acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

MAReason: Adaptive Retrieval and Deep Proof Planning for Mathematical Analysis in Lean 4

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Formal theorem proving in mathematical analysis requires finding relevant results in Mathlib, Lean's mathematical library, and connecting them into a complete argument. Language-model provers can invoke unavailable library facts or fail to turn relevant premises into a complete proof. We present MAReason, which uses Lean verification to trigger escalation around a fixed OProver-8B. It first strengthens the premise context for whole-proof generation. Persistent verification failure triggers a change in proof granularity to independently grounded and verified obligations, followed by final composition and Lean verification. MAReason-Corpus provides domain-specific, Lean-verified supervision with benchmark-overlap removal. We evaluate on MA-ProofBench's 200 problems, comprising undergraduate analysis (Level I) and Ph.D.-qualifying analysis (Level II). With eight candidates per retrieval stage and eight Deep search trajectories, MAReason raises Pass@8 from 4% to 19% on Level I and from 1% to 4% on Level II relative to direct OProver-8B, using additional staged search. Mathlib hallucination fractions among failed candidates fall from 54.6% to 49.9% on Level I and from 39.0% to 35.9% on Level II. In a separate study, domain adaptation with MAReason-Corpus improves Level I performance on the base model but solves no Level II problems. These results support domain adaptation for easier analysis proofs and verified proof planning for harder obligations.

Primary area:
other topics in machine learning (i.e., none of the above)
Keywords:
Lean 4 Formalization, Mathematical Analysis Theorem Proving, Adaptive Retrieval, Deep Proof Planning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 25%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.75 over 4 reviews, above 25% of the others.
Reviewer_k4AoOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies automatic theorem proving in Lean 4 for mathematical analysis. The authors propose MAReason, which retrieves relevant lemmas and decomposes unresolved goals into auxiliary lemmas for proof generation and repair. They also construct MAReason-Corpus from existing Lean resources. Experiments on MA-ProofBench show that the system improves proof success rates. The authors further use stage ablations and separate fine-tuning experiments to study the effects of the components and training data.

Critical strengths
  1. The authors generate auxiliary lemmas for the target theorem, prove them with separate retrieval and local repair, and combine them into a complete proof. This connects lemma generation with its actual use while allowing intermediate steps to be checked separately.

  2. Compared with direct generation using OProver-8B, the full system improves the solve rate on MA-ProofBench from 4% to 19% for undergraduate problems and from 1% to 4% for PhD qualifying exam problems.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Prover Agent [1] already generates auxiliary lemmas when direct proving fails, proves and repairs them using Lean feedback, and uses the verified lemmas to complete the target proof. This overlaps with MAReason’s core workflow, but the paper does not discuss this work or clarify the differences. The additional contribution of the proposed retrieval and planning design remains unclear.

  2. The full system uses GPT for reasoning and planning and adds proof attempts and repair rounds, but lacks comparisons with similar model support and search budgets. Its Pass@1 is computed from the batch retained after routing and is not directly comparable with the baseline Pass@1. These differences make it difficult to determine how much of the improvement comes from the proposed design.

[1] Baba et al. (2025). Prover Agent: An Agent-Based Framework for Formal Mathematical Proofs*. arXiv:2506.19923.

Questions for authors
  1. Could the authors explain the main differences between MAReason and Prover Agent? In particular, what do the retrieval and planning designs add to the existing auxiliary lemma generation and repair workflow?

  2. With the same model configuration and search budget, does MAReason still improve over a baseline that uses retrieval to generate and repair complete proofs?

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Prover Agent Comparison and Scope of Our Contribution

Thank you for your careful review. We respond to each weakness and question below.

The 100-problem comparisons discussed below are supplementary local experiments, separate from the paper's GPT/Gemini main configuration. Their solved counts are not Pass@8 results.

W1. Relationship to Prover Agent and the scope of our contribution

Thank you for pointing us to Prover Agent. We omitted this important comparison from the related work, and the original manuscript did not explain the boundaries of our contribution clearly enough. We agree that prior work has explored generating auxiliary lemmas after direct proving fails, repairing them using Lean feedback, and using them to complete the target proof. What we aim to investigate further is how to combine staged retrieval with a proof blueprint containing explicit dependencies, while establishing a separate retrieval context for each lemma. We will add a discussion of Prover Agent, distinguish the ideas we build on from our specific design choices, and explain these differences in our response to Q1.

