- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The authors present a harness for formal math reasoning and code verification using Lean. The core idea is to have a coordinator model that will revise the entire proof plan based on the feedback from prover subagents. The paper applies the harness to strong frontier models (Fable, Sol, Opus) and shows strong results on formal math and code verification benchmarks.
Critical strengths
-
The main results (Table 1) are strong. The proposed harness outperforms the native harnesses of the base models (Claude Code and Codex respectively), at any level of reasoning effort. The improvement on FATE-X, a less saturated benchmark, is particularly noteworthy.
-
The case studies in Section 4.5 (particularly, the first one) supports the motivation that repairing a subgoal locally can get stuck in a loop, whereas the harness can escape it via a global coordinator revising the entire proof strategy.
Critical weaknesses
- (Major) The novelty of the paper seems overstated.
- The paper claims that its main contribution is: its global coordinator is able to receive feedback from prover subagents and repair the overall proof strategy (lines 20-24, 142-149). However, the authors seem to mischaracterize related works, e.g., Godel-Architect [1] and Hilbert [2]. Appendix C.3 in the Goedel-Architect paper shows that their blueprint refining step is also allowed to change the global structure of the blueprint: “If the lemma is structurally unfixable, drop it and re-route the nodes that depended on it.” Hilbert also mentions that “Any remaining unsolved subgoals at this point trigger a failed proof attempt, prompting us to restart the subgoal decomposition process for the theorem” (Section 3.2.2).
- (Major) The paper does not control for, or report sufficiently, on the cost.
-
The paper misses most details about the task budget allocated to different components of the harness: e.g., per-agent budget, maximum number of retries, total amount of API cost / number of tokens.
-
Prior systems (Section 4.2) mostly use older or cheaper models (e.g., DeepSeek-V4-Flash). It is unclear if the improvement in the performance is due to an improvement in the base model or the harness design.
-
The paper also compares against the same base model + native harness (Claude Code or Codex). However, since the native harness is a general-purpose harness, it is not surprising that a specially designed harness would outperform it. Also, when comparing the computation cost of the two harnesses (Appendix A), there are a few questionable choices: 1) on “Medium” questions where the native harness gets 1 or 2 correct out of 3 tries, the comparison is between 1 run of Maestro vs. all 3 runs of native harness; 2) no cost is reported on runs where Maestro fails. Intuitively, if the coordinator repeatedly tries to repair a proof, the total cost might blow up.
-
Similarly, when comparing against the baseline without using a global coordinator (Section 4.4), replicating the efforts of previous harness designs, the paper does not report any compute cost of the baseline.
- (Major) Missing details on the advantage of the global coordination
-
The paper misses quantitative analysis of 1) how often the global coordinator revises the proof; 2) whether revising the proof meaningfully contributes to a success.
-
Even in Section 4.4 where they compare against a baseline without using a global coordinator, the authors fail to provide enough experimental detail for this baseline. The list of agent roles is missing and so is the system prompt for each agent.
[1] Chung et al., Goedel-Architect: Streamlining Formal Theorem Proving with Blueprint Generation and Refinement, arXiv 2026.
[2] Varambally et al., Hilbert: Recursively Building Formal Proofs with Informal Reasoning, ICLR 2026.
Questions for authors
-
What exactly is the difference between Maestro and existing blueprint-based systems like Goedel-Architect and Hilbert? Please clarify which part of the “global coordination” is novel in this system.
-
How does Maestro compare against other baselines under the same total cost budget? Please provide a matched cost comparison: e.g., accuracy vs. budget results against at least the native harness and the no-coordinator baselines. Please also clarify the total / per-agent resource limits. Please also report on the cost of the unsuccessful runs.
-
(Minor) How were the submitted Lean proofs validated? Were there checks on ‘cheats’ (e.g., agents rewriting the target statements)?
-
(Minor) Can the authors clarify some minor discrepancies in the manuscript? For example, Appendix B says each configuration is run three times, whereas the caption in Figure 5 says the numbers were averaged across two or three runs. Also, Section 3.1 says “The planner revises until the judge accepts” (lines 211-212), but Appendix E shows that “If six proposer-judger revisions do not pass, the latest translatable ordinary plan may publish with a
JUDGER-REJECTED FALLBACKlabel.” (lines 1681-1682) Even more minor, but please clarify that ArxivLean008 in line 460 is Problem 8 from the March 2026 release of the ArxivLean. As of right now, it is confusing as to whether it is from the March / June split.
2 comments
W2 & Q2 & W3: Comparison with Goedel Architect with matched budget
We add two same-backbone comparisons with Goedel-Architect at matched budgets. In particular, we use 1) Claude Opus 5 with high reasoning effort as the backbone on the FATE-X dataset; 2) Qwen3.8 27B with xhigh reasoning effort as the backbone on the AlgoVeri dataset with only proof generation. We compare Maestro with Goedel-Architect’s official code release and report the solved rate with a matched cost budget. We can see that, for each budget, our method achieves a similar or higher solve rate compared to Goedel-Architect. With a growing budget, Goedel-Architect’s solve rate plateaus at 80% on FATE-X and 36% on AlgoVeri while our proposed method reached 93% and 56%, respectively. This demonstrates the superiority of our method. We revised our paper by adding a visualization of these results in Appendix C.
