- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
VCRS selects features for multi-view multi-label data. It combines original labels with clustered label-group responses, learns concept-specific view weights, and then applies sparse corrections to concepts that are poorly represented by the base features. Experiments on six datasets report improvements over six baselines.
Critical strengths
- The motivation is reasonable. Shared feature selection can miss information needed by particular labels, and different labels may depend on different views.
- The method achieves the highest reported AP on all six datasets. The ablations provide initial evidence that the proposed components help.
Critical weaknesses
- The proposed mechanisms lack direct evidence. Overall gains do not show that concepts use more suitable views or that compensation helps poorly represented concepts. Relational concepts are averages of grouped labels, and the ablation removes several components together. Without separate tests or concept-level analysis, it is unclear whether the method works for the reasons claimed.
- The motivation is already present in work on view-specific labels and label-specific features. The paper does not clearly establish what its routing and compensation add, and comparisons with the closest methods are missing. This makes the contribution difficult to judge.
Questions for authors
- What evidence shows that routing selects suitable views and that compensation improves the identified concepts on held-out data? Do separate ablations or a comparison with random label groups support the proposed explanation?
- What is the specific advance over existing methods using view-specific labels or label-specific features, and what evidence supports that distinction?
We thank the reviewer for recognizing our research motivation and experimental performance. We provide the following clarifications and additional information in response to the comments. To examine whether routing selects more suitable views, we added an equal-cardinality view-replacement experiment in Appendix F to complement the ablation study in the main text. Rather than evaluating overall predictive performance, we summarize concept reconstruction errors on an independent test set. On yeast, VOC07, and MIRFlickr, the aggregated concept reconstruction errors of VCRS are 0.8018, 0.9286, and 0.7979, respectively, all lower than the 0.8313, 0.9391, and 0.8533 obtained with alternative routing, representing an average relative reduction of 3.72%. Thus, the improvement is associated with concept-conditioned view selection rather than simply combining more views. Consistently, Table 4 shows that removing the routing module reduces AP on MIRFlickr from 0.7760 to 0.7648.
To assess the effectiveness of the compensation targets, Appendix G.1 examines the relationship between concept reconstruction error and label prediction difficulty on an independent test set. The Spearman correlation coefficients on yeast, VOC07, and MIRFlickr are 0.9508, 0.9038, and 0.9663, respectively, indicating that concept reconstruction error is an effective audit criterion for identifying harder-to-predict concepts. To distinguish targeted compensation from the benefits of compensation in general, we also conducted an equal-size random-compensation control. We matched the numbers of compensated atomic and relational concepts separately to those in VCRS, while randomly selecting compensation targets within each category. To control for additional Stage II iterations, we also evaluated no_comp. For each seed, it shares VCRS's Stage I solution and continues updating H, B, A, and W for the same number of Stage II iterations, while fixing R(v)=0 for all views. The AP results (mean ± std) on four datasets with different label-space sizes are as follows:
VCRS achieves higher AP than both no_comp and Random on all four datasets. In particular, VCRS's sparse compensation mechanism achieves more pronounced performance gains on Corel5K, which has a larger label space and provides a more discriminative evaluation setting. Together, these findings support the value of concept auditing and sparse compensation.
To clarify the distinction from methods using view-specific labels or label-specific features, we take DHLI, as discussed in the main text, as an example. Whereas DHLI partitions labels into common, view-specific, and noisy categories, VCRS operates at the granularity of atomic and relational concepts. It adaptively allocates view information using observability constraints Ovk and continuous routing weights Avk, and, after shared row-sparse base feature selection, activates sparse compensation R only for audited under-represented concepts, rather than assigning labels to fixed views or applying compensation indiscriminately. This also distinguishes VCRS from approaches that only learn label-specific features. Under the same experimental protocol, DHLI and VCRS were each tuned using validation AP. The mean test AP results (DHLI / VCRS) on emotions, yeast, Corel5K, SCENE, VOC07, and MIRFlickr, respectively, are 0.7161 / 0.7871, 0.7432 / 0.7604, 0.3682 / 0.3974, 0.8493 / 0.8571, 0.6639 / 0.7011, and 0.7622 / 0.7760. VCRS achieves higher AP on all six datasets, with an average improvement of 2.94 percentage points.