- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper explores spiking state-space models (SSMs) for radar signal analysis. This is a meaningful direction, as the temporal modeling capabilities of spiking neural networks (SNNs) remain underexplored.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
-
I could not tell how the proposed spiking SSM differs from existing spiking SSMs. The current description gives too little technical detail to understand its operation. A diagram explaining the computation would also help.
-
RF neurons already exhibit resonance and have been used in sequence modeling. What does the proposed resonant SSM add beyond RF-based models? The paper needs to explain this difference and include a comparison with these models.
-
The main method takes up less than one page, leaving several basic questions unanswered. Which parts of the design are new, what benefits do they bring, and which operations are spike-driven? I am also unsure what the radar input is: does the model receive raw waveforms, or are they first converted into image representations?
-
Tables 1–3 extend beyond the page margins, and Figure 2 does not distinguish the proposed components from the existing ones. The use of SiLU also needs explanation. Does it introduce non-spiking computation? If so, how does this affect the computational savings expected from the SNN?
-
Most of the SNN baselines are older models. Comparisons with recent spiking Transformers are missing, as are comparisons with existing spiking SSMs. Since the paper presents a spiking SSM, the latter comparison is needed to assess what the proposed design adds.
Questions for authors
See weakness
8 comments
Response to Reviewer KcY9
Response to Q3: In this paper, in addition to proposing an oscillatory spiking SSM, we also propose multiple radar-application-specific architectures, unlike previous works (Bal & Sengupta, 2025; Shen et al., 2025; Fabre et al., 2025). The dataset-specific input representations and preprocessing requirements are summarised in Table 6, distinguishing preprocessed radar inputs from the raw FMCW signals used by RF-SpecSpkSSM. Further implementation details are provided in Appendices A.2.3, A.2.4, A.2.5, A.2.6 and A.2.7. We have included the following paragraph in the main text of the revised manuscript to clarify the radar input representations and preprocessing requirements.
Radar Input Representations: The RFspkSSM models demonstrate robust performance across a wide range of radar representations depending on the task and/or the availability of publicly available data formats. More specifically, AOPHand, mmFiT, and MMActivity use radar-derived point clouds, Google Soli uses preprocessed range-Doppler frames, MMVR uses dual-view radar heatmaps, and EgoHands uses synchronised radar and IMU sequences. In contrast, RF-SpecSpkSSM processes raw FMCW ADC samples before conventional range-Doppler transformation. Only basic signal conditioning is retained, while the range and Doppler FFTs are replaced by the proposed RF-SpecSpkSSM spectral front end, as illustrated in Figure 4 of Appendix A.2.7. The dataset-specific input representations and preprocessing requirements are further detailed in Table 11 of the Appendix.
Table 6: Radar input representations used across the RFspkSSM models. Input shapes exclude the batch dimension.
| Dataset | Model Input | Input Preparation |
|---|---|---|
| AOPHand | Point cloud, | Subsampling/padding to 64 points, training-set normalisation, and reshaping. |
| mmFiT | Point cloud, | Subsampling/padding to 64 points, training-set normalisation, and reshaping. |
| MMActivity | Point cloud, | Subsampling/padding to 64 points, native feature scale, and reshaping. |
| Google Soli | Range-Doppler, | Single-channel selection and frame-wise flattening. |
| MMVR | Dual-view heatmaps, per view | Precomputed, temporally synchronised horizontal-depth and vertical-depth heatmaps. |
| EgoHands | Radar–IMU sequences, | Temporally synchronised radar and IMU sequences. |
| Aircraft Marshalling | Raw FMCW ADC, | Fast- and slow-time DC removal, Hann windowing, and segmentation into 17 overlapping windows (192 chirps, hop 48). |
Response to Q4: We thank the reviewer for raising this point. We have followed the simplified operation-based analyses of Bal & Sengupta (2025); Liao et al. (2026), the energy model estimates computational cost using MACs and spike-driven ACs. Another goal of this work is also to drive future hardware designs. In RFspkSSM, binary spikes enable accumulation-based computation, whereas operations on real-valued features, including convolutions and linear projections, require dense MACs. In particular, SiLU and GELU are conventional nonlinear activations and do not constitute spike-driven computation. Although SiLU introduces non-spiking computation, its element-wise complexity is , which is lower than the complexity of dense linear layers, consistent with the analysis of nonlinear activation costs in P-SpikeSSM (Bal & Sengupta, 2025). Compared with GELU, which involves evaluating the Gaussian cumulative distribution function, SiLU uses a simpler sigmoid-based formulation, potentially reducing activation overhead.
