- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes A^3Flow, an unsupervised optical flow estimation method. It builds on U^2Flow by incorporating three modules: an attention residual encoder (AttnResEncoder), adaptive uncertainty gating via ResidualFiLM, and content-and-position global motion aggregation (CP-GMA). Experiments show promising results.
Critical strengths
- The methodology is generally sound, the training and evaluation protocols are standard, and the results are valid and promising.
- The method section explains the architecture of each proposed module in detail, supported by mathematical formulations.
Critical weaknesses
- The method section mainly describes what the proposed modules are. The motivations are stated but not supported by analysis or evidence specific to optical flow. The results are largely empirical and offer few insights. The performance improvements remain a black box, which makes the results less compelling. Unsupervised optical flow is a poorly constrained problem. I would expect improvements to come from heuristics or ideas rooted in traditional computer vision, i.e., methods whose effectiveness under such weak constraints can be understood, rather than treating the problem as pure engineering, as is often done in supervised optical flow.
- The ablation study in Table 2 is incomplete. If the three proposed modules are independent of each other, the ablation should cover all 8 possible combinations rather than only 4.
- The mathematical notation is inconsistent, imprecise, and at times confusing. Examples include, but are not limited to:
- Lines 178–181 use and but , while Fig. 2 uses and .
- Eq. (2): is not defined.
- Eq. (3): is not defined. The definition is also circular: on the left, is defined in terms of and , while on the right, and are defined in terms of .
- Eq. (2) uses to denote the sigmoid function, while Line 284 uses to denote the key projection. denotes both the uncertainty (log-variance) and the scalar coefficient in Eq. (8).
- Eq. (10) is confusing: and index and , but and are not defined.
- Concatenation is written as in Eqs. (2) and (7), but as in Line 291.
- The presentation could be more polished:
- The figures are not in vector format (e.g., EPS/PDF) and may show artifacts when zoomed in.
- Formatting is inconsistent: Sections 1–3 use “Fig.” (e.g., Line 161), while Section 4 uses “Figure” (e.g., Line 411).
- Table 3: the best value in the second column (5.49) is not in bold. Table 4: the best values in the last two columns are not in bold.
- Typo in Line 351: → .
Questions for authors
See weaknesses.