acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

SPLiT: Channel-Aware Learning for Quantum Error Mitigation

Abstract

Quantum error mitigation (QEM) improves observable estimates on noisy quantum devices. Circuit-specific estimation and explicit channel inversion incur additional execution, characterization, or sampling costs. Direct learned regressors enable fast inference on new circuits but leave noise accumulation implicit, which can impair accuracy under depth extrapolation and device drift. We propose SPLiT (Sparse Pauli–Lindblad Transformer)), which reformulates learned mitigation around explicit layerwise noise channels. A causal Transformer predicts channel rates, from which we construct a survival prior that accumulates analytically across layers. Observable-conditioned residuals refine this shared prior into deterministic mitigation coefficients for individual Pauli terms. A differentiable qubit-transfer dynamic program evaluates the prior exactly for open-chain channels with per-layer cost linear in qubit count. Relative-position attention supports depth extrapolation, while calibration and measurement conditioning adapt predictions to noise drift without retraining. Across a simulation sweep of four circuit families spanning structured and random circuits under three noise models, SPLiT achieves the lowest mean absolute error (MAE) in of settings, with – lower MAE on multi-Pauli energy tasks than the strongest baseline in each setting. It also achieves the lowest reported MAE under temporal drift, beyond training depths, and on a -qubit benchmark.

Primary area:
applications to physical sciences (physics, chemistry, biology, etc.)
Keywords:
Quantum error mitigation, Physics-informed machine learning, Transformers

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 15%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 3.00 over 3 reviews, above 85% of the others.
Reviewer_1mv9OpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes SPLiT, a learning-based quantum error mitigation framework that uses a Transformer to predict layerwise Pauli–Lindblad noise rates. It computes a cumulative survival prior and combines it with learned observable-specific corrections to estimate ideal expectation values.

The paper makes the following contributions: (1) A channel-aware learning framework that explicitly models noise accumulation; (2) an efficient dynamic programming algorithm that computes the survival prior in O(n)O(n) time per layer; and (3) mechanisms for generalizing to deeper circuits and adapting to noise drift.

Simulations across four circuit families and three noise models show that SPLiT outperforms six baselines in 10 of 12 settings, with improved results under depth extrapolation, noise drift, and a 100-qubit benchmark.

Critical strengths

The paper combines layerwise Pauli–Lindblad noise modeling with Transformer-based learning and observable-specific corrections. This physics-informed approach is a meaningful departure from direct regression and provides a structured way to model noise accumulation, potentially improving generalization.

Critical weaknesses

The proposed survival prior represents the probability of net identity errors at individual circuit layers, which is not equivalent to the attenuation of a specific observable. The paper does not adequately justify why this quantity should serve as an effective mitigation factor. Although observable-specific residuals are introduced to compensate for this discrepancy, their effectiveness relies on learning rather than a clear theoretical foundation. This raises concerns about the soundness and generalizability of the central approach.

The method requires ideal expectation values for supervised training, but the paper does not adequately explain how such labels can be obtained efficiently for large quantum circuits that cannot be simulated classically. Furthermore, all experiments are simulation-based, without validation on real quantum hardware. These limitations raise significant concerns about the practicality of the proposed approach and whether the reported improvements will translate to real-world quantum computing systems.

The simulation methods used for the 100-qubit benchmark, including how the ideal labels and noisy measurements are computed, whether tensor-network or other approximations are employed, and how their accuracy is validated, are not clearly presented.

Questions for authors

A. Can you provide theoretical justification for the survival prior?

The central idea is to use

Sl=∏j=1lcI(λj)S_l=\prod_{j=1}^{l}c_I(\lambda_j)

as a basis for mitigating observable errors. However, SlS_l measures the probability that each layer produces a net identity Pauli error. This is not equivalent to the attenuation of a particular observable. For example, under bit-flip noise with probability pp:

  • The survival prior is 1−p1-p.
  • The attenuation of ZZ is 1−2p1-2p.
  • The attenuation of XX is 11.

The authors introduce learned residuals to compensate for these differences, but this raises a fundamental question: Why is the survival prior a better starting point than directly learning observable-specific attenuation?

I would expect a controlled ablation comparing the survival prior against a learned denominator without that prior. Without such evidence, the value of the paper's central modeling choice remains uncertain.

B. SPLiT requires ideal expectation values as supervised training labels. For small quantum circuits, these can be obtained through classical simulation. However, for large circuits beyond classical simulation capabilities, obtaining ideal results is precisely the difficult problem. The paper does not demonstrate a practical training procedure using data obtainable from real quantum hardware. This raises questions about whether the method can be deployed on quantum circuits for which error mitigation is most needed.

C. The authors report results for a 100-qubit TFIM Hamiltonian, suggesting scalability. However, computing exact ideal and noisy expectations for a general 100-qubit circuit is classically infeasible. The paper does not adequately explain the simulation techniques used to generate these values, including any approximations and their accuracy. Furthermore, the O(n) dynamic programming algorithm only computes the survival prior; it does not efficiently simulate the entire noisy quantum circuit. Without a clear explanation of how the 100-qubit benchmark data were generated, it is difficult to assess the significance of the scalability claims.

D. SPLiT requires noisy measurements from circuit prefixes and auxiliary single-qubit Pauli measurements. Obtaining these measurements on real hardware may require additional circuit executions and measurement settings. Although the paper emphasizes efficient inference and linear-time survival-prior computation, it does not provide a comprehensive comparison of quantum measurement costs against existing QEM approaches. Consequently, it is unclear whether SPLiT actually reduces the total resources needed for error mitigation.

