- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates the problem of progress estimation based on historical context in long-term embodied tasks. The authors constructed ContextProgress-Bench, which includes 24 operational tasks and 120 trajectories, covering three types of scenarios: state recall, sequence tracking, and distinguishing recurring events. Manual context diagnosis revealed that existing PRMs may still fail to accurately assess progress even when provided with historical information; after providing the correct context, the error rates of five models were reduced by 77%–82%. Based on these findings, the paper proposes ProgressCompass, which uses a general-purpose VLM to provide task context to a frozen PRM and advances subtasks through a cycle of completion verification and memory updates. Built on RoboMeter-4B, the system reduces progress error by 63% and improves the Spearman correlation coefficient from 0.53 to 0.93.
Critical strengths
The system significantly improves the progress estimation performance of existing reward models. With the RoboMeter-4B weights frozen, ProgressCompass reduces the MAE on ContextProgress-Bench from 25.4 to 9.3, a decrease of approximately 63%; the Spearman correlation coefficient increased from 0.53 to 0.93. This indicates that the complete system simultaneously improves the accuracy of progress estimates and the temporal consistency of the prediction curves across the context-dependent tasks tested.
Critical weaknesses
- The incremental contributions of the method, the roles of its modules, and its applicability across reward models have not yet been fully clarified.
R²VLM has utilized recursive processing to decompose and complete local video maintenance tasks, and the two-stage experiments in the original RoboMeter work also employed a VLM to decompose subtasks, with the reward model determining completion and advancing to the next stage. Therefore, the paper needs to more clearly explain the mechanisms of the independent Verifier, expected state changes, and memory updates following verification—specifically, what new features it adds compared to existing approaches and which errors it specifically addresses that previous methods failed to handle. Existing ablation studies primarily focus on the expected state change and have not sufficiently validated the individual contributions of the Orienter, PRM, Verifier, and Navigator. Additionally, the Orienter uses Qwen3.5-27B, the Verifier and Navigator use Qwen3.5-9B, and the PRM uses RoboMeter-4B. The lack of control experiments involving module removal or replacement, standardized auxiliary VLM configurations, and inference budget control makes it difficult to distinguish whether performance improvements stem from module design, auxiliary model capabilities, or increased inference calls. In particular, to verify the independent contribution of PRM, it is necessary to replace PRM with a simple scoring rule or direct scoring by the same VLM while retaining the task decomposition, memory, and verification processes.
Furthermore, the complete framework has only been validated on RoboMeter-4B. The manual context diagnosis for the five PRMs relies on manually provided context and subtask boundaries and cannot replace cross-model validation of the complete automated framework. We recommend integrating another representative PRM while keeping the auxiliary VLM and evaluation protocol fixed, and reporting both accuracy and inference overhead to clarify the framework’s scope of applicability.
- Differences in sampling settings in the manual context diagnosis require explanation.
Appendix C shows that the sampling interval for Robo-Dopamine was changed from 5 (without context) to 10 (with context), while the maximum number of input frames for TOPReward was changed from 96 to 48. Therefore, in addition to context, the visual input configurations were also altered between the two sets of experiments. Given that the two sets of experiments processed full videos and subtask clips, respectively, these adjustments may be justified; however, the paper has not provided a sufficient explanation. We recommend that the authors explain the reasons for these adjustments, report the actual number of input frames and temporal coverage, and include a control group with consistent sampling settings or provide evidence that these differences do not affect the main conclusions, in order to more fully support the attribution of performance improvements to context.
Questions for authors
Questions:
- How is the independent contribution of each module verified? Aside from ablation experiments on the expected state change (\tau_t), have there been any controls where modules were removed or replaced, and where the auxiliary VLM capabilities and inference call budgets were controlled? In particular, when preserving task decomposition, memory, and validation workflows, how much independent benefit does PRM provide compared to simple scoring rules or direct scoring by the same VLM?