We have now completed a local Prover Agent comparison on the same set of 100 problems, using Qwen2.5-Math-7B-Instruct and OProver-8B. In these runs, MAReason generated 8,674,232 output tokens, compared with 12,528,259 for Prover Agent, approximately 30.8% fewer. However, the two methods solved different numbers of problems, and this comparison did not show a solved-count advantage for MAReason. We therefore cannot use these output-token figures to claim better overall efficiency or proving ability. We will explain the mechanisms shared by the two systems and their specific differences, and limit our contribution claim to the organization of staged retrieval, proof obligations, and their dependencies.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Clarifying Pass@1, Auxiliary Models, and Search Budgets

W2. Pass@1, auxiliary models, and additional search

Thank you for raising these two issues. First, presenting the two Pass@1 values side by side in Table 1 can indeed be misleading. For direct generation, we generate eight complete proofs per problem, calculate the fraction that pass Lean verification, and average that fraction across all problems. For MAReason, we take the eight retained candidates from the first stage in which at least one complete proof passes verification, and calculate the same fraction. A problem receives zero if all stages fail. Earlier failed batches and intermediate lemma attempts are not included in these eight candidates. Thus, the MAReason value measures the success fraction within the post-routing batch. We will label this definition explicitly and report the number of whole problems with Lean-verified final proofs as the main outcome.

To examine the role of auxiliary models, we compared four role configurations on the separate 40-problem Hard-Dev set. Hard-Dev was selected from the fixed 2% validation subset of MAReason-Corpus, considering proof length, source, and domain coverage. Its setup is described in Section 4.3 (page 7), Table 3, and Appendix C.2. In the fully local configuration, Qwen2.5-Math-7B-Instruct handles reasoning and premise filtering, while OProver-8B handles proof blueprints, auxiliary-lemma proofs, final proofs, and repair. The other configurations replace reasoning and blueprint construction with GPT-5.6-sol (xhigh), replace filtering with Gemini-3.7-Flash, or replace both groups of roles. All four configurations use the same OProver-8B for proof generation and Lean 4.28.0 for verification.

The final Lean-verified solved counts are:

ConfigurationReasoningBlueprintFilteringSolved / 40
A: Fully localQwenOProverQwen12/40 (30.0%)
B: GPT planningGPTGPTQwen28/40 (70.0%)
C: Gemini filteringQwenOProverGemini9/40 (22.5%)
D: GPT + GeminiGPTGPTGemini29/40 (72.5%)

The fully local configuration solves 12 problems. With GPT reasoning and planning support, this increases to 28; the joint configuration solves 29, or 17 more than the fully local configuration. Final proofs are still generated by the fixed OProver-8B. These results indicate that stronger reasoning and planning support can help the same proof model complete more targets. However, B and D differ by only one solved problem, and replacing only the filter with Gemini does not improve the solved count. We will therefore distinguish the roles of the different auxiliary models carefully.

This experiment also supports your concern that auxiliary-model support has an important effect on the results. Because the role configurations do not have identical call budgets, they do not isolate improvements due to workflow design alone. These are configuration comparisons on Hard-Dev; we will report them separately from the MA-ProofBench main experiments and explain each configuration's model roles and budget.

We have also completed a local budget-tier comparison of the full workflow, standard retrieval followed by repeated sampling, and standard retrieval followed by whole-proof repair on the same 100 MA-ProofBench problems: 50 Level I and 50 Level II. The models are Qwen2.5-Math-7B-Instruct and OProver-8B, with no paid APIs. At the low-budget tier, the full workflow solves four problems, while each simpler baseline solves three. The reported mean output-token counts per problem are 77,478, 94,676, and 93,511, respectively, corresponding to approximately 18.2% and 17.1% lower output volume for the full workflow. This shows a limited benefit at the low-budget tier and lower generation output, but does not establish a general advantage across all budget tiers or in total computational cost. We will specify the budget caps and averaging scope, and separately account for generation, repair, and Lean-verification costs.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Lemma-Specific Retrieval, Proof Planning, and Baseline Comparisons

Q1. What retrieval and planning add beyond Prover Agent

Thank you for the follow-up. We share with Prover Agent the basic idea of first attempting direct proving and then using verified auxiliary lemmas to complete the target. Our specific design choices concern two aspects.

