acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Spatial But Not Temporal Reward Sparsity Drives Slow Policy Learning

Abstract

A primary difference between reinforcement and supervised learning is that rewards are generally sparse in both space and time: few actions yield high reward (spatial sparsity), and rewards may only be provided after temporally extended sequences of actions (temporal sparsity). How these factors impact policy learning dynamics is undertheorized, especially because it is difficult to design a theoretical setting interesting enough to capture relevant phenomenology, but simple enough to treat analytically. In this paper, we propose and analytically solve a minimal model of learning to pursue a moving target which naturally incorporates both spatial and temporal reward sparsity. We show mathematically that spatial sparsity can produce exponential slowdowns in learning, and that temporal sparsity is comparatively benign, only yielding a comparatively short additional phase of pursuit trajectory refinement. We also show that the presence of highly variable environmental state features can—without complex function approximators—produce an implicit curriculum effect which makes learning from sparse rewards polynomially rather than exponentially slow. We provide a wealth of relevant calculations, whose utility is in part that they sharpen our intuitions about reward sparsity.

Primary area:
learning theory
Keywords:
reinforcement learning, policy learning, sparse rewards, theory, learning dynamics

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 1%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 3.67 over 3 reviews, above 99% of the others.
Reviewer_Z3VrOpenReview ↗
Rating
4
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

The paper analyzes the impact of spatially and temporally sparse rewards on policy learning for a particular type of problem, i.e., pursuing a moving target in a continuous space.

Critical strengths
  1. The direction is interesting and relevant to the RL community. It provides structural insights into the impact of spatial and temporal factors of reward sparsity which could help to devise better algorithms.
  2. The paper is well-motivated and presented with a clear outline, notation, and illustrations. Since I am no expert in this field, there is a chance that I missed some details, though.
Critical weaknesses

The paper focuses on a very specific problem type (i.e., moving target pursuit), which limits the generality of the analysis.

Questions for authors

None

1 comment

Thank you for reading our paper and for your kind words. We did our best to make some highly technical content comprehensible, and are very glad you found it clear.

We absolutely agree that our focus was on a very specific problem type. We think this focus was reasonable given that considering a specific setting allows us to perform a much more mathematically detailed analysis, but it does leave open questions related to how well our conclusions generalize to more realistic settings (e.g., nontrivial environmental transitions, value learning, sampling noise...). Although a broad empirical study would probably bloat the paper too much, we still think it could be interesting to include some empirical results for more realistic environments. We've done some pilot studies like this already, and so far our main conclusions (e.g., spatial sparsity can cause exponential slowdowns) have held even if various assumptions are relaxed.

Reviewer_Uh9hOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper does a theoretical analysis of the role of reward spatial sparsity versus temporal sparsity in the convergence of a gradient descent-based REINFORCE agent that has knowledge of the dynamics but doesn't have knowledge about the location of the goal, and it only receives sparse reward when close to the goal (spatial sparsity controlled by a parameter in the model). There is also temporal sparsity in the problem in that the agent has to take multiple actions and then it receives reward. The authors ask the question of which one of spatial versus temporal sparsity is more detrimental for convergence. This is a very interesting and important problem in RL, as in most practical RL applications reward is sparse and a rigorous understanding of types of reward sparsity and its effect on convergence is definitely missing in the literature. The paper shows that spatial sparsity controls the sample complexity rather than temporal sparsity. Showing that only in a regime where spatial sparsity is not very large (or, equivalently, exploration noise is very large to account for the reward sparsity), the agent can learn in polynomial time (polynomial in initial error); otherwise, the convergence time is exponential in the initial error. The authors show that allowing the goal to change, hence making the problem harder, actually helps with convergence time. They split the learning dynamics into a faster and a slower part and show that in this case the faster part dynamics evolves such that it sets up a polynomial-time convergence problem for the slower part, hence forming an implicit curriculum.

Critical strengths

-The paper's research question is very interesting, important, and novel. I am well familiar with exploration literature and haven't seen such a study before.

