acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Muscles Know First: Decoding Hand Motion from Wrist EMG for Latency-Compensated Vision-Based Robot Teleoperation

Abstract

Vision-based teleoperation has become the most accessible way to drive a dexterous robot hand, but a dramatic delay (150–400 ms) of robot hand motion against the operator’s current pose forces the operator to slow down and wait for the robot, owing to the inherent flaws of the vision-based method. To overcome this limitation, we present Muscles Know First (MKF), a latency-conditioned two-stream forecaster that fuses the fresh surface electromyography (sEMG) stream with the delayed pose stream, predicting the operator’s pose passed onto the robot. Experiments are separately conducted with motion tracking and hand–object contact tasks. For the motion tracking task, MKF recovers 61% of the tracking error caused by latency on unseen users with non-accumulated characteristic, and three control groups attribute the sEMG contribution to its timing rather than to its content. In a MuJoCo Shadow Hand testbed with three contact tasks timed to the operator’s motion, the proposed MKF restores success rate from 57/26/13% to 92/83/67%, respectively, under 300 ms of latency with an inference time of only 8.5 ms. The outcomes of this study reveal a promising way for low-latency and more accurate robot hand teleoperation, potentially promoting dexterous robotic manipulation.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
teleoperation, surface electromyography, sEMG decoding, latency compensation, hand pose forecasting, multimodal fusion, dexterous manipulation, human-robot interaction

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 30%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.67 over 3 reviews, above 70% of the others.
Reviewer_XsUMOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper aims to tackle the significant latency of vision-based teleoperation. It proposes to utilize an additional sensor modality, i.e., a surface electromyography (sEMG) wristband, to compensate for the latency. The paper proposes Muscles Know First (MKF), a two-stream framework that effectively fuses the vision and sEMG signals.

Critical strengths
  1. The idea of using sEMG to compensate for the latency of vision-based robot teleoperation is interesting, reasonable, and effective.
  2. The method is built on a practical assumption of differential latency between vision-based hand tracking and sEMG signals. The proposed MKF tackles these temporally unaligned modalities with a two-stream framework.
  3. The paper has performed thorough experiments on the emg2pose benchmark.
Critical weaknesses

The biggest issue is that there is no guarantee that the method can be actually applied to real robot teleoperation. The paper does not provide any real-world demonstrations of robot teleoperation, which is far more complicated. Moreover, the experiments only consider a fixed wrist.

Questions for authors

The current experiments only consider a fixed wrist. In real robot teleoperation, the operator needs to move and rotate the wrist while moving the fingers. Will wrist movement affect the sEMG signals for finger prediction, and how can MKF be extended to 6-DoF wrist and arm motion?

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Author Response to Reviewer XsUM (Part 1/2: Overview & W1)

Thank you for the positive assessment (Weak acceptance) and for recognizing both the practicality of pairing delayed vision with a low-latency sEMG wristband and our thorough evaluation on emg2pose. Below, we report our newly completed 23-stage wrist/arm evaluation directly in this comment and address your concern and two-part question in order (anonymized code and MuJoCo suite: https://anonymous.4open.science/r/muscles-know-first-34799/).


W1: Real-world robot teleoperation applicability and the fixed-wrist setup

Response: We appreciate this insightful comment; we apologize for not making two key points clearer in the initial manuscript:

  • (1) Why we use offline replay (and next-step physical deployment): We use offline replay to isolate open-loop forecasting accuracy from operator adaptation: in live teleoperation, operators facing delay instinctively slow down ("move-and-wait") and never repeat the exact same motion twice, which masks true compensation rates across baselines (No compensation, Kin-only, DM-KF, MKF). Replaying emg2pose (370 h, 193 users) through real-tracker degradations (WiLoR, MediaPipe) and a 100 ms robot execution delay lets us compare algorithms fairly on identical trajectories; closing the loop with human-in-the-loop adaptation on physical hardware is our immediate next step (clarified in Abstract, Sec. 1, and Sec. 6).

  • (2) Human operators move their wrists and arms freely (only the simulated robot base is fixed): In emg2pose, human operators do not fix their arms on a table—they move their wrists and arms freely in space across diverse heights, postures, wrist rotations, and reaches (MKF beats Kin-only in 23/23 stages, shown in Q1 below). We fixed the simulated Shadow Hand base in MuJoCo solely to isolate 20-DoF finger-timing accuracy from 6-DoF robot-arm IK errors—matching how vision teleoperation systems (AnyTeleop, Qin et al., 2023) decouple local hand control from arm control.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Author Response to Reviewer XsUM (Part 2/2: Q1 — Wrist/Arm Motion & 6-DoF Extension)

Q1: Will wrist movement affect sEMG signals for finger prediction, and how can MKF be extended to 6-DoF wrist and arm motion?

Response: We greatly appreciate the insights and valuable two-part question.

(1) Does wrist movement hurt sEMG finger prediction? (New 23-stage test across 20 unseen users)

Physiologically, wrist flexion/extension, deviation, and forearm rotation do affect forearm sEMG through shared finger–wrist muscles, stabilizing co-contraction, and slight electrode shifts. Predicting 20 wrist-local finger angles removes global wrist motion from the output space, though raw sEMG still contains both wrist and finger activity.

While our MuJoCo hand mounts a fixed wrist to isolate finger timing, human operators in emg2pose move their wrists and arms freely. To test directly whether active wrist and arm motion degrades MKF, we broke down our 20-unseen-user, 3-run evaluation (2,172 test files at L=300 ms,Δ=100 msL = 300\text{ ms}, \Delta = 100\text{ ms}) across all 23 emg2pose gesture stages (added in Sec. 4 & Appendix G.5 Table 23):

Gesture Stage (20 Unseen Users, L=300 msL=300\text{ ms})Wrist & Arm InvolvementFilesStaleKin-onlyMKF (Ours)Gain vs. Kin
Near/far reach & fist graspFull-arm forward reaching & punch grasp7016.54°10.77°7.70°+28.5%
Doorknob turn & fist graspForearm pronation/supination during grasp4315.35°9.69°7.54°+22.2%
Wrist flexion & abductionExplicit wrist flexion, extension & deviation787.71°5.96°4.77°+20.0%
Two-handed freestyle motionContinuous bimanual free-space motion15413.21°9.91°7.99°+19.4%
Fast table-tennis & throwing swingsRapid forehand/backhand wrist swings5112.50°8.02°6.59°+17.8%
One-handed freestyle motionContinuous unimanual free-space motion11417.05°11.95°9.97°+16.6%
All 23 Stages Combined23 / 23 stages improved (+2.3% to +28.5%, median +16.0%)2,1729.26°6.86°5.73°+16.4%

MKF beats Kin-only in every single stage (23/23): even quiet rest/desk stages improve by +2.3%–4.0% (1.887° → 1.843° on unconstrained rest), while active finger, wrist-rotation, and arm-reaching stages improve by +7.8% to +28.5% (median +16.0%). Because MKF re-anchors every 20 ms to q(≤t−L)q(\le t - L) and attends over 1 s of 16-channel sEMG trained across varied arm/wrist postures, it separates finger motion bursts from background wrist activity (while physical testing under external object loads remains an important next step).

