- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper identifies an overlooked failure mode: local highlights inject channel-dependent biases into the log image that survive cross-channel subtraction. HDRNet addresses this with LHA (RGB-guided bounded attenuation before ratio construction), dual-domain SLRE/SSR branches (SSR using a real non-negative response for phase preservation), residual-gated fusion, and training-time HPR.
Critical strengths
- Clear and useful failure-mode characterization:this paper shows that highlight-induced bias is injected before ratio construction and survives cross-channel subtraction (Eqs. 3–5). This is a sharper observation than the "ratio-then-correct" paradigm of YOLA/FRBNet, and it directly motivates the pre-ratio correction design.
- Correction placement is empirically justified: Fig. 5 uses equal-capacity correction heads to isolate the information-availability effect: the RGB-conditioned head reaches AUROC 0.788, whereas the ratio-domain head reaches 0.414 (below chance). The subsequent robustness comparison (mAP drop 0.22 vs 0.45/0.43) makes the argument self-consistent.
- Phase-preservation claim and efficiency profile are notable: Constraining FRBNet's sign-unconstrained complex modulation to a real non-negative response is a principled fix, triangulated by controlled phase intervention and filter transplant (Fig. 8). The efficiency result (10.5K params, 12.4 ms, +3.6% FLOPs) is genuinely attractive.
Critical weaknesses
- Novelty is largely incremental: SLRE inherits YOLA's zero-mean local filters; SSR is essentially FRBNet's complex multiplier restricted to a real magnitude response; LHA is a learned highlight mask with bounded log-domain subtraction. The combination is reasonable, but the work offers no substantially new modeling insight.
- Gains are modest and lack statistical validation: Main tables (1–3) are single-run, with no seeds, variance, or confidence intervals. Ablation deltas (Table 4) are only 0.6–1.9 points and likely fall within run-to-run noise, weakening the "consistent gains" claim. The theoretical analysis (Eqs. 3–5) also gives no magnitude condition or bound for the residual ∆i − ∆j.
Questions for authors
See Weaknesses
Dear Authors,
Thank you for the detailed rebuttal and the additional experiments. The transfer results in Table 6 and the clarification regarding the loss coefficients address some of my concerns. However, my main concern about novelty remains. As Reviewer igh1 also noted, SLRE and SSR closely follow YOLA and FRBNet, respectively. The proposed LHA and HPR components yield modest gains of 0.6–0.9 mAP when added to existing front ends.
My own research has focused primarily on this area, and I still see the proposed method as an incremental advance over prior work, which I do not find sufficient for ICLR. I will therefore maintain my original score.