acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Agentic Orchestration Policy: Asynchronous Reasoning and Control for Embodied Coding Agents

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Coding agents can construct and revise robot behavior during execution, but their deliberation takes time. A single reasoning process can delay work that different robot components could perform independently. We introduce Agentic Orchestration Policy (AOP), an asynchronous framework of persistent coding agents that reason and act for configurable robot control groups. A hyper-agent coordinates their work, deciding what to delegate, which actions must wait for others, and when to control coupled groups directly. This lets local work progress concurrently while coordination adapts to physical dependencies. Across 72 real-world rollouts in 25 task/platform settings, reduces task-balanced time cost relative to Direct Policy in all three categories: Fully Parallel, Parallel-Sequential, and Collaborative, with a 28.2% reduction overall. On Collaborative tasks, it also has lowers mean time cost than a fixed robot arm assignment, which we call fixed delegation. Case studies show how members prepare actions in parallel and how fixed delegation can delay shared actions through repeated planning and waiting. We will release the framework code and a rollout dataset containing observations, generated programs, actions and feedback to support research on how coding agents reason and act in the physical world.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
Embodied AI, Robot Control, Coding Agents, Multi-Agent Systems, Asynchronous Reasoning, Agentic Coordination

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_CQFLOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Agentic Orchestration Policy (AOP), an asynchronous multi-agent framework for embodied coding agents that aims to improve robotic task efficiency by addressing the bottleneck of centralized reasoning. AOP employs persistent coding agents to independently observe, reason, and act for different robot control groups, while a hyper-agent dynamically manages task delegation, synchronization, and control ownership. Evaluated through 72 real-world rollouts across 25 task/platform settings, AOP achieves a 28.2% reduction in task-balanced time cost compared with Direct Policy and outperforms Fixed Delegation on collaborative tasks. The paper also introduces a real-world rollout dataset containing agent interactions, generated programs, actions, and execution feedback.

Critical strengths
  • Clear motivation and practical significance. The paper presents a clear research motivation. Existing coding agents face a reasoning bottleneck in parallel robotic operations, as centralized reasoning can delay otherwise independent actions. AOP addresses this issue through asynchronous reasoning and execution, offering practical value for improving robotic task efficiency.
  • Comprehensive system design. AOP provides a relatively complete system design that integrates persistent agents, asynchronous execution, event-based synchronization, and dynamic control ownership. These mechanisms enable flexible coordination among different robot components.
  • Promising real-world experimental results. AOP is evaluated through 72 real-world robot rollouts across 25 task/platform settings, achieving average efficiency improvements across all three task categories. The detailed case studies and failure analyses further demonstrate the practical effectiveness of the proposed framework.
Critical weaknesses
  • Limited methodological novelty. The main contribution primarily lies in integrating existing multi-agent orchestration and asynchronous execution mechanisms. Although dynamic control ownership introduces some novelty, the paper does not propose a substantially new coordination algorithm. Therefore, the contribution is mainly engineering-oriented, with relatively limited methodological novelty.
  • Insufficient analysis of efficiency gains. Although AOP reduces task completion time, the paper lacks a detailed breakdown of the time spent on reasoning, waiting, and physical execution. Consequently, it is difficult to determine how much of the efficiency improvement comes from asynchronous reasoning, local task specialization, or more effective coordination.
  • Limited scalability and generalizability evaluation. Although AOP is presented as a general asynchronous coordination framework, all experiments are restricted to fixed-body dual-arm manipulation involving only two primary control units. The effectiveness of AOP in more complex embodied tasks involving additional control units remains unexplored, leaving its scalability and generalizability insufficiently validated.
Questions for authors

See Weaknesses.

3 comments

Thank you for recognizing AOP’s clear motivation and practical significance, comprehensive system design, and promising real-world results. Below, we clarify our methodological contribution, analyze the sources of efficiency gains, and present evidence that AOP extends beyond two-arm manipulation.