-The paper is extraordinarily well written!! For a heavy theory paper, it reads very well and easily. The authors do an amazing job abstracting away the details of the proof and only showcasing the big picture and intuitions in the main text while also giving sufficient technical details to make it sound and grounded.

  • The theoretical results seem sound, and the use of gradient descent dynamics to obtain results is a great choice as it makes the problem closer to practical setups.

  • The analysis done in Section 5 and the discovery of the implicit curriculum is very interesting and surprising.

  • The paper starts by showing the solution to a simpler version of the problem and builds on that to introduce the more elaborate version later, an approach that is very helpful in understanding the concept.

Critical weaknesses
  • The main weakness of the paper is the way it models spatial versus temporal sparsity. The agent knows the model of the environment and can decide the overall movement for the entire episode in one shot, so in that sense it is really like a linear bandit as opposed to RL. Time is only incorporated into the model through an effort cost that assigns a cost for each action in each timestep. This is not a good model that shows the importance of difficulty of temporal sparsity. Temporal sparsity in practice makes problem much harder because the dynamics in faraway states are unknown, but since the authors assume the dynamics is known that difficulty is never captured. I would argue that just by looking at the model itself even without reading the proof it was kind of clear that the spatial sparsity is the main difficulty in this problem formulation, as the problem can be solved without taking time into account and once goal was reached one can optimize for single steps. I still think the paper is valuable and the model and math is interesting but i would ask the authors to acknowledge this limitation and also suggest a few ways to alternative their model to take harder temporal sparsity into account for future work. For instance if they take learning the environment dynamics into account and if the eniornment dynamics is time dependent (to capture state dependency) the real difficulty of temporal sparsity is revealed.
Questions for authors
  • Can you make it clearer that your model only models a very special and simple type of temporal sparsity difficulty and suggest a few ways to adjust the model to incorporate a more realistic setup for future work?

  • Can you rewrite lines 63-69 in a clearer and more intuitive way?

  • There is no reference to the figures in the main text, and this makes the figures separate from the paper and easy to miss. Incorporate the messages of the figures into the main text, please.

  • You introduce the exploration noise covariance matrix BtB_t, giving the impression that this is part of the policy and should be optimized, but later in Section 3 you assume it to be constant and solve the ODE only for bb, make this clearer in the main text. Also explain why it is a reasonable assumption that B~\tilde{B} is isotropic. What is the implication of this assumption for κ\kappa?

  • In Equation 19, B∗B^* is obtained as a function of Δb\Delta b, this means the learner should know Δb\Delta b to set the right exploration noise variance, but this is unrealistic since bfb_f is unknown.

  • In Section 6 you don't take the convergence time of WW into account; how would that change the convergence time?

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal (part 1)

Thank you for reading our paper and for your kind words. We did our best to make some highly technical content comprehensible, and are very glad you found it clear. We hope our comments below address your remaining concerns, but please let us know if they do not!

Acknowledging issues with our formulation of temporal reward sparsity

The main weakness of the paper is the way it models spatial versus temporal sparsity. The agent knows the model of the environment and can decide the overall movement for the entire episode in one shot, so in that sense it is really like a linear bandit as opposed to RL. Time is only incorporated into the model through an effort cost that assigns a cost for each action in each timestep. This is not a good model that shows the importance of difficulty of temporal sparsity. Temporal sparsity in practice makes problem much harder because the dynamics in faraway states are unknown, but since the authors assume the dynamics is known that difficulty is never captured. I would argue that just by looking at the model itself even without reading the proof it was kind of clear that the spatial sparsity is the main difficulty in this problem formulation, as the problem can be solved without taking time into account and once goal was reached one can optimize for single steps. I still think the paper is valuable and the model and math is interesting but i would ask the authors to acknowledge this limitation and also suggest a few ways to alternative their model to take harder temporal sparsity into account for future work. For instance if they take learning the environment dynamics into account and if the eniornment dynamics is time dependent (to capture state dependency) the real difficulty of temporal sparsity is revealed.

