- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes QuaD, a LiDAR out-of-distribution (OOD) detection method that distinguishes feature changes caused by sensing quality from those caused by unknown objects. Building on the dual-head LIDO framework, QuaD introduces two modules. QCRL learns class-specific canonical anchors from high-quality observations and predicts quality-conditioned feature displacements. QCAE converts semantic, contrastive, and displacement evidence into anomaly scores using class- and quality-conditioned quantile distributions. Experiments on nuScenes-OoD, SemanticKITTI-OoD, SemanticPOSS-OoD, and STU show consistent improvements over LIDO.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses an important LiDAR perception problem by explicitly modeling how distance and local sparsity affect normal feature representations, rather than simply adjusting anomaly thresholds, and the improvement from 6.79 to 20.94 AP with QCRL alone (Table 4) provides strong evidence for the value of this approach. Furthermore, the separate ablations of QCRL and QCAE, including the improvement from 20.94 to 26.66 AP when adding QCAE, along with experiments on conditioning variables and evidence fusion (Tables 10–11), help explain the method's contributions, while consistent improvements across multiple LiDAR OOD benchmarks demonstrate its potential.
Critical weaknesses
-
The state-of-the-art claim is too broad because NDP-EE (CVPR 2026) reports much stronger STU validation results (74.24 AP and 1.43 FPR@95 versus QuaD's 40.25 AP and 19.26 FPR@95), although NDP uses a different backbone and synthetic OOD supervision, so the results do not directly invalidate QuaD's contribution under ID-only training; additionally, Section 5.2 reports ablations on the nuScenes-OoD test set without clearly explaining whether model selection was performed independently, although this alone does not establish test-set tuning.
-
The effects of quality conditioning and the reliability of conditional quantile estimation are not sufficiently validated, as QCRL provides most of the improvement over LIDO (6.79 to 20.94 AP), while joint Class+Quality conditioning improves AP from 23.68 to 26.66 over unconditional QCAE (Table 10), which cannot be attributed to quality alone; moreover, the poor Class-only result (13.30 AP), high Quality-only FPR@95 (63.64), and lack of controlled sensing-degradation experiments leave open questions about interactions between conditioning variables, estimation stability, and whether distance and sparsity capture actual sensing quality rather than correlations with object geometry or class.
Questions for authors
Which training or validation split was used to fit the QCAE quantile model? Were the nuScenes-OoD test-set ablation results used for model selection, or was a separate development split used?