acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Generalised Counteractive Reinforcement Learning

Abstract

Reinforcement learning has been the epicenter of immense scientific progress over the past decade, standing at the forefront of transformative advancements that enable agents to learn in high-dimensional spaces solely by interacting with an environment via trial and error without any supervision. Nonetheless, the learning process remains highly sensitive to the dimensions of the environment; as MDP complexity grows, the search space expands, agents continue to face a fundamental tension between complexity and policy success. Related to this disparity, recent work established a principled approach revealing that counteractive actions result in experiences with higher temporal differences. While influential, these results were founded on the assumption of discrete action spaces. In this work we focus on overcoming this tension and the agent’s interaction with high-dimensional MDPs. We introduce a theoretically grounded foundational paradigm for reinforcement learning that accelerates the learning process without introducing any computational complexity. Our analysis demonstrates that learning with counteractive actions is a principled basis for scalable and efficient training. We conduct extensive experiments in high-dimensional complex MDPs and the empirical results verify the theoretical analysis provided in our paper demonstrating that generalized counteractive reinforcement learning results in accelerated and effective learning.

Primary area:
reinforcement learning
Keywords:
counteractive learning, temporal difference learning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_6AXrOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes a novel method to improve the exploration strategy of the deep RL algorithms. The method is to sample in actions that have relatively low estimated Q values. The paper proves that sampling lower estimate Q values will result in larger TD errors and provide interesting mathematical statements that local maximals correlates to lower Q-values. Experiment show that by changing the exploration strategy, it yeilds higher training efficiency and asympotatic results comparing to other results.

Critical strengths
  1. The method is interesting and simple, but the gap is substantial empirically.
  2. The focus of the problem is long but overlooked field in deep RL algorithms.
Critical weaknesses

The explroation issue has been explored in many prior works like RND back in 2017/18/19. Though some of the methods are more complicated than the proposed method, it is still worth comparision with all the existing methods. the method focus on locomotin tasks only, however, it is unclear whether this method are useful in other RL tasks. the mathematcial results is not directly related to the results. why exploring large TD error placed will have better results and trainin efficiency?

Questions for authors
  1. explain the correlation from theory findings with the empricial results.
  2. compare with prior works on RL exploration.
1 comment

We are truly glad to hear that you found that our method provides substantial improvements in training efficiency and higher asymptotic performance in a long standing overlooked field of deep RL algorithms, and further that our approach is interesting and simple.

  1. ”Why exploring large TD error placed will have better results and trainin efficiency?”

The rather well known fact regarding higher temporal difference and faster learning is a foundational principle in reinforcement learning and can also be found in quite early work starting from [1], which is also cited in our paper.

[1] Andrew W Moore and Christopher G Atkeson. Prioritized sweeping: Reinforcement learning with less data and less time. Machine Learning, 1993.

  1. "Explain the correlation from theory findings with the empricial results."

The theoretical result of Theorem A.4 shows that sampling counteractive actions i.e. actions with values lower than the current policy on average, will lead to larger temporal difference updates. As we also discussed above, the fact that larger temporal differences lead to faster learning is a foundational principle in reinforcement learning [1]. In Section 3 through Theorem 3.6 and 3.12, we prove that counteractive actions can be sampled from the tails of the current policy distribution. In Section 4 and Section 5, we report empirical analysis results, and these results verify the theoretical analysis in Section 3 and demonstrate that CoAct-PG obtains larger temporal difference updates and indeed leads to faster learning and substantially better asymptotic performance.

  1. ”The explroation issue has been explored in many prior works like RND back in 2017/18/19.”

We would like to kindly point out that RND [1] doubles the number of parameters that need to be trained and learned. The focus of these methods includes introducing high computational cost and sample complexity to obtain high scores for a few selected games, while our objective is to increase sample efficiency across the entire benchmark without introducing computational complexity which is perfectly aligned with very recent work [2]. Our algorithm introduces zero additional computational cost and complexity while achieving effective and efficient learning across the entire benchmark. Further note that prior work (NeurIPS 2025 Spotlight) [2] already demonstrated that Counteractive RL performs substantially better than count-based methods (UCB), epsilon greedy, NNs and CFN.

[1] Yuri Burda, Harrison Edwards, Amos Storkey, Oleg Klimov. Exploration by Random Network Distillation, ICLR 2019.

[2] Counteractive RL: Rethinking Core Principles for Efficient and Scalable Deep Reinforcement Learning, NeurIPS 2025. [Spotlight Presentation]

Reviewer_5jU1OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper shows that the learning with counteractive actions that targeting at the low state-action values improves the scalable and efficient RL training. The counteractive actions increases the temporal differences and potentially induce more unique experiments. Various experiments in multi-dimensional MDPs verify the improved performance.

