was promising. Here GD-QLC was used to build a fixed size circuit (10 layers) whose parameters then initialize QAOA training. I think practically this may be the most relevant use case of GD-QLC when one is constrained by the number of layers they can use and want to initialize the QAOA circuit in a good training regime.
Critical weaknesses
My main concern is novelty. GD-QLC is essentially a greedy layerwise gradient descent method. Each layer's parameter is initialized at zero, trained with some finite GD steps, before they freeze the layer and add a new one. Layerwise training like this is well established for VQA’s, (See [1, 2, 3, 4]). By Lemma 1 the feedback of observable A is the derivative of the energy w.r.t the new layers control parameters, so GD-QLC is just gradient descent on that parameter. Growing a QAOA circuit using commutator gradients is the core idea of ADAPT-QAOA [3] and similar to this body of work. The main difference is that GD-QLC never re-trains earlier layers, but this work doesn't cite layerwise training methods or discusses how GD-QLC relates to it and I think this is needed. Adding one such method to the benchmarks would also be valuable.
Another concern is how the benchmarks are reported. GD-QLC performs L GD steps per layer, so plotting performance only against the number of layers understates its cost relative to QLC like methods (at L = 5, 200 layers of GD-QLC require five times as many evaluations as 200 layers of FALQON). The noiseless comparisons should therefore also be plotted against total gradient steps or measurement cost. Fig. 7 partially addresses this by fixing the per-iteration shot budget but the other experiments should also include a budget style plot.
Questions for authors
Experiments use which is much larger than the bound in Theorem 1 & 2 (/Smoothness constant). Do the theorems cover the reported runs? How sensitive is GD-QLC to learning rate choice?
The abstract states that feedback-based methods can mitigate barren plateaus. Could the authors support this with a citation or experiment and discuss it in relation to GD-QLC, which was proposed partly for the same purpose [1]?
[1] Skolik, Andrea, et al. "Layerwise learning for quantum neural networks." Quantum Machine Intelligence 3.1 (2021): 5.
[2] Campos, Ernesto, Aly Nasrallah, and Jacob Biamonte. "Abrupt transitions in variational quantum circuit training." Physical Review A 103.3 (2021): 032607.
[3] Zhu, Linghua, et al. "Adaptive quantum approximate optimization algorithm for solving combinatorial problems on a quantum computer." Physical Review Research 4.3 (2022): 033029.
[4] Kverne, C., Akewar, M., Huo, Y., Patel, T. & Bhimani, J.. (2026). WSBD: Freezing-Based Optimizer for Quantum Neural Networks . Proceedings of The 29th International Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Statistics, in Proceedings of Machine Learning Research 300:4150-4158 Available from https://proceedings.mlr.press/v300/kverne26a.html.
2 comments
Thank you for addressing my review. I appreciate the updated framing and novelty discussion and your plan to add more experiments.
However as these additions are phrased as "future work" I cannot evaluate your response further until a new version of your work is uploaded. If I am not mistaken the current draft is still the old one. I'd be happy to go further over your response once your updated draft is in.
We thank the reviewer for this insightful feedback and for highlighting the connection to established layerwise VQA training methods. Below we will address their careful comments point by point.
Weakness 1
ADAPT-QAOA uses commutator gradients to select operators from a candidate pool at each layer and subsequently re-optimizes all variational parameters globally. This leads to compounding optimization overhead relative to GD-QLC as new layers are added. In contrast, GD-QLC keeps the driver Hamiltonian Hd fixed and uses the commutator expectation value A(l)=⟨i[Hd,Hp]⟩ directly to update a single control variable.
While GD-QLC shares the high-level structure of freezing earlier layers, it differs from existing layerwise VQAs. Heuristic layerwise VQAs rely on off-the-shelf black-box classical optimizers (and multi-evaluation parameter-shift or finite-difference rules) without global Lipschitz smoothness bounds, Lyapunov stability conditions, or finite-shot convergence guarantees. By contrast, GD-QLC obtains exact gradients directly from the single commutator observable Ak(l) and ensures satisfaction of the Lyapunov condition with strict monotone energy descent (Theorem 1), alongside a convergence rate in expectation to a per-layer stationary point under unbiased shot noise (Theorem 2). Relative to established layerwise VQA training, GD-QLC serves as a hybrid bridge between variational optimization and feedback-based quantum Lyapunov control.
We agree that explicitly situating GD-QLC relative to this literature will strengthen the paper, and we will add a dedicated discussion and citations covering layerwise circuit learning (Skolik et al.) and adaptive commutator-based methods such as ADAPT-QAOA (Zhu et al.).
Following the reviewer’s suggestion, we will add a comparison against a frozen layerwise QAOA baseline (parameter-fixing QAOA) in the revised manuscript to empirically highlight the trade-offs in circuit depth, measurement cost, and convergence stability.
Weakness 2
We agree that plotting against layer count alone understates GD-QLC’s cost when L>1. We will add noiseless comparisons against cumulative gradient/feedback evaluations and estimated measurement shots, counting each of the L updates and the observable groups used to estimate them. Layer-count plots will be presented as depth comparisons, while resource-matched plots will support claims about efficiency. Figure 7 addresses finite-shot performance under its stated budget convention.
Question 1
We thank the reviewer for raising the distinction between the theorem and the empirical schedule. In our empirical studies we have found that we can choose much larger learning rates for the system compared to the learning rates used in Theorem 1 & 2. We have observed in our research that GD-QLC performs well over a wide range of learning rates. We recognize that a more thorough discussion on learning rates is needed to clarify the difference between the theorems and the empirical results. In the revised paper we will include a discussion of this point and we will include a plot illustrating the effect of learning rate on performance gains.
Question 2
We are not aware of a concrete research paper demonstrating barren plateau mitigation for quantum Lyapunov control methods. But historically, QLC methods have been motivated based on this. For example, (Magann et al., 2022a) discusses feedback structure as a possible way to avoid some variational-training difficulties. These results motivate the question but do not establish barren-plateau mitigation for GD-QLC. We will add the relevant citations, and describe this as an open empirical question for GD-QLC.
We look forward to further insightful discussions regarding these points.