First, retrieval moves from the complete target to individual lemmas. MAReason initially uses standard and reasoning-guided retrieval to support whole-problem proving. After entering Deep Mode, it retrieves Mathlib premises separately for each lemma using the lemma statement and the overall strategy. Different lemmas can therefore receive the library facts they need, rather than sharing the same set of goal-level retrieval results. Prover Agent's method description primarily proposes auxiliary lemmas through informal reasoning and then uses the proved lemmas to reconsider the complete proof; it does not describe this lemma-specific retrieval mechanism.

Second, the dependencies between lemmas and their final connection to the target are recorded before lemma proving begins. MAReason's blueprint contains two to four auxiliary statements, the original assumptions each may use, prerequisite dependencies, and the final step connecting them to the target. The system checks the blueprint's structure and the validity of the statements, proves the obligations in dependency order, and supplies verified prerequisite lemmas to later steps. Compared with Prover Agent's exploration of special cases or intermediate facts to discover a strategy, this design places more emphasis on specifying in advance how proof obligations are organized and connected.

We will distinguish these design choices from the lemma-generation, Lean-verification, and feedback-repair mechanisms shared by both systems, so that the contribution is stated more accurately. Our comparison of the method descriptions refers to Prover Agent, Sections 3.1–3.3.

As noted in W1, the completed local Prover Agent comparison on the same 100 problems uses Qwen2.5-Math-7B-Instruct and OProver-8B. MAReason generates 8,674,232 output tokens versus 12,528,259 for Prover Agent, approximately 30.8% fewer. However, this comparison does not show a solved-count advantage for MAReason. Lower output volume therefore does not establish better overall efficiency or proving ability. We will explain both the shared mechanisms and the specific differences, and limit the contribution claim to the organization of staged retrieval, proof obligations, and dependencies.

We have also completed five local configurations on the same 100 problems: the full configuration, no proof decomposition, no node-level retrieval, no feedback repair, and Always-Deep. The auxiliary model is Qwen2.5-Math-7B-Instruct and the prover is OProver-8B. These results do not show a solved-count advantage for the full configuration. We will therefore not interpret cumulative gains across stages as evidence that every component independently helps. The revision will distinguish design motivation from experimentally established conclusions and report configurations, budget caps, and actual generation and verification use. Further component evaluation under the main model configuration remains future work.

Q2. Comparison with whole-proof retrieval and repair under the same model setup and search budget

We have completed a local budget-tier comparison of the full workflow, standard retrieval plus repeated sampling, and standard retrieval plus whole-proof repair on the same 100 MA-ProofBench problems, with 50 from each level. These runs use Qwen2.5-Math-7B-Instruct and OProver-8B without paid APIs.

At the low-budget tier, the full workflow solves four problems, while each simpler baseline solves three. The reported mean output-token counts per problem are 77,478 for MAReason, 94,676 for repeated sampling, and 93,511 for whole-proof repair. MAReason's output volume is approximately 18.2% and 17.1% lower, respectively.

These results show a limited low-budget benefit and less generation output, but do not establish superiority at every budget tier or in total computational cost. We will specify the budget caps and the scope over which the means are calculated, and separately explain generation, repair, and Lean-verification costs.

Reviewer_K4h3OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

MAReason is a staged system for Lean proving, starting from OProver8B fixed. First, it retrieves Mathlib results and asks OProver to prove the whole theorem. If Lean rejects every attempts, it tries a more detailed search for relevant results. If it fails as well, it breaks the theorem into a few auxiliary lemmas, finds results for each lemma, proves and repairs them separately, and checks the assembled proof in Lean. MAReasonCorpus is constructed as a separate training experiment. On MA-ProofBench, the full system solves 19 of 100 Level I problems and 4 of 100 Level II problems at Pass@8, compared with 4 and 1 for direct OProver-8B. These are gains for the full staged system. The experiments do not yet show how much of the gain comes from the proposed change in proof structure rather than the extra search and repair.