A. Methodological novelty

The central insight of AOP is to let a strong coding agent itself reason about and perform coordination, taking on decisions that would otherwise be prescribed through handicrafted coordination rules. For an advanced agent system, we do not need to specify many human rules that could restrict the agent’s ability to adapt its coordination to the evolving physical situation.

AOP therefore does not require a separate hand-designed coordination algorithm to determine every delegation, synchronization, or takeover. The coding agent makes these task-dependent decisions from observations, interaction history, and member feedback.

For capable coding agents, the design challenge is how to build scaffolding that supports reliable, consistent, and efficient execution. AOP provides the following mechanisms:

  • Retain local knowledge when assignments change. Each member keeps its observations, conversation history, and generated programs across assignments and control transfers. It can continue from previous work without restarting its session or rebuilding its local context.
  • Use message buffers for asynchronous communication. Instructions and reports remain in message buffers until the receiving agent confirms receipt. Agents can therefore work at different speeds, with updates kept available while a recipient is busy.
  • Event-based synchronization. An agent can wait for one or all specified events while other agents continue working. For example, during flower insertion, one arm prepares and orients its flower while the other finishes inserting and withdrawing from the shared vase. The lead waits for the clearance report before authorizing the next insertion. This report provides the synchronization event, allowing independent preparation to continue while access to the vase is coordinated.
  • Maintain exclusive control ownership during handoffs. The framework accepts commands for each control group only from its current owner, and ownership cannot change while a call to the robot controller is in progress. Handoffs preserve member context and existing controller targets, allowing responsibility to change without stopping motion or releasing held objects.

These mechanisms define how agents can work concurrently and transfer control, while leaving task-dependent coordination decisions to the coding agent.

Therefore, our methodological contribution combines agent-directed coordination as part of the embodied policy, with an asynchronous framework that supports this form of control. The design leaves coordination strategies open to the agent while explicitly specifying the mechanisms through which agents interact and control the robot.

B. Analysis of efficiency gains

We analyzed execution traces to examine how asynchronous work, effective coordination, and local specialization relate to AOP’s efficiency gains.

1. Asynchrony accommodates more agent work in less elapsed time.

We examine the major timing components associated with AOP’s efficiency gains over Direct. The original study covers the 25 settings reported in the submission. The additional repeated-trial study uses five trials per task and policy across six tasks. Negative values contribute to shorter AOP elapsed time, indicating efficiency gains, while positive values represent additional agent work.

Timing components in minutesOriginal studyRepeated trials
Additional reasoning work+4.95+6.29
Overlap between agents’ reasoning−8.17−9.51
Overlap between reasoning and robot execution−1.35−1.44
Overlap between control groups’ execution−0.18−0.14
Elapsed-time reduction−4.80−5.23

Both studies show the same pattern that reasoning-to-reasoning and reasoning-to-execution overlap dominates the efficiency gain, while execution changes comparatively little.

2. Effective coordination matters beyond enabling parallel agents.

Fixed Delegation and AOP use the same model configurations and both support asynchronous work. The following results examine the role of adaptive coordination in reducing elapsed time on collaborative tasks in the repeated-trials.

Timing in minutesFixed DelegationAOP
Total reasoning work46.9223.29
Time with concurrent reasoning14.786.86
Coordination waiting13.862.85
Elapsed time28.8314.46

Fixed spends more time reasoning concurrently yet takes longer overall, while AOP incurs less reasoning work and coordination waiting. For example, in the basket task, one arm’s grasp attempt moved the basket, shifting the handle the other arm was approaching. This would trigger another round of communication and planning to update the grasp target and coordinate the next attempt, reflecting the overhead of coordinating tightly coupled actions through separate member agents. Therefore, these results demonstrate the value of adaptive coordination on coupled tasks, beyond simply allowing agents to run asynchronously.

3. Local specialization contributes modestly

In AOP, each member focuses on local tasks, which is intended to simplify its decisions. Calculating members’ average response time between tool interactions, we see 5.58 seconds (AOP) versus 6.22 seconds (Direct) in the repeated-trials. This suggests a modest local response-time benefit under the specialized member configuration, so our finding here is: local specialization contributes to some extent, but the major gains are from asynchrony and effective coordination.

