- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Promise-based Partner Coordination (PPC), a training framework for zero-shot coordination with unfamiliar AI and human partners. An LLM generates and refines executable promises that specify when coordination rules apply and which actions satisfy them. Different promise combinations and randomized enforcement shape a population of training partners. A separate, unconstrained Promisee learns to respond to these partners using a trust estimator trained to infer enforcement probabilities from local interaction history. Evaluation covers Overcooked-v1, Overcooked-v2, and Hanabi, including self-play, cross-play between seeds of the same method, external AI partners, and a 40-participant human study. PPC reports improvements over the tested baselines, with additional support from common-partner BR-Prox evaluation on Overcooked-v1 and human collaboration. Evaluation uses frozen policies without LLM calls or action masking of the Promisee.
Critical strengths
-
Promises make training-partner behaviors inspectable, with recognizable conventions such as yielding and handoffs. Randomized enforcement introduces variation while leaving the responding agent unconstrained.
-
Forty participants evaluate all methods across both Overcooked variants and two-player Hanabi. Randomized presentation, concealed method identities, and paired participant-level analysis strengthen the comparison. The reported gains provide practical evidence of transfer to human partners without using human trajectories for training.
-
The common held-out partner pool provides complementary evidence beyond same-method cross-play. Figure 19 reports aggregate BR-Prox of 0.866 versus 0.769 for the strongest baseline on Overcooked-v1.
Critical weaknesses
-
Table 1 uses method-specific partner distributions, so its SP/XP ranking combines task competence and within-method compatibility with partner adaptation. Shared Promiser populations across PPC seeds further limit the interpretation of cross-seed XP (Appendix G.5). Figures 18–19 provide more direct evidence of external-partner generalization, but appear only in the appendix: BR-Prox covers Overcooked-v1, and inter-algorithm cross-play covers one setting per environment. The main comparison should distinguish within-method compatibility from performance with common test partners.
-
The framework depends on domain semantics and environment-specific integration. Although summaries and promises are LLM-generated, generation requires detailed task dynamics, state/observation/action definitions, role observability, and implementation interfaces (Table 5). Each layout or player-count condition receives its own promise set (Table 7). The experiments demonstrate a reusable workflow for structured games, but the effort and manual intervention needed to integrate a new environment are not quantified. Appendix A acknowledges the focus on recurrent, locally identifiable decisions; broader portability remains uncertain.
-
Component ablations support the combined design, but do not isolate promise constraints from useful semantic priors and training choices. SemDiv already generates semantic behaviors and reward programs with feedback [1], and CoMeDi targets strategic diversity [2]; neither is evaluated. A controlled reward-versus-constraint comparison with matched semantic information would clarify the contribution. PPC also receives hyperparameter search and different Overcooked optimizer settings without comparable baseline tuning.
[1] Li et al. LLM-Assisted Semantically Diverse Teammate Generation for Efficient Multi-agent Coordination. ICML, 2025. Paper.
[2] Sarkar et al. Diverse Conventions for Human-AI Collaboration. NeurIPS, 2023. Paper.
Questions for authors
-
Could Figures 18–19 be summarized in the main text, with Table 1 explicitly framed as task competence and within-method compatibility? Are broader common-partner AI evaluations available for Overcooked-v2 and Hanabi beyond the representative settings in Figure 18?
-
What inputs, environment-specific interfaces, and manual interventions are required for a new environment? How variable are results across independently generated promise sets?
-
Can one existing layout compare reward-based partner generation with promise constraints under matched semantic specifications, population size, learner, tuning budget, and evaluation information?
-
What signal is supplied in the “true trust” ablations for unconstrained Promisee partners, and does it represent enforcement or fulfillment?