Critical strengths
  • The paper evaluates MAReason on MAProofBench, which contains 100 undergraduate level and 100 Ph.D. qualifying Lean 4 analysis problems. With OProver-8B, the full system solves 19 vs 4 on Level 1 and 4 vs 1 on Level 2 at Pass@8 compared with direct OProver8B, though it uses more search.
  • The authors check auxiliary statements, individual proofs, and the final assembled proof. The appendix gives a concrete trace of both a successful decomposition and a failure, which helped me understand what the system can and cannot do.
Critical weaknesses
  • The main gain is not well isolated. In Table 2, Standard Retrieval Level 1 Pass@8 increases from 4% to 12%. Reasoning Retrieval adds no further solved problems, while Deepmode improves the result to 19%. But Deepmode adds decomposition, separate retrieval for each lemma, local repair, and more attempts together. Table 1 also compares the staged systems with direct runs that use way less total searches. I think there is one missing comparison is one with a similar total compute budget. I cannot tell whether the proposed switch to smaller proof tasks is better than spending the same budget on a simpler search and repair pipeline without this ablation. The paper's pass@1 number also needs further taking care, it is measured within the batch retained after routing, not from one end to end attempt.

  • I also considered that the new contribution over existing systems is not yet convincing enough for the added complexity. MAReason builds on LeanSearchv2 for multistep retrieval, and OProver for proof generation and repair, and the broader line of work on proving through subgoals. The paper's main distinction is how it connects these parts, but it does not compare against a simpler combination of them. The end to end evaluation is also limited to one 200 problems' analysis benchmark, only 4 Level 2 problems are solved, and most problems enter the expensive Deepmode. I would like stronger evidence that this workflow is worth its cost and works beyond this setting showcasing generalizability.

Questions for authors
  • At a similar total budget of model calls, generated tokens, and Lean checks, how does MAReason compare with standard retrieval followed by more OProver attempts or compiler guided repair?

  • Which part of Deep mode accounts for the gain from 12 to 19 solved Level 1 problems: the auxiliary lemma plan, lemma specific retrieval, or local repair?

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Budget Comparisons, Deep Mode Ablations, and Generalization

Thank you for your careful review. We respond to each weakness and question below.

The 100-problem comparisons discussed below are supplementary local experiments, separate from the paper's GPT/Gemini main configuration. Their solved counts are not Pass@8 results.

W1. Attribution of the Deep Mode gains and the definition of Pass@1

Thank you for the reminder. For direct generation, the reported Pass@1 is the fraction of eight directly generated whole-problem candidates that pass Lean, averaged across all problems. MAReason instead uses the eight retained candidates from the first stage containing a Lean-verified complete proof. Problems unsolved by all stages receive zero. Earlier failed batches and intermediate lemma attempts are excluded from this candidate pool. We will explicitly label the latter metric “post-routing batch Pass@1” and use whole-problem solved counts as the main outcome.

The local budget comparison and five-configuration Deep Mode ablation have now been completed. At the low-budget tier, the full workflow solves four problems, while each simpler baseline solves three, and the reported mean output-token volume is approximately 17%–18% lower. However, the component ablation does not show a solved-count advantage for the full configuration. We therefore cannot attribute the paper's increase from 12 to 19 solved Level I problems to an individual component. The detailed results and cost-accounting scope are addressed in Q1 and Q2.

W2. Incremental contribution, complexity, and generalization

Thank you for raising the contribution and generalization questions. We agree that MAReason builds on existing retrieval, proof-generation, and repair components. Our specific focus is how, when whole-problem proving remains incomplete, the system organizes the retrieval contexts, proof obligations, and dependencies of individual lemmas, and checks whether their local proofs can be used in the final composition.

If an earlier stage already obtains a complete proof that passes Lean verification, escalation stops. Only unresolved targets enter Deep Mode. We have completed budget comparisons with simpler workflows and Deep Mode component ablations, and explain their results and limitations in Q1 and Q2. The current evidence primarily concerns mathematical analysis. It does not establish generalization across datasets or mathematical domains, and we will narrow the corresponding claims.

Q1. Comparison at similar budgets of model calls, output tokens, and Lean checks

Thank you for the suggestion on budget fairness. We have completed a local budget-tier comparison of the full workflow, standard retrieval plus repeated sampling, and standard retrieval plus whole-proof repair on the same 100 MA-ProofBench problems, with 50 Level I and 50 Level II problems. These runs use Qwen2.5-Math-7B-Instruct and OProver-8B without paid APIs.