Our theoretical energy analysis follows the operation-based MAC/AC methodology adopted in prior SNN and hybrid ANN–SNN architectures (Horowitz, 2014; Bal & Sengupta, 2025; Liao et al., 2026; Panda et al., 2020; Aydin et al., 2024; Lee et al., 2026). Our hybrid ANN-SNN design is further motivated by emerging neuromorphic platforms such as Innatera Pulsar. The use of LIF neurons potentially makes the model amenable for implementation in analog neuromorphic chips (Innatera, 2026; Richter et al., 2024).
Response to Reviewer KcY9
Response to Q5: We thank the reviewer for highlighting these presentation issues. The principal contributions in Figure 2 are the OscSpikeSSM-based RF-SpikingOSS blocks, multidirectional spiking scans along the radar axes, depth-aware cross-view fusion, and the proposed query-based pose prediction and refinement architecture, as detailed in Section 4.3 and Appendix A.2.5. Our additional experiments further establish these contributions. In architecture-matched comparisons, OscSpikeSSM achieves 89.24% average accuracy across four radar benchmarks, outperforming P-SpikeSSM (82.94%), as reported in Table 4 of our response to Reviewer HPF1 (Q1). Furthermore, applying Raw OscSpikeSSM directly to MMVR yields a centre-distance error of 38.28 cm, compared with 9.20 cm for our proposed MMVR-OscSpikeSSM architecture (Table 2 of our response to Reviewer WzBt (Q3)). This substantial improvement demonstrates the importance of adapting OscSpikeSSM to the spatial and geometric structure of radar data. Thus, the proposed radar-specific architecture, designed around OscSpikeSSM constitutes an additional contribution of our work. We have revised Figure 2 caption to explicitly distinguish the proposed components from standard operations. We have also reformatted Tables 1-3 to fit within the page margins, with clearer headings, spacing, and consistent notation.
Response to Q6: As you know, one of the goals of this work is to advance the field of spiking state-space models (SSMs). Recent research has shown that SSMs are computationally simpler and can help overcome the quadratic complexity of transformers. Unlike conventional Transformers with self-attention complexity, efficient SSMs offer sequence scaling through structured state updates (Gu et al., 2022; Gu & Dao, 2024), making them attractive for long-range temporal modelling in resource-constrained radar sensing. Moreover, given the biological closeness of these SNNs, this work could also help bridge the gap between deep learning and neuroscience.
We provide architecture-matched comparisons with LinOSS and P-SpikeSSM in Table 4 of the revised manuscript, in which only the temporal core is replaced, while the surrounding architecture and training protocol are retained. OscSpikeSSM achieves 89.24% average accuracy across four radar benchmarks, compared with 85.64% for LinOSS and 82.94% for P-SpikeSSM, under comparable model capacities. Furthermore, we compare against recent spiking Transformers, including SpikFormer and SpikingResFormer, using the benchmarks reported by Liao et al. (2026). As shown in Table 1 in Section 4.2, mm-OscSpikeSSM achieves an average accuracy of 86.72% across AOPHand, mmFiT, and MMActivity, compared with 83.57% for SpikFormer and 81.65% for SpikingResFormer, while using substantially fewer parameters. Spiking Transformers generally aim to approach ANN Transformer performance while improving computational efficiency through spike-driven processing. We also compare against RAPTR (Kato et al., 2025), a recent Transformer-based architecture (NeurIPS 2025), with no subsequent directly comparable MMVR study. Our MMVR-OscSpikeSSM achieves lower centre-distance error, lower model memory, and lower theoretical compute energy (Tables 5-6, Section 4.3).
Response to Reviewer KcY9
We would like to thank you for your feedback. Your comments have considerably helped with improving the clarity of the revised manuscript.
