- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
In this paper the author investigate the impact of input segregation on the resulting computation learned by a small network of morphologically realistic neurons trained to perform sensorimotor tasks. The author start from a recent experimental finding in mice where induced silencing of apical dendrites resulted in impaired relearning, while established behaviour was left mostly unaffected. To computationally study the impact of dendritic organisation on the kind of solution learned by a network, the authors trained a network a biologically realistic neurons on a rule-following task where sensory information was routed to the basal dendrites while additional context (informationally redundant with the sensory signal) was routed either to the basal or apical dendrites during training. At test time the context signal was withdrawn, and the network with input segregation (i.e. context in the apical compartment) showed significant reduced performance degradation. A subsequent interventional experiment in which the input sensory connections were swapped between the two configurations, illustrated how such sensory connections were indeed largely responsible for the different performance losses, with a sensory weight-matching training configuration further validating the point as the resulting configuration almost closed the gap between the two configurations. Lastly, the author proposed a proof-of-concept demonstration in a closed-loop task where input segregation resulted in better performances.
Critical strengths
The work opening motivation (a recent experimental finding on the impact of apical dendrites deactivation on mice behaviour) is intriguing and the subsequent experimental design is well crafted, with the two explored configurations (basal and apical context input) evaluated on subsequent test-time withdrawal of the context signal. The subsequent interventional experiments help locate the source of the observed difference in the sensory connections that training sculpts depending on context segregation. The final more realistic task is a nice addition towards more realistic closed-loop scenario.
Overall, the framing of dendritic organisation as a form of inductive learning bias is a valuable (and novel) contribution, which would be interesting for the field. Finally, the paper is generally well written with polished figures and a detailed appendix.
Critical weaknesses
One important limitation of the work concerns the various limits inherited from the complexity of simulating a network of morphologically-extended biologically realistic neurons. One obvious limit concerns the scale of the explored networks ( neurons) and the simplicity of the main task (although the authors do include the more realistic CoffePush task, which in turn however did result in significantly reduced differences; Fig.5C). A second limitation concerns the difficulty in interpreting the result due to the many degrees of freedom of the considered neural models: Fig. 2B shows a dependency between the apical-basal gap on one of the model parameters (), and it thus remains unclear how much (or whether) the observed gap is robust to changes in other model parameters that have a range of biologically plausible values (e.g. does an increase in overall firing rates alters the picture?)
Questions for authors
- Does the proposed principle of dendritic organisation as a learning bias extend to simplified multi-compartment neurons (e.g. Poirazi & Papoutsi Nat. Rev. Neuro. 2020; Capone et al. PNAS 2023; Graham et al. Neural Comp. 2025)? Or is there some important aspect that is lost by abstracting away the morphology?
- In the main task, the context is redundant so that even without context the network learns the task equally well (Fig. 2A). What happens if the context is not redundant? The CoffeePush task (Fig. 5B) seems to be hinting to the fact that input segregation generally helps performances, while the gap itself becomes more comparable between the two.
- How dependent are the findings (observed learning bias) on the choice of the learning algorithm (e.g. e-prop Bellec et al. Nat. Comms. 2020)? Or do these differences persist with longer training?
5 comments
Response to Question 1: Simplified multicompartment models and what morphological abstraction loses
The review by Poirazi and Papoutsi (2020) systematically discusses dendritic computation models at different levels of abstraction. Following the abstraction hierarchy, we tested an abstract gain network (Wybo et al., 2023), a three-compartment spiking model (Capone et al., 2023), and a reduced 20-compartment L5 pyramidal cell model (Bahl et al., 2012; Graham et al., 2025) on the same task (new Appendix F, Figs. S14–S15, Table S11). Simplified models fail without active dendrites, whereas a reduced biophysical model with active dendrites works:
Gain and three-compartment models give the opposite pattern. Without the cue, modulatory/apical routing performs worse than additive/basal routing in both the gain model (withdrawal-cost gap = -0.2315) and the three-compartment model (withdrawal-cost gap = -0.1387 under BPTT; -0.1365 under e-prop). Input segregation or gain modulation alone is therefore not enough.
