- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
MulGeCa uses estimated depth to improve open-vocabulary segmentation through scene-conditioned text embeddings, depth-guided feature aggregation, and mask feature reweighting. Experiments examine cross-dataset performance and the effects of depth quality, model capacity, and individual components.
Critical strengths
- Using depth to reduce mixing between nearby objects is well motivated, and the method improves its segmentation baseline across several benchmarks.
- The appendix provides useful controls for auxiliary feature capacity, depth quality, computational cost, and variation across training runs.
Critical weaknesses
- DFormerv2 already uses depth-based geometric relations to guide self-attention, but is not discussed. Vireo also deserves more than a passing citation given its use of depth and language for open-vocabulary segmentation. These connections matter for judging the novelty.
- CPMR is compared with different kernels, but not with a strong learned mask-pooling alternative. Mask-Adapter is cited and included in the cost analysis; a matched accuracy comparison would better establish the value of the proposed pooling rule.
- The MAFT+ Base results differ from those in the official repository. I suggest distinguishing reproduced from published numbers and clarifying whether the baseline and MulGeCa share the same training and inference settings.
- The main performance claims are stronger than the full results support. The large model shows mixed gains over MAFT+ and trails stronger methods in Appendix Table 19. This should be reflected in the main discussion.
- Some details needed to reproduce the geometry experiments remain unclear, including depth normalization, and the strength of the noise perturbations. These settings should be specified explicitly.
Questions for authors
- Were the MAFT+ Base results reproduced under the same settings as MulGeCa, and what explains the difference from the released baseline?