- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper first analyzes the differences between generated images and natural images in a statistical sense, in terms of the moment ratio and envelope variation. Then, it proposes RealSynz, a post-processing module for correcting the distribution of the generated image to be closer to that of a natural image. Specifically, the moment ratio is corrected via a closed form equation and envelope variation is corrected via redistribution of the band and adding texture. A map is estimated with a small convolutional network to act as a control field to decide where and how strongly each operation should be applied.
Critical strengths
-
The paper is very clearly written. The motivation is convincing with supporting analyses. The method is developed with a coherent storyline. The experiments make many useful observations. I enjoyed reading the paper.
-
The method is developed based on thorough analyses and observations. Closed-form solutions are used when possible, while deferring variable aspects to a small neural network. The paper overall provides a fresh perspective on how unnaturalness of generated images can be handled.
Critical weaknesses
My biggest concern is whether the proposed method indeed makes generated images look natural. I believe the most important experiment should be a perceptual study showing whether the generated images indeed look more closer to natural images (or become hard to distinguish) to the human eye. The paper defers this to future work, but I think it's a critical component to validate that the proposed ideas are indeed working. Frankly, the texture added by the proposed method in Fig 1, Fig 3, Fig 12-16 all look very synthetic to my eyes. Another good way to validate would be to run off-the-shelf synthetic image detectors (some are reviewed in l472-477) to check if they are more likely to classify the generated images as natural images after the proposed post-processing has been applied.
The paper mainly provides quantitative results showing envelope variation and moment ratio becoming more similar to those of natural images (Table 1 and Table 2), however, I believe this is an obvious result since the proposed method directly optimizes for lowering those two values.
Questions for authors
N/A
3 comments
Response to Reviewer 423X (2/2)
W3
Another good way to validate would be to run off-the-shelf synthetic image detectors (some are reviewed in l472-477) to check if they are more likely to classify the generated images as natural images after the proposed post-processing has been applied.
We selected three AI-generated image detectors:
- AIDE [1] combines the highest- and lowest-frequency patches of an image, selected by DCT, with a CLIP embedding of the whole image.
- SSP [2] classifies the noise residual of the flattest 32-pixel patch of an image.
- Community Forensics [3] is a whole-image detector trained on images from thousands of generators to generalize to unseen ones.
We used the authors' released official weights and evaluation code. For each generator, we evaluate its 1,000 generated images before and after RealSynz. The table below reports the percentage of images classified as real, where higher values indicate that fewer images are detected as synthetic.
| Generator | AIDE | SSP | Community Forensics |
|---|---|---|---|
| FLUX.2 Klein | 22.6 87.5 | 21.8 62.9 | 57.4 80.1 |
| Qwen-Image | 3.40 26.8 | 39.2 56.3 | 34.6 67.7 |
| Z-Image | 3.50 41.6 | 3.80 40.0 | 51.4 70.8 |
| FLUX.1-dev | 10.0 18.1 | 4.70 33.4 | 8.50 33.6 |
| SANA | 16.8 38.3 | 26.0 41.0 | 0.80 2.40 |
After applying RealSynz, all three detectors classify more images as real for all five generators. We have added these results to Section 3.2 and Table 1 of our revised version.
W4
The paper mainly provides quantitative results showing envelope variation and moment ratio becoming more similar to those of natural images (Table 1 and Table 2), however, I believe this is an obvious result since the proposed method directly optimizes for lowering those two values.
The effectiveness of RealSynz has been validated by the human perceptual study (W1) and the AI-generated image detectors (W3). In addition, we evaluated two additional texture statistics that RealSynz does not use for training: Portilla–Simoncelli (PS) statistics [4] are a few hundred wavelet statistics from which visually similar textures can be synthesized, and GLCM correlation [5] measures how strongly the gray levels of neighboring pixels co-vary. We compute both on 4,000 surface crops of size from the 1,000 FLUX.2 Klein generated images, before and after RealSynz, and on crops from real images. We then measure the distance between the statistics of generated and real crops, normalized so that two random halves of the real images are 1.0 apart. Lower values are closer to real images.
| Metric () | Unedited | RealSynz |
|---|---|---|
| PS distance | 1.70 | 1.42 |
| GLCM correlation distance | 3.40 | 1.30 |
The results show that RealSynz reduces both distances, even though neither statistic is used in its training. We have added these results to Appendix D.3 and Table 17 of our revised version.
[1] Yan et al. A Sanity Check for AI-generated Image Detection. ICLR 2025.
[2] Chen et al. A Single Simple Patch is All You Need for AI-generated Image Detection. arXiv 2024.
[3] Park and Owens. Community Forensics: Using Thousands of Generators to Train Fake Image Detectors. CVPR 2025.
[4] Portilla and Simoncelli. A Parametric Texture Model Based on Joint Statistics of Complex Wavelet Coefficients. IJCV 2000.
[5] Haralick et al. Textural Features for Image Classification. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics 1973.
Appreciate the authors providing the additional results. The user study, evaluation using AI image detectors, and the additional quantitative metrics that are independent of training are all great evidence supporting the proposed method. I believe they make the submission much stronger. The new qualitative figures (Fig 3, Fig 17) look much more convincing as well. My concerns have been addressed and I am confident in raising my score to 3 (weak acceptance).
Response to Reviewer 423X (1/2)
We thank the reviewer for the feedback. We conducted a human perceptual study and ran three AI-generated image detectors on generated images before and after RealSynz, as suggested.
W1
We conducted a human perceptual study with 20 participants, each of whom evaluated the same 25 image pairs, each showing an unedited image and the same image after RealSynz, and selected the one they perceived as more natural and realistic.
A participant or image favors RealSynz if RealSynz was chosen in more than half of its trials. The preference for RealSynz over the unedited images is significant and consistent. We have added the study to Section 3.2 and Table 2 of our revised version.
W2
We agree that RealSynz is not perfect, and some of the added texture can still look synthetic under strong enlargement. Nevertheless, both our human perceptual study (W1) and the AI-generated image detectors (W3) show that RealSynz consistently makes generated images more realistic than the unedited ones: participants chose the RealSynz image in 73.4% of trials, and all three detectors classify more RealSynz images as real for all five generators.