- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes OmniVaria, a blind omnidirectional video super-resolution framework that models the interaction between unknown degradations and spherical geometry. It introduces probabilistic degradation conditioning with an information bottleneck regularizer, along with implicit temporal aggregation without explicit motion estimation. Experiments on three benchmarks show promising performance, particularly under unseen blur levels.
Critical strengths
1.The paper addresses a meaningful and relatively underexplored problem by extending blind video super-resolution to omnidirectional videos.
2.The paper makes an accurate observation that fisheye imaging and ERP projection jointly lead to spatially varying degradations and complicate temporal correspondence in omnidirectional videos.
Critical weaknesses
1.Several core ideas, including implicit degradation representation learning, separating degradation information from image content, and information bottleneck regularization, have already been explored in blind image super-resolution. While adapting these ideas to omnidirectional videos is meaningful, the methodological contributions beyond geometry-aware extensions of existing approaches could be better clarified.
2.The evaluation is limited to a single synthetic fisheye degradation pipeline with isotropic Gaussian blur and downsampling. Although the model generalizes to unseen blur levels, its effectiveness under other degradation types or realistic capture conditions remains unclear.
Questions for authors
1.Since both degradation representation learning and information bottleneck regularization are well-studied in blind SR, please clarify the specific methodological novelty of this framework over existing approaches.
2.How does the proposed GCVIB formulation fundamentally differ from standard IB methods? It would be helpful to provide more concrete evidence showing how it suppresses image content in the learned degradation representations.
3.The generalization experiments only vary blur levels within a fixed degradation process. Can the model handle entirely different degradation types beyond isotropic Gaussian blur?
4.All current evaluations rely on synthetic data. Have the authors tested the model on real-world omnidirectional videos with more complex, natural degradations?
2 comments
Thank you for the authors' detailed response and additional experiments; however, my main concerns regarding methodological novelty and real-world applicability remain insufficiently addressed, so I will maintain my original rating.
First, we sincerely appreciate your thorough and constructive review, which helped improve the manuscript and inspired our future work. Regarding your concerns, we hope the following responses address them, and we would appreciate any further suggestions.
W.1 & Q.1 Methodological Contribution
Ans.: Thanks for your constructive comments. We would like to emphasize that OmniVaria follows a unified geometry-driven design to address the coupled spatial and temporal challenges of blind ODVSR.
Specifically, fisheye imaging and ERP reprojection transform unknown capture degradations into spatially varying distortions. Rather than merely compensating for geometric distortion, PSDC uses explicit spherical geometry to guide unknown degradation inference, producing latitude-structured Gaussian conditions that enable spatially varying, posterior-statistics-guided feature modulation. GCVIB further regularizes the information capacity of these conditions while preserving reconstruction-relevant information, potentially alleviating over-specialization to training degradation statistics. Meanwhile, projection-dependent motion deformation complicates temporal correspondence, motivating IOTA to aggregate recurrent features without explicit flow estimation or warping.
Thus, geometry explicitly guides degradation conditioning and motivates temporal aggregation, forming a coherent reconstruction framework. Our geometry-conditioning, local-condition, and temporal-alignment ablations further substantiate these design choices.
W.2 & Q.3 Generalization Beyond Gaussian Blur
Ans.: Thanks for your thorough comments which made us realize the importance of generalization. To this end, we conduct zero-shot evaluation on three unseen degradation families using ODV360.
As shown above, OmniVaria consistently outperforms the baselines, showing promising generalization capability toward unknown degradations.
Q.2 GCVIB Formulation and Content Suppression
Ans.: Thank you for this insightful comment, which helped us realize that our phrasing regarding the role of GCIVB was inappropriate. GCVIB builds upon standard IB regularization but differs due to its geometry-conditioned, latitude-structured probabilistic representations that directly guide spatially varying HR reconstruction.
Specifically, the KL regularizer provides a variational upper bound on I(Z;X∣C), constraining the information retained by the inferred conditions from LR observations given the known ERP geometry. Meanwhile, the reconstruction-relevance term I(Z;Y∣F,C) motivates preserving information complementary to the existing reconstruction features and geometric prior. This regularization of information compression and reconstruction relevance is particularly important for blind ODVSR. Without such regularization, GCDI may overfit to the degradation statistics during training, potentially reducing the reliability of feature adaptation under unseen degradations, as demonstrated in W.2 & Q.3.
Therefore, we reposition GCVIB's role as a regularization of probabilistic degradation conditioning and promote generalization capability through the joint optimization of the compression and reconstruction objectives. We have revised the manuscript to align our description with the mathematical and experimental support.
Q.4 Evaluation on Real-world Omnidirectional Videos
Ans.: Thanks for your thorough comments. Evaluating blind ODVSR under natural capture degradations remains challenging but meaningful. While existing ODVSR benchmarks concentrate on constructing LR frames through synthetic degradations, i.e., fisheye downsampling and HEVC compression. In the current stage, we derive a zero-shot evaluation on synthetic degradations as an alternative assessment. Your valuable suggestions have motivated us to further develop a real-world ODVSR benchmark containing more complex, natural degradations in our future work.
Currently, we are trying our best to incorporate these valuable results and method repositioning into the revised manuscript, and we are pleased to address any further questions.