C. Scalability and generalizability

AOP defines members by physical responsibilities beyond individual arms. On a Galaxea R1 Pro robot, we extend member instantiation to a body agent controlling the chassis and torso, alongside the two arm agents. The robot is asked to collect flowers from separate locations and to put them in a floor-level basket.

The following selected examples illustrate asynchronous work and coordination across these three members at multiple stages of the rollout.

InteractionTimestamped evidence
Route planning during arm execution08:45–09:13: The body agent plans the navigation route. Meanwhile, the right arm retracts with its flower during 08:49–08:58 and reports readiness for transport at 09:11.
Chassis movement during scene interpretation09:37–09:55: The left agent reassesses the destination basket from newly available views. During this assessment, the body executes a backward chassis movement at 09:48–09:51. The left agent’s report subsequently informs the navigation direction.
Synchronization before torso movementThe right agent reports readiness at 15:39, and the left reports its flower retained after inward retraction at 16:48. After both reports, the lead authorizes the body agent to lower the torso at 17:05, with the arms holding their positions.
Concurrent work across all three members20:46–21:02: The body agent plans chassis realignment, the right agent evaluates flower-placement poses, and the left arm physically retracts with its flower. All three members progress concurrently.
Body realignment followed by arm placementThe right agent reports completed placement and a stable empty arm at 27:02. The lead authorizes chassis realignment at 27:10. After the body reports completion at 28:36, the lead authorizes left-arm placement at 28:50, which the left agent reports completed at 32:02.

These interactions show that the body agent participates in the same asynchronous reasoning and coordination as the arm agents, extending AOP beyond two-arm manipulation. We will add a figure to visually illustrate this extension in paper.

Reviewer_UKeoOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

Agentic Orchestration Policy (AOP) is an asynchronous robot policy in which persistent coding agents write and revise control programs during execution, while a coordinating agent decides how to split and rejoin that work.

Coding agents can inspect a scene and build task-specific motion programs on the fly, but reasoning is slow. AOP separates independent progress from coordination.

Critical strengths

The problem is easy to grasp. The paper argues that the organization of reasoning and command ownership is part of the policy. Study 2 tests this on eight collaborative settings while holding the lead model, the member models, and the reasoning budgets fixed. AOP is faster on every one of those settings, and the completion at successive time cutoffs shows both earlier progress and a higher chance of finishing.

Real-world testing, used 4 robot setups, 25 tasks, and 72 runs, including putting flowers in a vase etc.

Critical weaknesses

Who acts is a prompted choice, not a coordination rule. The hyper-agent is the lead coding agent. At each step it can delegate a group, order access to a shared object, or take the groups back and command them itself. Nothing in the method specifies which of those is appropriate. Equation (1) writes this as a policy πH, but the policy is the model’s response to role instructions and history.

How the robots are grouped is predetermined. For example, "left hand plus gripper" is one group, "right hand plus gripper" is another group. This is the human configuration. The coordinator is only responsible for assigning tasks to these groups and cannot decide which joints must be moved together by themselves. There is no layer of specialized collision prevention controller below.

Questions for authors

Did the speed increase occur because the master agent took its hands back and took over the control itself, or because each hand did its own thing? In 31 AOP experiments, only 9 times did the master agent temporarily regain control of one of the hands. The remaining 22 times, from start to finish, it was the respective agents of the left and right hands that were in charge, and the master agent did not take back control.

Were these 72 experiments all pre-determined? The paper states that there were some "trial runs" and "unfinished" experiments that were not included in these 72 experiments. However, it does not mention how many times they were removed, nor does it specify the criteria for removal. However, if the unsuccessful experiments that were not satisfactory were simply discarded after seeing the results, this figure cannot be taken seriously.

3 comments

Thank you for recognizing the importance of organizing reasoning and control and the strength of the Collaborative evaluation. We address your concerns below.


Quoted comment #1
Who acts is a prompted choice, not a coordination rule. The hyper-agent is the lead coding agent. At each step it can delegate a group, order access to a shared object, or take the groups back and command them itself. Nothing in the method specifies which of those is appropriate. Equation (1) writes this as a policy πH, but the policy is the model’s response to role instructions and history.