Can you make it clearer that your model only models a very special and simple type of temporal sparsity difficulty and suggest a few ways to adjust the model to incorporate a more realistic setup for future work?

This is a great point, and another reviewer (UPvb) has a similar issue. We absolutely agree that our model of temporal sparsity is quite limited, and that the nature and consequences of temporal sparsity are usually more complex. In particular, we agree that issues like closed-loop control and unknown (and possibly quite complex) environmental state dynamics add difficulties that we do not really consider here, which plausibly qualitatively change the nature of the problem.

We should disclose here that part of our goal in working out this paper's theory was to build tools and intuitions for understanding how temporal aspects of RL affect learning. Ideally, this paper is a springboard, and in future work we can tackle some of these issues---maybe not all at once, but perhaps we can gradually get closer. At least in our experience, if temporal aspects of RL are considered in theories along these lines, control is 'open-loop' or actions are assumed not to affect state transitions (see, e.g., this paper that inspired us: https://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10404). In other words, while our model of temporal sparsity is simple, we think this reflects the field's current (limited) understanding.

We propose to deal with this issue in two ways. First, we will add more extensive commentary of it to the Discussion (and to an appendix if we run out of space). This includes commenting on some of the ways we could make the model richer (e.g., closed-loop control, more complex environment dynamics...) and speculating on how they could change our high-level results.

Second, we think it would be interesting to add some simple RL experiments with a slightly more complex pursuit environment. This would probably be close to the setting of the paper, but more complex in ways we can't address mathematically yet: we could make control closed-loop, rewards be provided throughout an episode rather than just at the end, and we could play with different target trajectories to make state dynamics more interesting. While it would bloat the paper to explore this setting exhaustively, we think a few targeted experiments could help convince the reader that our high-level conclusions still hold in more complex RL environments. We've already piloted some simple, small-scale experiments along these lines, so we're fairly confident this is true.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal (part 2)

(continued)

Technical points

You introduce the exploration noise covariance matrix BtB_t, giving the impression that this is part of the policy and should be optimized, but later in Section 3 you assume it to be constant and solve the ODE only for bb, make this clearer in the main text.

Great point, we will edit the text to make this clearer. (Part of the issue in the original version was space, but this issue isn't as bad if there's an extra page.)

We chose not to optimize BtB_t for a few reasons. The most important one is that it makes the math a lot harder; REINFORCE gradients with respect to BtB_t are messier than gradients with respect to bb and WW. It's already quite hard to carry out a detailed mathematical analysis of the model we study, and we made choices like this to keep it as tractable as possible.

The secondary reason is that we discovered an interesting connection between the 'optimal' choice of BtB_t (Sec. 5) and feature-variability-associated weight dynamics (Sec. 6); this connection is pretty clean if BtB_t is not optimized, but becomes less so otherwise.

Also explain why it is a reasonable assumption that B~\tilde{B} is isotropic. What is the implication of this assumption for κ\kappa?

Recall that κ\kappa effectively controls the 'reward radius', with the agent only receiving appreciable (target-associated) reward if they are within 1/κ1/\sqrt{\kappa} of the target. Also recall that B~−1:=(1/κ)I+∑t=0M−1Bt−1Δt .\tilde{B}^{-1} := (1/\kappa) I + \sum_{t=0}^{M-1} B^{-1}_t \Delta t \ . The assumption that B~\tilde{B} is isotropic is equivalent to assuming that all of the BtB_t are isotropic. This is reasonable if there's no reason to prefer being more exploratory along one spatial direction than another. For example, in a pursuit kind of setting, being 'more exploratory' might mean I just generally try out more random actions, rather than (say) only trying out more actions along the xx-axis.

We make the isotropic B~\tilde{B} assumption in Sec. 3 (spatial sparsity -> learning slowdown) because it allows us to derive a pretty clean formula for convergence time. Without that assumption, it doesn't seem like such a simple formula is possible to derive (although one expects the behavior to be pretty similar for slightly anisotropic B~\tilde{B}).