At the low-budget tier, the full workflow solves four problems, while each simpler baseline solves three. The reported mean output-token counts per problem are 77,478, 94,676, and 93,511, respectively. The full workflow therefore uses approximately 18.2% and 17.1% fewer output tokens than the two baselines.

This shows a limited low-budget benefit and lower generation output, but does not establish a general advantage across all budget tiers or in total computational cost. We will specify the budget caps and averaging scope, and separately account for generation, repair, and Lean-verification costs. This is a comparison by budget tier; it does not mean that actual model calls, generated tokens, and verification use are all simultaneously equal across methods.

Q2. Individual contributions of planning, lemma-specific retrieval, and local repair

Thank you for suggesting that we separate the components' effects. We have completed five local configurations on the same 100 problems: the full configuration, no proof decomposition, no node-level retrieval, no feedback repair, and Always-Deep. The auxiliary model is Qwen2.5-Math-7B-Instruct and the prover is OProver-8B.

These results do not show a whole-problem solved-count advantage for the full configuration. We will therefore not interpret cumulative improvements across stages as evidence that each component independently helps. The revision will distinguish design motivation from experimentally established conclusions and report each configuration, its budget caps, and its actual generation and verification use. Further ablation under the main model configuration remains future work.

Accordingly, we cannot currently attribute the paper's increase from 12 to 19 solved Level I problems specifically to the auxiliary-lemma plan, lemma-specific retrieval, or local repair.

Reviewer_KgenOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents MAReason, a staged theorem-proving framework for mathematical analysis in Lean 4. It uses Lean verification to escalate from standard premise retrieval to sketch-guided retrieval and, if necessary, to a proof blueprint with independently retrieved, verified, and repaired auxiliary lemmas. The paper also introduces MAReason-Corpus, a collection of 309,953 Lean-verified theorem–proof pairs, and evaluates both inference-time search and domain-specific adaptation on 200 MA-ProofBench problems. MAReason improves Pass@8 over direct OProver-8B from 4% to 19% on Level I and from 1% to 4% on Level II, although these gains come with substantially more search computation.

Critical strengths
  1. A practical, verification-driven approach. MAReason uses Lean verification to decide when to move from whole-proof generation to structured decomposition. Its checks on auxiliary lemmas and final proof composition make the approach technically sound and practically useful.

  2. Substantial experiments and useful empirical findings. The paper evaluates 200 benchmark problems and includes retrieval, planning, and data ablations. The results demonstrate meaningful improvements on Level I and provide a useful analysis of the remaining challenges on Level II.

Critical weaknesses
  1. MAReason uses substantially more search than direct generation, so the reported gains cannot be attributed solely to its escalation strategy. A comparison under matched computational budgets is needed.

  2. Retrieval, decomposition, and compiler-guided repair have existing precedents. The current ablations do not clearly isolate the contribution of each component or establish that verification-triggered escalation is better than simpler alternatives.

  3. MAReason-Corpus shows some benefits at smaller sampling budgets, but ties the matched OProofs baseline at Pass@32, and all training conditions score zero on Level II. The evidence therefore supports a narrower claim about domain adaptation than a general advantage of the proposed corpus.

Questions for authors
  1. Can the authors compare MAReason with direct sampling and an always-decompose baseline under matched generation and verification budgets?
  2. Can the authors isolate the effects of decomposition, lemma-level retrieval, and compiler-guided repair while keeping the overall search budget fixed?
2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Search Budgets, Workflow Contributions, and Corpus Scope

Thank you for your careful review. We respond to each weakness and question below.

The 100-problem comparisons discussed below are supplementary local experiments, separate from the paper's GPT/Gemini main configuration. Their solved counts are not Pass@8 results.

W1. Additional search and attribution to the escalation strategy

Thank you for the reminder about budget fairness. We have completed a local budget-tier comparison of the full workflow, standard retrieval plus repeated sampling, and standard retrieval plus whole-proof repair on the same 100 MA-ProofBench problems, with 50 Level I and 50 Level II problems. These runs use Qwen2.5-Math-7B-Instruct and OProver-8B without paid APIs.

