- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
JDSG adds a quadratic third-difference smoothing step to the intermediate clean-action estimates of a frozen Diffusion Policy. It then continues DDIM sampling with the original noise prediction, avoiding backpropagation through the policy. The paper first compares post-hoc smoothers and then evaluates sampling-time guidance on simulated precision-manipulation tasks and two physical robot tasks. The main question is whether smoothing during sampling improves control beyond applying the same smoother to the final action chunk.
Critical strengths
-
Being able to modify a frozen policy is appealing here. JDSG needs neither policy retraining nor a backward pass through the denoiser, which makes it a plausible addition to an existing Diffusion Policy implementation.
-
The quadratic objective gives a clear way to balance jerk reduction against changes to the proposed trajectory. The resulting linear solve is simple, and the reader can inspect what the smoother is doing.
-
The initial filter comparison is useful. It considers several common smoothers and reports both trajectory change and jitter, helping distinguish aggressive smoothing from changes that also preserve task success.
-
The Tool Hang improvement on the physical robot is encouraging. Including both hanging and insertion helps establish that the intervention can be useful in contact-sensitive manipulation, even though the comparison with post-hoc smoothing is still needed.
Critical weaknesses
-
I am not yet convinced that smoothing during sampling helps enough over smoothing afterward. Correcting the reported averages leaves gains of 1.33 points in clean simulation and 0.89 under visual shift over TPJM, with no uncertainty shown. The robot experiments compare only against DP, leaving the most relevant control out.
-
The comparison with established smoothing methods is incomplete. LiPo is formally published, has public code, and also combines jerk minimization with limits on trajectory deviation. Although it handles chunk transitions differently, it is a relevant comparator. The paper cites it but evaluates only simpler filters and its own TPJM variant.
-
Table 4 includes a guidance weight of 1e-10. Under the stated unscaled third-difference operator, that produces almost no change to a local clean estimate. Is a time-step factor or normalization missing from the description? This needs resolving before attributing the corresponding success gains to jitter reduction.
-
Jitter reduction is measured for post-hoc smoothing, but the main JDSG experiments report success alone. Nearby coherence methods also measure executed motion and inference cost. JDSG needs corresponding jerk, trajectory-deviation, and action-chunk latency comparisons against DP and TPJM to support its smoothness and efficiency claims.
Questions for authors
-
Are hyperparameters chosen on separate validation rollouts before reporting success? Please also explain what the three seeds vary, since that determines how much confidence to place in the small differences between the smoothing methods.
-
Would applying guidance only near the end of sampling work just as well? Comparing it with full guidance at similar achieved jitter would help explain whether denoiser feedback matters beyond the amount of smoothing.
-
Do the visual-shift gains persist with the weights selected in the clean setting? Table 4 appears to retune them for the shifted condition, so I am unsure whether this experiment demonstrates transfer to an unseen appearance change.