- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper did some specific improvements on the task of transforming analog circuit images to SPICE format with VLLM. Compared with existing works like Circuit-Think, the major improvements contains:
- The CoT information is extended from 3 steps to 5 during SFT. Device ports and wire tracing information are added
- The reward is more calibrated during RL, including polyline F1 and evidence binding reward
- A verifier (named CPPV in the paper) that penalize circuits that break basic physical rules (e.g., missing terminals, internal shorts) during RL
Critical strengths
- A verifier based on physical rules makes very good sense in the circuit2netlist task
Critical weaknesses
- This paper seems to be a regular iteration upon existing works like Circuit-Think, extending and crafting CoTs and rewards.
- The performance improvement is also pretty "regular". I won't say it is marginal, but considering that circuit2netlist is a very application-oriented task, and this paper focuses solely on this task, I can’t help but wonder about the practical significance of this article. Sadly, in real application, the difference between 66% and 76% accuracy may not be as large as it seems (from "not reliable at all" to "a bit better, but still not reliable at all"). To make matters worse, the metric of accuracy here seems already a pretty relaxed one, allowing partial correct circuits to gain scores. I wonder how would a "netlist exact match rate" looks like, i.e., the precentage of SPICE netlist that exactly recovered the circuit image.
Questions for authors
See "weaknesses"