- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies automatic theorem proving in Lean 4 for mathematical analysis. The authors propose MAReason, which retrieves relevant lemmas and decomposes unresolved goals into auxiliary lemmas for proof generation and repair. They also construct MAReason-Corpus from existing Lean resources. Experiments on MA-ProofBench show that the system improves proof success rates. The authors further use stage ablations and separate fine-tuning experiments to study the effects of the components and training data.
Critical strengths
-
The authors generate auxiliary lemmas for the target theorem, prove them with separate retrieval and local repair, and combine them into a complete proof. This connects lemma generation with its actual use while allowing intermediate steps to be checked separately.
-
Compared with direct generation using OProver-8B, the full system improves the solve rate on MA-ProofBench from 4% to 19% for undergraduate problems and from 1% to 4% for PhD qualifying exam problems.
Critical weaknesses
-
Prover Agent [1] already generates auxiliary lemmas when direct proving fails, proves and repairs them using Lean feedback, and uses the verified lemmas to complete the target proof. This overlaps with MAReason’s core workflow, but the paper does not discuss this work or clarify the differences. The additional contribution of the proposed retrieval and planning design remains unclear.
-
The full system uses GPT for reasoning and planning and adds proof attempts and repair rounds, but lacks comparisons with similar model support and search budgets. Its Pass@1 is computed from the batch retained after routing and is not directly comparable with the baseline Pass@1. These differences make it difficult to determine how much of the improvement comes from the proposed design.
[1] Baba et al. (2025). Prover Agent: An Agent-Based Framework for Formal Mathematical Proofs*. arXiv:2506.19923.
Questions for authors
-
Could the authors explain the main differences between MAReason and Prover Agent? In particular, what do the retrieval and planning designs add to the existing auxiliary lemma generation and repair workflow?
-
With the same model configuration and search budget, does MAReason still improve over a baseline that uses retrieval to generate and repair complete proofs?
3 comments
Clarifying Pass@1, Auxiliary Models, and Search Budgets
W2. Pass@1, auxiliary models, and additional search
Thank you for raising these two issues. First, presenting the two Pass@1 values side by side in Table 1 can indeed be misleading. For direct generation, we generate eight complete proofs per problem, calculate the fraction that pass Lean verification, and average that fraction across all problems. For MAReason, we take the eight retained candidates from the first stage in which at least one complete proof passes verification, and calculate the same fraction. A problem receives zero if all stages fail. Earlier failed batches and intermediate lemma attempts are not included in these eight candidates. Thus, the MAReason value measures the success fraction within the post-routing batch. We will label this definition explicitly and report the number of whole problems with Lean-verified final proofs as the main outcome.
To examine the role of auxiliary models, we compared four role configurations on the separate 40-problem Hard-Dev set. Hard-Dev was selected from the fixed 2% validation subset of MAReason-Corpus, considering proof length, source, and domain coverage. Its setup is described in Section 4.3 (page 7), Table 3, and Appendix C.2. In the fully local configuration, Qwen2.5-Math-7B-Instruct handles reasoning and premise filtering, while OProver-8B handles proof blueprints, auxiliary-lemma proofs, final proofs, and repair. The other configurations replace reasoning and blueprint construction with GPT-5.6-sol (xhigh), replace filtering with Gemini-3.7-Flash, or replace both groups of roles. All four configurations use the same OProver-8B for proof generation and Lean 4.28.0 for verification.
The final Lean-verified solved counts are:
| Configuration | Reasoning | Blueprint | Filtering | Solved / 40 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A: Fully local | Qwen | OProver | Qwen | 12/40 (30.0%) |
| B: GPT planning | GPT | GPT | Qwen | 28/40 (70.0%) |
| C: Gemini filtering | Qwen | OProver | Gemini | 9/40 (22.5%) |
| D: GPT + Gemini | GPT | GPT | Gemini | 29/40 (72.5%) |
The fully local configuration solves 12 problems. With GPT reasoning and planning support, this increases to 28; the joint configuration solves 29, or 17 more than the fully local configuration. Final proofs are still generated by the fixed OProver-8B. These results indicate that stronger reasoning and planning support can help the same proof model complete more targets. However, B and D differ by only one solved problem, and replacing only the filter with Gemini does not improve the solved count. We will therefore distinguish the roles of the different auxiliary models carefully.
This experiment also supports your concern that auxiliary-model support has an important effect on the results. Because the role configurations do not have identical call budgets, they do not isolate improvements due to workflow design alone. These are configuration comparisons on Hard-Dev; we will report them separately from the MA-ProofBench main experiments and explain each configuration's model roles and budget.
We have also completed a local budget-tier comparison of the full workflow, standard retrieval followed by repeated sampling, and standard retrieval followed by whole-proof repair on the same 100 MA-ProofBench problems: 50 Level I and 50 Level II. The models are Qwen2.5-Math-7B-Instruct and OProver-8B, with no paid APIs. At the low-budget tier, the full workflow solves four problems, while each simpler baseline solves three. The reported mean output-token counts per problem are 77,478, 94,676, and 93,511, respectively, corresponding to approximately 18.2% and 17.1% lower output volume for the full workflow. This shows a limited benefit at the low-budget tier and lower generation output, but does not establish a general advantage across all budget tiers or in total computational cost. We will specify the budget caps and averaging scope, and separately account for generation, repair, and Lean-verification costs.