4 comments
Table R.3. Additional baselines (Table 1). Cells: SP / XP, mean SD across seeds; v1/v2 denote Overcooked-v1/v2.
| Environment | Layout | IPPO | CoMeDi | SemDiv | PPC |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overcooked-v1 | Counter Circuit | 158.00±27.00 / 32.00±12.00 | 165.00±26.90 / 128.90±32.60 | 39.90±48.00 / 42.10±36.90 | 260.00±22.00 / 231.00±29.00 |
| Coordination Ring | 287.00±23.00 / 41.00±11.00 | 311.20±19.50 / 231.50±80.20 | 98.80±10.00 / 87.60±17.20 | 325.00±9.00 / 311.00±9.00 | |
| Cramped Room | 253.00±9.00 / 187.00±36.00 | 243.40±8.40 / 227.40±33.70 | 192.40±15.10 / 183.00±12.80 | 260.00±4.00 / 252.00±7.00 | |
| Forced Coordination | 200.00±29.00 / 10.00±11.00 | 194.60±8.40 / 188.00±10.00 | 166.90±15.20 / 149.50±28.80 | 320.00±12.00 / 317.00±28.00 | |
| Overcooked-v2 | Grounded Coordination Simple | 138.00±17.00 / -60.00±39.00 | 50.00±79.40 / -5.20±80.50 | 114.40±48.70 / 110.50±46.60 | 156.00±23.00 / 117.00±14.00 |
| Grounded Coordination Ring | 162.00±9.00 / -18.00±29.00 | 113.20±22.80 / 67.90±28.60 | 42.00±18.70 / 44.80±10.50 | 167.00±12.00 / 120.00±58.00 | |
| Test Time Simple | 149.00±32.00 / -69.00±46.00 | 8.00±10.60 / -0.10±14.30 | 60.90±58.00 / 46.40±41.50 | 165.00±18.00 / 140.00±13.00 | |
| Test Time Wide | 178.00±30.00 / -51.00±12.00 | 126.60±32.50 / 78.90±35.60 | 71.80±38.70 / 67.90±32.00 | 186.00±9.00 / 167.00±25.00 | |
| Demo Cook Simple | 142.00±35.00 / 12.00±17.00 | 132.80±58.60 / 82.30±47.40 | 101.20±72.60 / 98.60±68.20 | 173.00±55.00 / 150.00±59.00 | |
| Demo Cook Wide | 152.00±41.00 / 9.00±6.00 | 122.00±53.60 / 19.20±55.40 | 79.30±28.00 / 72.80±25.50 | 195.00±12.00 / 149.00±34.00 | |
| Hanabi | 2 players | 23.50±0.50 / 7.30±4.40 | 14.57±1.21 / 14.32±0.77 | 13.37±0.41 / 13.47±0.26 | 23.00±0.20 / 22.90±0.30 |
| 3 players | 23.00±0.20 / 8.60±1.50 | 16.20±0.71 / 15.84±0.76 | 12.61±0.46 / 12.52±0.34 | 22.70±1.00 / 21.90±1.20 | |
| 4 players | 22.50±0.60 / 4.20±1.90 | 13.75±1.70 / 13.54±0.89 | 14.62±1.17 / 14.67±0.75 | 22.70±0.50 / 21.10±0.40 | |
| 5 players | 21.70±0.90 / 6.00±2.10 | 15.05±2.27 / 14.82±1.60 | 13.24±1.14 / 13.11±0.93 | 22.00±0.30 / 20.50±0.60 |
PPC achieves higher XP than both added baselines in every setting. To isolate the effect of action constraints under the same semantics, Reward-based PPC keeps the promises, five Promisers, recurrent ego learner, sampled gates, and inferred-trust evaluation, but replaces masks with Promiser-only rewards of for fulfillment and for violation. Each Promiser and ego receives 30M training steps. Random masking provides a complementary control without meaningful promises.
Table R.4. Promise controls (Tables 6 and 20). Mean SD across layout means.
| Environment | Eval. | FCP | Random masking | Reward-based PPC | PPC |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overcooked-v1 | SP | 153.50±52.28 | 171.93±50.17 | 234.11±65.20 | 291.25±36.14 |
| Overcooked-v1 | XP | 160.00±50.77 | 184.45±42.71 | 203.30±63.95 | 277.75±42.80 |
| Overcooked-v2 | SP | 66.67±37.08 | 38.53±25.18 | 127.16±52.43 | 173.67±14.42 |
| Overcooked-v2 | XP | 50.50±20.86 | 39.28±25.30 | 62.33±38.04 | 140.50±19.17 |
PPC outperforms Reward-based PPC and random masking in both Overcooked versions. The former supports the tested action-constraint implementation over intrinsic rewards with matched promises; the latter shows that arbitrary restrictions alone are insufficient. Thus both meaningful promises and constraint-based enforcement contribute to the results (Appendix G.3.1).
