- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper revisits the widely adopted full-resolution semantic segmentation paradigm for landslide mapping and proposes treating output resolution as an important task design variable. The authors argue that existing landslide datasets may suffer from ambiguous boundaries, incomplete annotations, and spatial inconsistencies, making pixel-level supervision not always the most appropriate choice. To address these issues, the paper employs max pooling to transform model predictions and ground-truth labels into different spatial resolutions and uses a BCE-Dice loss for training, without introducing a new network architecture. Experimental results demonstrate that appropriately reducing output resolution can improve region-level landslide detection performance on certain datasets, although the optimal resolution varies across datasets. However, the methodological novelty is relatively limited, and the authors should further clarify how the proposed approach differs from existing studies. Furthermore, the paper lacks an in-depth explanation of the underlying mechanisms that determine the optimal output resolution.
Critical strengths
The research question is of practical significance. This paper aims to address spatial uncertainty in landslide mapping supervision and the potential mismatch between pixel-level predictions and practical region-level decision-making needs. Rather than focusing solely on improving network architectures, the study offers a valuable and practically relevant perspective on landslide mapping.
Critical weaknesses
-
The methodological novelty is limited, and the distinction from existing studies needs to be further clarified. The core method involves applying max pooling to the model's output logits and supervision labels, followed by loss computation at a coarser spatial resolution. This operation is relatively common and is closely related to multiple instance learning, region-level supervision, and pooling-based weakly supervised segmentation. Although the authors emphasize that their contribution lies in reformulating the landslide mapping task rather than proposing a new network architecture, the fundamental differences from these existing approaches have not been sufficiently explained. I suggest including representative baselines from task reformulation or weakly supervised segmentation methods. The authors should also clearly distinguish between the technical novelty of the proposed method and the empirical findings specific to landslide mapping. For a machine learning conference such as ICLR, it is particularly important to clarify what broader insights these findings offer to the machine learning community.
-
The causal relationship between weak annotations and the benefits of coarse-grained prediction remains unclear. The central motivation of this paper is that coarser output resolutions can alleviate supervision issues arising from incomplete annotations and ambiguous boundaries. However, the current experiments do not provide sufficient evidence to establish this mechanism.
-
The underlying mechanisms determining the optimal output resolution are not sufficiently explored. One of the main conclusions of this paper is that different datasets exhibit different reliable resolution sweet spots. However, the current analysis relies primarily on empirical sweeps over output resolutions, without providing a quantitative explanation of the relationship between the optimal resolution and dataset characteristics. Establishing a more interpretable principle for selecting the appropriate output resolution would substantially enhance the scientific value of this work.
-
The practical value of the proposed approach has not been sufficiently validated. The paper emphasizes that coarse-grained predictions better align with the practical needs of region-level landslide screening, but it lacks more concrete downstream application evaluations. I suggest including additional application-oriented evaluation metrics, such as object-level recall and small-landslide detection rates.
-
The experimental results should be supported by repeated runs. I recommend repeating the main experiments with at least five different random seeds and reporting the mean and standard deviation to better assess the robustness and statistical variability of the results.
Questions for authors
Please refer to the Critical Weaknesses section for details.