acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

JDSG: Jitter Decreasing Shortcut Guidance for Diffusion Policy in Precision-sensitive Manipulation Tasks

Abstract

Generative behavior cloning methods such as Diffusion Policy can produce intra-chunk trajectory jitter that may compromise contact stability in precise manipulation. We first show that post-hoc trajectory-preserving jitter-minimization improves task success, suggesting that intra-chunk trajectory jitter is a contributing factor to policy failure. Our analysis indicates that effective smoothing must balance jitter reduction with preservation of the generated trajectory. However, post-hoc smoothing modifies only the completed action chunk, leaving no opportunity for iterative denoising steps to refine the trajectory. Incorporating a smoothing objective into diffusion sampling offers an alternative, but directly differentiating through the policy network introduces additional inference cost. We introduce Jitter Decreasing Shortcut Guidance (JDSG), an inference-time method that applies trajectory-preserving jitter-minimization during diffusion sampling without policy-network backpropagation. At each denoising step, JDSG adjusts the intermediate clean action estimate using a quadratic objective that penalizes third-order temporal differences and deviations from the unmodified estimate. This adjustment requires only a small linear-system solve, after which sampling proceeds using the policy’s predicted noise. On the evaluated simulation tasks, JDSG achieves higher average success rates than both the base Diffusion Policy and post-hoc jitter-minimizing optimization, including under the tested visual distribution shift. Real-world experiments further show improvements over the base policy. These findings support sampling-time, trajectory-preserving jitter-minimization as a useful approach to improving precise manipulation.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
Behavior Cloning, Diffusion Policy, Loss-based Guidance, Manipulation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_boFrOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

JDSG adds a quadratic third-difference smoothing step to the intermediate clean-action estimates of a frozen Diffusion Policy. It then continues DDIM sampling with the original noise prediction, avoiding backpropagation through the policy. The paper first compares post-hoc smoothers and then evaluates sampling-time guidance on simulated precision-manipulation tasks and two physical robot tasks. The main question is whether smoothing during sampling improves control beyond applying the same smoother to the final action chunk.

Critical strengths
  • Being able to modify a frozen policy is appealing here. JDSG needs neither policy retraining nor a backward pass through the denoiser, which makes it a plausible addition to an existing Diffusion Policy implementation.

  • The quadratic objective gives a clear way to balance jerk reduction against changes to the proposed trajectory. The resulting linear solve is simple, and the reader can inspect what the smoother is doing.

  • The initial filter comparison is useful. It considers several common smoothers and reports both trajectory change and jitter, helping distinguish aggressive smoothing from changes that also preserve task success.

  • The Tool Hang improvement on the physical robot is encouraging. Including both hanging and insertion helps establish that the intervention can be useful in contact-sensitive manipulation, even though the comparison with post-hoc smoothing is still needed.

Critical weaknesses
  • I am not yet convinced that smoothing during sampling helps enough over smoothing afterward. Correcting the reported averages leaves gains of 1.33 points in clean simulation and 0.89 under visual shift over TPJM, with no uncertainty shown. The robot experiments compare only against DP, leaving the most relevant control out.

  • The comparison with established smoothing methods is incomplete. LiPo is formally published, has public code, and also combines jerk minimization with limits on trajectory deviation. Although it handles chunk transitions differently, it is a relevant comparator. The paper cites it but evaluates only simpler filters and its own TPJM variant.

  • Table 4 includes a guidance weight of 1e-10. Under the stated unscaled third-difference operator, that produces almost no change to a local clean estimate. Is a time-step factor or normalization missing from the description? This needs resolving before attributing the corresponding success gains to jitter reduction.

  • Jitter reduction is measured for post-hoc smoothing, but the main JDSG experiments report success alone. Nearby coherence methods also measure executed motion and inference cost. JDSG needs corresponding jerk, trajectory-deviation, and action-chunk latency comparisons against DP and TPJM to support its smoothness and efficiency claims.

Questions for authors
  1. Are hyperparameters chosen on separate validation rollouts before reporting success? Please also explain what the three seeds vary, since that determines how much confidence to place in the small differences between the smoothing methods.

