- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes structure-factor coordinates, an input representation for predicting the frequency response of finite-aperture wave systems from the active element coordinates. The structure factor is computed directly from the point set and compressed into radial spectra and angular moments at multiple scales. It is then appended as an additional input to point-based predictors (Transolver-MS, Point-DeepONet), and to the proposed model named SURFNO that combines a fitted kernel transform with a learned residual.
Critical strengths
- The structure factor connects the element layout to the wave response through a known physical relation, which leads to improvements in two different predictors.
- is computed directly from the point set, which avoids the sensitivity to rasterization observed for the CNN baseline.
Critical weaknesses
-
Readability. The paper needs substantial revision to improve readability.
- The paper contains many unnecessary and defensive phrases throughout the paper, which do not convey meaningful information but hinder understanding. A few examples: "MS means multiscale, not multiple seeds", "This is reuse of a physical representation, not evidence that ...".
- Claims are often raised and then immediately walked back, making the main message difficult to identify.
- Essential details are missing, including the Transolver-MS and Point-DeepONet architectures, S(q) fusion and readout, original-model preliminaries, and the detilas of ( range, bins, harmonic orders).
-
Unclear contributions. It is difficult to identify the core contribution of the paper.
- The proposed "physical input interface" appears more like an additional input feature: it is the classical structure factor, which the authors acknowledge is not novel, compressed by standard radial/angular averaging and appended as an input feature.
- The other two listed contributions provide limited empirical support for this feature and mostly negative findings.
- SURFNO, the only new model, is neither listed as a contribution nor the best-performing predictor.
-
What is reusable, and why? The paper does not establish what makes the representation "reusable" or what benefit this provides.
- S(q) is a deterministic function of the coordinates already given to the models, serving as an additional hand-crafted global descriptor.
- The representation itself appears not reusable in practice: each model is modified to accept S(q) and trained separately, while the cross-physics experiments also fit separate models.
- Experiments do not clearly demonstrate the advantages of sharing the representation.
-
Insufficient evaluations. The experiments do not sufficiently support the main claims.
- The experiments mainly test whether improves prediction as an additional input, not whether it is reusable.
- Even as a feature ablation, Tab. 2 only removes from the authors' modified models. Comparisons with the original models adapted with a minimal output modification is missing, and the geometry-only Transolver is reported in Tab. 9 but its accuracy is not compared against the proposed models.
- In inverse design, the search procedure appears more important than the representation: SURFNO and CNN perform on par under the same search, while the path directly using performs worst. These results contradict with the paper's main claims and need more thorough analysis and explanations.
Questions for authors
- What exactly is reused beyond the formula for computing ? Can the authors provide an experiment demonstrating a benefit of reuse, e.g., transferring a trained encoder across predictors or physical systems?
- How do the original Transolver and DeepONet, adapted with a minimal output modification and using coordinates alone, perform on the acoustic benchmark? What is the accuracy of the geometry-only Transolver in Tab. 9?
- In inverse design, SURFNO and CNN perform on par under the same search, while the path directly using performs worst. Could the authors provide deeper analysis on these results and connections of these results to the advantages of the reused representation?
3 comments
Thank you for the detailed response. Unfortunately, my concern regarding the contribution and reusability still remains.
The revised version now lists contributions as 1) , 2) encoder transferability on the same task, 3) SURFNO as an interpretable baseline. In my view, using as input offers little new insight and seems to have limited novelty. Second, it would be more convincing if the authors showed what advantages and findings "transferring the encoder on the same task" could give. Finally, SURFNO doesn't give improvement in terms of accuracy, while the interpretability claim needs further discussion and validation.
Regarding the reusability, it's difficult to claim that a representation directly derived from a well-known physical formulation is a "reusable representation", while the encoder transferability on the same task needs more discussion, particularly in terms of its advantages.
I appreciate the efforts to improve readability and provide additional results. I'm raising the score, but I still lean toward rejection for the reasons above.
Thank you for reconsidering the paper
Your comments help us clarify how the representation, encoder-transfer experiment and interpretable baseline support one central contribution.
Contribution. We construct multiscale, directional coordinates that organize global interference information into a common input for different geometry-to-response predictors. This allows us to investigate whether the spectral features learned within one architecture remain useful when its geometry encoder and readout change.
Advantages and findings of reuse. On the same acoustic task, transferring one frozen Transolver-MS spectral encoder to Point-DeepONet reduces mean MAE by 13.1% relative to training from scratch and by 35.5% relative to a randomly initialized frozen encoder, across three target seeds (Table 3). The latter control establishes that the learned weights carry useful information. Freezing also gives the lowest mean MAE among the four initialization/training conditions, while fine-tuning does not improve mean MAE over ordinary training. Thus, the experiment demonstrates that useful spectral features can survive an architectural change without further adaptation. With the source encoder available, target training takes 359 seconds versus 1,163 seconds from scratch. Source training costs 1,303 seconds.
