- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents PADSIM, a 3D Gaussian Splatting (3DGS)-based closed-loop simulator for autonomous driving with controllable pedestrian augmentation. The system integrates interaction-aware pedestrian trajectory generation, avatar animation, and illumination-consistent rendering. Specifically, the proposed IDMG pipeline combines social-force-based motion modeling with collision avoidance, while GLICS uses estimated scene illumination to adjust the appearance of inserted pedestrian Gaussians. The authors also introduce three metrics to quantify scenario complexity.
Experiments evaluate pedestrian collision rates against RESCUE, illumination consistency before and after relighting, scenario complexity, and the closed-loop performance of several autonomous driving policies. The authors report improved collision avoidance, better illumination consistency, and increased scenario complexity.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses a relevant problem in autonomous driving simulation. Controllable pedestrian behaviors are important for evaluating driving policies under safety-critical interactions.
The integration of pedestrian motion generation, animated Gaussian avatars, scene rendering, and driving policy inference into a unified simulation framework is a potentially useful engineering contribution. The reported collision-rate improvements over RESCUE also suggest that the interaction-aware motion module can improve pedestrian placement and trajectory feasibility.
Critical weaknesses
1. Insufficient downstream validation and questionable practical value.
The paper does not convincingly demonstrate that PADSIM provides meaningful or reliable autonomous driving evaluation. Table 6 only reports driving performance on two augmented scenarios, without controlled comparisons against the original scenes or other simulation methods. Moreover, Figures 4 and 5 show noticeable appearance discrepancies between inserted pedestrians and the backgrounds. It is unclear whether the observed driving failures result from challenging pedestrian interactions or synthetic visual artifacts. The paper also fails to establish why PADSIM is preferable to existing closed-loop benchmarks such as HABIT, as the inserted pedestrains still remain mesh style.
2. Unclear closed-loop interaction and limited methodological novelty.
Algorithm 1 and Appendix E.4 describe pedestrian motion generation as an offline process, while Algorithm 2 claims online pedestrian updates in response to ego actions. This inconsistency raises doubts about whether pedestrians genuinely react to the driving policy. The real-time claim also lacks end-to-end FPS measurements. Furthermore, the proposed components largely combine existing techniques, including social force models, ORCA, PACER, and conventional illumination models, without sufficiently demonstrating the advantages of their integration.
The manuscript also contains obvious presentation issues. Appendix A begins with the unfinished placeholder "I will add a discussion of related work on relighting here." Additionally, Algorithm 2 incorrectly references Eqs. (26)–(27) for HD-Score computation, although these equations define collision-rate metrics. Such errors raise concerns about the manuscript's technical verification.
Questions for authors
Can the authors evaluate downstream planner performance after reducing the noticeable visual artifacts in the inserted pedestrians? This may require an additional harmonization module or pipeline, potentially leveraging video generation models or APIs. Given the substantial appearance discrepancies in the current visual results, I find it difficult to assess whether the reported planning failures reflect meaningful pedestrian interactions or artifacts introduced by the simulation.