In Equation 19, B∗B^* is obtained as a function of Δb\Delta b, this means the learner should know Δb\Delta b to set the right exploration noise variance, but this is unrealistic since bfb_f is unknown.

This is a great point. We think it ultimately has to do with what one means by an 'optimal' exploration policy. One possible meaning is that it is optimal given the agent's current knowledge; clearly, with respect to that definition, our notion of B∗B^* doesn't make sense, because (exactly as you say) bfb_f is unknown.

On the other hand, one could also define an 'optimal' exploration policy as one which maximizes learning gradients, regardless of what the agent knows. This is what we assume here, and it's subtly different from the above 'optimal given the agent's knowledge' definition. We like to think of it as, if you are a teacher watching a student learn to catch a target, how should you set the target radius to help them learn as quickly as possible? The teacher could know bfb_f, and instruct the learner to be more or less exploratory depending on how close they are to reaching the target on average. But this is just an interpretation, of course.

This point is a bit subtle, so we will try to comment on it explicitly in the revised version. Thanks for pointing this out to us.

In Section 6 you don't take the convergence time of WW into account; how would that change the convergence time?

This is a very astute observation! We tried really hard to derive a more precise convergence time result that takes WW dynamics into account (i.e., an expression analogous to Eq. 8), but we were unfortunately unable to do this. It may be the case that there just doesn't exist a nice closed-form formula for this.

This is why we used the time scale separation strategy. If the weights change much more quickly than the biases, then (due to the implicit curriculum effect), the convergence time essentially becomes the same as in the pure bias case when the 'optimal' BtB_t curriculum is used. One doesn't expect adding WW dynamics to slow things down, so this suggests that the convergence time outside this regime is somewhere between having no weights (Eq. 8) and using the optimal curriculum (Eq. 23). This is a bit heuristic, of course.

We're not sure how to tackle this problem theoretically, so we think the simplest thing to do would be to add some supplementary plots showing what happens when the time scale separation idea doesn't quite hold. We expect the above intuition to be roughly correct, and saw something like this in earlier experiments, but this remains to be checked.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal (part 3)

(continued)

Clarity of prose

Can you rewrite lines 63-69 in a clearer and more intuitive way?

Certainly! Is this clearer?

Before:

We show that temporal sparsity causes agents to learn to reach the target before they optimize their pursuit trajectories, and that the time between these phases is determined by a certain matrix's eigenvalues.

We show that, when there are highly variable environmental state features, an effect due to learning dynamics makes learning polynomially rather than exponentially slow.

After:

We show that temporal sparsity causes agents to learn to reach the target before they optimize how they get to it, and we connect the delay between these phases of learning to the eigenvalues of a certain matrix.

We show that when environmental state variance is high, learning involves transient weight increases that effectively increase exploration and make learning polynomially rather than exponentially slow.

Missing figure references

There is no reference to the figures in the main text, and this makes the figures separate from the paper and easy to miss. Incorporate the messages of the figures into the main text, please.

This was an embarrassing oversight on our part! We apologize for the error and will fix this in the updated PDF.

Reviewer_UPvbOpenReview ↗
Rating
4(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
3
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper tries to separate two reasons sparse rewards can make learning hard: the rewarding region is small, and the reward comes only after a sequence of actions. The authors study a simple target-pursuit model with a linear Gaussian policy, an endpoint reward, and an effort cost. In the mean-update limit, they find that spatial mismatch can make learning exponentially slow. They also explain why reaching the target and improving the path happen at different rates.