(2) How MKF extends to 6-DoF wrist and arm teleoperation

In standard vision-based teleoperation systems (e.g., AnyTeleop, Qin et al., 2023), global 6-DoF wrist/arm control and local 20-DoF finger control are already modular (added with diagram in Appendix G.5 Fig. 9):

  • 20-DoF finger & wrist-angle pathway (MKF): MKF plugs directly into the hand controller to predict the 20 wrist-local finger joint angles q^finger(t+Δ)\hat{q}_{\text{finger}}(t + \Delta) from delayed vision + fresh 16-channel forearm sEMG. Moreover, because forearm sEMG directly captures wrist flexors, extensors, and forearm rotators (as in Kang & Hong, 2025; Kang et al., 2026), MKF's same two-stream architecture can jointly predict wrist rotation angles alongside the 20 finger joints.

  • Parallel 6-DoF arm/wrist pathway: For 3D wrist translation in workspace (driven by elbow and shoulder muscles above the wristband), a parallel kinematic forecaster (Kin-only trunk) predicts the 6-DoF wrist target from the camera's wrist trajectory for the robot arm's IK controller—and can optionally incorporate upper-arm sEMG (Feleke et al., 2021) or onboard wristband motion sensors when available.

The authors' response has clarified some of my concerns. However, without real-world results, I am not fully convinced of the method's applicability to real-world robot teleoperation. Nevertheless, I will maintain my original rating due to the novel exploration of the problem and well-verified results on the benchmark.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Thank you for your support and positive evaluation

Thank you very much for taking the time to read our response and for maintaining your positive rating! We truly appreciate your recognition of our novel exploration of latency-compensated teleoperation and our benchmark verification, and your constructive suggestions on wrist/arm motion and 6-DoF integration have made the paper much clearer and stronger.

Reviewer_o4ieOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
3(+1)
Read review
Paper summary

The paper addresses a practical bottleneck in vision-based dexterous-hand teleoperation: the robot receives the operator’s hand pose only after substantial camera and processing latency. MKF is a latency-conditioned two-stream Transformer that combines a delayed visual pose stream with fresh wrist sEMG and forecasts future hand poses over a range of vision latencies. Its central hypothesis is that muscle activity contains timely information about ongoing or imminent motion that is absent from the delayed visual stream.

The evaluation combines large-scale experiments on emg2pose, streaming forecasting, pose degradations calibrated using three egocentric tracking pipelines, and recorded-operator replay in three MuJoCo Shadow Hand contact tasks. The revised manuscript evaluates all 20 unseen users across 2,172 recordings and three training runs, and expands the contact-task evaluation to 644 feasible events. Three causal controls are used to distinguish the contribution of timely sEMG from model capacity and generic multimodal denoising.

Critical strengths

1. The causal attribution to sEMG timing is convincing.
The time-shuffled EMG, synchronized-delay EMG, and zeroed-EMG training controls jointly isolate the importance of fresh muscle activity. In particular, the gain disappears when the temporal relationship is disrupted, while matching the EMG delay to the vision delay substantially reduces the benefit. The zeroed-EMG control also makes a model-capacity explanation unlikely. These experiments directly support the paper’s central physiological and temporal claim rather than merely establishing a correlation.

2. The revised experiments demonstrate that the benefit is broad-based across users.
The full 20-unseen-user evaluation resolves my original concern that the improvement might be concentrated in a small subset of users. MKF improves performance for all 20 users at every tested latency and in every training run. At 300 ms latency, Kin-only reduces error from 9.26° without compensation to 6.86°, while MKF further reduces it to 5.73°, an additional 16.4% improvement over the strong kinematic baseline. Reporting the complete per-user distribution is substantially more informative than the earlier limited-batch evaluation.

The active-versus-frozen decomposition further clarifies the source of the improvement under degraded tracking: approximately 93% of the error reduction occurs on active frames rather than frozen frames. This makes dropout filling an unlikely primary explanation and strengthens the interpretation that fresh sEMG supplies useful temporal information.

3. The contact-task evidence and its auditability are substantially improved.
The expanded three-run, 20-user evaluation covers 644 feasible events and provides user-cluster bootstrap confidence intervals. MKF improves over Kin-only on all three tasks, with positive confidence intervals for the paired differences. The authors also explain the model-blind parameter-setting procedure, retain the unsuccessful sliding-bin design, report parameter sweeps, and release the task-generation and scoring code. These additions address my original concerns about modest event counts, training variability, and possible task-parameter selection effects.

4. The revised framing is appropriately calibrated.
The abstract now reports the strong Kin-only baseline alongside MKF and explicitly describes the evaluation as offline replay and simulation. The paper also retains negative results and failure cases. This makes the claims more faithful to the evidence and increases my confidence in the reported positive findings.

Critical weaknesses

1. Live closed-loop teleoperation remains untested.
All evidence still comes from recorded data and simulation. The current experiments do not measure how a human operator adapts to MKF predictions, nor do they test the complete camera–wristband–robot pipeline under real sensing, communication, and actuation conditions. Consequently, the results establish promising open-loop forecasting and replay-based evidence rather than demonstrated improvement in live teleoperation. The revised manuscript now states this boundary clearly, so I regard this primarily as a limitation of scope and an important direction for future work rather than an unresolved soundness objection.

2. The incremental tracking gain remains moderate, and the task evidence is still simulation-based.
A substantial portion of the recoverable error is already handled by Kin-only. The additional sEMG benefit is meaningful and consistent, but smaller than the full improvement relative to no compensation. Likewise, the advantage over Kin-only is relatively modest on Catch compared with Gate and Timed Release. Although the expanded evaluation and released code considerably strengthen the task-level results, author-designed MuJoCo tasks remain less independent and less ecologically complete than physical manipulation benchmarks. The abstract’s revised presentation appropriately reflects this distinction.

Questions for authors

No further questions. The authors have satisfactorily addressed all of my original questions:

  1. The contact-task parameter-setting procedure, parameter sweeps, retained negative result, and released task/scoring code address my auditability concern.
  2. The complete per-user results resolve my concern about whether the EMG gain is broad-based across unseen users.
  3. The active/frozen decomposition clarifies that the degraded-vision improvement is not primarily attributable to dropout robustness.
  4. The revised manuscript now integrates the full 20-user headline results, defines the bootstrap and Max Single-Run pp statistics, and includes the additional contact-task and degradation experiments.
5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Author Response to Reviewer o4ie (Part 1/3: Overview, W1 & W2)

Thank you for recognizing our causal timing controls, our large-scale cross-user study on emg2pose, and our transparent reporting of boundary and failure cases. We have completed all requested follow-up experiments and report the full results directly below (anonymized code and MuJoCo suite: https://anonymous.4open.science/r/muscles-know-first-34799/).


