- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The authors propose TDFlow, a truncated diffusion model for optical flow that uses an initial flow estimate as an anchor and denoising in a single step to reduce computation, paired with a feature-space warping decoder to maintain accuracy. Author report state-of-the-art results with significantly lower latency than prior diffusion-based methods.
Critical strengths
Diffusion-based flow methods are known to be slow, and This paper makes the whole thing single-step with large measured speedups in latency and memory. That directly addresses the main blocker for deploying generative flow estimators in practice, and the accuracy is kept at a competitive level.
The truncated diffusion policy is integrated on top of several existing anchors from different method families, and it consistently improves all of them. This shows the idea is not tied to one specific backbone, which makes easier for others tasks to adopt.
Critical weaknesses
Q1:The paper tests five anchors for compatibility, but never analyzes how anchor quality affects the final gain or where the quality floor is. If the flow anchor is bad enough that the true flow falls outside the noise perturbation range, yet this is not tested.
Q2:All compared methods are from 2025 or earlier. For an ICLR 2027 submission, how do we know TDFlow still beats the latest 2026 methods? Please note that WAFT is ICLR2026, but it was published earlier on the internet.
Q3:The no-noise ablation already reaches KITTI EPE 3.02 vs. 2.87 with noise,the difference is not significant. This suggests the CFSW residual decoder is the real workhorse while diffusion adds only marginal benefit. No comparison against flow matching or deterministic regression is provided. Is the choice of diffusion necessary?
Questions for authors
Please answer the question, carefully, the weak acceptance is not fixed.
9 comments
Response to Reviewer f4Gx (R3)
Q2. Comparison with recent methods from 2025–2026.
We have updated Table 3(a,b) (p. 7) of the revised manuscript to include these recent methods, with benchmark and cross-dataset results kept separate, and added brief discussion and the corresponding references. We broaden the comparison to FlowSeek (ICCV 2025), OFM (CVPR 2026), FreeFlow and MegaFlow (ECCV 2026), FlowIt (BMVC 2026), and the CVPR 2026 ViSCALE Workshop method of Chanda and Kumar. Table R9 compares hidden-test results after target-benchmark training; Table R10 examines cross-dataset generalization without target-domain flow fine-tuning. These are published results with method-specific pretraining and training budgets.
Table R9. Published hidden-test results after target-benchmark training. Sintel columns are EPE; KITTI is Fl-all (%). Lower is better. All listed methods use two input frames.
| Method | Venue | Clean | Final | KITTI Fl-all |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| OFM | CVPR 2026 | 0.94 | 1.85 | 3.78 |
| FlowIt | BMVC 2026 | 1.01 | 2.45 | 4.50 |
| FreeFlow | ECCV 2026 | 1.03 | 1.99 | 4.06 |
| TDFlow | Ours | 0.96 | 1.84 | 3.34 |
Sources: OFM, Table 1 [3]; FlowIt v2, Table 1 [6]; and FreeFlow, Table 4 [7]. FlowIt and FreeFlow use the published S configurations. The FlowIt row uses its TartanAir-pretrained setting; FreeFlow uses additional cross-view pretraining.
TDFlow improves all three reported metrics over the listed FlowIt and FreeFlow results. OFM is slightly better on Clean, while TDFlow has lower Final EPE and KITTI Fl-all. These results position TDFlow as competitive across the reported benchmarks.
Table R10. Cross-dataset evaluation on Sintel (train) and KITTI-2015 (train), without target-domain flow fine-tuning. C: FlyingChairs; T: FlyingThings3D; TA: TartanAir. Pretrained visual/depth representations and training budgets remain method-specific.
| Method | Venue | Flow-training data | Clean | Final | KITTI EPE | KITTI Fl-all |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FlowSeek-L | ICCV 2025 | C+T | 1.07 | 2.21 | 3.82 | 12.5 |
| FlowSeek-S | ICCV 2025 | TA+C+T | 1.05 | 2.37 | 3.32 | 11.0 |
| FlowSeek-L | ICCV 2025 | TA+C+T | 1.03 | 2.18 | 3.31 | 11.2 |
| Chanda and Kumar | CVPRW 2026 | C+T | 1.46 | 2.81 | – | – |
| FlowIt | BMVC 2026 | TA+C+T | 0.90 | 2.18 | 4.81 | 17.3 |
| MegaFlow | ECCV 2026 | C+TA+T | 0.89 | 2.07 | 3.00 | 10.6 |
| TDFlow | Ours | C+T | 0.87 | 2.09 | 2.87 | 9.30 |
Sources: FlowSeek, Table 3 [5]; Chanda and Kumar, Table 1 [4]; FlowIt v2, Table 2 [6]; and MegaFlow, Table 1 [8]. CVPRW denotes the CVPR 2026 ViSCALE Workshop. Dashes mean that no value is taken from the cited table. The target datasets' training splits are used for evaluation because their ground truth is public; their flow labels are not used for target-domain fine-tuning in this comparison. MegaFlow (ECCV 2026) additionally uses pretrained VGGT/DINOv2 representations. We use its main comparison Table 1, not the slightly different values in its ablation Table 6.