At the low-budget tier, the full workflow solves four problems, while each simpler baseline solves three. The reported mean output-token counts per problem are 77,478, 94,676, and 93,511, respectively. MAReason's output volume is approximately 18.2% and 17.1% lower than the two baselines.

This shows a limited benefit at the low-budget tier and lower generation output, but does not establish a general advantage across all budget tiers or in total computational cost. We will specify the budget caps and averaging scope, and separately explain generation, repair, and Lean-verification costs. We will therefore describe the main results as the solving performance of the specified complete system, rather than attribute the entire improvement over direct generation to the escalation strategy alone.

W2. Existing components and the contribution of verification-triggered escalation

Thank you for pointing out the overlap with existing work and the limits of the current evidence. We agree that retrieval, lemma decomposition, and compiler-feedback repair have all been studied previously; we do not claim that these components themselves are new.

Our focus is how the system progressively escalates based on Lean verification. It first attempts whole-problem retrieval and proof generation. If a stage obtains a complete proof that passes Lean, escalation stops. Otherwise, Deep Mode organizes the unresolved target into auxiliary proof obligations with explicit dependencies, establishes separate retrieval contexts for the individual lemmas, and performs local proving, repair, and final composition checks. We will explain this organization and its relationship to existing work more clearly.

The local budget comparison and five-configuration Deep Mode ablation are now complete, with detailed responses in Q1 and Q2. The low-budget tier shows a limited benefit, but the current results do not establish a general solved-count advantage for the full configuration or the independent contribution of each component. We will narrow the contribution claims accordingly and clearly distinguish the local configuration from the paper's main model configuration.

W3. Scope of the MAReason-Corpus results

Thank you for reminding us to narrow the corpus contribution. We agree that the current results support adaptation specifically to mathematical analysis, rather than general superiority across all mathematical domains.

MAReason-Corpus contains approximately 294.9k examples after domain selection and quality control. Although approximately 87.6% of its examples originate from OProofs, its size is smaller than OProofs-Matched, which contains approximately 365.8k examples. Under the paper's Goedel-Prover-V2-8B setting with one epoch of LoRA fine-tuning, its Level I Pass@1 and Pass@8 are 2.156% and 3.953%, respectively, compared with 1.688% and 3.792% for OProofs-Matched. At Pass@32, both reach 5%, and all training conditions solve no Level II problems.

We will therefore limit the conclusion to the following: in the evaluated mathematical-analysis task and experimental setting, the smaller curated corpus performs better at lower sampling budgets and ties OProofs-Matched at the larger budget. These results do not support a generalization claim across mathematical domains or on Level II.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Sampling Baselines and Deep Mode Component Ablations

Q1. Comparison with direct sampling and an always-decompose baseline

We have completed a local budget-tier comparison of the full workflow, standard retrieval plus repeated sampling, and standard retrieval plus whole-proof repair on the same 100 MA-ProofBench problems, with 50 from each level. The models are Qwen2.5-Math-7B-Instruct and OProver-8B, without paid APIs.

At the low-budget tier, the full workflow solves four problems, while each simpler baseline solves three. The reported mean output-token counts per problem are 77,478, 94,676, and 93,511, respectively, corresponding to approximately 18.2% and 17.1% lower output volume for MAReason. These are limited low-budget and generation-output benefits, not evidence of general superiority across all budget tiers or in total computational cost. We will specify the budget caps and averaging scope, and separately explain generation, repair, and Lean-verification costs.

We have also completed the five local configurations that include Always-Deep. They do not establish an overall solved-count advantage for the full workflow. Importantly, the repeated-sampling baseline here retains standard retrieval and is not equivalent to direct generation without retrieval. These local results also do not replace stricter budget attribution under the paper's main model configuration.

Q2. Component ablations under a fixed overall search budget

Thank you for suggesting that we separate the components' effects. We have completed five local configurations on the same 100 problems: the full configuration, no proof decomposition, no node-level retrieval, no feedback repair, and Always-Deep. The auxiliary model is Qwen2.5-Math-7B-Instruct and the prover is OProver-8B.

These results do not show a whole-problem solved-count advantage for the full configuration. We will therefore not interpret cumulative improvements across stages as evidence that each component independently helps. The revision will distinguish design motivation from experimentally established conclusions and report each configuration, its budget caps, and actual generation and verification use. Further evaluation under the main model configuration remains future work.