Critical strengths
  • Splitting spatial and temporal sparsity is a good question. The model lets the authors work through the distinction rather than just offer intuition.
  • The eigenvalue analysis gives a clear reason for learning the endpoint first and refining the path later.
Critical weaknesses
  • I'm not convinced by the broad wording about temporal sparsity. When M increases, T stays fixed, so the same physical interval is just split into more steps. Appendix A.2 also scales the learning rate by M, and the noise and initialization are chosen to control endpoint statistics. These choices are reasonable for the model, but they matter for the claim that the rate doesn't depend on M. This isn't the same as making a real task take longer.
  • The ODE averages away sampling noise. That leaves out how often a finite batch actually gets a useful reward, and how noisy the gradient becomes as a sequence gets longer. A mean gradient can behave well while being expensive to estimate. I'd keep the claims about learning dynamics separate from claims about sample complexity.
  • The temporal structure is quite special. Actions add linearly to the endpoint, different steps have separate parameters, and there is no closed-loop feedback or irreversible intermediate mistake. The effort cost is what drives path refinement. This is a useful setting, but it leaves out a lot of what makes delayed credit assignment hard elsewhere.
  • The implicit curriculum needs large feature variability, timescale separation, and a small enough effort term. I'd like to know how much of the effect survives when those assumptions are only roughly true. Right now, its range of usefulness is hard to judge.
Questions for authors
  1. What do the rates look like if the per-parameter learning rate stays fixed as M grows? This needn't produce an exponential penalty, but it would make the role of the rescaling clearer.
  2. What happens if step duration stays fixed and total duration T grows instead?
  3. Does finite-batch REINFORCE still show the endpoint/refinement split? How does the sampling budget needed to see it change with M?
  4. How large does the feature variability need to be for the implicit curriculum to show up? How much timescale separation is really needed?
  5. Can you show one small extension with shared parameters or feedback? I'd also narrow the title and abstract to what the model actually establishes.
5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal (part 1)

Thank you for reading our paper and for your helpful comments. We hope our comments below address your remaining concerns, but please let us know if they do not!

Acknowledging issues with our formulation of temporal reward sparsity

The temporal structure is quite special. Actions add linearly to the endpoint, different steps have separate parameters, and there is no closed-loop feedback or irreversible intermediate mistake. The effort cost is what drives path refinement. This is a useful setting, but it leaves out a lot of what makes delayed credit assignment hard elsewhere.

Can you show one small extension with shared parameters or feedback? I'd also narrow the title and abstract to what the model actually establishes.

This is a great point, and another reviewer (Uh9h) has a similar issue. We absolutely agree that our model of temporal sparsity is quite limited, and that the nature and consequences of temporal sparsity are usually more complex. In particular, we agree that issues like closed-loop control and unknown (and possibly quite complex) environmental state dynamics add difficulties that we do not really consider here, which plausibly qualitatively change the nature of the problem.

We should disclose here that part of our goal in working out this paper's theory was to build tools and intuitions for understanding how temporal aspects of RL affect learning. Ideally, this paper is a springboard, and in future work we can tackle some of these issues---maybe not all at once, but perhaps we can gradually get closer. At least in our experience, if temporal aspects of RL are considered in theories along these lines, control is 'open-loop' or actions are assumed not to affect state transitions (see, e.g., this paper that inspired us: https://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10404). In other words, while our model of temporal sparsity is simple, we think this reflects the field's current (limited) understanding.

We propose to deal with this issue in two ways. First, we will add more extensive commentary of it to the Discussion (and to an appendix if we run out of space). This includes commenting on some of the ways we could make the model richer (e.g., closed-loop control, more complex environment dynamics...) and speculating on how they could change our high-level results.

Second, we will add some simple RL experiments with a slightly more complex pursuit environment. This would probably be close to the setting of the paper, but more complex in ways we can't address mathematically yet: we could make control closed-loop, actions at different time steps share parameters, rewards be provided throughout an episode rather than just at the end, and we could play with different target trajectories to make state dynamics more interesting. While it would bloat the paper to explore this setting exhaustively, we think a few targeted experiments could help convince the reader that our high-level conclusions still hold in (at least some) more complex RL environments. We've already piloted some simple, small-scale experiments along these lines, so we're fairly confident this is true.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal (part 2)

(continued)

Technical points related to MM scaling

What do the rates look like if the per-parameter learning rate stays fixed as M grows? This needn't produce an exponential penalty, but it would make the role of the rescaling clearer.

