- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper argues that AI governance should target within-jurisdiction evaluations and proposes an analysis framework to instantiate its arguments. Specifically, instead of focusing on the evaluation on frontier models, researchers should also evaluate the specific situations in the local area of interest (e.g., Jakarta) such as the affordability (PAI) and management by local authority (DVR). Authors have also found that the Joules per Task (JpT) reported by different measurements can have significant differences. Case studies demonstrate the proposed analysis framework.
Critical strengths
- The proposed argument is generally clear and seems an underrepresented topic in recent discussions on AI governance.
- The anlyses (Figures 1 and 2) are concrete and useful to this research direction.
Critical weaknesses
- This paper is hard to follow. Certain linguistic patterns produce a lot of complex sentences such as "....: ..., ..., and ..." or "...: ...; ...", which undermine the readability. Though main arguments and figures are understandable, the low readability may prevent readers from engaging in deeper thinking.
- Although this paper's main statement is regionality of AI governance, analysis around Figure 1 seems not directly related to that discussion. In my understanding, Figure 1 says that different measures can lead to very different estimates on energy consumption. Why this figure helps or instantiates regional analysis? Please let me know if I am wrong. Additionally, deep discussions around why this argument was valuable and underexplored are also lacking from my perspective. Such discussions are critical given that this paper is close to a position paper.
Questions for authors
- How does Figure 1 relate to regionality of AI governance?
- I think there is a subtle difference between "AI governance in global south" and "AI governance in a specific region". Both are mixed in this paper. For example, you can also discuss the affordability and local management in Germany or Japan. Your proposed idea and instantiated framework can work on these countries as well, but global south was set as a keyword for this paper. Do you intend to distinguish between the AI governance in global south and in a specific region? Which one is your main argument?