- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces RIM-Net, a rotation-robust method for wearable human activity recognition. It constructs rotation-invariant motion states using dynamic acceleration and angular velocity magnitudes, combined with reliability-weighted geometric alignment. The architecture features an Adaptive Quadrature Harmonic Encoder (AQHE) to extract local motion patterns via state-conditioned multi-frequency quadrature filters, and Cross-Part Phase-Relation Learning (CPRL) to capture frequency-specific temporal coordination across sensor locations. Evaluated on five benchmarks under subject-independent protocols, RIM-Net achieves state-of-the-art weighted F1 scores on four datasets with only 58K–104K parameters, while ablation studies confirm the effectiveness of both AQHE and CPRL.
Critical strengths
-
The motion-state construction has a clear geometric interpretation and an explicit invariance guarantee under fixed sensor-frame rotations. This is a useful alternative to relying exclusively on data augmentation to learn orientation robustness.
-
The method performs well across several HAR datasets. Importantly, the authors investigate both the contributions of AQHE and CPRL and the mechanisms within these modules, providing more convincing evidence than an end-to-end comparison alone.
Critical weaknesses
-
The proposed state discards the direction of gravity and retains only the magnitudes and alignment of dynamic acceleration and angular velocity. For an ideal stationary window with constant acceleration and zero angular velocity, the dynamic acceleration residual becomes zero. Consequently, different static postures can become indistinguishable to the model.
-
The synthetic rotation evaluation applies a fixed coordinate rotation shared by the accelerometer and gyroscope at each location. This is precisely the setting for which the representation is analytically invariant. Consequently, these results do not establish robustness to practical sensor reattachment, location displacement, time-varying orientation, or imperfect sensor alignment. Furthermore, the rotation robustness experiments do not include a direct comparison with the rotation-invariant TRI-HAR baseline under the same perturbations. The exact subject partitions and activity-label protocols also need to be specified more clearly, particularly for Opportunity.
Questions for authors
-
Can the authors provide per-class F1 scores and confusion matrices, especially for static activities? How does the model retain information necessary to distinguish stationary postures after gravity-related directional information has been removed?
-
Can the authors evaluate time-varying orientation perturbations or realistic sensor reattachment, and include TRI-HAR under the same rotation-robustness protocol?
-
What are the exact subject assignments, activity-label definitions, and retained input channels for each benchmark? Can the authors clarify the input-channel descriptions in Section 4.1 relative to the configurations in Appendix Table 4?
-
Since the magnitude of the complex phase relation is deterministically recoverable from its real and imaginary components, what explains the large performance drop when the explicit reliability channel is removed?
Dear authors, we would appreciate your response to the questions raised in our review. We remain open to discussion and would be happy to clarify any of our points. Thank you.