The current results do not allow us to attribute gains reliably to one component under fixed overall search expenditure. We will report actual resource use as well, rather than compare budget caps alone.

Reviewer_EjYvOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents MAReason, a workflow for proving mathematical-analysis theorems in Lean 4. With OProver-8B as the fixed proof generator, it escalates from Standard Retrieval to Reasoning Retrieval and then to Deep Mode when verification fails. This workflow uses compiler feedback for local repair before final composition. The authors report improved proof success on MA-ProofBench using this additional staged search. They also construct MAReason-Corpus and separately investigate its value for domain-specific adaptation.

Critical strengths
  1. A useful verification-guided hierarchical workflow to proof construction and repair. The workflow addresses both premise selection and incomplete proof structure. Decomposing unsuccessful whole-proof attempts into independently checked obligations makes repair more targeted, while final Lean verification ensures that the assembled proof establishes the original theorem.

  2. An informative experimental structure and a potentially useful domain resource. The evaluation examines overall effectiveness, component contributions, and domain-specific supervision separately, which help characterize the contributions and limitations of individual components. MAReason-Corpus could also provide useful infrastructure for analysis-specific prover development.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Insufficient isolation of workflow improvements from auxiliary models and additional computation. MAReason-8B uses GPT for reasoning and planning and Gemini for filtering, so its comparison with direct GPT-5.5 is not a sufficiently isolated comparison (the observed improvement is possibly gained from the extra models rather than the design of workflow itself). Although the paper explicitly acknowledges these differences and provides useful ablations, the experiments do not establish whether the workflow outperforms simpler alternatives under comparable resources (cost, both for computation-cost and time-cost). Matched-budget comparisons are needed to distinguish the benefits of escalation and decomposition from stronger model assistance and greater search effort.

  2. Limited demonstrated added value and accessibility of MAReason-Corpus. Domain-aligned supervision outperforming broader training data is useful but, by itself, provides a relatively limited methodological insight. The observed benefits are model-dependent and concentrated on easier problems, where the adaptation experiments solve no Level II problems. The corpus’s broader contribution could be its value as a reusable resource. However, the submitted manuscript provides no access link to the corpus or its construction artifacts, limiting independent validation and practical reuse.

  3. A minor presentation concern is Figure 2: inconsistent font styles and overlapped texts (e.g. "Retrieval Promises"), thus reduce its presentation score.

Questions for authors
  1. Under comparable total computational cost or wall-clock time, does MAReason outperform repeated sampling or a simpler retrieval-and-repair workflow? Can you account for planning, filtering, auxiliary proof generation, repair, and Lean verification costs together?

  2. Can you provide anonymized access to MAReason-Corpus, construction scripts, fixed splits, and experimental artifacts so that its quality, reproducibility, and reuse potential can be assessed?

I would consider increasing my rating if these concerns are well addressed.

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Auxiliary Models, Corpus Results, and Figure Presentation

Thank you for your careful review. We respond to each weakness and question below.

The 100-problem comparisons discussed below are supplementary local experiments, separate from the paper's GPT/Gemini main configuration. Their solved counts are not Pass@8 results.

W1. Effects of auxiliary models and additional computation

Thank you for pointing out how auxiliary-model configurations affect the interpretation of the results. MAReason studies the complete workflow of retrieval, planning, proof generation, and verification. We chose closed-source models for high-level planning and premise filtering to improve the reliability of these supporting stages. Final Lean proofs are still generated by OProver-8B and checked by the same Lean verifier.

We have completed a planner/filter configuration comparison. On this separate 40-problem development set, the fully local configuration uses Qwen2.5-Math-7B-Instruct for reasoning and filtering, and OProver-8B for proof blueprints, proof generation, and repair, and solves 12 problems. Replacing high-level planning and blueprint construction with GPT increases the solved count to 28. Replacing only the filter with Gemini gives nine solved problems, while using GPT planning together with Gemini filtering gives 29.

These results show a clear association between planning-model choice and final solving performance in this setting, whereas Gemini filtering does not show a consistent benefit. We will explain the configurations and their effects more clearly, and avoid attributing all improvements from auxiliary models to workflow design.