Physical interpretability. We agree that the acoustic core ablation shows no accuracy gain from adding the core. Its interpretation can be assessed more directly in Figure A1, which compares physical and fitted kernels. The fitted spectral bands shift toward higher radial wavenumbers as antenna frequency increases, and toward lower wavenumbers as diffraction wavelength increases, following the respective physical relations. These observations connect the fitted weights to physically meaningful spatial scales. SURFNO makes this spectral contribution and the learned correction separately inspectable. For coupled acoustics, the fitted core represents an effective spectral-to-response mapping.
Together, these results show how the proposed coordinates support learned-feature reuse across two architectures and permit physical inspection of the spectral-to-response relation.
Thank you for the four concerns. We revised the presentation and added input, original-model and encoder-transfer controls. References use revised numbering.
1. Readability and missing details. Section 3.1 now explains points → intensity → radial/angular channels → multiscale tensor → predictor. It defines reciprocal ranges, seven scales, 64 radii, 32 azimuths, orders 2/4/6/12 and the 7×9×64 tensor. Appendix B.2/Table B2 specify geometry/spectral encoders, fusion and readout dimensions. Tables B1/B3 collect physical/data parameters and training protocols. Repeated defensive phrasing is removed; Appendices A–E organize derivation, implementation, prediction, reuse and design.
2. Contribution and SURFNO. Structure-factor coordinates compress geometry-derived relative-phase information into a common multiscale directional input for different predictors.
The added three-seed SF/FFT comparison holds predictor capacity, geometric inputs and the 120-epoch budget fixed, using a common fixed IDCT adapter:
Means ± sample SD; every pair improves MAE/RMSE (Table 2). The comparison includes sampling/preprocessing and irregular-template raster collisions. A separate from-scratch unseen-template test improves both predictors while retaining a generalization gap (Table 4).
SURFNO is an interpretable baseline: its fitted response kernel and learned residual are inspectable separately. Its purpose is physical interpretation, not necessarily best accuracy. Coupled-acoustic coefficients are effective mappings rather than uniquely identified mechanisms. Fixed-budget with/without-core MAEs of 0.0986/0.0974 dB do not show a core accuracy gain (Appendix C.4).
3. What is reused? We transfer 159,680 spectral-module parameters from seed-0 Transolver-MS to Point-DeepONet; geometry processing and readout remain target-specific. Four conditions pair other initializations across three target seeds, using the same acoustic split, 120 target epochs and validation-RMSE selection:
Frozen transfer improves every target seed: 13.1% lower mean MAE than random/trainable and 35.5% lower than random/frozen. Fine-tuning does not improve mean MAE (Table 3; Appendix D.1). Target training falls from 1163 to 359 s; including 1303 s source training gives 1662 s for one source-plus-target fit. This is same-task cross-predictor reuse with one source encoder, not cross-physics transfer. Antenna/diffraction models are fitted separately.
4. Original models and geometry-only accuracy. Submitted Table 9's geometry-only Transolver achieves 0.13818 dB MAE, with 365,933 parameters and coordinates, layout and 11 descriptors. Revised Table C5 now reports its accuracy. New coordinates-only controls use three seeds, 120 epochs and validation-RMSE selection:
Table C3 specifies adaptations and per-seed results. DeepONet selects epochs 118/119/120; its result describes this configuration, not a convergence limit. These architecture controls differ in capacity. Direct input evidence comes from matched-capacity SF/FFT and full/zero studies. Continued full/zero now covers three seeds, each arm continuing its own independently initialized lineage with historical early stopping (Table C2).
5. Inverse design. Across 72 antenna targets, spectrum-mediated paths achieve median exact-evaluator MAEs of 3.44×10⁻⁵/3.41×10⁻⁵ versus 2.39×10⁻⁴ for the strongest direct-logit path; differing budgets make this a complete-procedure comparison. Across 30 acoustic targets, matched CNN/SURFNO swap search gives 0.0750/0.0771 dB, versus 0.2031 for spectrum-first and 0.2730 for continuous-mask search (Figure 3; Table 5).
Coupled amplitudes, finite windows and discrete realization add dependencies beyond Fourier intensity. Antenna results support spectral design; acoustic results favor feasible geometry refinement. Forward gains do not imply inverse gains for every predictor (Appendix E).