- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes PixelSR, a real-world image super-resolution framework that models restoration as a deterministic pixel-space flow from a low-quality image to a clean high-resolution image. The model predicts the clean image and derives the flow for iterative refinement. The authors also propose using the number of sampling steps to control the fidelity–perception trade-off. Experiments evaluate PixelSR on synthetic and real-world benchmarks and compare it with several diffusion-based restoration methods.
Critical strengths
-
The paper explores a clear alternative to noise-centric restoration by directly predicting clean images in pixel space. Its deterministic trajectory is a potentially useful way to reduce sensitivity to random noise and preserve input structure.
-
The evaluation covers synthetic and real-world benchmarks, includes full-reference and no-reference metrics, and studies how the number of sampling steps affects the results.
Critical weaknesses
-
The distinction from related flow-based SR methods is not sufficiently established. The paper discusses FlowSR (ICCV 2025) and FluxSR (ICML 2025), which also use flow-based trajectories for super-resolution, but does not include them in the main comparison. A clearer technical comparison is needed to support the novelty and performance claims.
-
Algorithm 1 contains an apparent typographical error. Its interpolation weights are reversed relative to Equation (1) and the inference procedure.
-
The sampling-step experiments do not consistently support a progressive fidelity–perception trade-off. For example, on DRealSR, the 10-step result outperforms the 50-step result on all reported metrics, making the effect of sampling-step count on this trade-off unclear.
-
The contribution of direct clean-image prediction is not isolated. The ablations do not compare direct HQ-image prediction with velocity prediction using the same backbone and trajectory, so the gains attributable to this prediction formulation remain unclear.
-
The claim that the trajectory remains on the image manifold is insufficiently supported. Linear interpolation between LQ and HQ images does not by itself establish that intermediate states remain on the natural-image manifold. This claim requires further explanation or supporting evidence.
Questions for authors
-
How does PixelSR differ technically from FlowSR and FluxSR?
-
Could you compare clean-image prediction with velocity prediction using the same backbone and trajectory? This would help assess the contribution of the proposed prediction formulation.
-
On DRealSR, the 10-step setting outperforms the 50-step setting across all reported metrics. How do you interpret this result, and how does it support the claimed fidelity–perception trade-off?
-
What do you mean by the claim that the interpolation trajectory remains on the image manifold?