- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This manuscript studies whether dendritic growth can be used as a task-driven learning mechanism without backpropagation. The authors iteratively modify dendritic morphology, simulate the resulting neuronal responses, and evaluate each candidate structure using a refitted linear readout. Experiments are conducted on synchrony detection, direction classification, and displacement estimation. The results show that performance improves as morphology develops, that redistributing the selected inputs across neurons reduces performance, and that increasing connectivity does not always lead to better prediction. The manuscript further analyzes these observations through remapping experiments and comparisons among HH, Passive, and Point neuron implementations.
Critical strengths
The research question is interesting, and studying neuron-level learning through structural adaptation rather than conventional backpropagation is a reasonable and potentially useful direction. And the remapping experiments go beyond a simple before-and-after performance comparison and provide some analysis of how input organization affects the learned representation.
Critical weaknesses
- The main contributions are relatively basic and largely consistent with existing structural-learning knowledge. The manuscript shows that structural adaptation can improve performance, that input organization matters, and that denser connectivity is not always better, but it does not clearly establish what new insight is specifically enabled by dendritic computation.
- The current experiments do not sufficiently isolate which structural or biophysical factors are responsible for the observed gains. In addition, the Point model differs from the dendritic models in input representation and training procedure, which complicates the interpretation of the connectivity–performance comparison.
Questions for authors
- The main findings are broadly consistent with known structural-learning behavior. What new insight does the dendritic setting provide beyond showing that these effects also occur in a biophysical neuron model?
- The Point model differs from the dendritic models in both input representation and training procedure. How are these differences excluded as explanations for the different connectivity–performance trends?
- In the source-held remapping experiment, reassigning source identities to fixed contact sites changes the dendritic location and local integration context associated with each source. How can the effect of neuron-level allocation be separated from the effect of within-neuron dendritic placement?
- Morphological growth simultaneously changes connectivity, effective synaptic strength, and dendritic signal propagation. Although HH and Passive provide a partial comparison, which of these coupled factors is primarily responsible for the reported improvement?