- Why did the human context diagnosis alter the visual sampling configuration? Please explain the rationale for changing the sampling interval in Robo-Dopamine from 5 to 10 and the maximum number of frames in TOPReward from 96 to 48, and describe how the actual number of input frames and temporal coverage changed. Are there any analyses or comparisons to support the conclusion that these differences do not substantially affect the context-based gains?
- Does the R²VLM baseline employ a complete recursive reasoning process? Please provide the specific checkpoint, local video segment length, and frame sampling settings used by R²VLM in Figure 5, and clarify whether the task decomposition and completion status in the historical CoT are propagated and updated round by round. This information is crucial for verifying whether the comparison closest to the baseline is sufficient.
Recommendations for Future Work: Given a fixed auxiliary VLM and evaluation protocol, integrate the complete automated framework into other representative PRMs to verify cross-model applicability; the current empirical conclusions should be explicitly limited to the tested RoboMeter-4B configuration.
4 comments
Response to Reviewer pMqX (2/n)
Concern 3: The gain may come from larger auxiliary models or more inference calls.
Directly prompting Qwen3.5-27B gives 19.42 MAE, versus 9.82 for ProgressCompass. The tested frontier models score lower still. The model-size ablation above supports where we use larger models, but these comparisons do not isolate the effect of additional calls.
| Method | State MAE↓ | Count MAE↓ | Sequence MAE↓ | Overall MAE↓ | Spearman ρ↑ | Pearson r↑ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ProgressCompass (based on RoboMeter) | 10.50 | 7.52 | 10.52 | 9.82 | 0.941 | 0.933 |
| Opus 5.5, direct prediction | 8.61 | 6.78 | 7.52 | 7.72 | 0.964 | 0.951 |
| GPT-6 Astra, direct prediction | 6.29 | 4.71 | 7.36 | 6.37 | 0.975 | 0.961 |
| Qwen3.5-27B, direct prediction | 26.78 | 21.80 | 12.11 | 19.42 | 0.719 | 0.702 |
| Qwen3.5-9B, direct prediction | 40.98 | 35.79 | 25.08 | 33.06 | 0.433 | 0.456 |
| RoboMeter, direct prediction under the comparison settings | 30.17 | 24.92 | 22.36 | 25.65 | 0.513 | 0.504 |
Concern 4: With decomposition, memory, and verification kept, does the PRM beat a simple rule or direct VLM scoring?
We replaced only the progress estimator. RoboMeter-4B beats the best Qwen replacement by 23% in MAE (9.82 vs. 12.74). “Abs” predicts completion percentage; “delta” predicts the change since the previous sample. All four Qwen variants use temperature 0.7 and top_p 0.8.
| Progress Estimator | State↓ | Count↓ | Sequence↓ | Overall MAE↓ | Spearman ρ↑ | Pearson r↑ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RoboMeter-4B | 10.50 | 7.52 | 10.52 | 9.82 | 0.941 | 0.933 |
| Qwen3.5-27B, abs | 12.23 | 14.84 | 11.98 | 12.74 | 0.915 | 0.908 |
| Qwen3.5-9B, abs | 14.96 | 15.68 | 13.32 | 14.44 | 0.907 | 0.897 |
| Qwen3.5-9B, delta | 19.67 | 19.05 | 15.71 | 17.85 | 0.865 | 0.853 |
| Qwen3.5-27B, delta | 23.19 | 18.87 | 15.48 | 18.93 | 0.897 | 0.872 |
On manually annotated subtasks, ProgressCompass also beats the fixed 50% guess (22.43 vs. 25.61); the five standalone PRMs do not. This measures within-subtask changes, separately from the full-loop replacement test.
Concern 5: Why do the visual sampling settings change in the manual-context diagnosis?
