- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a variant of neural BP termed Neural Syndrome Flow (NSF), formulated as a learned recurrent solver. The authors show improvements with respect to BP as well as other neural BP decoders, although the gains are very limited (as shown in Figures 3 and 4).
Critical strengths
The proposed decoder shows some improvement (albeit marginal in some cases, and in some others it performs worse) than BP and other neural BP decoders.
Critical weaknesses
The main weakness is that the contribution is too limited and lacks sufficient depth to warrant publication at ICLR. The shown improvements are of some value, although the improvement in terms of BER is very limited in most cases (and the proposed approach performs worse than other neural BP for some BCH and polar codes). In any case, the contribution is simply too narrow.
In my view, a simple idea has been expanded to a full ICLR paper. I find very little in the proposed approach that is surprising or conceptually substantial.
Note that, improving upon existing methods does not, by itself, warrant a publication, particularly at a venue such as ICLR. Indeed, a lot of purely engineering work can improve upon the state-of-the-art, without constituting a significant research contribution.
The construction is largely heuristic, with neither theoretical analysis nor novel insight. The paper does not demonstrate a substantial advance in scientific understanding or methodology.
For a paper that evaluates the performance of LDPC decoders, performance results should be reported in terms of FER curves (alternatively BER curves, but FER is preferred) as a function of Eb/N0, as it is customary in any coding paper. So please, replace the tables that give the -ln(BER) as a function of SNR with FER curves. These provide a much clearer picture of decoding performance and make comparisons easier to assess.
Even if this tabular format has been used in previous neural BP papers, that is not a good reason to retain a poor way of presenting decoding results. These kind of results would not be appreciated in any serious coding paper. Authors should follow established practice in coding rather than perpetuate an inadequate presentation format.
For polar and BCH codes the comparison should include the state-of-the-art decoders, i.e., CRC+list decoding and OSD, respectively.
Questions for authors
See weaknesses.