W1: Evaluation on replayed data and simulation, and clarifying the scope in the abstract

Response: We appreciate this insightful comment, and we apologize for not stating this scope clearly enough in the original Abstract. We chose offline replay deliberately to isolate open-loop forecasting accuracy from operator adaptation: in live teleoperation, operators facing delay instinctively slow down ("move-and-wait") and never repeat the exact same motion twice, which masks true algorithm gains and prevents a fair, apples-to-apples comparison across controllers. Replaying emg2pose (370 h, 193 users) in MuJoCo lets us test every method (No compensation, Kin-only, DM-KF, MKF) on the exact same ground-truth trajectories and millisecond contact deadlines, alongside strict causal controls (time-shuffled and delayed sEMG). Now that this controlled baseline comparison is established, closing the loop with human-in-the-loop adaptation on physical hardware is our immediate next step, and we have made both this rationale and scope explicit in the Abstract, Sec. 1, and Sec. 6.


W2: Incremental gain over Kin-only, contact-task event counts/seeds, and uncertainty estimation

Response: We greatly appreciate this helpful suggestion. While 61% reflects full-system error recovery relative to no compensation (8.41° → 5.66°), we updated the Abstract to report our strongest unimodal baseline (Kin-only, 38% recovery to 6.69°) right beside MKF so the incremental value of sEMG is clear upfront.

  • Why a 15.4%–16.4% tracking gain produces large contact-task gains: In continuous recordings, the hand is often still or moving smoothly, where Kin-only already extrapolates well. Fresh sEMG specifically helps when the hand suddenly starts, closes, or reverses during the (t−L,t](t - L, t] blind window where delayed vision sees nothing—which is right when contact deadlines are won or lost.

  • Expanded 3-run, 20-unseen-user contact evaluation with 95% CIs: To strengthen statistical rigor beyond two runs and modest event counts, we trained a third 50k-step Kin-only and MKF pair (three independent training runs total) and evaluated an expanded 200-recording unseen-user benchmark (10 recordings ×\times 20 held-out users, yielding 347+196+101=644347 + 196 + 101 = 644 feasible events — ~3$\times$ larger) using 10,000-resample paired user-cluster bootstrap 95% CIs:

Task (200 Unseen-User Recordings, L=300 msL=300\text{ ms}, 3 Runs)Events (Users)No Comp.Kin-onlyMKF (Ours)MKF −- Kin [User 95% CI]Max Single-Run pp
Catch347 (20)57.9%79.9%85.5%+5.6 pp [+2.1, +9.4]0.033
Gate196 (19)10.7%70.1%86.9%+16.8 pp [+10.6, +25.6]3.1×10−63.1 \times 10^{-6}
Timed Release101 (18)48.5%55.8%71.3%+15.5 pp [+7.7, +25.3]0.016

On the original 51-recording set across three runs, No comp. / Kin-only / MKF likewise reach 63.2 / 68.4 / 84.2% (+15.8 pp, CI [+5.9, +27.6]) on Catch, 5.0 / 52.2 / 77.8% (+25.6 pp, CI [+14.9, +35.8]) on Gate, and 38.8 / 42.9 / 64.0% (+21.1 pp, CI [+10.0, +30.6]) on Timed Release. Moreover, under realistic WiLoR/MediaPipe pose noise plus a 100 ms robot execution delay across the 200-recording benchmark, MKF's lead over Kin-only widens further to +12.4–13.0 pp on Catch and +22.4–24.5 pp on Gate (added in Sec. 5.2 Table 6 & Appendix G.3 Table 21).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Author Response to Reviewer o4ie (Part 2/3: Q1 — Parameter Protocol & Open-Source Code)

Q1: Procedure and timeline for fixing contact-task parameters (Table 11), and release of task/scoring code

Response: We appreciate this insightful question and apologize that the parameter-locking protocol was described too briefly initially.

  • Physical grounding and model-blind timeline: None of the task constants (Table 11; now Table 13) were tuned on model outputs; all were set from real-world manipulation physics and unshifted human motion q(t)q(t) before evaluating Kin-only or MKF:

    1. Catch (ball-arrival offset: −60 ms-60\text{ ms} release / +68 ms+68\text{ ms} arrival): Dropping a 50 g ball from h=8 cmh = 8\text{ cm} clearance above an open palm gives a Newtonian free-fall time tfall=2h/g=2(0.08)/9.81=128 mst_{\text{fall}} = \sqrt{2h/g} = \sqrt{2(0.08)/9.81} = 128\text{ ms} (vimpact=2gh=1.25 m/sv_{\text{impact}} = \sqrt{2gh} = 1.25\text{ m/s}). Releasing 60 ms60\text{ ms} before finger-closure onset—reflecting natural mid-flight grasp initiation—places palm arrival at +68 ms+68\text{ ms}, after which an unclosed palm sheds the rebounding ball within ≈130 ms, physically creating an ≈200 ms delay tolerance.

    2. 200 ms gate margin & ±200 ms\pm 200\text{ ms} hatch window (matching that ≈200 ms physical scale): Closing a guard shutter at v=0.3 m/sv = 0.3\text{ m/s} (standard collaborative-robot safe speed scale) with a 200 ms gate margin (typical human visual reaction time) equals a Δx=vΔt=6.0 cm\Delta x = v\Delta t = 6.0\text{ cm} (≈3 finger-widths) physical clearance buffer; likewise, dropping 25 cm25\text{ cm} (tfall=226 mst_{\text{fall}} = 226\text{ ms}) into a ±200 ms\pm 200\text{ ms} hatch window (400 ms400\text{ ms} total) corresponds to a 20–30 cm conveyor slot moving at 0.5–0.75 m/s.

    3. Strict pre-evaluation lock-in & wide parameter sweeps: Event feasibility was defined solely from ground-truth human replay (L=0L=0), and when our first sliding-bin release design showed no MKF gain (37% vs. 34%), we kept it in full (Appendix C.1 Table 7) rather than retuning parameters. Full physical sweeps across 81/81 Catch combinations (offsets 0–120 ms, radii, elasticities; Table 16), horizontal throw speeds 0–1 m/s (Fig. 8), and 6/6 Gate speed ×\times margin settings (Table 17) confirm that MKF's lead does not depend on any single parameter choice (clarified in Appendix B.2).

