- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The manuscript presents a work on long-video understanding under a fixed MLLM frame budget. It introduces two training-free, model-agnostic, plug-and-play frame-selection methods. The claimed contributions include a cosine-similarity-based query–video (QV) frame-scoring method that operates on token vectors from the pre-trained encoders, and a query–answer–video (QAV) aligned frame-selection method that incorporates the multiple-choice answer options as inference-time cues through max-over-options scoring. Experiments conducted on MLVU, Video-MME, and LongVideoBench validate the proposed methods.
Critical strengths
The paper is well presented and easy to follow. Experiments conducted on MLVU, Video-MME, and LongVideoBench validate the proposed methods. Different duration groups have been tested.
Critical weaknesses
The novelty is limited, and the proposed methods are incremental over existing query-aware methods. QV largely follows a conventional retrieval-based frame selection approach using question-frame similarity. Meanwhile, QAV relies on predefined answer options, limiting its applicability to open-ended video question answering. The practical generality of the proposed methods remain unclear. On the experiments side, only a 16-frame setting is considered.
Questions for authors
The proposed methods are incremental over existing query-aware methods. Please better state the novelty of the proposed method compared to the existing works.
The improvements compared to existing methods on the three datasets are very limited, with only a fixed 16-frame setting. Please better explain the reasons of the improvements? It would be interesting to know if the improvements could be consistent to different settings.