  2. Would applying guidance only near the end of sampling work just as well? Comparing it with full guidance at similar achieved jitter would help explain whether denoiser feedback matters beyond the amount of smoothing.

  3. Do the visual-shift gains persist with the weights selected in the clean setting? Table 4 appears to retune them for the shifted condition, so I am unsure whether this experiment demonstrates transfer to an unseen appearance change.

Reviewer_RXjbOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies intra-chunk trajectory jitter — small, high-frequency position fluctuations within a generated action chunk — as a contributing cause of failure in precision-sensitive manipulation with Diffusion Policy. The authors first conduct a post-hoc smoothing study on the state-based Tool Hang task, comparing Gaussian filtering, Savitzky–Golay filtering, moving-average filtering, and a "trajectory-preserving jitter-minimization" (TPJM) objective based on a third-order finite-difference penalty. TPJM yields the only statistically significant success-rate improvement over the base policy (60.83% → 63.20%, 95% CI [+0.27, +4.47] pp) and achieves the strongest jitter reduction (−97.09%) at a moderate trajectory deviation (1.898). Motivated by this, the authors propose Jitter Decreasing Shortcut Guidance (JDSG), which applies the closed-form TPJM operator to the position component of the intermediate clean action estimate at every reverse-diffusion step, then reuses the denoiser's predicted noise in the DDIM update. This avoids backpropagation through the policy network. JDSG is evaluated on Coffee, Square, and Tool Hang in simulation (clean and a visual distribution shift) and on real-world Peg-in-Hole and Tool Hang with an SO-101 arm, showing average gains of +4.33 pp (clean), +3.33 pp (visual shift), and +8.00 pp (real world) over Diffusion Policy, and generally outperforming post-hoc TPJM.

Critical strengths

Well-motivated problem. Intra-chunk jitter in contact-rich, precision-sensitive manipulation is a plausible and underexplored failure mode, and the paper is clearly structured around a coherent hypothesis → diagnostic study → method → evaluation narrative.

The post-hoc smoothing study is a useful diagnostic. Comparing four smoothers under a controlled protocol (1,000 episodes × 3 seeds) and reporting confidence intervals, rather than only point estimates, is good practice. The jitter-reduction vs. trajectory-deviation trade-off analysis (Table 1) is informative and supports the claim that how one smooths matters, not just whether one smooths.

Computational efficiency of the proposed method is genuinely attractive. Framing TPJM as a clean-estimate shortcut in the spirit of MPGD, with a closed-form linear-system solve and a single policy-network evaluation per denoising step with no backward pass, is a sensible engineering choice for latency-sensitive robot control. The method is simple and easy to implement.

Critical weaknesses

Insufficient novelty. The core technical contribution is the composition of two existing ideas: (i) a standard third-order finite-difference (minimum-jerk-style) regularizer with a closed-form solution, which is classical trajectory smoothing, and (ii) the MPGD clean-estimate shortcut for guidance. The paper itself states that MPGD "provides a basis for applying guidance without this computational requirement" and that JDSG "draws on this shortcut formulation." What remains is substituting a particular quadratic objective into a known guidance template. There is no new theoretical insight, no new guidance formulation, and no analysis of why shortcut guidance with a linear operator is preferable to, or different from, alternatives (e.g., projection-based methods, constrained sampling, or simply applying the same operator as a proximal step on the noisy iterate). The claim of novelty over ACG (Park et al., 2025) is largely architectural (UNet vs. Transformer, single vs. double model evaluation) rather than conceptual. For ICLR, the contribution falls below the bar of a substantive methodological advance.

Writing and presentation are non-compliant. The manuscript as provided has substantial formatting problems: the PDF text extraction shows page-1 line numbering artifacts and, more importantly, the references section is followed by large blocks of bare line numbers (pages 10–11), indicating a broken or unpolished submission. Table 1 and Table 3 have duplicated captions; Table 3's caption appears twice ("3: Real-world success rates..." and "Table 3: Real-world..."). Table 2 has a malformed structure with rowspan artifacts. The AI Use Statement and Reproducibility Statement have duplicated headers. Section 4.4 cites "a 2.33-point gain obtained by post-hoc TPJM" whereas Table 2 reports +3.00 for post-hoc TPJM under clean conditions — an internal inconsistency. These are not cosmetic quibbles for a venue with a strict submission format; they indicate the manuscript was not carefully proofread.