  • Open-source code: Our anonymized repository is live at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/muscles-know-first-34799/ (Reproducibility statement), including the training and streaming evaluation code, the standalone MuJoCo contact-task simulation suite (scene builders, onset detector, model-blind pure-delay calibration scripts, physics scorer, and benchmark event lists), and multi-run evaluation scripts.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Author Response to Reviewer o4ie (Part 3/3: Q2, Q3 & Q4)

Q2: Per-user distribution of the EMG gain in Table 1 across the unseen-user split

Response: We appreciate the insights and valuable suggestion. Across all 20 held-out unseen users (2,172 recordings, 3 runs; averaging runs per user before computing user-level medians, IQRs, and paired bootstrap 95% CIs), 20 out of 20 unseen users improve at every latency and in every single training run, confirming that the gain is broad-based across users:

Vision Latency LLUsers ImprovedPer-User Median Gain [IQR]Min–Max User GainPaired Δ\DeltaMAE [95% CI]Pooled Kin →\to MKF (3 Runs)
0 ms20/20 (all 3 runs)+5.7% [4.4%, 6.6%]+3.4% – +12.6%0.19° [0.16°, 0.23°]3.20° →\to 3.01° (+5.8%)
100 ms20/20 (all 3 runs)+12.3% [11.3%, 14.7%]+8.3% – +21.9%0.67° [0.57°, 0.76°]5.05° →\to 4.41° (+12.6%)
200 ms20/20 (all 3 runs)+15.5% [14.1%, 18.4%]+9.3% – +23.7%1.01° [0.87°, 1.15°]6.19° →\to 5.22° (+15.7%)
300 ms20/20 (all 3 runs)+16.6% [14.4%, 20.3%]+8.4% – +23.9%1.18° [1.01°, 1.35°]6.86° →\to 5.73° (+16.4%)

Individual results for all 20 held-out unseen users (Users 1–20) at L=300 ms,Δ=100 msL = 300\text{ ms}, \Delta = 100\text{ ms} (Kin-only →\to MKF, 3-run mean):

UserKin →\to MKF (Gain)UserKin →\to MKF (Gain)UserKin →\to MKF (Gain)UserKin →\to MKF (Gain)
User 16.38° →\to 5.09° (+20.2%)User 64.86° →\to 4.45° (+8.4%)User 115.93° →\to 4.92° (+17.1%)User 167.58° →\to 5.98° (+21.1%)
User 27.66° →\to 5.96° (+22.1%)User 76.81° →\to 5.19° (+23.9%)User 126.26° →\to 5.60° (+10.5%)User 177.04° →\to 5.82° (+17.3%)
User 36.56° →\to 5.80° (+11.6%)User 87.55° →\to 5.98° (+20.7%)User 139.31° →\to 7.59° (+18.4%)User 187.09° →\to 5.80° (+18.3%)
User 46.23° →\to 5.55° (+10.9%)User 98.96° →\to 7.09° (+20.9%)User 147.36° →\to 6.19° (+15.9%)User 195.89° →\to 4.96° (+15.7%)
User 57.87° →\to 6.67° (+15.2%)User 105.98° →\to 5.10° (+14.8%)User 157.08° →\to 5.95° (+16.0%)User 207.09° →\to 6.14° (+13.4%)

At L=300 msL=300\text{ ms}, 16/20 users gain >14%, 6/20 gain >20%, and even the smallest individual gain (User 6) is +8.4% (4.86° → 4.45°), with < 0.02° run-to-run spread (+16.4% ± 0.3%). (Table 1's initial evaluation used a 400-batch limit covering the first 2 unseen users [6.69∘→5.66∘6.69^\circ \to 5.66^\circ, +15.4%+15.4\%]; full 20-user results across all latencies are added in Sec. 4 Table 3 [top] & Appendix G.1 Table 19.)


Q3: Under degraded vision (Table 4), how much of the MKF–Kin-only gap reflects dropout robustness vs. temporal lead?

Response: We appreciate this insightful question. In Appendix D's L=200 msL=200\text{ ms} freeze test, 11.70° is the uncompensated stale pose, while Kin-only gets 9.47° and MKF gets 8.54°. Splitting all 888,321 streaming ticks shows:

Tracking State (L=200 msL=200\text{ ms})Ticks (% Stream)UncompensatedKin-onlyMKF (Ours)MKF$-$KinShare of Error Reduction
Frozen (dropout)54,665 (6.2%)11.70°9.47°8.54°-0.93° (+9.9%)7.0%
Active (non-frozen)833,656 (93.8%)10.12°7.76°6.95°-0.81° (+10.5%)93.0%
  • (1) Normal active frames drive 93% of the gain: Dropouts contribute only 7.0% of the total error reduction. Consistently, in Table 4 (now Table 5), HOT3D + WiLoR (0.22/s dropouts) and EgoEMG (0.0045/s, 50×50\times fewer dropouts) show almost identical gains at L=300 msL=300\text{ ms} (+11.0% vs. +10.8%).

  • (2) Freshness dominates at high latency: Across all three chains in Table 5, MKF's gain starts at 3.9%–5.5% at L=0 msL=0\text{ ms} (denoising + physiological lead, matching the 2.3%–4.7% content gain under synchronized delay in Table 9) and doubles to 8.7%–11.0% at L=300 msL=300\text{ ms}, confirming that sEMG freshness provides over half of the high-latency benefit (clarified in Sec. 5.1 & Appendix D).


Q4: Real closed-loop validation with a live camera, wristband, and robot hand (Future Work)

Response: We appreciate your constructive perspective and thank you for noting that live hardware testing is not required for your current rating. In Sec. 6 and Appendix G.5 (Fig. 9), we outline our next-step physical teleoperation setup pairing live RGB hand tracking, a 16-channel sEMG wristband, and a physical robot hand/arm to evaluate closed-loop human-in-the-loop adaptation in real-world manipulation.

Reviewer_5y2cOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4(+1)
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2(−1)
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper addresses the latency of vision-based dexterous teleoperation. The camera-derived hand pose usually arrives 50–300 ms late , while a wrist sEMG band delivers muscle activity with negligible delay. The authors propose Muscles Know First (MKF), a latency-conditioned two-stream transformer. It reads 1 s of delayed hand pose, with the latency L given as an input, and lets it attend to 1 s of fresh sEMG envelope through cross-attention. It then predicts the next 500 ms of hand pose as an offset from the latest delayed pose. A single model covers L from 0 to 300 ms and is re-anchored to the newest pose at every control tick, so errors do not accumulate.

The paper claims three contributions:

  • a large-scale, cross-user measurement of how much anticipatory information sEMG carries about future hand pose;
  • the MKF forecaster itself;
  • a simulated teleoperation testbed for continuous hand tracking and for contact tasks timed to the operator’s motion.

These claims are supported by experiments on meta's sEMG dataset emg2pose (370 h, 193 users) under three held-out splits (unseen users, unseen gestures, or both), three control experiments (time-shuffled, synchronized-delay and zeroed EMG), sensitivity tests on a misestimated latency, pose degradation calibrated on real egocentric trackers, and a MuJoCo Shadow Hand replay.

The main findings are:

  • At 300 ms of latency, MKF recovers 61% of the latency-induced tracking error on unseen users, against 38% for a kinematics-only version.
  • The control experiments attribute most of the EMG gain to its freshness rather than its content.
  • In three contact tasks, success at 300 ms of latency rises from 57/26/13% without compensation to 92/83/67% with MKF, at an inference time of 8.5 ms.
Critical strengths

One model that works across users and latencies, on real EMG.

MKF is trained on real sEMG and motion capture from well-known meta dataset emg2pose and serves every latency from 0 to 300 ms with a single network. Its gain on unseen users is almost the same as within-subject (15.4% vs. 15.5% at L = 300 ms, Table 13). Per-user fine-tuning does not help (App. A), and a ±100 ms error in L costs at most 0.42°.

