- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Deep ZakaiJ, a probabilistic time series forecasting framework that combines Zakai-based latent-state filtering with a structured neural jump-diffusion decoder. The encoder uses Strang splitting to separate prior propagation, diffusion innovation, and jump innovation. Experiments on synthetic and financial datasets demonstrate improvements in probabilistic forecasting performance over various baselines.
Critical strengths
-
The design is well-motivated. The integration of explicit latent-state filtering with jump-diffusion forecasting provides a principled and interpretable framework. Separating continuous dynamics from jump events is a reasonable and useful modeling choice.
-
Encouraging experimental results are provided. The evaluation includes both synthetic and real-world financial datasets, with diverse baselines and multiple probabilistic metrics. The consistent improvements in CRPS and interval scores support the effectiveness of the proposed approach.
Critical weaknesses
-
The ablation studies are conducted mainly on the synthetic dataset, and the improvements from individual filtering components are relatively small. Additional ablations on real-world datasets would better establish the necessity of the proposed structured filtering mechanism.
-
Insufficient evaluation of future jump prediction. Although jump-aware forecasting is a central motivation, the current evaluation does not clearly distinguish predicting future jump risks from detecting regime changes after jumps have occurred. Aggregate forecasting metrics and regime-change analyses alone do not sufficiently demonstrate the model's ability to anticipate future jump events.
Questions for authors
Could the authors evaluate forecasting performance at different lead times before actual jump events, compared with periods without jumps? Event-conditioned CRPS/IS90 or jump-probability calibration would help clarify the model's ability to predict future jump risks.
Response to Reviewer MhVd
Thank you for your constructive comments. We ran the paper's ablations on XAU/USD, BTC/USDT and MSTR over five seeds, and evaluated the forecast jump probability on all four datasets.
1. Ablations on the real datasets. Test segment, mean ± std over five seeds.
Compared with Decoder-only, Deep ZakaiJ improves LogLik from 2.62/2.59/1.98 to 3.32/2.87/2.29 and reduces CRPS from 0.0058/0.0118/0.0190 to 0.0054/0.0081/0.0128 on XAU/BTC/MSTR, and it has higher LogLik than GRU belief on all three datasets. Removing any splitting component increases CRPS on all three datasets, and the effect can be large: without B, XAU/USD MAE rises from 0.0075 to 0.0303; without A, BTC/USDT RMSE from 0.0158 to 0.0305; without RψA, MSTR RMSE from 0.0256 to 0.0345.
2. Prediction of future jumps. You asked whether the model predicts future jump risk, as distinct from detecting jumps after they occur. At forecast origin t and lead h, Deep ZakaiJ propagates the filtered belief through the latent dynamics and issues
p(t,h)=P(Nt+h−Nt+h−1≥1FtX)=E[1−e−λ(θt+h−1)ΔtFtX],
a forecast made before the target increment is observed. NeuralMJD issues the same quantity from the jump intensity it infers from the context window. Each forecast, at every lead h∈{1,…,100}, is scored against the true jumps on Synthetic and the 1%-level Lee–Mykland jumps on the real datasets. Higher log score and lower ECE (ten equal-count bins) are better; lead-group log scores are seed means.
Deep ZakaiJ has a better log score and ECE than NeuralMJD on all four datasets, and the advantage holds at leads 51–100. On Synthetic its ECE is 28% lower.