We tested whether the sampling differences explain the gains in Table 1. The table reports global progress MAE.
| Model | Context | Sampling setting | Avg. count | MAE↓ | Spearman ρ↑ | Pearson r↑ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Robo-Dopamine | No | Interval 10 | 60.1 | 15.59 | 0.745 | 0.762 |
| Robo-Dopamine | No | Interval 5 | 119.7 | 15.74 | 0.740 | 0.752 |
| Robo-Dopamine | Yes | Interval 10 | 13.3 | 3.43 | 0.975 | 0.962 |
| TOPReward | No | Frame cap 96 | 96 | 30.95 | 0.559 | 0.542 |
| TOPReward | Yes | Frame cap 48 | 47.9 | 6.70 | 0.905 | 0.890 |
| TOPReward | Yes | Frame cap 96 | 88.1 | 6.69 | 0.924 | 0.911 |
Avg. count: scoring points for Robo-Dopamine; input frames for TOPReward.
- Robo-Dopamine: Halving the interval nearly doubles the number of scoring points without context, but MAE changes by only 0.15. At interval 10, MAE is 15.59 without context vs. 3.43 with context.
- TOPReward: The 48-frame cap was reached in 539 of 552 subtask clips. Raising it to 96 increases the actual input from 47.9 to 88.1 frames on average, but MAE is nearly unchanged (6.70 vs. 6.69). At the same 96-frame cap, MAE is 30.95 without context vs. 6.69 with context.
The gains remain after matching the sampling parameter. The full-episode and subtask conditions still differ in their boundaries and global step positions, and Robo-Dopamine also receives a different goal image.
Concern 6: Does the R²VLM baseline run the full recurrent process and carry task history between rounds?
We evaluated R²VLM using the original baseline's recurrent inference procedure. The model processes successive video clips and carries its task decomposition and completion history from one round to the next, following the original method.
Concern 7: The complete automated framework is tested only with RoboMeter. Does it work with another PRM?
Why RoboMeter? It can score the current subtask from the instruction and observed frames. Reference-based VLAC, ProgressLM, and our Robo-Dopamine setup need a reference video, a visual or textual demonstration, or a goal image, respectively. We have not tested TOPReward in the full loop.
Can the estimator be swapped? Yes. On the same 120 episodes, Qwen3.5-27B and 9B give MAEs of 12.74 and 14.44, versus 9.82 with RoboMeter-4B. The loop supports other estimators, but a second specialized PRM remains untested.
Follow-up on the Verifier and PRM generalization
Thank you for your detailed response and the additional experiments. I have two follow-up questions that may help further clarify the contributions and the scope of applicability of this method.
- What is the specific contribution of the Verifier?
The ablation study on model scale shows that reducing the Verifier from 9B to 4B increases the MAE from 9.82 to 13.95. While this indicates that the choice of Verifier affects performance, it does not fully quantify the contribution of the Verifier compared to a system that does not use one.
Thank you for providing the baseline using Qwen task decomposition combined with RoboMeter. However, since this baseline employs a fixed schedule, the difference between it and ProgressCompass is not limited solely to the inclusion of a Verifier.
Could you test a version that omits the Verifier—where the system proceeds directly to the next step once the PRM proposes a candidate completion point—while keeping other components as consistent as possible? Additionally, please clarify how memory is updated in this version. Comparing the MAE and the frequency of premature advancements would help quantify the contribution of the verification step to the overall system.
- Can the complete framework be generalized to other PRMs?
The experiment involving the replacement of Qwen demonstrates that the framework can accommodate different progress estimators. However, the fully automated framework has currently only been evaluated using one specific PRM: RoboMeter.
Would it be possible to test the complete framework using a different, compatible PRM, while keeping the other components and the evaluation pipeline unchanged? Comparing the performance of that PRM when running independently versus when integrated into ProgressCompass would help determine whether the benefits of this method extend beyond RoboMeter. If such an experiment is difficult to implement, clarifying the scope of applicability for the current results would also be helpful.