Response #1. Your observation captures an intentional design choice. The central insight and conceptual novelty of AOP is to let a strong coding agent itself reason about and perform coordination, taking on decisions that would otherwise be prescribed through human-designed coordination rules. For an advanced agent system, we do not need to specify many human rules that could restrict the agent’s ability to adapt its coordination to the evolving physical situation.

In fact, for a capable coding agent, the design challenge is to build scaffolding for it to work reliably, consistently, and efficiently. AOP addresses this by providing persistent member contexts, asynchronous execution, buffered communication, event-based waiting, ownership checks, etc., making AOP much more than a trivial prompting implementation.

The scaffolding design balances agent freedom in choosing task-dependent coordination with structured mechanisms for carrying out those choices reliably and consistently.

We would like to additionally note that, the hyper-agent and lead agent are conceptually different roles: the hyper-agent handles coordination, while the lead agent directly controls the whole robot. Using one instance for both is an implementation choice for two reasons: they share substantial agent context, making separate instances wasteful, and the frontier coding agent is powerful enough to serve both roles.


Quoted comment #2
How the robots are grouped is predetermined. For example, "left hand plus gripper" is one group, "right hand plus gripper" is another group. This is the human configuration. The coordinator is only responsible for assigning tasks to these groups and cannot decide which joints must be moved together by themselves. There is no layer of specialized collision prevention controller below.

Response #2. Human grouping provides a useful physical inductive bias. An arm and its gripper form a natural functional unit whose actions are closely related, while separate units can progress independently when the task permits. Asking the agent to discover this partition introduces an additional problem: a poor partition could separate closely coupled actuators or combine weakly related ones, making local responsibilities less coherent.

We therefore configure physical responsibilities while leaving task-dependent coordination to the agent. The hyper-agent decides objectives, dependencies, synchronization, and when several groups should come under direct lead control. Automatically discovering actuator groupings is outside our present scope. We anticipate that unconstrained grouping could produce suboptimal partitions and introduce additional reasoning and coordination overhead, particularly when naturally coupled actuators are assigned to separate member agents.

Collision avoidance also involves both policy reasoning and low-level control. Agents can develop and revise coordination logic during execution, including sequencing shared access (in fig. 1, the flower insertion case) and adjusting motion plans to reduce interference. This does not guarantee collision-free execution. Dedicated collision prevention requires complementary low-level motion control engineering, which is outside the focus of this study.

Quoted comment #3
Did the speed increase occur because the master agent took its hands back and took over the control itself, or because each hand did its own thing? In 31 AOP experiments, only 9 times did the master agent temporarily regain control of one of the hands. The remaining 22 times, from start to finish, it was the respective agents of the left and right hands that were in charge, and the master agent did not take back control.

Response #3. These mechanisms address different task conditions, which is precisely why AOP makes coordination adaptive. When work can proceed fully or partly in parallel, we expect AOP to exploit concurrent member reasoning and execution. Keeping work delegated is beneficial in these situations, including when the lead coordinates occasional dependencies or shared access. When actions are tightly coupled, keeping control distributed can introduce additional communication, waiting, and coordination overhead. We therefore allow AOP to bring coupled actions under direct lead control. Takeover is an option for these situations, not a requirement for every episode.

The observed behavior is consistent with this design: all nine takeover episodes occurred on Collaborative tasks. Across the 22 episodes without takeover, AOP achieves 30.7% lower task-balanced time cost than Direct, benefiting from asynchronous member reasoning and execution. Across the seven settings containing the nine takeover episodes, AOP achieves 54.4% lower cost than Fixed Delegation, benefiting from the flexibility to execute coupled actions directly instead of keeping control permanently delegated. These comparisons support both retaining delegated execution where it is effective and allowing direct lead control when distributed coordination becomes costly.

