- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces DEER and its lightweight counterpart, FAWN, by aligning the training target with probability-flow dynamics and explicitly mapping channel noise levels to diffusion time. The motivation stems from inconsistencies between discrete predictions, continuous diffusion updates, and syndrome-based time indexing in existing neural decoders. The proposed framework is intuitive and well motivated, and the experiments demonstrate favorable BER–latency trade-offs across several code families compared with the evaluated neural baselines.
Critical strengths
1.The paper identifies concrete limitations of existing diffusion-based neural decoders and uses them to motivate its design choices. This makes the work intuitive and strongly motivated.
2.The author's method, building correspondence between channel noise level and diffusion time, together with the derivation of the regression objective, directly addresses the identified training–inference mismatch, which is rational and rigorous.
3.The effort to reduce efficiency is appreciated.
Critical weaknesses
-
There appears to be an inconsistency between the legend of Fig. 2(a) and the corresponding text.
-
Please discuss the scope and limitations of the proposed framework more explicitly. The BER evaluation primarily concerns short codes over binary-input AWGN channels, while the long-code experiments mainly demonstrate runtime scaling. It would be helpful to discuss the challenges of extending the approach to other channel models or higher-order modulation, and to distinguish the demonstrated computational scalability from the evidence for error-correction performance at longer code lengths.
Questions for authors
-
There appears to be an inconsistency between the legend of Fig. 2(a) and the corresponding text.
-
Please discuss the scope and limitations of the proposed framework more explicitly. The BER evaluation primarily concerns short codes over binary-input AWGN channels, while the long-code experiments mainly demonstrate runtime scaling. It would be helpful to discuss the challenges of extending the approach to other channel models or higher-order modulation, and to distinguish the demonstrated computational scalability from the evidence for error-correction performance at longer code lengths.
We thank the reviewer for the positive assessment and the suggestions on presentation and scope. The figure inconsistencies are addressed in our response to Reviewer TcU4, and we will correct Figures 1 and 2 in the revised manuscript.
Our formulation considers BPSK transmission over a binary-input AWGN channel. Most error-rate experiments concern short block lengths. We will state this scope explicitly and distinguish these results from the long-code runtime measurements. Extending the formulation to other channels requires adapting the channel model, interpolation, and corresponding training target; the present analysis does not directly establish such extensions.
Although the heterogeneous decoder offers a favorable accuracy–latency trade-off on the evaluated short codes, its DEER component does not share FAWN’s linear-scaling attention implementation. We have not completed a comparable long-code error-rate evaluation under our current hardware and training configuration. The long-code experiments therefore demonstrate runtime scaling rather than decoding accuracy at those lengths.
Evaluating FAWN on longer codes is an important direction for future work. Its lower per-evaluation cost may also permit larger-capacity variants under a comparable computational budget. Whether such variants can match or outperform DEER at longer block lengths remains to be established experimentally.
Higher-order modulation would require revisiting the symbol mapping, likelihood representation, and diffusion formulation. We appreciate the reviewer’s suggestion and will discuss these challenges as limitations and directions for future work. These extensions are beyond the scope of the current BPSK-AWGN evaluation.