Table 1: Same backbone comparison with matched budget on FATE-X
| Method | $0.25 | $0.50 | $1 | $2 | $5 | $10 | $20 | $50 | $100 | $200 | $500 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Goedel-Architect | 0% | 2% | 6% | 22% | 43% | 50% | 61% | 74% | 79% | 79% | 80% |
| Maestro | 1% | 3% | 6% | 21% | 37% | 51% | 63% | 80% | 84% | 90% | 93% |
Table 2: Qwen3.8 backbone comparison with matched budget on AlgoVeri
| Method | $0.01 | $0.02 | $0.05 | $0.10 | $0.20 | $0.50 | $1 | $2 | $5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Goedel-Architect | 0% | 3% | 6% | 8% | 13% | 22% | 32% | 36% | 36% |
| Maestro | 1% | 4% | 9% | 13% | 22% | 30% | 42% | 48% | 58% |
Regarding the cost of failed runs, Maestro keeps attempting a proof until the budget is exhausted. When given a hard task, we want the agent to continue pursuing a solution and trying different ideas instead of giving up. Although this can incur high costs (the budget limit) on failed problems, it also increases the chance of solving a problem.
We also analyzed our proof traces on FATE-X and found that only approximately 5.6% of coordinator turns request decomposition alone. Other turns can combine redirecting provers, launching independent explorers, and making substantial edits to the workspace. Moreover, we believe the benefits of our pipeline can be clearly shown through the same-backbone, matched-budget comparison with Goedel-Architect.
Q3: Lean checking details
All proofs were checked by Lean, and we additionally verify that the original statement remains unchanged and audit the final proof to scan for any “sorry” or “admit” placeholders and disallowed axioms. A proof is counted as successful only if it passed all these checks.
Q4: Response to minor discrepancies
-
We thank the reviewer for identifying the discrepancies. Figure 5 reports results averaged over three runs. The caption was incorrectly retained from an earlier version of the figure. We will correct it in the revision.
-
In the implementation, we limit the planner-judge revision loop to six rounds to prevent repeated rejections from exhausting the available budget. If no plan is accepted within this limit, the latest translatable ordinary plan may be published with a JUDGER-REJECTED FALLBACK label, as described in Appendix E. The rejection feedback allows the coordinator to reassess the overall proof development and may prompt a more substantial revision of the proof plan. We will clarify this detail in Section 3.1.
-
Unclarity in arXivLean release. We thank the reviewer for pointing out the minor discrepancies. We fixed them in the paper.
We thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback. If our response and revision address your concerns, we would be sincerely grateful if you would consider raising your score.
We thank the reviewer for the thoughtful review. The suggestions are valuable for us to improve our work. Below, we provide a point-by-point response to the key concerns in our paper.
Q1 & W1: Clarification on the contribution of this paper
Our central motivation is that when a proof plan leads to a subgoal that resists proof, there are two important decisions to make: whether and how to revise the proof plan, and how to pursue the open goal. A mathematician might give a promising argument more time, try an idea that worked on a related subgoal, introduce more helper lemmas, or reconsider the strategy that produced the subgoal, and they do this by careful reasoning over the current overall status. In a fixed pipeline like Goedel-Architect, however, these two decisions are largely fixed, and not determined from any reasoning. Maestro gives both decisions to a coordinator that reasons from the current proof state and the evidence gathered across the proof development history. The central technical details were provided in the original submission, and we will reiterate in detail how, in Maestro, the agent made these two important decisions compared to Goedel-Architect.
Revising the proof plan. Indeed, Goedel-Architect already uses structured diagnoses and formal disproofs to revise its blueprint globally. Its refinement prompt defines a largely fixed behavior, where the model is asked to repair or remove a lemma judged false and to introduce helper lemmas when a statement appears true but too hard to prove. This basically maps “wrong lemma” to a local lemma repair, and “a hard yet true lemma” to further decomposition. However, this decision is not optimal. It’s very possible that the whole proof development has gone down an unproductive route, and the suitable repair is to fully discard the current route and reconsider another possible direction. Maestro therefore extends this refinement mechanism by letting the coordinator decide whether and how to revise the proof blueprint itself based on its reasoning about the whole proof development trajectory instead of any fixed mapping. For example, the coordinator was observed to revise a hard yet true lemma that resists several rounds of reproof and decomposition by discarding the whole route and building scaffolds that lead to a completely new proof strategy.
Pursuing the open goal. When a goal is diagnosed as PROOF_TOO_HARD, Goedel-Architect’s refinement prompt directs the model to add helper lemmas. Maestro extends this behavior by supporting multiple forms of worker dispatch (section 3.2) and letting the coordinator choose how to pursue each open goal. Dispatching a decomposer recovers Goedel-Architect’s prescribed response to this diagnosis, but the coordinator can also give a promising prover more budget, retry with targeted guidance, or launch an independent attempt. For example, if progress on a sibling lemma or the coordinator itself sees a useful reduction, the coordinator can pass it along as a hint and give the prover another chance to close the goal directly, without adding new proof scaffolding. If the same obstacle persists after several rounds of adding helper lemmas or resists several rounds of different strategies, the coordinator can reconsider the proof plan itself, launch independent explorers to investigate alternatives, and abandon the stalled route if a more promising one emerges. All these described behaviors are outside of Goedel-Architect’s capability.