Quoted comment #4
Were these 72 experiments all pre-determined? The paper states that there were some "trial runs" and "unfinished" experiments that were not included in these 72 experiments. However, it does not mention how many times they were removed, nor does it specify the criteria for removal. However, if the unsuccessful experiments that were not satisfactory were simply discarded after seeing the results, this figure cannot be taken seriously.

Response #4. Our earlier wording did not clearly distinguish the following three categories:

  1. Primary evaluation cohort: the 72 episodes used for the main experimental comparisons.
  2. Three additional episodes: included in the appendix sensitivity analysis.
  3. Development attempts: exploratory and incomplete runs outside the formal evaluation.

The three additional episodes are the only runs from the formal evaluation stage excluded from the primary comparison. Their exclusions had the following reasons. E018 inadvertently used a different number of pens and therefore did not match that setting’s workload and was excluded from the primary comparison. But we included it in the appendix to serve as a partial observation of sensitivity. E065 and E026 used the same experimental conditions as their primary-cohort counterparts but were interrupted when the API account ran out of credits. The robot remained untouched during service restoration, and the downtime was excluded in their elapsed time calculation. However, resuming execution split the execution and reasoning traces across separate rollout records. Because we are releasing the rollouts as a dataset for studying coding-agent behavior, we wanted complete, uninterrupted rollout records. We therefore replaced these fragmented runs with new uninterrupted repetitions in the primary cohort.

Development attempts were collected before we finalized the framework, using different harness versions, prompts, tool sets, tool definitions, or underlying models. These were development runs outside the controlled experiments reported in the paper.

We have already included all comparable formal-evaluation episodes with uninterrupted rollout records in the primary comparison, including unsuccessful runs. We genuinely hope our earlier unclear expressions wouldn’t affect the overall understanding about the significance of this research.

To complement the original study’s task coverage and better understand the consistency and sensitivity of AOP, we conducted five trials per task and policy across six tasks, comparing Direct, Fixed Delegation, and AOP in 90 rollouts. Corresponding trials used initial placements matched as closely as possible across policies. These repetitions assess variation within each task and the consistency of our efficiency conclusions. The table reports mean ± standard deviation of 30-minute-capped time cost, in minutes, where AOP achieves lower mean time cost than Direct on all six tasks, with a 29.4% reduction overall.

TaskDirectFixed DelegationAOP
Wipe and arrange towels23.73 ± 3.8415.16 ± 2.9812.54 ± 1.95
Sort cubes and batteries21.61 ± 3.0717.44 ± 9.4514.30 ± 5.87
Insert four flowers27.06 ± 3.7925.59 ± 5.1322.89 ± 6.78
Assemble a sandwich22.96 ± 9.0626.50 ± 7.8212.17 ± 4.70
Fold a towel19.74 ± 7.9827.85 ± 4.1016.47 ± 3.36
Lift a milk carton13.50 ± 9.3429.82 ± 0.4112.45 ± 2.37
Reviewer_Rc2POpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper presents Agentic Orchestration Policy (AOP), a framework where persistent coding agents control robot groups under a coordinator that assigns tasks and can take over control for coupled actions. Across 72 real-world episodes covering 25 task/platform settings, AOP reports a 28.2% reduction in task-balanced time cost over Direct, with additional comparisons against Fixed Delegation.

Critical strengths
  1. Local agents retain context and continue analysis while the coordinator reassigns tasks or takes control of coupled groups (Section 3).

  2. The real-world evaluation covers three dependency categories and four robot installations.

  3. AOP has lower mean time cost than Direct in 23 of 25 settings and than Fixed in all eight collaborative settings.

  4. Including the three additionally disclosed episodes still gives a 22.54% reduction in time cost over Direct (Appendix B.3).

  5. Detailed traces, including the shared-vase and milk-carton examples, illustrate adaptive sensing and diagnosis, while negative cases reveal coordination costs (Appendices C and E.3).

Critical weaknesses
  1. Appendix A excludes exploratory and incomplete attempts without clear inclusion rules or a complete list of excluded attempts.

  2. The primary comparison uses a 13.03-minute AOP pen-placement episode instead of an earlier 57.93-minute attempt, and the sensitivity analysis does not establish whether all comparable attempts are included (Appendix B.3).

