- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper derives an Interval Denoiser from the flow-matching ODE: a weighted average of denoising predictions that enables one- or two-step generation directly in pixel space. It explains how this target relates to Pixel MeanFlow and CTM, analyzes a difference in their training updates, and uses residual clipping and a time-sampling curriculum to stabilize large steps.
On class-conditional ImageNet 256×256, it reports 4.55 FID with one network evaluation and 3.98 with two, without an autoencoder or perceptual loss. Ablations show that the curriculum provides most of the measured gain; with clipping alone, the new method and Pixel MeanFlow perform similarly.
Critical strengths
A clear theoretical account of the prediction target. Deriving the Interval Denoiser from the flow-matching ODE gives a precise interpretation of the quantity predicted by Pixel MeanFlow and connects it to CTM. This makes the paper useful beyond its specific implementation.
Critical weaknesses
-
The Pixel MeanFlow comparison is not matched to the paper’s strongest training recipe. The main baseline is not retrained with the same residual clipping and time-sampling curriculum, even though the curriculum accounts for most of pID’s measured improvement and could be applied to pMF. The reported FID gap therefore does not establish that pID is the better method.
-
The practical benefit of the new objective remains unclear. With clipping and a static sampler, pID and pMF achieve nearly identical FIDs (9.25 vs. 9.34). The paper explains their theoretical update difference, but does not show that this difference yields a meaningful, reproducible gain under matched conditions.
Questions for authors
-
Decision-critical comparison: Can pID match or surpass pMF’s best reported result under a comparable setup, including perceptual loss if that result uses it? If the claim is specifically about generation without perceptual loss, please instead compare against pMF trained with the same full recipe, including clipping and curriculum.
-
Clarification of the contribution: Beyond a more principled derivation, what measurable benefit does the pID objective provide over pMF? With clipping alone, their reported results are nearly identical; please isolate any gain in generation quality, training stability, or efficiency attributable to the new objective.
2 comments
Matched comparison addresses concern; overall assessment unchanged
Thank you for adding the matched comparison and clarifying the contribution. This addresses my concern about the missing control experiment. The results demonstrate the curriculum’s usefulness for both methods, but do not establish a practical advantage of the pID objective over pMF.
I appreciate the theoretical interpretation and explicit sampling rule. However, I remain unconvinced that the additional contribution beyond pMF and CTM is sufficiently substantial to change my overall assessment. I will therefore maintain my weak-reject recommendation.
We greatly appreciate the reviewer’s feedback on our paper. We respond to each point below.
(1) Can pID match or outperform pMF when both methods use the same full training recipe? In our matched 160-epoch comparison on ImageNet-256, we used one training seed per method and no perceptual losses. pMF-B/16 achieved a lower 1-NFE FID than pID-B/16 (7.06 vs. 7.55). With the pMF objective fixed, the curriculum lowered its FID by 2.28 points relative to the static LN(0.8, 0.8) baseline of 9.34.
(2) What does the pID formulation offer beyond pMF? In the matched B/16 experiments, we did not establish a quality, stability, or efficiency advantage for the pID objective over pMF. Our formulation addresses gaps in the interpretation and evaluation of pMF [3] and provides guidance for training interval predictions:
[1] Li and He. Back to Basics: Let Denoising Generative Models Denoise. CVPR, 2026.
[2] Geng et al. Mean Flows for One-step Generative Modeling. NeurIPS, 2025.
[3] Lu et al. One-step Latent-free Image Generation with Pixel Mean Flows. ICML, 2026.
[4] Kim et al. Understanding, Accelerating, and Improving MeanFlow Training. CVPR, 2026.
[5] Zhang et al. AlphaFlow: Understanding and Improving MeanFlow Models. ICLR, 2026.
[6] Chen and Lipman. Flow Matching on General Geometries. ICLR, 2024.