Critical strengths

This paper extends the counteractive RL from discrete state/action space to the continuous space and shows the performance improvements compared with other baseline algorithms. The counteractive actions sample module is easy to understand, and authors also provide the explanations whether this could work from the policy geometry view.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The proposed method's performance heavily relies on the counteractive action sample policy Λϕ(⋅∣s)\Lambda_{\phi}(\cdot|s), but how to get this distribution is not clearly shown in the paper.
  2. The theoretical assumptions such as strict concavity of Q and bounded third-order derivatives in definition 3.4 may need more justifications. Also, the defintion A.1 that assume normal action and counteractive actions have similar immediate reward is too strong. Further justifications of these assumptions are required.
  3. A larger TD error may not guarantee better performance, and the link between these two are missed in the analysis.
  4. The MuJoCo tasks only have 2-8 action dimensions, so the ability to scale up to higher dimensions is not shown in the experiments.
Questions for authors

Please refer to the weakness part.

1 comment

We are truly glad to see that you found our paper clear, easy to understand and follow, showing the performance improvements, and further interesting, providing insights from the policy geometry view. We truly appreciate you valuing the presentation, soundness and quality of our paper highly.

  1. ”The proposed method's performance heavily relies on the counteractive action sample policy Σϕ(⋅,s)\Sigma_\phi(\cdot,s), but how to get this distribution is not clearly shown in the paper.”

Counteractive actions are sampled from the tail of the policy distribution itself.

  1. The theoretical assumptions such as strict concavity of Q and bounded third-order derivatives in definition 3.4 may need more justifications. ”

In here, strict concavity is only for nearby a local maximum, i.e. that the local maxima are non-degenerate peaks of the function. The bounded third-order derivatives just mean the Q function cannot have extreme fluctuations in curvature. These are the "well-behaved" conditions that are canonically used to justify why sufficiently small step sizes allow gradient descent to converge, the same foundational intuition underlying modern deep learning optimization.

  1. “A larger TD error may not guarantee better performance, and the link between these two are missed in the analysis.”

The rather well known fact regarding higher temporal difference and faster learning is a foundational principle in reinforcement learning and can also be found in quite early work starting from [1], which is also cited in our paper.

[1] Andrew W Moore and Christopher G Atkeson. Prioritized sweeping: Reinforcement learning with less data and less time. Machine Learning, 1993.

  1. "Also, the defintion A.1 that assume normal action and counteractive actions have similar immediate reward is too strong. Further justifications of these assumptions are required."

This is the main counterintuitive principle that yields accelerated learning via counteractive actions which has also been established by the prior work [1]. This counterintuitive principle can be better understood when we understand the difference between the optimal state-action value function Q∗Q^* and QθQ_\theta. In particular, the difference between aQθmina_{Q_\theta}^\text{min} and aQ∗mina_{Q^*}^\text{min} is the defining factor of how counteractive actions result in higher temporal differences.

[1] Counteractive RL: Rethinking Core Principles for Efficient and Scalable Deep Reinforcement Learning, NeurIPS 2025. [Spotlight Presentation]

  1. ”The MuJoCo tasks only have 2-8 action dimensions, so the ability to scale up to higher dimensions is not shown in the experiments.”

The term "high-dimensional" refers to the contrast between continuous state-action spaces and the small, finite discrete action settings of prior work [1]. Even for an R111×R8\mathbb{R}^{111} \times\mathbb{R}^8 continuous state action space, naive discretization with just 10 bins per dimension produces 10810^8 actions per state, making prior discrete methods intractable.

[1] Counteractive RL: Rethinking Core Principles for Efficient and Scalable Deep Reinforcement Learning, NeurIPS 2025. [Spotlight Presentation]

Reviewer_4qWbOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

In this work the Authors present an extension of the counteractive RL framework (Korkmaz, 2025) to high-dimensional continuous settings. The Authors formally characterize their setting and present CoAct-PG as a method which exploits counteractive exploration for continuous control. Authors claim their methodology makes the learning process more efficient without adding computational complexity and justify this claim by an empirical evaluation over the MuJoCo tasks against standard RL baselines.