  3. Twenty of 25 settings have only one Direct and one AOP rollout, with unmatched initial placements, limiting confidence in the size and consistency of the efficiency gain (Tables 5–7; Section 4.2).

  4. Completion relies on recorded policy outcomes without an independent assessment under common physical-success criteria, so time-cost differences may partly reflect different stopping standards (Section 4.2; Appendix B.2).

  5. Fixed towel episode E040 reaches a quarter-sized footprint around minute 21 but is classified as failed after further finishing, while Direct and AOP accept residual wrinkles (Appendix C; Table 8).

  6. Both cup-stacking methods record completion despite cup damage, without establishing comparable finishing quality (Appendix B.2).

Questions for authors
  1. What are the episode inclusion rules for the primary comparison?

  2. Why were E018, E065, and E026 excluded while their later counterparts were included?

  3. Can you list all other excluded exploratory or incomplete attempts, with configuration differences and exclusion reasons?

  4. Does including all comparable attempts preserve the reported efficiency advantage?

  5. Can the recordings be reassessed using common physical-success criteria that distinguish first goal attainment from optional finishing?

  6. How would E040 and the two cup-stacking episodes be scored under these criteria?

  7. How would this reassessment change the results in Tables 1–3?

3 comments

Thank you for recognizing the framework’s benefits and for identifying important questions about episode inclusion and physical evaluation. We address these concerns below.


A. Experimental clarification

The experimental records comprise three categories:

  1. Primary evaluation cohort: episodes used for the main experimental comparisons.
  2. Three additional episodes: included in the appendix sensitivity analysis.
  3. Development attempts: exploratory and incomplete runs outside the primary comparison.

Three additional episodes. E018 used four pens, whereas the corresponding primary evaluation setting used six. Because of this difference in workload, we excluded E018 from the primary comparison and only included it in the appendix sensitivity analysis.

E065 and E026 used the same experimental conditions as their primary-cohort counterparts but were interrupted because the API account ran out of credits, preventing further model calls. Although the robot remained untouched during service restoration and we excluded the downtime from the reported elapsed times, resuming execution split the execution and reasoning traces across separate rollout records. Because we are releasing the rollouts as a dataset for studying coding-agent behavior, we wanted the dataset to contain complete, uninterrupted rollout records. We therefore replaced these fragmented runs with new uninterrupted repetitions in the primary cohort, while retaining the interrupted episodes in the appendix sensitivity analysis.

These three additional episodes are the only runs from the formal evaluation stage that we exclude from the primary comparison.

Development attempts. The other exploratory and incomplete runs were conducted during framework development, before we finalized the framework. They used different harness versions, with differences in prompts, tool sets, tool definitions, and underlying models. These were development runs and outside the controlled experiments in the paper.


B. Additional repeated-trial study

Given the substantial time and effort required for real-world robot experiments, the original study prioritized task coverage to examine AOP across diverse tasks and robot setups. We complement this breadth with repeated trials to assess how performance varies within the same task and whether the observed efficiency gains hold consistently across executions.

We conducted five trials per task and policy on six tasks spanning all three dependency categories. Direct, Fixed Delegation, and AOP were each evaluated on every task, giving 90 rollouts with fresh agent sessions. For each task, corresponding trials across policies used pairwise-matched initial object placements, reproduced in the real world as closely as possible.

With a 30-minute-capped time cost, AOP achieves lower mean cost than Direct on all six tasks, with a 29.4% reduction averaged across tasks. Those numbers are in minutes, and we report standard deviation as well.