The real value is, prior EMG delay compensation trained one model per user for a fixed delay, so removing per-user calibration is what would make this usable in practice, since calibration is a really a bottleneck when put these kind of device into large-scale application.

Critical weaknesses

1. The EMG is real, but the teleoperation isn't.

The EMG and the hand pose both come from well-known meta emg2pose, so the signals themselves are real. But everything around them is simulated. The "vision" stream is the mocap pose shifted by L, the robot is a MuJoCo Shadow Hand replaying recorded free-space gestures, and the objects in the contact tasks are virtual and timed to the operator's own recording. That leaves out the things the motivation is actually about.

First, there's no human in the loop. As the introduction itself notes, operators under latency slow down or move and wait, and they would also react to a forecaster's mistakes. Replaying open-loop recordings assumes neither happens.

Second, the tracker noise looks too easy. Real tracker errors are biased and depend on pose and occlusion, especially around grasps, which is exactly when the tasks are scored. The AR(1)-plus-freeze model in Table 4 matches the measured magnitude, correlation time and loss rate, but it is independent of pose. App. B.3 notes that tracker error depends little on hand speed, but that doesn't show it is independent of pose. The synthetic noise also seems easy to filter out: Kin-only alone brings the MediaPipe-degraded error from 22.4° (held pose, L = 0) down to 8.4–9.7°. The paper reads results like this as compensation also removing tracking error. I read them as a sign that the synthetic noise is much easier than the real thing.

Third, as far as I can tell (please correct me if I'm wrong), the headline contact-task numbers (92/83/67%) come from models trained and run on the clean mocap stream. The degraded-input models are evaluated only on tracking error (Table 4, and the freeze test in App. D), never on the contact tasks. The tasks also execute only the next 20 ms of the forecast at each tick, so the roughly 100 ms robot-side delay that motivates Δ = 100 ms isn't modeled.

The conclusion is upfront that sim2real transfer and a human-in-the-loop study are left for future work, but the title and framing still present this as robot teleoperation. At a minimum, I'd like to see the contact tasks rerun under the Table 4 degradations and with the robot-side delay modeled (Δ = 100 ms). A test on real data is also within reach: EgoEMG, which the paper already uses to calibrate tracker noise, contains real EMG together with real egocentric video and mocap labels. MKF could be evaluated there with the released vision estimator's output as the delayed pose stream, possibly after retraining for that EMG device. (The hand crops there are located from mocap, but the estimator's errors are real.)

2. The results point to EMG being fresh, not to muscles "knowing first".

The title and contribution (i), "the first large-scale, cross-user measurement of how much anticipatory information sEMG carries about future hand pose", suggest that EMG lets the model see ahead. The paper's own numbers say otherwise:

  • Most of the recovery is kinematic. Of the 4.5° added by 300 ms of latency, kinematic forecasting recovers 1.7° and EMG another 1.0°. Most of the 61% in the abstract therefore comes from the kinematic forecaster, not from EMG.
  • The physiological lead is small. At L = 0, where only physiology separates the two streams, EMG is worth 5.6%, about 0.17°.
  • EMG is no better than kinematics at detecting an upcoming movement before it starts (App. E).
  • The gain is freshness. By the authors' own synchronized-delay control, most of the EMG gain, seven to thirteen points, comes from EMG not being delayed rather than from it being ahead.

The paper reaches this conclusion itself. my concern is that the title and contribution (i) don't. To me, this is best described as fusing a fresh but noisy signal with a delayed but accurate one, which is the classical delayed-measurement fusion problem, as usually shown in camera–IMU fusion. I'd suggest bringing the title and contribution (i) in line with the paper's own conclusion, or explaining what is anticipatory beyond freshness.

3. The baseline that best matches the freshness story is missing.

If the benefit comes from freshness, the obvious thing to try is an existing EMG decoder anchored to the delayed pose and run forward on the most recent EMG. The released vemg2pose tracking checkpoint is built to integrate from a known starting pose, but in Table 2 it only gets the true pose once every 5.9 s. Even so, it reaches 9.28° at Δ = 100 ms, far better than the regression decoders (13.3–14.0°) and not far from holding a 300 ms-old pose (8.41°). Re-initializing it from q(t−L) at every tick, or fusing its output with the stale pose in a delayed-measurement Kalman filter, would be cheap and would use existing models. Without this anchored baseline, I can't tell how much the cross-attention design adds over a simple fusion of existing parts. A smaller point: since most of the recovery is kinematic (point 2), ALIEN (Wei et al., 2025), a learned motion predictor for arbitrary latency that the paper cites, would also be a natural comparison.

Questions for authors
  1. Are the contact-task results in Sec. 5.2 (92/83/67%) from models trained and run on the clean mocap stream? And does the testbed add any robot-side delay, or does each tick directly execute the 20 ms slice of the forecast?

  2. Could you rerun the contact tasks with the pose stream degraded to the Table 4 chains (at least MediaPipe and WiLoR), and with each command applied 100 ms after it is issued (Δ = 100 ms)? If MKF keeps most of its advantage over Kin-only there, I'd be much more convinced by the teleoperation claim.

  3. If the gain comes from EMG being fresh, the simplest way to use it would be to take an existing EMG decoder and anchor it to the delayed pose. Could you try the released vemg2pose tracking checkpoint, restarted from q(t−L) at every tick, both on its own and with its output fused with the stale pose in a delayed-measurement Kalman filter? If MKF still clearly beats these, that would show the cross-attention design adds something beyond just combining existing parts.

6 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Author Response to Reviewer 5y2c (Part 1/3: Overview & W1)

Thank you for the thorough, constructive review and for recognizing the practical value of calibration-free, cross-user sEMG compensation across arbitrary latencies. We are especially grateful for the three concrete tests you suggested: (1) testing MKF on real RGB pose outputs from EgoEMG, (2) rerunning contact tasks under WiLoR/MediaPipe degradations with a 100 ms execution delay, and (3) restarting vemg2pose from q(t−L)q(t - L) every tick alone and inside a Delayed-Measurement Kalman Filter. We ran all three experiments in full, report the complete results directly below in your exact order, and released our code and MuJoCo suite at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/muscles-know-first-34799/.


W1: "The EMG is real, but the teleoperation isn't" — (1) no human in the loop, (2) synthetic vs. real tracker errors (EgoEMG), and (3) clean/20 ms contact tasks

Response: We appreciate these insightful comments and address your three sub-points in exact order:

  • (1) First — Why no human in the loop (offline replay vs. live adaptation): We use offline replay deliberately to isolate open-loop forecasting accuracy from operator adaptation: in live teleoperation, operators facing delay instinctively slow down ("move-and-wait") and never repeat the exact same motion twice, which masks true compensation rates across baselines (No compensation, Kin-only, DM-KF, MKF). Replaying emg2pose (370 h, 193 users) tests all controllers on identical ground-truth trajectories; closing the loop with human-in-the-loop adaptation on physical hardware is our immediate next step (clarified in Abstract, Sec. 1, Sec. 6).