Section 5.1 clarifies baseline tuning and PPC's SP-selected benchmark-wide configuration; the promise controls use matched Promiser and ego training budgets.
References
[1] Li et al., "LLM-Assisted Semantically Diverse Teammate Generation for Efficient Multi-agent Coordination", ICML 2025.
[2] Sarkar et al., "Diverse Conventions for Human-AI Collaboration", NeurIPS 2023.
Q4 (True-Trust Ablation Protocol)
The true-trust ablation does not assume that every partner has a known enforcement vector. During training with Promisers, the variant uses their sampled enforcement probabilities, setting . Unconstrained Promisees have no corresponding enforcement target, so the existing estimator infers trust from their behavior relative to predefined promise categories, including during self-play. SP and XP evaluation use inferred trust for all partners, as shown in Figures 9 and 29. Thus, the ablation tests access to oracle enforcement information during Promiser-partner training, not at evaluation, and does not treat observed fulfillment as enforcement.
Once again, we thank the reviewer for the careful review. We hope these additions clarify PPC's design and generalization.
I’ve raised my rating to 3. I find the Overcooked-v1 results convincing: PPC leads on all four layouts when every method faces the same unseen partners. The expanded cross-play results give me more confidence that PPC can coordinate beyond its training population. I also appreciate the new controls showing that cross-play remains strong with independently trained Promisers and that action constraints outperform reward-based enforcement using the same promises.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for their positive reassessment and encouraging feedback. We are pleased that the additional experiments have addressed the main concerns and provided stronger evidence supporting our proposed approach. We greatly appreciate your thoughtful feedback and consideration throughout the discussion.
We thank the reviewer for the questions on generalization, promise generation, controlled comparisons, and true trust. Below, we respond to each point.
W1/Q1 (Generalization to Unseen Partners)
Table 1 measures task competence through SP and compatibility between independently trained policies of the same method through XP. It does not, by itself, establish generalization to external partners. We now make this distinction explicit in the main text and present held-out XP and BR-Prox as separate evaluations in Figure 4 and Table 2. We also extended held-out XP to all Overcooked layouts and Hanabi team sizes in both ego and partner roles, with full results in Figures 19–21.
Table R.1. Held-out XP, ego / partner. Approximate averages exclude diagonals and equally weight other methods and all layouts/team sizes.
PPC leads both roles in Overcooked-v1/v2 and the partner role in Hanabi, while FCP leads as Hanabi ego. For a common-pool test, all egos face the same unseen biased partners in v1; PPC obtains the highest BR-Prox (Table 2). The pool is uninformative in v2/Hanabi, where the full held-out matrices provide broader coverage. These results support coordination with partners beyond PPC's training population.
W2/Q2 (Automatic Promise Generation and Variability)
Applying PPC to a new environment requires a task specification and an interface through which promises can be checked and executed. These inputs include dynamics, state, observation, and action definitions, and role information, as summarized in Table 7. Given these specifications, the same pipeline generates state summaries and executable promises, validates them, and refines them using interaction feedback without manual promise design or editing. We clarify this procedure in Appendices C.1–C.3.
To assess variation across generations by the same LLM, we independently repeated promise generation, refinement, Promiser learning, and ego learning, then cross-played the resulting egos.
Table R.2. Shared versus independent construction (Table 15). SP/XP: mean ± SD over layout means. Time counts one shared or ten independent constructions plus the same ego-training term.
Although promise definitions and action sets vary across runs, XP remains comparable to the shared setup. This supports coordination without identical promises or a shared Promiser population, while explaining why the default shares construction to save cost (Appendix F.4).
W3/Q3 (Baseline Comparisons and Promise Ablations)
To distinguish the contribution of semantic task knowledge from that of promise constraints, we added two types of evidence: comparisons with SemDiv [1] and CoMeDi [2] across all benchmarks, and a controlled reward-based variant using PPC's own promises. SemDiv uses the same LLM, recurrent backbone, five generated partners, and per-ego budget as PPC, but retains specialized egos and an evaluation-time LLM selector. PPC instead adapts one Promisee through inferred trust, without evaluation-time LLM calls, as described in Table 11.