TaskDirectFixed DelegationAOP
Wipe and arrange towels23.73 ± 3.8415.16 ± 2.9812.54 ± 1.95
Sort cubes and batteries21.61 ± 3.0717.44 ± 9.4514.30 ± 5.87
Insert four flowers27.06 ± 3.7925.59 ± 5.1322.89 ± 6.78
Assemble a sandwich22.96 ± 9.0626.50 ± 7.8212.17 ± 4.70
Fold a towel19.74 ± 7.9827.85 ± 4.1016.47 ± 3.36
Lift a milk carton13.50 ± 9.3429.82 ± 0.4112.45 ± 2.37

C. Human assessment of physical progress and completion

To compare what the robots achieve under common physical-success criteria, we conduct a human assessment covering both the original 72 task-coverage episodes and the new 90 repeated-trial episodes. Human annotators follow a shared task-specific grading rubric, marking when physical milestones are first reached and assigning scores for completed work and partial achievement. The rubric defines the main milestones and their scores, while allowing annotators’ discretion to assign intermediate scores based on the physical quality of the observed result.

We report graded physical-progress scores on a 0–100 scale, where higher scores indicate greater physical achievement. We compute the Normalized AUC (area under curve) by integrating each episode’s progress curve over the 30 minutes and dividing by such a time period. Higher normalized AUC indicates more physical progress achieved earlier. We average episodes within each task setting, then weight settings equally.

Table C1. Original task-coverage comparison. Each cell reports Direct / AOP. Bold indicates the highest normalized AUC in each row.

Task category10 min20 min30 minNormalized AUC
Fully Parallel (6)49.3 / 81.387.5 / 100.093.8 / 100.060.3 / 75.2
Parallel-Sequential (11)61.8 / 71.696.9 / 96.198.9 / 99.167.4 / 73.1
Collaborative (8)56.9 / 69.771.9 / 92.584.4 / 98.856.9 / 70.8
All 25 settings57.2 / 73.386.6 / 95.993.0 / 99.262.3 / 72.9

Table C2. Collaborative subset of the original task-coverage study. Each cell reports Direct / Fixed Delegation / AOP.

Task10 min20 min30 minNormalized AUC
Ordered towel fold55.0 / 25.0 / 55.090.0 / 52.5 / 100.090.0 / 70.0 / 100.064.0 / 37.4 / 71.1
Basket lift100.0 / 25.0 / 62.5100.0 / 62.5 / 100.0100.0 / 62.5 / 100.077.9 / 46.4 / 73.1
Shirt fold85.0 / 90.0 / 90.085.0 / 90.0 / 90.085.0 / 90.0 / 90.073.3 / 72.1 / 77.4
Bottle opening10.0 / 10.0 / 25.010.0 / 10.0 / 50.010.0 / 10.0 / 100.08.5 / 9.4 / 38.4
Fruit-basket lift100.0 / 25.0 / 100.0100.0 / 100.0 / 100.0100.0 / 100.0 / 100.080.4 / 44.2 / 84.9
Milk-carton lift0.0 / 0.0 / 100.050.0 / 75.0 / 100.0100.0 / 100.0 / 100.033.5 / 46.7 / 72.8
Pot onto book25.0 / 20.0 / 50.050.0 / 20.0 / 100.0100.0 / 20.0 / 100.047.3 / 16.2 / 69.4
Basket onto sponge80.0 / 20.0 / 75.090.0 / 20.0 / 100.090.0 / 20.0 / 100.070.1 / 18.2 / 79.3
All 8 settings56.9 / 26.9 / 69.771.9 / 53.8 / 92.584.4 / 59.1 / 98.856.9 / 36.3 / 70.8

Table C3. Repeated trials. Each cell reports Direct / Fixed Delegation / AOP, averaged over five trials per task and policy.

Task10 min20 min30 minNormalized AUC
Wipe and arrange towels46.7 / 80.0 / 80.080.0 / 100.0 / 100.0100.0 / 100.0 / 100.060.5 / 72.0 / 73.7
Sort cubes and batteries46.7 / 70.0 / 76.786.7 / 86.7 / 96.7100.0 / 90.0 / 100.062.5 / 65.8 / 75.2
Insert four flowers30.0 / 15.0 / 35.070.0 / 55.0 / 90.090.0 / 70.0 / 95.046.7 / 34.8 / 56.6
Assemble a sandwich39.9 / 38.7 / 68.050.7 / 58.1 / 91.666.4 / 58.1 / 91.640.3 / 42.3 / 69.2
Fold a towel61.0 / 27.0 / 55.088.6 / 61.4 / 92.690.4 / 90.6 / 92.663.6 / 40.9 / 65.1
Hold a milk carton80.0 / 40.0 / 60.0100.0 / 50.0 / 100.0100.0 / 60.0 / 100.075.2 / 35.6 / 70.1
All 6 tasks50.7 / 45.1 / 62.479.3 / 68.5 / 95.191.1 / 78.1 / 96.558.1 / 48.6 / 68.3

These comparisons show that AOP retains an aggregate advantage under common physical scoring, complementing the elapsed-time results.