  • (2) Second — Synthetic AR(1) noise vs. real pose-dependent RGB tracker errors (EgoEMG): We agree that zero-mean AR(1) noise can be smoothed out in time-averaged MAE whereas real RGB estimators have pose- and occlusion-dependent bias. Following your suggestion, we tested MKF directly on EgoEMG's released RGB pose estimator stream across 32 training (7.4 h), 3 validation, and 5 held-out unseen test subjects (8-channel MindRove wristband, Δ=100 ms\Delta = 100\text{ ms}, scored against motion capture across all 4 protocols without selection; added in Sec. 5.1 & Appendix G.4 Table 22):

EgoEMG Protocol (Real RGB Pose + 8-Channel sEMG)RunsL=0 msL = 0\text{ ms}L=100 msL = 100\text{ ms}L=200 msL = 200\text{ ms}L=300 msL = 300\text{ ms} (Kin →\to MKF, Gain [range])
1. Raw envelope, trained on real RGB17.13° →\to 7.18° (-0.7%)7.66° →\to 7.70° (-0.5%)8.19° →\to 8.22° (-0.4%)8.68° →\to 8.71° (-0.4%)
2. DC + comb-notch, trained on real RGB27.37° →\to 7.39° (-0.3%)7.92° →\to 7.90° (+0.3%)8.45° →\to 8.39° (+0.6%)8.94° →\to 8.88° (+0.8% [+0.1, +1.4%])
3. DC + comb-notch, mocap-trained →\to RGB test37.59° →\to 7.50° (+1.2%)8.19° →\to 8.06° (+1.7%)8.77° →\to 8.57° (+2.3%)9.30° →\to 9.05° (+2.7% [+1.7, +3.7%])
4. Synth.-noise mocap-trained →\to RGB test17.34° →\to 7.31° (+0.3%)7.89° →\to 7.82° (+0.9%)8.42° →\to 8.31° (+1.2%)8.90° →\to 8.78° (+1.3%)

Raw consumer-band DC offsets (-31 to -61 mV, Protocol 1) hurt cross-user transfer, whereas after DC + 50 Hz comb-notch filtering (Protocols 2–4), sEMG gains grow monotonically with latency (+0.8% RGB-trained; +2.7% across 3/3 runs zero-shot from mocap to real RGB at L=300 msL=300\text{ ms}). These gains are smaller than on emg2pose (+8.7%–11.0%), matching our scaling curve (Table 10): EgoEMG has 50×50\times less training data (7.4 h / 32 users, 8 channels — below our ~40-user saturation point) plus a ~7.1° pose-dependent RGB bias even at L=0L=0.

  • (3) Third — Contact tasks rerun under Table 4 degradations + 100 ms robot-side delay: Rerunning all three MuJoCo contact tasks under HOT3D + WiLoR and HOT3D + MediaPipe degradations with a 100 ms execution queue (D=100 msD = 100\text{ ms}) (full table in Q2 below), while Kin-only lowers time-averaged MAE by smoothing noise, that temporal smoothing lags sharp grasp closures and withdrawals—so MKF's lead over Kin-only widens from +5.6 pp to +12.4–13.0 pp on Catch and reaches +22.4–24.5 pp on Gate (added in Sec. 5.2 Table 6 & Appendix G.3 Table 21).
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Author Response to Reviewer 5y2c (Part 2/3: W2, W3 & Q1)

W2: Meaning of "Muscles Know First," stream freshness, and the 61% breakdown

Response: We appreciate this insightful comment; we updated the Abstract and Sec. 1 (Contribution i) so the split between kinematic forecasting and sEMG freshness is completely explicit:

  • Why muscles arrive first at the controller: From a vision-based robot controller's standpoint, "Muscles Know First" describes the arrival order of motor signals (Fig. 1c): muscle activity reaches the wristband ~50–200 ms before finger motion (EMD) and another L∈[100,300] msL \in [100, 300]\text{ ms} before the camera pipeline delivers that motion. Rather than claiming pre-onset intention decoding from rest (which our Appendix E rules out), our contribution is separating and measuring both parts—showing that while the L=0L=0 physiological lead is 5.6% (0.19°), sEMG freshness across (t−L,t](t - L, t] grows the cross-user gain over Kin-only to +16.4% (1.18°) at L=300 msL=300\text{ ms}.

  • Updated Abstract & Contribution (i): We now state Kin-only (38% recovery, 8.41° → 6.69°) and MKF (61% full-system recovery to 5.66°, +15.4% over Kin-only; +16.4% [6.86° → 5.73°] across all 20 unseen users) side-by-side, compare contact tasks directly against Kin-only, and rewrite Contribution (i) in plain terms to emphasize that the gain comes mainly from observing live muscle activity during the camera's 100–300 ms delay window rather than from the smaller physiological lead at zero latency.


W3: Value of cross-attention over per-tick anchored vemg2pose / Delayed-Measurement KF, and ALIEN

Response: We appreciate the insights and valuable suggestion. As shown in Q3 below, restarting vemg2pose from q(t−L)q(t - L) every tick (alone or inside two DM-KF variants) removes multi-second drift (10.22° → 6.99°), yet still trails even Kin-only (6.86°), whereas MKF (5.73°) beats every anchored/KF variant by 1.26°–1.51° (18%–24%) on 20/20 unseen users while running 7×7\times faster (1.35 ms vs. 9.75 ms same-GPU forward median). Integrating local sEMG steps from a single stale pose misses ongoing deceleration, joint limits, and multi-finger coordination present in the 1 s pose history—confirming that cross-attention adds substantial value beyond combining existing parts. We also expanded Sec. 2 on ALIEN (Wei et al., CVPR 2025), noting that as a pose-only arbitrary-latency predictor, ALIEN shares Kin-only's (t−L,t](t - L, t] blind window—and our lag-conditioned Kin-only serves as the exact backbone-matched pose-only counterpart on 20-DoF hands.


Q1: Were Sec. 5.2 contact results on clean mocap, executing the 20 ms slice directly?