An active 20-compartment biophysical model reproduces the apical advantage. Bahl et al. (2012) compressed a reconstructed L5 pyramidal neuron into seven anatomical regions (20 compartments) optimized against experimental voltage responses, preserving dendritic Ca2+ spikes and soma–dendrite coupling. Retaining active channels and AMPA/NMDA/GABA synapses reproduces our main result: cue removal raises apical NMSE only from 0.0468 to 0.0500, versus 0.0335 to 0.0833 for basal routing (withdrawal-cost gap = +0.0466).
Removing active dendritic channels erases most of the advantage. Making dendrites passive in the 20-compartment model—while keeping compartment separation, axial coupling, and NMDA synapses—cuts the withdrawal-cost gap to 0.0210, and removing only apical tuft Ca2+ channels cuts it to 0.0092 (Appendix F.3, Fig. S15B,D). Abstracting away active dendritic dynamics thus loses the core mechanism; how fine branch topology in the full Larkum et al. (2009) morphology further shapes learning remains an open question for future work.
Taken together, our results support a more specific conclusion: the learning bias induced by dendritic input organization depends on the combination of spatial input organization and local active dendritic dynamics. Abstract gain models and three-compartment models can retain computational features such as input modulation or spatial segregation, but these features alone are insufficient to determine the context dependence acquired through learning.
Response to Question 2: Nonredundant context and the interpretation of robotic control results
The informational relationship between sensory input and context determines what withdrawal measures. We distinguish fully redundant context, task-essential context, and the partially redundant phase cues used in the robotic tasks.
Fully redundant context isolates learned reliance on an additional pathway. In the main task, sensory input already encodes both direction and rule, and context repeats the rule. The task remains solvable after withdrawal, which reveals different learned solutions despite comparable full-input performance. Post-training sensory-weight exchange transfers the behavioral effect, while sharing sensory weights during training reduces it (Fig. 3). This connects the withdrawal phenotype to how the sensory mapping was acquired.
Task-essential context changes the meaning of the same intervention (new control in Appendix B, pp. 22–23). When the same sensory stimulus requires different actions under different rules, context supplies information needed to select the response. Auditory rule-switching tasks exemplify this structure (Zhang et al., 2026). We implemented this setting by disconnecting input from the 20 rule-encoding sensory channels, retaining direction input and the remaining training and evaluation settings.
Both routes learn the task with context present, but their errors rise to approximately 1.0 after withdrawal:
| Routing | Context-present NMSE | Post-withdrawal NMSE | NMSE increase |
|---|---|---|---|
| Apical | 0.059 ± 0.002 | 1.040 ± 0.002 | 0.981 ± 0.004 |
| Basal | 0.056 ± 0.011 | 1.022 ± 0.002 | 0.966 ± 0.012 |
Here, withdrawal removes the rule information needed to determine the target. Similar full-input errors do not imply identical representations or learning dynamics. Under task-essential context, those differences would be better examined through learned responses, synaptic organization, or acquisition dynamics, because the post-withdrawal error is dominated by missing task information. The redundant-context design makes that learning question directly accessible through behavior.
The robotic tasks combine substantial sensory–context overlap with explicit stage information (Appendices D, I). CoffeePush and Hand-insert require continuous control of the geometric relationships among the end effector, object, and target. Their phase cues identify stages such as reach/contact/push or approach-and-grasp/transport-and-align/lower-and-insert. Linear classifiers recover phase labels from current sensory observations with cross-validated balanced accuracies of 97.7% and 97.33%, respectively, on the expert-demonstration data (Appendices D.2 and I.2). Stage information is therefore substantially accessible through sensory input, while the explicit cue also incorporates trajectory history.
Knowing the stage does not specify the complete action: within each stage, the controller must still map continuous geometry to movement. Context can consequently influence both current action selection and how sensory–action mappings are organized during learning. Consistent with this interpretation, apical routing shows higher mean cue-present success and smaller mean withdrawal costs in both tasks (means across three networks; withdrawal costs in percentage points, pp; Tables S7, S12):
| Task | Apical success with cue (%) | Basal success with cue (%) | Apical withdrawal cost (pp) | Basal withdrawal cost (pp) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CoffeePush | 49.40 | 45.84 | 1.37 | 3.46 |
| Hand-insert | 41.64 | 37.67 | 2.06 | 5.34 |
Hand-insert extends the comparison to different action requirements. Its withdrawal cost is smaller for apical routing in every seed. Apical post-withdrawal success also exceeds basal post-withdrawal success and the independently trained context-free reference in every seed; the corresponding means are 39.58%, 32.33%, and 37.09% (Table S12).