Under C+T optical-flow training without target-domain flow fine-tuning, TDFlow achieves competitive cross-dataset performance against the listed recent configurations, including methods using additional TartanAir training data. It has lower errors than the listed FlowSeek and FlowIt results, and lower Sintel EPE than Chanda and Kumar. Relative to MegaFlow, TDFlow has lower Clean EPE and KITTI errors, while MegaFlow has slightly lower Final EPE (2.07 vs. 2.09).
References
[3] Ao Luo et al. Optical Flow Matching: Reframing Optical Flow as Continuous Transport Dynamics. CVPR, 2026.
[4] Praroop Chanda and Suryansh Kumar. Rethinking Dense Optical Flow without Test-Time Scaling. CVPR Workshops, ViSCALE, 2026.
[5] Matteo Poggi and Fabio Tosi. FlowSeek: Optical Flow Made Easier with Depth Foundation Models and Motion Bases. ICCV, 2025.
[6] Sadra Safadoust et al. FlowIt: Global Matching via Hierarchical Transformers and Optimal Transport for Optical Flow. BMVC, 2026.
[7] Vladislav Bargatin et al. FreeFlow: A Bias-Free Hierarchical Transformer for Optical Flow Estimation. ECCV, 2026.
[8] Dingxi Zhang, Fangjinhua Wang, Marc Pollefeys, and Haofei Xu. MegaFlow: Zero-Shot Large Displacement Optical Flow. ECCV, 2026.
Response to Reviewer f4Gx (R3)
Q3. Is the gain mainly from CFSW, given the cited 3.02 EPE?
The 3.02 KITTI EPE row in Table 5 is “Without CFSW,” not the no-noise control. Anchor only omits the final refinement update; w/o TDP retains that additional WAFT update and CFSW decoder but disables TDP. The independently retrained w/o TDP model therefore provides the direct additional-update control:
Table R11. Components and the independently retrained w/o TDP control, which retains the extra refinement update. C+T optical-flow training.
| Configuration | Sintel Clean EPE | Sintel Final EPE | KITTI EPE | KITTI Fl-all (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Anchor only | 1.03 | 2.32 | 3.23 | 10.75 |
| w/o TDP (refinement retained) | 1.01 | 2.29 | 3.21 | 10.63 |
| Without CFSW | 0.93 | 2.14 | 3.02 | 9.87 |
| Full TDFlow | 0.87 | 2.09 | 2.87 | 9.30 |
Relative to the retrained w/o TDP control, TDFlow reduces Sintel Clean/Final EPE by 13.9%/8.7%, KITTI EPE by 10.6%, and KITTI Fl-all by 1.33 percentage points (12.5% relative). Since both configurations retain the final refinement update, the gain goes beyond adding that update alone. Removing CFSW also hurts accuracy, supporting complementary contributions from feature alignment and TDP.
The fine-tuned comparison in Table R1 shows the same direction, with Sintel EPE decreasing from 1.08/2.36 to 0.96/1.84; the fine-tuned KITTI gains are smaller. The ten-seed experiment measures inference-noise variation at a fixed checkpoint, so the reductions above are empirical effect sizes rather than training-seed significance estimates.
The OFM [3] comparison in Q2 provides context from a recent flow-matching method, while the independently retrained deterministic control isolates the benefit of our formulation within the retained refinement architecture. These results support its effectiveness, rather than establish diffusion as uniquely necessary.
References
[3] Ao Luo et al. Optical Flow Matching: Reframing Optical Flow as Continuous Transport Dynamics. CVPR, 2026.
Response to Reviewer f4Gx (R3)
Q1. How does anchor quality affect the gain, and what happens with no informative anchor?
The submitted compatibility study spans several anchor qualities. Table R7 reproduces the KITTI values and mean relative reduction over EPE and Fl-all, following the manuscript's Eq. (6).
Table R7. Refinement across anchor families after C+T training. Fl-all and PG are percentages.
The three less accurate baselines obtain larger mean relative improvements than DPFlow. Their corresponding Sintel improvements are 5.8%, 7.8%, and 4.7%, compared with 3.1% for DPFlow. This supports effectiveness beyond highly accurate anchors. The relationship is not strictly monotonic: initial aggregate error does not describe the spatial structure or correctability of errors.
We additionally trained a pure-noise-initialized configuration, replacing the informative flow anchor with pure noise while retaining image conditioning:
Table R8. Final predictions of separately trained initialization configurations. These are not errors of the initial noise.
The pure-noise configuration still learns optical-flow prediction from image evidence, but is substantially less accurate. This supports the anchor's role as an informative motion prior.
The decoder is supervised against ground-truth flow, so its predicted residual is not bounded by the injected perturbation magnitude. The pure-noise result supports the benefit of an informative anchor in the tested training configuration.