Response: We appreciate this insightful question—yes, your reading is exact, and we apologize that this was not stated more prominently. The original Sec. 5.2 tasks used models trained and run on clean delayed mocap poses and executed each tick's Δ=20 ms\Delta = 20\text{ ms} prediction at the next 50 Hz step (D=20 msD = 20\text{ ms}, with no extra robot-side delay), while Table 4 (now Table 5) degraded models were tested on tracking MAE (clarified in Sec. 5.2, and extended to degraded vision + D=100 msD = 100\text{ ms} in Table 6 / Q2 below).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Author Response to Reviewer 5y2c (Part 3/3: Q2 & Q3)

Q2: Rerunning contact tasks under MediaPipe and WiLoR degradations with 100 ms execution delay (Δ=100 ms\Delta = 100\text{ ms})

Response: We greatly appreciate this helpful suggestion. We reran all three MuJoCo contact tasks under HOT3D + WiLoR and HOT3D + MediaPipe pose degradations and an explicit 5-tick FIFO command queue (executing the Δ=100 ms\Delta = 100\text{ ms} forecast slice via a 5-tick FIFO queue, D=100 msD = 100\text{ ms}, 400 ms total delay at L=300 msL = 300\text{ ms}) on identical ground-truth events across our 200-recording unseen-user benchmark (10 recordings ×\times 20 users, 347+196+101=644347 + 196 + 101 = 644 events, with user-cluster 95% CIs) (added in Sec. 5.2 Table 6 & Appendix G.3 Table 21):

Pose Stream (L=300 msL = 300\text{ ms})Delay DDCatch (n=347n=347) No/Kin/MKF (MKF$-$Kin [95% CI])Gate (n=196\) No/Kin/MKF (MKF$-$Kin [95% CI])Release (n=101\) No/Kin/MKF (MKF$-$Kin [95% CI])
Clean mocap (3 runs)20 ms57.9 / 79.9 / 85.5% (+5.6 [+2.1,+9.4])10.7 / 70.1 / 86.9% (+16.8 [+10.6,+25.6])48.5 / 55.8 / 71.3% (+15.5 [+7.7,+25.3])
Clean mocap (3 runs)100 ms50.7 / 78.8 / 84.0% (+5.2 [+1.5,+9.8])6.6 / 62.8 / 82.1% (+19.4 [+12.9,+27.2])48.5 / 48.8 / 63.4% (+14.5 [+7.6,+22.4])
HOT3D + WiLoR20 ms47.3 / 73.8 / 83.6% (+9.8 [+4.7,+15.9])11.2 / 58.7 / 85.7% (+27.0 [+16.3,+39.8])40.6 / 47.5 / 59.4% (+11.9 [+3.7,+22.0])
HOT3D + WiLoR100 ms45.0 / 74.1 / 86.5% (+12.4 [+8.4,+16.8])7.1 / 55.1 / 77.5% (+22.4 [+12.1,+34.0])42.6 / 42.6 / 59.4% (+16.8 [+2.7,+32.3])
HOT3D + MediaPipe20 ms44.7 / 70.0 / 83.0% (+13.0 [+8.8,+18.1])9.7 / 47.5 / 73.5% (+26.0 [+17.9,+34.4])26.7 / 39.6 / 59.4% (+19.8 [+9.0,+32.8])
HOT3D + MediaPipe100 ms43.8 / 67.4 / 80.4% (+13.0 [+8.1,+19.1])8.7 / 49.0 / 73.5% (+24.5 [+15.8,+34.7])25.7 / 38.6 / 45.5% (+6.9 [-5.4,+17.3])

(The original 51-recording set shows the same D=100 msD = 100\text{ ms} gains: WiLoR +14.2 / +50.0 / +10.2 pp; MediaPipe +15.9 / +43.3 / +2.0 pp.) Rather than shrinking, MKF's advantage over Kin-only widens under tracker noise and D=100 msD = 100\text{ ms} on Catch (+5.6 →\to +12.4–13.0 pp, p≤7×10−6p \le 7 \times 10^{-6}) and Gate (+16.8 →\to +22.4–24.5 pp, p≤4×10−11p \le 4 \times 10^{-11}), as Kin-only's noise smoothing lags rapid transitions.


Q3: Released vemg2pose restarted from q(t−L)q(t - L) every tick, alone and fused in a Delayed-Measurement KF

Response: We greatly appreciate this valuable suggestion. Using the released recurrent vemg2pose tracking model strictly causally (poses up to t−Lt - L, 2 kHz sEMG up to tt, with Kalman filter weights tuned strictly on the validation split), we tested Anchored vemg2pose (pose hold / +velocity) and two Delayed-Measurement Kalman Filters (State-Buffer: a two-state position–velocity Kalman filter rolled forward across (t−L,t](t - L, t] via vemg2pose velocity updates; Linear Fuse: precision-weighted fusion) across all 20 unseen users (2,172 files) at Δ=100 ms\Delta = 100\text{ ms} (added in Sec. 4 Table 3 [bottom] & Appendix G.2 Table 20):

Method (Δ=100 ms\Delta = 100\text{ ms}, 20 Unseen Users)Same-GPU Fwd MedianL=100 msL = 100\text{ ms}L=200 msL = 200\text{ ms}L=300 msL = 300\text{ ms}Users Beaten by MKF (L=300L=300)
Stale q(t−L)q(t-L) / Pose-only KF<0.1 ms6.91° / 7.03°8.47° / 9.38°9.26° / 11.32°20/20 / 20/20
Anchored vemg2pose (hold / +velocity)9.75 ms6.08° / 5.75°6.99° / 6.73°7.28° / 6.99°20/20 (+20.3% / +17.7%)
DM-KF (State-Buffer / Linear Fuse)9.80 ms5.77° / 5.75°6.80° / 6.73°7.58° / 7.01°20/20 (+24.1% / +18.0%)
Kin-only Transformer (3 runs)0.89 ms5.05°6.19°6.86°20/20 (median +16.6%)
MKF (Ours, 3 runs)1.35 ms4.41°5.22°5.73°—
  • (1) Cross-attention beats modular re-anchoring on 20/20 users: Per-tick restarting removes drift (10.22° → 7.28°), just as you predicted, yet even at Δ=0 ms\Delta = 0\text{ ms} (6.07°) and Δ=20 ms\Delta = 20\text{ ms} (6.20°) at L=300 msL=300\text{ ms}, anchored vemg2pose/DM-KF has higher error than MKF's 100 ms future forecast (5.73°), as single-pose integration misses 1 s kinematic context (deceleration, joint limits, synergy).

  • (2) 7×7\times faster inference: Re-running vemg2pose's sequential 50 Hz LSTM from t−Lt - L to tt every tick takes 9.75 ms same-GPU forward median (single-sample streaming, 95th percentile 14.9 ms), versus 1.35 ms same-GPU forward median for MKF (vs. 8.5 ms end-to-end on RTX 3090 in Table 12).

Comments on the paper

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General response to the AC and all reviewers

Dear Area Chair and Reviewers,

We are grateful to the Area Chair for handling our submission, and to Reviewers XsUM, o4ie, and 5y2c for their careful, constructive reviews and thoughtful engagement during the discussion.

Strengths noted by the reviewers.

  • Calibration-free, plug-and-play compensation across users and latencies. All three reviewers highlight the practical value of pairing delayed vision with a fresh wrist sEMG stream (XsUM, o4ie, 5y2c). Unlike prior sEMG delay predictors that train one model per user for a fixed delay, a single MKF network serves any latency L∈[0,300] msL \in [0, 300]\,\text{ms} on unseen users with zero per-user calibration (5y2c: "removing per-user calibration is what would make this usable in practice").
  • Convincing causal attribution. Three control groups—time-shuffled, synchronized-delay, and zeroed sEMG—jointly isolate live sEMG timing during the (t−L,t](t-L, t] blind window as the true source of gain (o4ie: "The causal attribution is convincing rather than correlational"; 5y2c).
  • Reusable scientific knowledge for teleoperation. Beyond proposing a fast two-stream forecaster (8.5 ms8.5\,\text{ms} end-to-end; 1.35 ms1.35\,\text{ms} GPU forward median), the study "turns a widely held intuition into quantitative engineering knowledge that future teleoperation systems can build on" (o4ie).