We have also completed a local budget-tier comparison of the full workflow, standard retrieval plus repeated sampling, and standard retrieval plus whole-proof repair on the same 100 MA-ProofBench problems, with 50 Level I and 50 Level II problems. These runs use Qwen2.5-Math-7B-Instruct and OProver-8B without paid APIs. At the low-budget tier, the full workflow solves four problems, while each simpler baseline solves three. The reported mean output-token counts per problem are 77,478, 94,676, and 93,511, respectively. The full workflow therefore has approximately 18.2% and 17.1% lower output volume than the two baselines.

This shows a limited low-budget benefit and lower generation output, but does not establish a general advantage across all budget tiers or in total computational cost. We will specify the budget caps and averaging scope, and separately account for generation, repair, and Lean-verification costs. This local supplementary experiment does not call GPT or Gemini. It provides additional evidence about performance with weaker auxiliary-model support, but does not replace an attribution comparison under the original closed-source-assisted configuration.

W2. Value, scope, and accessibility of MAReason-Corpus

Thank you for reminding us to clarify the scope of the corpus contribution. MAReason-Corpus is intended to provide a smaller, curated fine-tuning resource for mathematical analysis. Although most examples originate from OProofs, the question we aim to examine is whether selecting data for the target domain can improve domain adaptation compared with using broader training data directly.

Under the paper's Goedel-Prover-V2-8B setting with one epoch of LoRA fine-tuning, the Level I results are:

Fine-tuning corpusTraining examplesPass@1Pass@8Pass@32
MAReason-Corpus294.9k2.156%3.953%5.000%
OProofs-Matched365.8k1.688%3.792%5.000%
OProofs-Full1.02M1.813%2.991%3.000%

In this setting, MAReason-Corpus uses fewer examples, outperforms OProofs-Matched at lower sampling budgets, and exceeds the full-OProofs results on all three reported metrics. However, it ties OProofs-Matched at Pass@32, and all training conditions solve no Level II problems. We will therefore limit the conclusion to the observed mathematical-analysis adaptation benefit. These results do not establish a general advantage across models, mathematical domains, or harder problems.

We now provide anonymous access to the complete corpus shards, construction scripts, statistics, and verification materials to facilitate independent inspection and reuse:

MAReason corpus and construction materials

W3. Figure 2 font consistency and overlapping labels

Thank you for your careful reading and for pointing out the presentation issues in Figure 2. In the camera-ready version, we will make the fonts consistent, adjust the overlapping labels, and check readability at the figure's actual display size in the paper.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

End-to-End Costs and Anonymous Reproducibility Materials

Q1. End-to-end computational cost and wall-clock time

Thank you for raising end-to-end cost. We have completed a local comparison on the same 100 MA-ProofBench problems, with 50 Level I and 50 Level II problems, using Qwen2.5-Math-7B-Instruct and OProver-8B without paid APIs. At the low-budget tier, the full workflow solves four problems, while each simpler baseline solves three. The reported mean output-token count per problem is 77,478 for the full workflow, compared with 94,676 for repeated sampling and 93,511 for whole-proof repair, reductions of approximately 18.2% and 17.1%, respectively.

These results show a limited low-budget benefit and lower generation output. However, output tokens do not represent total computational cost: the full workflow uses more Lean checks, and the current results do not establish that it outperforms simpler baselines at every budget tier. In the revision, we will explain cost accounting for planning, filtering, proof generation, repair, and verification, and further assess comparisons under the paper's main model configuration. We will avoid describing reduced generation output as an overall efficiency advantage.

Q2. Anonymous access to the corpus, scripts, splits, and experimental artifacts

Thank you for the suggestion. We now provide anonymous downloadable MAReason-Corpus materials, including the complete corpus shards, construction and filtering scripts, quality statistics, Lean/Mathlib environment information, data manifests, checksums, and training-example IDs. Reviewers can read, verify, or reconstruct the complete corpus without rerunning the construction pipeline.

The released corpus is used entirely for fine-tuning and has no separate training/validation split. The included ID lists fix training-example membership and record order. The scope of this release is the corpus, construction code, and statistical materials.

Anonymous access: MAReason artifacts

The SHA-256 checksum of the reconstructed complete corpus is:

8f019874098fb002504632086b8ac8d717345f4a6e9c36ec408032c3eb9e9776

Thanks for the authors' thorough replies. I have no more question.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.