- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces an unsupervised learning approach designed to model and segment the hierarchical and recurrent structure of continuous time series. The pipeline explicitly separates the modelling into two scales:
- Local scale: The UnitAlign module uses a self-supervised encoder coupled with a dynamic clustering algorithm (DeepDPM) to learn a vocabulary of basic units.
- Global scale: The MotifFormer module relies on a Transformer architecture to learn how these local units assemble to form complex patterns of variable length as texts can do. The method also incorporates a continuous maintenance mechanism that allows the unit and pattern vocabularies to evolve as the time series progress, without having to relearn everything from scratch.
Experiments have been done on 6 different datasets and compared with 6 other methods. Different metric are computed for comparison.
Critical strengths
1- This approach propose to solve the problem of over-segmentation by avoiding the fragmentation of a complex pattern however not grouping in a single pattern a sequence of recurrent units. 2- The method allows for online time series interpretation. 3- The ablation studies shows that both parts of the framework are necessary and articulated. 4- The ablation study on the encoder dependence shows that the methods is overall robust to the representation.
Critical weaknesses
1- The method often fails to reach an interesting SegRation which shows that the methods may tend to segment the signal into smaller units than required. 2- The method depends on many choices (weights in the objective functions, classifier, etc). No ablation study is proposed for them. 3- Several typos are in the References.
Questions for authors
1- The authors mention that in the UnitAligh module, they " alternate between representation adaptation and clustering until the assignments stabilize." Is the convergence ensured? What if the assignment switches form one cluster to another? Is this guiding the creation of new unit? 2- Can you explain the choice of L (eq: 3) and the influence it has on the results? 3- What is the influence of the classifier f? 4- What are the influence of all parameters in the objective functions and the chosen thresholds?
Thank you for your patience and constructive feedback. We have completed the additional experiments and analyses outlined in our earlier response and incorporated the findings into the revised manuscript.
We hope these additional experiments and clarifications address your concerns and strengthen the evidence for RONDO’s effectiveness and robustness, and we thank you again for your constructive feedback.