- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes BASP, which learns a fixed, ordered sensor layout for physical field reconstruction. Different prefixes support different sensor budgets without relocating retained sensors.
Critical strengths
The evaluation covers four datasets and four reconstructors. The OrderedCoords baseline provides a useful control for assessing PlaceNet beyond the shared training objective and nested structure.
Critical weaknesses
The novelty relative to sequential sensor placement is not sufficiently established. The idea of adding observations in sequence is well established, and a comparison with existing methods that naturally produce nested layouts would strengthen the paper.
The paper also provides limited insight into why joint training sometimes outperforms independent optimization. The current results do not clearly distinguish benefits from network parameterization, optimization, or training across budgets.
Questions for authors
How does BASP differ from existing sequential sensor placement methods, and could a representative nested placement baseline be included? Are the improvements over OrderedCoords consistent across optimization seeds?
We thank Reviewer kZ7z for highlighting the evaluation across four datasets and four reconstructors and the value of OrderedCoords in assessing PlaceNet’s contribution. We address the reviewer’s questions below.
We agree that sequential sensor addition is an established way to construct nested layouts. BASP’s contribution is to jointly learn a single sequence of continuous sensor coordinates from reconstruction feedback across budgets. PlaceNet generates this sequence using a physical field prior, ordered queries, and spatial suppression. During training, the losses at the sampled and maximum budgets allow early sensor positions to adapt to their contributions to both shorter prefixes and the full layout. At deployment, each budget uses a prefix of the learned sequence.
Table A compares BASP with two nested baselines using the same frozen reconstructor. Nested pivoted QR derives a sensor ordering from a fixed POD basis [1]. FixedCoords (Greedy) uses the same per-budget reconstruction MSE as BASP and optimizes only newly added coordinates at each budget increase, keeping earlier locations fixed. BASP achieves lower relative L2 error than nested pivoted QR and FixedCoords (Greedy) at all budget expansions.
Table A. Relative L2 errors of BASP, FixedCoords (Greedy), and nested pivoted QR.
BASP and OrderedCoords use the same cross-budget objective and nesting constraint. BASP achieves lower errors in all eight comparisons in Table 3, supporting the value of the PlaceNet parameterization under the same objective. Table B shows that independently trained BASP (single budget) also outperforms FixedCoords in all eight reported comparisons, so the benefit of PlaceNet is also observed under fixed-budget training.
Cross-budget supervision allows early sensor positions to be optimized for their contributions to both sampled prefixes and the full layout. The deployment order is learned through this shared reconstruction supervision without explicit importance labels. Removing the maximum-budget loss increases reconstruction error in all eight settings in Table 3, supporting the role of full-layout supervision in learning effective prefixes.
Table B. Single-budget comparison.
See our response to Weakness 1 and Table A for the nested baselines. BASP’s reported error is below the five-seed OrderedCoords mean in all eight settings (Table C).
Table C. Relative L2 errors (×10⁻²) of BASP and OrderedCoords.
[1] Manohar, Krithika, et al."Data-driven sparse sensor placement for reconstruction: Demonstrating the benefits of exploiting known patterns."IEEE Control Systems Magazine38.3 (2018): 63-86.