- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper propose TrACE, a trajectory-aware pretrain-and-adapt framework for in-loop VQE error mitigation. The trained model can provide corrected energy predictions to classical optimizers to enhance the training. The paper considers multiple use cases including TFIM, molecular energy and MaxCut benchmarks. The paper claims improved solution quality, convergence stability and optimization speed.
Critical strengths
- The problem is well motivated. QEM should not consider the deviation in single expectation values but how these deviations' effects on VQE optimizer.
- Evaluation metrics are better than conventional QEM benchmarks, especially for the purposr of VQE.
- Good collections of ablations including TFIM, MaxCut, H4 as well as noise settings.
Critical weaknesses
- The authors should elaborate whether the self-supervised adaptation can actually mitigate systematic error. (Eq. (14)–(17))
- Please explain why the \kappa_{t} is set to 0 during training and can expect that the model can learn the correct representation of trajectory context.
- Baseline comparisons are not entirely fair. For example, TrACE use 3 random seed while other baselines only have one run.
Questions for authors
1.Please clarify how the 100 qubit simulation is carried out. In the paper it said the MPS is used. It is atraightforward in noise free case, but how the "noisy" version is simulated. 2. Please provide the details of MPS bond dimension and truncation tolerance? 3. Please provide some perspectives on variational quantum circuits which are not simulable on shallow MPS as mentioned in this paper. This is important for the general applicatility of the proposed method.