- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces CoDR, a complementary-representation framework for cost aggregation, which employs CSD to establish separate cost and spatial representation spaces through asymmetric token flow, thereby alleviating the competition caused by a shared dense feature. Furthermore, they develop RD and SARC to preserve complementary cost and spatial representations and compose them for each input scene using lower-loss preference supervision.
Critical strengths
-
The motivation and design of this paper are clear and well-structured. It addresses the problem of open-vocabulary semantic segmentation from a novel perspective, demonstrating meaningful research significance.
-
The figures are visually appealing, and the writing is concise and precise.
Critical weaknesses
-
I notice that other OVS methods are often evaluated on the VOC20-b benchmark in addition to the benchmarks used in this paper. However, this paper lacks experimental results on VOC20-b. Furthermore, I have two concerns regarding the claimed state-of-the-art performance. First, the proposed method is not compared with the latest methods published in 2026. Second, the performance improvements on some datasets, such as VOC20, are relatively marginal.
-
Introducing the DINO encoder into open-vocabulary semantic segmentation to provide spatial guidance is reasonable. However, the methods compared in Table 1 lack similar settings, making it difficult to determine whether the performance improvements stem from the robust feature representations of DINO or from the proposed method itself.
Questions for authors
Please refer to Critical Weaknesses.
3 comments
Thank you very much for the authors' thoughtful responses. After carefully reviewing their clarifications, I fully recognize the significance of this work in open-vocabulary semantic segmentation. Therefore, I maintain my positive rating and recommend acceptance of the paper.
Thank You for Your Feedback
Thank you for carefully considering our responses and for recommending our paper for acceptance. We appreciate your thoughtful feedback, which helped us clarify our evaluation and explain our findings more clearly.
Response to Reviewer dJgQ
Dear Reviewer dJgQ,
Thank you for your specific suggestions on evaluation coverage, comparisons with recent methods, and the contribution of DINO. Our responses are as follows.
Q1: Missing evaluation on VOC20-b.
Thank you for identifying this omission. We additionally report the results for CoDR-B and CoDR-L on VOC20-b and list the available background-inclusive evaluation results for methods in Table 1:
Q2: Missing comparisons with 2026 methods and the small improvement on VOC20.
Thank you for raising this point. The submitted paper does not sufficiently compare our method with recent work, and we will expand these comparisons in the revision. Below, we list published results from relevant 2026 methods alongside CoDR's submitted results:
CoDR improves over DeCLIP by only 0.2 mIoU on VOC20, so the gain is indeed limited. Our method's main advantage is in large-vocabulary settings with more categories and more challenging semantic distinctions: compared with the best recent result on each dataset in the table, CoDR improves ADE847, ADE150, and PC459 by 1.4, 0.6, and 0.6 mIoU, respectively. This is consistent with our motivation to improve large-vocabulary generalization through complementary representations.
References
[1] InfoCLIP: Bridging Vision-Language Pretraining and Open-Vocabulary Semantic Segmentation via Information-Theoretic Alignment Transfer. AAAI 2026.
[2] LoGoSeg: Integrating Local and Global Features for Open-Vocabulary Semantic Segmentation. AAAI 2026.
[3] PCA-Seg: Revisiting Cost Aggregation for Open-Vocabulary Semantic and Part Segmentation. CVPR 2026.
[4] Reconstructing CLIP for Open-Vocabulary Dense Perception. CVPR 2026.
[5] HyperCLIP++: Fine-tuning CLIP for Open-vocabulary Semantic Segmentation in Hyperbolic Space. TPAMI 2026.
Q3: Do the improvements come from DINO or from CoDR's design?
The original Table 2 includes relevant controls, but we did not clearly explain the sources of the gains. We now add OpenAI CLIP-L controls without DINO; the remaining rows use EVA02-CLIP-L:
With OpenAI CLIP-L and no DINO, CoDR improves all five metrics over CAT-Seg, including +0.4 on both ADE847 and PC459. This provides direct evidence of gains without DINO.
With EVA02-CLIP-L and no DINO, adding CSD raises ADE847 from 17.9 to 18.4, and further adding Cost RD raises it to 19.0. The shared EVA+DINOv3 reference scores 18.5, compared with 19.8 for full CoDR, leaving a gap of 1.3. The gains therefore cannot be attributed entirely to DINO.
The added DINOv2 control replaces only DINOv3, using the same DINOv2 version as DeCLIP while keeping all other settings unchanged. It achieves 19.6 on ADE847, showing that the result does not depend on using the newer DINOv3.