- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a training-free sampling schedule adaptation method using truncated fractional differencing, which is applied to each arm joint's action sequence. The method aims to minimize the energy distance between the generated action distributions and the demonstration distributions to obtain an improved sampling schedule for each task and NFE budget. The goal is to optimize the sampling schedule to better align the generated action distribution with the demonstrations and improve task success under each fixed NFE budget. The authors validate the proposed method in both simulation and real-world robot experiments.
Critical strengths
The paper provides a comprehensive introduction and related work section. The writing is clear and easy to understand and follow.
The paper provides detailed theoretical support for the proposed method.
The proposed method is interesting. Instead of using gradient descent, it searches for an improved sampling schedule by proposing several candidate schedules and calculating their energy-distance losses to find the one that best aligns the generated actions with the demonstration data.
The method is validated on three real-world bimanual manipulation tasks, as well as simulation benchmarks.
Critical weaknesses
Limited success rate improvement: Compared with the baseline methods, the proposed method achieves relatively small success-rate improvements, generally around 2–5 percentage points. The results in Tables 1 and 2 do not demonstrate an obvious advantage of the proposed method over the baselines in either simulation or real-world experiments.
Ablation study: According to Table 3, removing observation conditioning by setting λ = 0 only slightly affects performance. In addition, the overall improvements of the proposed method over the baseline are relatively small. I am concerned about whether these minor improvements reflect a meaningful contribution from the observation-conditioning component or are simply due to random variation. Additional statistical analysis or ablation experiments would help clarify this.
Questions for authors
Clarity of the abstract: Could the authors provide a more explicit explanation of the term "generated–generated" in the abstract? This is the first time the term appears in the paper, and its meaning may not be immediately clear to readers.
Relationship between energy distance and task success: The experimental results do not provide sufficiently strong evidence of the proposed method's superiority over the baselines. Furthermore, the relationship between energy distance and task success is unclear. Does a lower energy distance consistently lead to a higher task success rate, including in out-of-distribution scenarios? An additional ablation study examining this relationship would be useful.
Overall, the proposed method is interesting and insightful. However, based on the experimental results, I do not see a clear or substantial advantage of the proposed method over the baseline methods. Additional experiments and analyses would help demonstrate the effectiveness and significance of the proposed approach.
Response to Reviewer pHTK
We appreciate your valuable feedback and support of our work.
To W1:
We re-ran Uniform and GYS for three additional rounds under identical settings and report the mean ± std over four rounds in Table A. GYS consistently outperforms Uniform across all 12 settings with small standard deviations (≤ 0.7%), confirming that the gains are stable rather than random variation. It improves the average success rate by 2.8 percentage points on both π0.5 and GR00T.
Moreover, in RoboTwin 2.0 Clean2Random (Table C in To Q2), schedules optimized offline from limited clean demonstrations generalize across visual and spatial variations to consistently improve task success rates over Uniform in randomized scenes. As a training-free method with zero inference overhead, this consistent improvement provides clear practical value.
Table A. Success rate (%), mean ± std over four rounds. Avg. is the mean ± std across the six budgets (from Table 1 of the revised PDF).
To W2:
Retaining λ>0 provides theoretical grounding for conditional distribution matching. Setting λ=0 compares only pooled marginal distributions across observations, which theoretically allows a schedule to score well despite per-observation mismatches. Incorporating the observation summary (λ>0) ensures a zero objective implies conditional action distribution agreement (Proposition 1).
In practice, because GYS searches for a single task-level schedule, the task-pooled signal already gives strong guidance, yielding similar schedules. Since λ is set automatically via the median heuristic with negligible overhead, we retain λ>0 as a principled safeguard.
To Q1:
A "generated–generated" difference is the difference between two action chunks independently generated at the same observation under different noise draws. We updated the abstract in the revised PDF to clarify both pairwise differences:
"...compares two types of pairwise differences between action chunks at each observation: differences of a generated chunk against a demonstration, and differences of two independent generated chunks against each other."
To Q2:
Table B. Energy score and closed-loop success rate across schedules (from Figure 4 of the revised PDF).
Table C. Generalization success rate (%) averaged across 50 RoboTwin 2.0 tasks in unseen domain-randomized scenes (from Table 3 of the revised PDF).
We welcome further discussion if any concerns remain.