- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes adaptive evidence extraction for open-vocabulary video visual relationship detection. It combines motion-aware segmentation, prediction of observation counts for trajectory pairs, and quality/diversity-based frame selection. Offline MLLM-derived priors provide weak supervision for count prediction. Results show improved relationship detection with fewer selected frames.
Critical strengths
- The method addresses a concrete limitation of fixed observation budgets and offers a coherent mechanism for adapting visual evidence to temporal dynamics.
- The evaluation provides useful support for the proposed design and its accuracy–computation trade-off.
Critical weaknesses
The baseline Novel mAP is 14.45 in Table 3 but 16.45 in Table 7, while All mAP is 25.22 in both. The main text does not explain a setting difference.
Questions for authors
Do Tables 3 and 7 use the same baseline checkpoint and Novel SGDet evaluation setting? If so, please identify and correct the erroneous value. Otherwise, please explain the setting difference and ensure the component comparison uses a consistent baseline.
Response to Q1: Thank you for identifying this inconsistency. Tables 3 and 7 use the same EOV-MMP-based baseline checkpoint and the same Novel SGDet evaluation setting. The Novel mAP value of 16.45 in Table 7 is a typographical error; the correct value is 14.45, consistent with Table 3. The All mAP value (25.22), FLOPs, runtime, and all results for our method remain unchanged. We have corrected the relevant entries in the revised manuscript.