Reviewer_jVYGOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes a learning based channel aware quantum error mitigation technique that uses a transformer to predict sparse Pauli Lindblad (SPL) rates along with observable correction residuals. The predicted SPL rates are used to calculate the cumulative survival prior using a qubit transfer DP on an open chain and together with the observable conditioned residual is used to obtain the mitigated expectation value. The method is evaluated over several circuit families and noise settings including depth extrapolation, and drifting noise scenarios.

Critical strengths
  1. Instead of direct regression, the paper introduces noise channel structure in the prediction model along with observable correction residuals. The survival prior together with observable residual and ALiBi attention seems to generalize well for unseen depths.

  2. The overall experimental evaluation is encouraging. The proposed method achieves lower MAE than other evaluated baselines in most of the settings listed.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The shared survival prior is used for all terms of an observable, although noise affects different Pauli terms differently. The observable residuals account for this, but it is not clear how much improvement in the mitigation scheme comes from the analytical prior compared to the residual given that SPL rates are used both in prior and residual calculation.

  2. Closely related transformer-based baselines are missing although they are mentioned in the related work. Without them, it is not clear how SPLiT compares with the existing transformer based QEM.

Questions for authors
  1. Could the authors provide an ablation showing the contribution of the shared analytical prior in the improvement?

  2. From the figures, it seems ZNE just improves a bit over the noisy outcome and closely follows the noisy curve. What noise scaling and fitting method were used here?

  3. For n=100 qubits with more than 1000 generators per layer, how often does the prior fall below ε\varepsilon in this setting? If this is frequent, then wouldn't the role of prior be limited?

  4. How sensitive is SPLiT if the noise falls outside the SPL generator set? For example, for cross talk between nonadjacent qubits? Will the existing observable residual compensate for it? Will it degrade gracefully?

Reviewer_zjMzOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes SPLiT, a learned quantum error-mitigation method that predicts layerwise sparse Pauli–Lindblad rates using a causal Transformer. A differentiable dynamic program computes the identity-error coefficient of each modeled channel, and their product supplies a survival prior. Observable-specific residuals convert this prior into mitigation coefficients. Relative positional encoding and calibration/measurement conditioning support depth extrapolation and adaptation to noise drift. Simulation experiments cover four circuit families and three noise settings, with additional extrapolation, drift, and 100-qubit evaluations. SPLiT reports the lowest MAE in 10 of 12 standard settings.

Critical strengths
  1. A concrete, computationally tractable physical prior. The four-state transfer recursion computes the modeled identity coefficient exactly with linear cost in qubit count per layer (Sec 3.4; Appendix A.3). This makes the structured prior usable inside end-to-end training. The paper appropriately limits this exactness claim to the specified channel coefficient.

  2. Consistent improvements on the multi-term energy tasks. SPLiT improves over the strongest reported baseline in all six QAOA/Hubbard settings, with MAE reductions of approximately 1.3–2.3×. Its favorable results under depth extrapolation and temporal drift provide additional evidence that the architecture has useful inductive biases.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The experiments do not isolate the central channel-modeling contribution. Appendix A.4 ablates positional encoding and conditioning, but not the survival prior itself or its interaction with the residual head. A direct-regression Transformer with the same backbone, inputs, and training budget is also missing. Consequently, the gains could arise substantially from model capacity, attention, or additional conditioning rather than the explicit channel representation.

  2. Practical measurement requirements are not adequately validated. The method consumes noisy measurements at circuit prefixes and auxiliary single-qubit expectations. Appendix A.2 states that the auxiliary context is computed before the separate readout-error model, while finite-shot budgets are not specified. These assumptions matter because the mitigation denominator can amplify measurement error. The 100-qubit result is also only 5.3% better in MAE than RF, without reported variability, making the large-system evidence less conclusive than the headline suggests.

Questions for authors
  1. What are the total measurement requirements, including circuit prefixes and auxiliary observables, and do all learned baselines receive equivalent inputs? Do the improvements persist when every measurement input includes finite-shot and readout noise?
  2. How does SPLiT compare with an otherwise identical direct-regression Transformer and with variants removing the survival prior or residual head?
  3. How are the 100-qubit ideal labels generated, and does the reported advantage persist across independently trained models and independently generated test sets?
1 comment

Thank the authors for the detailed responses. The comparison with the Transformer in the same setting partially addressed my concerns about attributing the improvements to the proposed components. I have two remaining concerns that may need clarification:

1.The RF MAE changes from 1.543 in the manuscript to 0.307, while the unmitigated MAE changes from 14.535 to 10.78. Since these changes cannot be attributed to SPLiT’s initialization, could you clarify which aspects of data generation, measurement, training, or evaluation changed, and confirm that all reported methods use the same revised protocol?

  1. Please specify the MPO bond dimension and truncation settings, and provide a convergence check showing that numerical error in the reference energies is sufficiently small relative to the reported mitigation errors.

I am inclined to raise my recommendation to weak acceptance, pending these clarifications.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
Area_Chair_JqtZOpenReview ↗

Please respond to the authors

Dear reviewers,

Thank you for your service.

The authors have provided their response to your initial reviews. As we approach the end of the author-reviewer discussion period, could you please respond to the authors’ rebuttal (if you haven’t done so already) and communicate the extent to which your concerns have been addressed, and whether you have any further questions and concerns?

Thanks, Your AC

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.