Key advantages established in our follow-up experiments (all integrated into the revised PDF in blue; code and standalone MuJoCo suite at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/muscles-know-first-34799/):

  1. Universal cross-user gain (o4ie, 5y2c, XsUM). Across all 20 held-out unseen users (2,172 recordings, 171,577 windows, 3 runs; Table 1), MKF cuts L=300 msL=300\,\text{ms} tracking error from 9.26∘9.26^\circ (uncompensated) and 6.86∘6.86^\circ (Kin-only) to 5.73∘5.73^\circ (+16.4%±0.3%+16.4\% \pm 0.3\%)—improving 20/20 unseen users at every latency in every run (median +16.6%+16.6\%) and winning 23/23 gesture stages (Table 3 & Table 23), including wrist flexion/abduction (+20.0%+20.0\%), forearm rotation (+22.2%+22.2\%), and full-arm reaching (+28.5%+28.5\%).
  2. End-to-end cross-attention decisively beats modular re-anchoring & Kalman fusion (5y2c). Restarting the released recurrent vemg2pose tracker from q(t−L)q(t-L) every tick—alone or inside two validation-tuned Delayed-Measurement Kalman Filters—trails even Kin-only (6.99∘–7.58∘6.99^\circ\text{--}7.58^\circ vs. 6.86∘6.86^\circ), whereas MKF (5.73∘5.73^\circ) beats every anchored/KF variant by 18%–24%18\%\text{--}24\% on 20/20 unseen users while running 7×7\times faster (1.35 ms1.35\,\text{ms} vs. 9.75 ms9.75\,\text{ms}, Table 1 & Table 3).
  3. Larger task-level margins under realistic tracker noise and 100 ms100\,\text{ms} execution delay (o4ie, 5y2c). Across 644 feasible contact events from all 20 unseen users (3 runs, 10k user-cluster bootstrap 95% CIs; Table 6), MKF lifts Catch, Gate, and Timed-Release success at L=300 msL=300\,\text{ms} from 58/11/49%58/11/49\% (uncompensated) and 80/70/56%80/70/56\% (Kin-only) to 86/87/71%86/87/71\% (pmax⁡≤0.033p_{\max} \le 0.033). Under real egocentric tracker degradations (WiLoR, MediaPipe) plus a 100 ms100\,\text{ms} execution delay (400 ms400\,\text{ms} total delay), MKF's lead over Kin-only widens further to +12.4–13.0 pp+12.4\text{--}13.0\,\text{pp} on Catch (pmax⁡≤7×10−6p_{\max} \le 7\times 10^{-6}) and +22.4–24.5 pp+22.4\text{--}24.5\,\text{pp} on Gate (pmax⁡≤4×10−11p_{\max} \le 4\times 10^{-11}), with 93.0% of degraded-vision error reduction driven by active motion frames (Sec. 5.1).

Post-discussion consensus across all three reviewers:

  • Reviewer XsUM confirmed maintaining their positive rating for "the novel exploration of the problem and well-verified results on the benchmark."
  • Reviewer o4ie confirmed that the new experiments "substantially address my main concerns" and concluded: "Overall, I consider my principal soundness concerns addressed," with all three requested revision items now fully incorporated into the uploaded PDF.
  • Reviewer 5y2c confirmed: "The anchored baseline solves my w3. so basically mkf beats every variant on 20/20 unseen users, and the rewritten contribution is a nice improvement too... So I'm happy with the core result on emg2pose now," with all table/headline alignments updated in the final PDF.

We sincerely thank all three reviewers and the Area Chair again for their valuable insights, which have made MKF much stronger!

Best regards, MKF Team

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

The motivation and vision behind Muscles Know First (MKF)

Dear Area Chair and Reviewers,

Beyond our point-by-point responses, we would like to briefly share the motivation and broader vision behind Muscles Know First (MKF).

Vision-based teleoperation has become the most accessible way for our community to control dexterous robot hands and collect manipulation demonstrations [1, 2], because an RGB camera requires no exoskeleton, no data glove, and no markers. Yet every vision pipeline pays an unavoidable latency tax (150–400 ms150\text{--}400\,\text{ms} from capture, pose inference, transport, and actuation [3]): the robot always executes a hand pose the operator has already left, forcing operators to slow down into unnatural "move-and-wait" motion [4] precisely when fast, contact-critical dexterity matters most.

Purely visual forecasting hits a physical ceiling: during the (t−L,t](t-L, t] delay window, a delayed camera sees nothing at all. When an operator suddenly initiates a grasp, withdraws from an obstacle, or opens the fingers to release, extrapolating stale poses cannot react to a motor command that has not yet entered the visual stream.

Our core motivation is simple: while the camera is still processing the past, an electrical wristband on the forearm is already reading the present—and the near future. Muscle activation precedes finger force physiologically, and arrives with negligible electrical delay. Previously, however, sEMG delay compensation required per-subject calibration for a fixed delay, preventing real-world adoption at scale. By training a single latency-conditioned cross-attention forecaster on 370370 hours across 193193 people [5], MKF shows for the first time that calibration-free commodity wrist sEMG reliably bridges the camera's blind window across 20/20 unseen operators and arbitrary vision delays in real time (8.5 ms8.5\,\text{ms}), without accumulating drift.

Just as low-cost wrist cameras became a standard sensor on manipulation platforms, we envision a slip-on, calibration-free sEMG wristband paired with any camera becoming a standard, plug-and-play modality for dexterous robotics—first to make bare-hand teleoperation responsive at natural human speed, and ultimately so that every demonstration our community records captures not only delayed visual geometry, but also timely muscle intent and contact effort for learning dexterous policies. We thank the reviewers again for questions and suggestions that sharpened both the science and the clarity of this work.

Best regards,

MKF Team


References: [1] Y. Qin et al., "AnyTeleop: A General Vision-Based Dexterous Robot Arm-Hand Teleoperation System", RSS, 2023. [2] A. Khazatsky et al., "DROID: A Large-Scale In-The-Wild Robot Manipulation Dataset", RSS, 2024. [3] E. Godden et al., "Robotic Characterization of Markerless Hand-Tracking on Meta Quest Pro and Quest 3 Virtual Reality Headsets", IEEE TVCG, 2025. [4] T. B. Sheridan and W. R. Ferrell, "Remote Manipulative Control with Transmission Delay", IEEE Trans. Human Factors in Electronics, 1963. [5] S. Salter et al., "emg2pose: A Large and Diverse Benchmark for Surface Electromyographic Hand Pose Estimation", NeurIPS, 2024.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.