The CoffeePush continuations directly test a learning effect. At epoch 20, each source controller is duplicated with identical weights and Adam states, then continued to epoch 50 with context retained or withdrawn. With context present at evaluation, retaining it during continued training improves apical success by 9.42 percentage points, positive in all three sources, and reduces basal success by 2.13 percentage points, negative in all three sources (Fig. 5C, Table S6B). Thus, the contribution of stage context depends on its route during learning, even when execution-time input availability is held fixed.
These findings answer both aspects of your question: apical routing is associated with better overall performance in these partially redundant settings, and the paired continuations show that context availability during learning changes later control. Together, these tasks distinguish learned dependence, loss of necessary information, and closed-loop consequences.
Response to Weakness
Thanks for your positive evaluation and for highlighting our framing of dendritic input organization as a learning inductive bias. We agree that network scale, task complexity, and parameter robustness are important limitations to address. In the revised manuscript, we have added comparisons across neuronal abstraction levels, analyses of different firing-rate regimes and extended training, and a second robotic manipulation task. All new additions are highlighted in blue.
Major Concern: Network Scale, Task Complexity, and Parameter Robustness
We thank the reviewer for recognizing the computational cost and simulation complexity associated with networks of morphologically detailed neurons. Because simulating multicompartment cable equations, active ion channels, and trial-level gradient replay is computationally expensive, our main circuit is currently limited to 32 excitatory and 8 inhibitory neurons, and we leave larger networks for future work.
Meanwhile, to address the reviewer's specific concerns, we have combined robustness analyses already present in the original manuscript with newly added experiments to broaden the model, parameter, and task coverage along several dimensions:
1. Parameter robustness: context learning rates and weight-update conditions (Appendix B, Fig. S5, already included in the original manuscript).
The original manuscript already examined context-weight learning rates set to 0.5, 1, and 2 times the baseline value, as well as a control condition in which context weights were frozen while all other parameters continued to be updated. The basal-minus-apical withdrawal-cost gaps were 0.04830, 0.05451, and 0.07600 at the three learning rates, respectively, and remained at 0.03741 when context weights were frozen. Although the magnitude of the difference varied with the learning configuration, the lower context dependence of apical routing was preserved across all these conditions. These existing results provide a basis for evaluating the influence of learning-parameter variations on our main finding.
2. Robustness across different levels of network activity (new Appendix H.1, Fig. S18).
To address the reviewer's specific question about firing rates, we varied the sensory input event rate to 0.75, 1, and 1.5 times its baseline value. The resulting mean population firing rates with context present after training were approximately 6, 11, and 24 Hz, respectively, covering substantially different levels of network activity. Under these three conditions, the mean basal-minus-apical withdrawal-cost gaps were 0.1163, 0.0545, and 0.0402, respectively. All three paired initializations retained the same direction of the routing difference. Increasing sensory drive reduced the magnitude of the difference but did not reverse its direction.
3. Robustness to longer training (new Appendix H.2, Fig. S19).
We extended training of the main model from 500 to 1,000 epochs, resuming from the epoch-500 checkpoints with their network weights and optimizer states restored. The mean basal-minus-apical withdrawal-cost gaps at epochs 500, 750, and 1,000 were 0.0545, 0.0541, and 0.0551. All three network pairs maintained a lower withdrawal cost for apical routing. Thus, the learning bias observed in our main experiments is not restricted to a particular training endpoint.
4. Extension to a second embodied manipulation task (new Appendix I, Fig. S20, Table S12).
To address the relative simplicity of the main task, we added a second MetaWorld manipulation task, Hand-insert, which involves three sequential stages: approach and grasp, transport and alignment, and lowering and insertion. This task involves action requirements and closed-loop interactions that differ from those in CoffeePush. In Hand-insert, the mean context-present success rate was 41.64% for apical routing and 37.67% for basal routing. After context withdrawal, the success rates decreased by 2.06 and 5.34 percentage points, respectively. Across all three seeds, basal routing consistently exhibited a higher withdrawal cost than apical routing. This extends our closed-loop control results from a single CoffeePush task to a second manipulation task.