Lemma-Specific Retrieval, Proof Planning, and Baseline Comparisons
Q1. What retrieval and planning add beyond Prover Agent
Thank you for the follow-up. We share with Prover Agent the basic idea of first attempting direct proving and then using verified auxiliary lemmas to complete the target. Our specific design choices concern two aspects.
First, retrieval moves from the complete target to individual lemmas. MAReason initially uses standard and reasoning-guided retrieval to support whole-problem proving. After entering Deep Mode, it retrieves Mathlib premises separately for each lemma using the lemma statement and the overall strategy. Different lemmas can therefore receive the library facts they need, rather than sharing the same set of goal-level retrieval results. Prover Agent's method description primarily proposes auxiliary lemmas through informal reasoning and then uses the proved lemmas to reconsider the complete proof; it does not describe this lemma-specific retrieval mechanism.
Second, the dependencies between lemmas and their final connection to the target are recorded before lemma proving begins. MAReason's blueprint contains two to four auxiliary statements, the original assumptions each may use, prerequisite dependencies, and the final step connecting them to the target. The system checks the blueprint's structure and the validity of the statements, proves the obligations in dependency order, and supplies verified prerequisite lemmas to later steps. Compared with Prover Agent's exploration of special cases or intermediate facts to discover a strategy, this design places more emphasis on specifying in advance how proof obligations are organized and connected.
We will distinguish these design choices from the lemma-generation, Lean-verification, and feedback-repair mechanisms shared by both systems, so that the contribution is stated more accurately. Our comparison of the method descriptions refers to Prover Agent, Sections 3.1–3.3.
As noted in W1, the completed local Prover Agent comparison on the same 100 problems uses Qwen2.5-Math-7B-Instruct and OProver-8B. MAReason generates 8,674,232 output tokens versus 12,528,259 for Prover Agent, approximately 30.8% fewer. However, this comparison does not show a solved-count advantage for MAReason. Lower output volume therefore does not establish better overall efficiency or proving ability. We will explain both the shared mechanisms and the specific differences, and limit the contribution claim to the organization of staged retrieval, proof obligations, and dependencies.
We have also completed five local configurations on the same 100 problems: the full configuration, no proof decomposition, no node-level retrieval, no feedback repair, and Always-Deep. The auxiliary model is Qwen2.5-Math-7B-Instruct and the prover is OProver-8B. These results do not show a solved-count advantage for the full configuration. We will therefore not interpret cumulative gains across stages as evidence that every component independently helps. The revision will distinguish design motivation from experimentally established conclusions and report configurations, budget caps, and actual generation and verification use. Further component evaluation under the main model configuration remains future work.
Q2. Comparison with whole-proof retrieval and repair under the same model setup and search budget
We have completed a local budget-tier comparison of the full workflow, standard retrieval plus repeated sampling, and standard retrieval plus whole-proof repair on the same 100 MA-ProofBench problems, with 50 from each level. These runs use Qwen2.5-Math-7B-Instruct and OProver-8B without paid APIs.
At the low-budget tier, the full workflow solves four problems, while each simpler baseline solves three. The reported mean output-token counts per problem are 77,478 for MAReason, 94,676 for repeated sampling, and 93,511 for whole-proof repair. MAReason's output volume is approximately 18.2% and 17.1% lower, respectively.
These results show a limited low-budget benefit and less generation output, but do not establish superiority at every budget tier or in total computational cost. We will specify the budget caps and the scope over which the means are calculated, and separately explain generation, repair, and Lean-verification costs.
Prover Agent Comparison and Scope of Our Contribution
Thank you for your careful review. We respond to each weakness and question below.
The 100-problem comparisons discussed below are supplementary local experiments, separate from the paper's GPT/Gemini main configuration. Their solved counts are not Pass@8 results.
W1. Relationship to Prover Agent and the scope of our contribution
Thank you for pointing us to Prover Agent. We omitted this important comparison from the related work, and the original manuscript did not explain the boundaries of our contribution clearly enough. We agree that prior work has explored generating auxiliary lemmas after direct proving fails, repairing them using Lean feedback, and using them to complete the target proof. What we aim to investigate further is how to combine staged retrieval with a proof blueprint containing explicit dependencies, while establishing a separate retrieval context for each lemma. We will add a discussion of Prover Agent, distinguish the ideas we build on from our specific design choices, and explain these differences in our response to Q1.
We have now completed a local Prover Agent comparison on the same set of 100 problems, using Qwen2.5-Math-7B-Instruct and OProver-8B. In these runs, MAReason generated 8,674,232 output tokens, compared with 12,528,259 for Prover Agent, approximately 30.8% fewer. However, the two methods solved different numbers of problems, and this comparison did not show a solved-count advantage for MAReason. We therefore cannot use these output-token figures to claim better overall efficiency or proving ability. We will explain the mechanisms shared by the two systems and their specific differences, and limit our contribution claim to the organization of staged retrieval, proof obligations, and their dependencies.