Wish this could solve your questions
Q1. What does the Verifier contribute?
The Verifier checks whether the expected change is visible before the system advances and updates its memory. We reran the same 120 episodes without the Verifier, keeping the other models, frame sampling, and evaluation protocol fixed.
Advancement and memory. Without the Verifier, the system advances as soon as RoboMeter’s score reaches the threshold. It records the subtask, its frame span, and the Orienter’s predicted after-state. With the Verifier, memory records the state observed at confirmed completion.
| Setup | Overall MAE ↓ | Spearman ρ ↑ |
|---|---|---|
| ProgressCompass with Verifier | 9.82 | 0.941 |
| No Verifier, threshold 0.6 | 17.15 | 0.870 |
| No Verifier, threshold 0.7 | 18.31 | 0.860 |
| No Verifier, threshold 0.8 | 18.77 | 0.883 |
| No Verifier, threshold 0.9 | 28.74 | 0.898 |
ProgressCompass with the Verifier achieves lower MAE and higher Spearman ρ than all four variants. The lowest MAE without verification is 17.15, compared with 9.82 for the full system.
Q2. Does ProgressCompass work with other PRMs?
Finding a compatible PRM is difficult because ProgressCompass scores each subtask before its endpoint is known. At that point, the loop has the frames observed so far and the current subtask description. A matching demonstration or goal image may be unavailable, which limits the ProgressLM and Robo-Dopamine fusion configurations we evaluated.
We tested VLAC and TOPReward both standalone and inside the full ProgressCompass loop on the same 120 episodes. We kept the Orienter, Navigator, Verifier, and evaluation protocol fixed across the integrated runs. The loop inferred the subtask boundaries, and VLAC received no reference video in either setup.
| PRM | Standalone MAE ↓ | In ProgressCompass MAE ↓ | MAE reduction ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|
| VLAC | 45.59 | 21.13 | 53.7% |
| TOPReward | 30.95 | 14.13 | 54.3% |
Both PRMs improved by about 54%, even though their standalone scores were less accurate than RoboMeter’s in our setup. RoboMeter still achieves the lowest MAE in the loop (9.82). These results show that the gains extend to two additional PRMs, while the choice of scorer still affects the final accuracy.
Response to Reviewer pMqX (1/n)
Thank you for recognizing that ProgressCompass improves accuracy and temporal consistency with a frozen RoboMeter-4B. We respond to each concern below.
Concern 1: R²VLM and RoboMeter already use task decomposition. What does ProgressCompass add?
ProgressCompass adds verified context updates to task decomposition. On ContextProgress-Bench, five PRMs have MAEs of 15.59–30.95 without explicit subtask context. Oracle context lowers those errors by 77–82% (Table 1); this condition also supplies annotated boundaries and step positions. Our system estimates progress without those annotations at inference time.
We adapted RoboMeter's multi-stage procedure (Sec. IV-Q3 and Appendix E.2): Qwen3.5-27B generates a fixed plan from the instruction and first frame; RoboMeter-4B advances when success probability exceeds 0.6. ProgressCompass instead checks completion and uses verified observations to update context.
Even against this staged baseline, MAE drops from 18.91 to 9.82 (48%). R²VLM also updates context, through recurrent reasoning. Our design separates local scoring from completion checks and carries verified observations forward.
Concern 2: The expected-transition ablation does not establish the separate roles of the Orienter, PRM, Verifier, and Navigator.
The four components have distinct roles (Section 4 and Appendix B):
Model-size ablation. We change only the auxiliary Qwen3.5 model sizes. The code and RoboMeter-4B stay fixed. State, Count, and Sequence report MAE.
Expected-transition ablation. Removing the description of what should change from the Verifier raises MAE from 9.3 to 17.5 and stalled episodes from 7 to 40. The Verifier still receives the subtask instruction. This tests the completion description, not whether the Verifier or Navigator can be removed.