Response to W1 and Q1: Technical Formulation and Working Mechanism: We clarify that the proposed OscSpikeSSM combines the second-order oscillatory state-space dynamics of LinOSS with the trainable neuronal parameterisation of SiLIF/AdLIF, as described in Section 3.1. Unlike conventional first-order spiking neurons, OscSpikeSSM maintains coupled position-like and velocity-like states, allowing temporal information to evolve through damped oscillations. Unlike non-spiking oscillatory SSMs, it incorporates threshold-based binary spike communication, spike-dependent feedback, and subtractive reset. Specifically, the state evolution follows
F_t &= -k u_{t-1} + B I_t - R s_{t-1},\\\\ v_t &= \frac{v_{t-1}+\Delta t F_t} {1+\Delta t c},\\\\ u_t &= u_{t-1}-r_{\mathrm{reset}}s_{t-1} +\Delta t v_t,\\\\ s_t &= H(u_t-\theta). \end{aligned} \tag{6}$$ Here, the learnable oscillator coefficients control damping, restoring dynamics, input coupling, and spike-dependent feedback. The underdamping constraint preserves oscillatory continuous-time modes, while the damped-IMEX discretisation and its discrete-time stability conditions are detailed in Appendix A.1.2. Spike-dependent feedback modifies the subsequent velocity evolution, whereas subtractive reset regulates firing without directly resetting the velocity-like state. These mechanisms allow oscillatory state evolution to continue across spike events. The working mechanism is illustrated through the phase-space trajectories in Figure 1 and the comparison with SiLIF and AdLIF in Figure 3 of Appendix A.1.1. To further establish their contributions, we conducted targeted ablations , reported in Table 5 of this rebuttal. These ablation results are also presented and discussed in our response to Reviewer HPF1 (Q2). Removing the underdamping constraint reduces accuracy from 92.14% to 91.43%, while removing spike-dependent feedback and subtractive reset reduces accuracy to 90.98% and 90.27%, respectively. The largest degradation occurs without subtractive reset, supporting its role in regulating spike activity while retaining oscillatory state evolution. Furthermore, the architecture-matched comparisons with LinOSS and P-SpikeSSM achieve average accuracies of 85.64% and 82.94%, respectively, compared with 89.24% for OscSpikeSSM across radar datasets. These comparisons retain the surrounding architecture and training protocol with comparable model capacities, providing evidence for the contribution of the proposed temporal dynamics. The complete results are provided in Table 4 of our response to Reviewer HPF1 (Q1). We also evaluate Raw OscSpikeSSM on MMVR, where the centre-distance error decreases from 38.28 cm for the raw model to 9.20 cm for the proposed radar-specific architecture. This comparison demonstrates the additional benefit of preserving radar geometry through multidirectional scans and depth-aware cross-view fusion, rather than attributing the improvement solely to the temporal core. These results are reported in Table 2 of our response to Reviewer WzBt (Q3). Additionally, replacing OscSpikeSSM with a conventional LIF core increases the MMVR centre-distance error from 9.20 cm to 11.35 cm, as discussed in Section 4.3. Together, the component ablations and matched temporal-core comparisons provide complementary evidence supporting the proposed design. **Response to Q2:** We thank the reviewer for raising this distinction. Our primary focus is on extending LIF-family spiking models to include second-order oscillatory dynamics, which do not currently exist. Unlike conventional resonate-and-fire (R&F) neurons, OscSpikeSSM combines trainable SiLIF/AdLIF parameterisation with stability-constrained oscillations, spike-dependent feedback, and subtractive reset (Section 3.1). We acknowledge existing R&F-based models and their potential hardware limitations in Appendix A.2.2, which is also provided below - Although recent resonate-and-fire (R&F) neuron-based SSMs have achieved strong performance on long-range classification benchmarks (Agrawal et al., 2026), their hardware realisation can require larger circuit footprints and silicon area than simpler LIF-family neurons (Le et al., 2023; Auge & Mueller, 2020). This can reduce the achievable neuron density on area-constrained hardware, limiting the number of neurons that can be implemented within a given chip area. This hardware gap motivates the development of oscillatory spiking dynamics that retain the simplicity of LIF-family neuron implementations while improving their ability to model long temporal dependencies. The use of LIF neurons also potentially makes the model amenable for implementation in analog neuromorphic chips such as Pulsar (Innatera, 2026; Richter et al., 2024).