This is a good question. Fortunately, the answer is pretty easy to arrive at. Because we expressed convergence times explicitly in terms of the learning rate η\eta when we derived them in Appendix B, we can see that making the change η→η/M\eta \to \eta/M (where we divide in order to undo our original multiplication by MM) just adds a factor of MM to the overall convergence times.

In other words, without compensating for the number of time steps, convergence automatically takes MM times longer with the same fixed learning rate. This kind of makes sense, since there are MM actions to learn (rather than 11, say).

Another way of saying this is: we tried to make the comparison between different MM fairer by increasing the learning rate with MM. If we don't do this, having to learn more actions is always (kind of trivially) harder / more time-consuming.

What happens if step duration stays fixed and total duration T grows instead?

Because the problem is set up so that only the ratio M:=T/(Δt)M := T/(\Delta t) matters (i.e., if we increase TT and Δt\Delta t but keep MM constant, every aspect of the setting is the same), this question is mathematically equivalent to the question of what happens if we increase MM. As we argue in the paper, not much changes---at least assuming η\eta scales with MM. Otherwise, as we just showed above, learning takes MM times longer.

I'm not convinced by the broad wording about temporal sparsity. When M increases, T stays fixed, so the same physical interval is just split into more steps. Appendix A.2 also scales the learning rate by M, and the noise and initialization are chosen to control endpoint statistics. These choices are reasonable for the model, but they matter for the claim that the rate doesn't depend on M. This isn't the same as making a real task take longer.

The way we look at it (sort of related to our previous answer), what really matter is not the absolute amount of time TT per episode, but the time TT relative to the only other time scale that matters, the time Δt\Delta t between successive agent actions. The main thing that seems to make learning harder is there being more things to learn (i.e., higher MM), although if this is compensated for in various ways (through scaling the learning rate and initialization with MM, as you point out) the effect becomes essentially negligible.

Our setup isn't perfect, but we think it has two virtues. First, there is a well-defined M→∞M \to \infty (continuous-time) limit, which is theoretically nice. Second, by scaling the learning rate and initialization with MM, we (at least in our view) remove the 'trivial' reasons increasing MM makes learning harder in order to isolate the more interesting ones.

In any case, you're absolutely correct that our MM-related claims depend on our assumptions (e.g., related to learning rate scaling). This is something we'll clarify in the revised Discussion, since it's a conceptually important point.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal (part 3)

(continued)

Other concerns

The ODE averages away sampling noise. That leaves out how often a finite batch actually gets a useful reward, and how noisy the gradient becomes as a sequence gets longer. A mean gradient can behave well while being expensive to estimate. I'd keep the claims about learning dynamics separate from claims about sample complexity.

Good point, we will try to better acknowledge the limitations of our model in the Discussion.

Does finite-batch REINFORCE still show the endpoint/refinement split? How does the sampling budget needed to see it change with M?

Our pilot experiments say the answer is yes, our high-level conclusions (e.g., regarding the endpoint/refinement split) still hold when finite-batch REINFORCE simulations are considered. We see the same MM scaling (as long as the batch size is not too small). Our impression is that our strong assumptions are required for mathematical analysis, but that our conclusions still more or less hold when they are somewhat relaxed in experiments.

How large does the feature variability need to be for the implicit curriculum to show up? How much timescale separation is really needed?

The implicit curriculum needs large feature variability, timescale separation, and a small enough effort term. I'd like to know how much of the effect survives when those assumptions are only roughly true. Right now, its range of usefulness is hard to judge.

We will do some simple experiments checking this. Based on some pilot experiments, our impression is that feature variability doesn't actually have to be that large (even on the order of ∼1\sim 1 is kind of fine, which is encouraging because 11 is much less than infinity).

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.