- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes TriFed, a trustworthy personalized federated generalization framework to address unseen clients in FL. The framework has three core components: shared FL part, private head with clustering FL part, and rejection.
Critical strengths
- this paper focuses on an important problem in FL: unseen clients, and proposes TriFed, a trustworthy personalized federated generalization framework to address this problem.
- the author has done a very clear literature review with recent works.
Critical weaknesses
-
I am not quite sure what the main contributions are. The authors summarize three bullet points in the Introduction. Regarding the first point, this reads to me more as a problem formulation and a description of the protocols rather than a concrete contribution. Regarding the second point, the proposed mechanism appears to consist of three common components: shared FL, private FL, and filtering (please see my further comments below regarding these components). I assume the authors consider this combination to be the core contribution, but I am not convinced that the combination itself is sufficiently strong to constitute the main contribution of a paper. I would encourage the authors to explain more explicitly what is novel beyond simply combining these components.
-
The filtering mechanism is defined based on “harmfulness,” which I find confusing. “Harmfulness” is a strong term in the FL literature and is typically used in adversarial settings. In this context, I assume the authors are instead referring to cross-client inconsistency. However, this raises another concern: if the underlying issue is merely cross-client inconsistency, why is filtering the most appropriate solution?
-
The paper also positions sample-level reliability control as a key distinction of TriFed, but it is not sufficiently established why such a fine-grained reliability mechanism is necessary or particularly well suited to the considered open federated setting.
-
Overall, I would conclude that the paper proposes a framework to address the unseen-client problem, but it does not clearly identify the central research problem or sufficiently define the scope. The current presentation leaves me with several open questions and would benefit from further refinement and additional supporting evidence.
Questions for authors
Please see Critical Weaknesses.