Method analysis is inadequate. No justification for the third-order difference specifically. Why order 3 rather than 2 or 4? The connection to minimum-jerk (Flash & Hogan, 1985) is asserted but not tested — no ablation over the difference order is reported, so the reader cannot tell whether the "trajectory-preserving" property is due to the order, the quadratic penalty form, or the relative weighting.

Questions for authors

On novelty relative to MPGD: Beyond substituting the TPJM objective into the MPGD clean-estimate shortcut, what is the conceptual contribution? Can you articulate a setting in which the shortcut formulation is necessary rather than merely convenient — i.e., where a post-hoc application of the same operator provably fails but the per-step version succeeds? The simulation gap (JDSG +4.33 vs. post-hoc TPJM +3.00 average) is small and not accompanied by CIs.

On the third-order choice: Please report an ablation over the finite-difference order (2, 3, 4) and over the penalty norm, isolating whether the benefit comes from the order, the quadratic form, or the trajectory-preservation term. Without this, the "minimum-jerk" motivation is unsupported.

Reviewer_KpfROpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies if temporal jitter inside an action chunk leads to more likely failure of diffusion policies, and proposes a method called Jitter Decreasing Shortcut Guidance (JDSG) to decrease the jitter of generated action chunks while preserving the original chunk’s motion. JDSG uses a motion preserving and jitter minimization objective that uses l2 deviation penalty and l2 third-order temporal differences and solved as a linear system with exact solution. The smoother is applied to replace the positional component of the A0 estimate at every DDIM step, using a MPGD-style clean-estimate shortcut. This is a pure inference time technique and also doesn’t require differentiation through the network. They evaluate the method in state-based Tool Hang, three image-based simulation tasks under clean and modified appearances, and two real-world tasks.

Critical strengths
  1. The proposed JDSG has a simple formulation and is plug and play.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited novelty and missing related works

    The shortcut comes from MPGD [1], and a squared third-difference penalty is a standard trajectory-smoothing objective. There is an existing relevant work called Motion Planning Diffusion [2], which already uses differentiable trajectory-smoothness costs for diffusion-guided robot motion planning.

  2. Limited empirical evidence and comparison to baselines

    In Table 2, JDSG improves over post-hoc TPJM by only 1.33 PP (clean) and 0.89 PP (under visual shift), without CI. In the physical experiments, the TPJM baseline is not used for comparison. I also think there are many other baselines the method can compare with such as:

    • MPD [2]
    • Ordinary cost-gradient guidance via classifier guidance style (such as CLIP guided Text 2 Image generation where the CLIP gradient could be calculated on the per step clean estimate and linearly combined with the current noisy tokens).
    • Guidance backpropagated through the denoiser style

[1] Y. He et al., “Manifold Preserving Guided Diffusion,” in Proc. International Conference on Learning Representations (ICLR), 2024. [Online]. Available: https://openreview.net/forum?id=o3BxOLoxm1

[2] J. Carvalho, A. T. Le, M. Baierl, D. Koert, and J. Peters, “Motion Planning Diffusion: Learning and Planning of Robot Motions with Diffusion Models,” in Proc. IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems (IROS), 2023, pp. 1916–1923. doi: 10.1109/IROS55552.2023.10342382.

Questions for authors
  1. In the paper, the image-based Tool Hang DP baseline achieves 55.67% SR. But in the original DP paper [1], image-CNN has a 95% best checkpoint SR. Why is there such a large difference in the baseline SRs?

  2. Could you provide some timing measurements of the proposed method? How much faster is it compared to the full backprop methods? How much latency does it add compared to the TPJM?

[1] C. Chi et al., “Diffusion Policy: Visuomotor Policy Learning via Action Diffusion,” The International Journal of Robotics Research, vol. 44, no. 10–11, pp. 1684–1704, 2025. doi: 10.1177/02783649241273668.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.