Critical strengths
  • The proposed methodology only modify the data collection without adding extra computation.
  • The algorithm is easy to implement and can be theoretically coupled with any RL algorithm.
Critical weaknesses
  • The overall paper presentation is messy and makes the work hard to follow. Experimental evaluation is presented over several figures with wrong caption, overclaimed results and organized in an unclear way. One of the main theoretical result for the approach is shown only in the appendix, and the Section 3 presentation of the setting is just a sequence of lemmas with little or none intuition provided by the Authors.
  • The method is not fully specified. Authors present CoAct PG in Alg. 1 without giving any details on how it was implemented for the experimental evaluation. The paper does not say how counteractive actions are generated in practice. Section 3 suggests sampling from the “low-density tails” of the policy, but it does not give any more details. It also does not say whether the critic is used to select them, or whether they are simply drawn far from the policy mean without relying on the critic estimate. Moreover, there are no information regarding the value of ϵ\epsilon or any other hyperparameter adopted in the experimental evaluation.
  • The results obtained are overclaimed. There is no evidence that "CoAct-PG achieves a 60.98% higher performance over the baseline". Fig. 6 show statistically equivalent performance on walker and slightly better performance on HalfCheetah. Fig. 3 can not be evaluated since there are no detail on how ϵ\epsilon-greedy was implemented, making all the comparison with the method unclear and not fair. Finally, Fig. 4 do not show this 60.98% overall improvement in the performance.
  • At the beginning of Section 4, DDPG is listed as a baseline, but it never appears in the following result presentation.
  • Fig. 5 does not show that counteractive transitions help. The critic is trained mostly on actions close to the policy, so it is less accurate on actions the agent rarely takes, and any such action will produce larger TD errors. The choice of using TD3 as a baselines for this figure makes little sense to me. A more informative analysis should have been performed against ϵ\epsilon-greedy.
  • The bound presented in Thm A.4 is informative only when D(s)>2δ+ηD(s) > 2\delta + \eta, which is when the critic is wrong about the counteractive actions. There is no comment in the paper that shows that larger TD errors lead to faster learning.

Minor:

  • The paper initially cite reasoning models as an example which motivates the work, but are never mentioned later on and are not part of the experimental evaluation.
  • The baselines (DDPG, TD3, SAC, PPO) and the objectives analyzed in Section 3 are not cited.
  • The chain MDP, which is presented as motivating example, is a discrete MDP, so it does not test the any of the paper contribution.
  • Fig. 1 caption say that the results shown are on Ant and Hopper, but to me it seems only Ant.
  • Fig. 2 show clearly 4 curves, but only two are labeled.
Questions for authors

See weaknesses

1 comment

We are glad to see you found that our method is widely usable, easy to implement, can be theoretically coupled with any RL algorithm, and does not introduce any computational complexity.

  1. ”The results obtained are overclaimed. There is no evidence that "CoAct-PG achieves a 60.98% higher performance over the baseline".

There is indeed evidence provided in our paper and this is verified by the results reported in page 8 in Table 1 and CoAct-PG indeed achieves a 60.98% higher performance over the baseline.

  1. ”The bound presented in Thm A.4 is informative only when D(s)>2δ+nD(s)> 2\delta + n, which is when the critic is wrong about the counteractive actions. There is no comment in the paper that shows that larger TD errors lead to faster learning.”

The rather well known fact regarding higher temporal difference and faster learning is a foundational principle in reinforcement learning and can also be found in quite early work starting from [1], which is also cited in our paper.

[1] Andrew W Moore and Christopher G Atkeson. Prioritized sweeping: Reinforcement learning with less data and less time. Machine Learning, 1993.

  1. "Fig. 5 does not show that counteractive transitions help. The critic is trained mostly on actions close to the policy, so it is less accurate on actions the agent rarely takes, and any such action will produce larger TD errors. The choice of using TD3 as a baselines for this figure makes little sense to me. A more informative analysis should have been performed against \epsilon-greedy."

We would like to kindly point out that, Figure 5 indeed shows that counteractive actions help. The central point of counteractive transitions is that low value actions will lead to faster learning with further higher asymptotic performance. The results reported in Figure 1, 3, 4, 6 and Table 1 indeed verifies the extensive and rigorous theoretical analysis in Section 3 and Section A.1., and demonstrate that the CoAct-PG learns much faster and substantially higher performing policies.

  1. ”The method is not fully specified. Authors present CoAct PG in Alg. 1 without giving any details on how it was implemented for the experimental evaluation. The paper does not say how counteractive actions are generated in practice.”

As also has been described in the paper, CoAct PG identifies counteractive actions by sampling from the low-density tails of the policy, and this directly corresponds to sampling c⋅σc\cdot\sigma standard deviations away from the mean μ\mu of the policy distribution itself.

Comments on the paper

1 comment

Dear Reviewers and Area Chair,

We thank you for investing your time to review our paper. We are truly glad that

Reviewer 4qWb found that our method is widely usable, easy to implement, can be theoretically coupled with any RL algorithm, and does not introduce any computational complexity.

Reviewer 5jU1 found our paper interesting, clear, easy to understand and follow, showing clear performance improvements, and further, providing insights from the policy geometry view. We truly appreciate Reviewer 5jU valuing the presentation, soundness and quality of our paper highly.

Reviewer 6AXr found that our method provides substantial improvements in training efficiency and higher asymptotic performance in a long standing overlooked field of deep RL algorithms, and further that our approach is interesting and simple.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.