Q&A

Q1. What are the episode inclusion rules for the primary comparison?
Q2. Why were E018, E065, and E026 excluded while their later counterparts were included?
Q3. Can you list all other excluded exploratory or incomplete attempts, with configuration differences and exclusion reasons?
A1&2&3. Please refer to the above experimental clarification in Section A. We genuinely hope our earlier unclear expressions wouldn’t affect the overall understanding about the significance of this research.

Q4. Does including all comparable attempts preserve the reported efficiency advantage?
A4. Yes. Restoring E065 and E026, the two interrupted episodes with matching task conditions, gives a 27.3% reduction in AOP’s task-balanced time cost relative to Direct, compared with the originally reported 28.2% reduction. E018 has a different number of pens and makes this episode totally not comparable and should not be included (Section A). Nevertheless, the broader appendix sensitivity analysis also includes E018, and shows a 22.5% reduction, which itself remains a meaningful reduction. The sensitivity analysis and additional repeated trials (Section B, which is an overall 29.4% reduction) thus provide complementary evidence for substantial efficiency benefits beyond the original episode comparison.

Q5. Can the recordings be reassessed using common physical-success criteria that distinguish first goal attainment from optional finishing?
A5. Yes. We appreciate your suggestion to evaluate from this perspective, which is indeed more aligned to human commonsense. The assessment in Section C credits physical milestones when they are first attained, independently of the agent’s stopping decision. This means AOP still demonstrates a clear efficiency advantage under common physical criteria.

Q6. How would E040 and the two cup-stacking episodes be scored under these criteria?
A6. The current annotations credit E040 with 20 points at 04:00 for engaging both lower corners, 25 at 06:00 as the first fold begins, 40 at 11:38 when the first fold is largely formed but the upper edge remains held, 50 at 12:49 when the first fold is completed, and 70 at 18:20 as the second fold proceeds. At 20:20, it receives 80 points for a quarter-sized footprint with bunched layers and a raised flap. This achieved state is therefore credited before the subsequent corrections. For cup stacking, Direct (E047) receives scores of 25, 50, 75, and 100 at 06:37, 09:37, 11:47, and 18:02, respectively. AOP (E058) receives scores of 25, 50, 75, and 90 at 03:17, 04:44, 08:30, and 10:07, respectively, with its final score reduced for visible cup damage. For Direct (E047), the cup already had minor wrinkles before execution due to repeated use of the experimental prop. The manipulation did not worsen them, so these pre-existing wrinkles did not reduce its score of 100. For AOP (E058), the manipulation visibly worsened the wrinkles, resulting in a score of 90. The above human assessment therefore accounts for each cup’s initial condition when judging damage caused during execution.

Q7. How would this reassessment change the results in Tables 1–3?
A7. The tables in Section C provide the reassessment under common physical-scoring criteria and support the original efficiency conclusions of Tables 1–3.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Withdrawal decision from authors and a thank you note

Dear Reviewers and Area Chairs,

Since the original submission, we have conducted additional experiments and made major changes to our research, which now differs substantially from the study described in our submission. We have therefore decided to withdraw our submission from ICLR 2027 and prepare a revised paper.

We sincerely thank you for your time, careful reading, and constructive suggestions. Your feedback has helped us strengthen the experimental evaluation, clarify our claims, and improve the presentation of the work. We will use your suggestions to further improve the revised paper.

Thank you again for the care and effort you have invested in reviewing our work. We wish you all the best in your research and future endeavors.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.