- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes COEX-FL, a federated attack framework for multi-target, multi-shape backdoors, where the malicious clients do not communicate during weight updates. Each attacker independently builds frequency-domain triggers from a shared Hadamard-based coding scheme.
Critical strengths
The backdoor triggers has training-free closed form construction, derived from the shared parameters and its own labels, requiring no runtime communication.
Critical weaknesses
-
Authors claim COEX-FL to be "non-colluding", however, all adversaries must share the same attack parameters and strategies. It is only that no information is exchanged during training. Authors should reposition and reframe the storyline. If Authors want to stick with the "non-colluding" setting, additional experiments should be added when other attackers can adopt different attack schemes.
-
The writing is very difficult to follow, especially in sec.3 methodology. Many notations are never explained. Eg: "mode" is a very important concept that describes the attack setting, and appears in the title, but authors never defined this term throughout the paper.
Questions for authors
How should one pick the hyperparameters like ? The writing suggests that these are controllers/gates of the attack strength, but no systematic ablations are provided for hyperparameter sensitivity.