- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
SymFashion uses a FLUX-based model for cloth-to-person generation, person-to-person garment transfer, try-off and cloth-to-model generation. Each task is represented on a two-slot person/garment canvas. During training, compatible forward and reverse views share a timestep and aligned noise, and a garment-weighted loss aligns their predicted clean endpoints after role permutation. The paper analyzes this consistency term while accounting for differences between joint and separate VAE encoding. Experiments on VITON-HD and DressCode compare the coupled model with the same model trained without the consistency loss, alongside specialist baselines and ablations of the coupling design.
Critical strengths
-
The two-slot representation gives the four tasks a common structure and makes the proposed consistency loss straightforward to apply. Compatible views come from the same person-garment sample, so the constraint has a concrete relationship to the desired output. This is a practical way to share information between tasks with different input and output roles.
-
The coupled and uncoupled models use the same architecture, data, supervised views and training budget. The coupled model improves VITON-HD unpaired C2P FID from 9.39 to 8.89, Try-Off FID from 8.55 to 8.20, and no-pose C2M mean-pairwise LPIPS from 0.252 to 0.226. The noise, weighting, gradient-flow and endpoint-loss ablations help explain which implementation choices matter.
-
The analysis accounts for the VAE encoding residual and examines what the consistency loss actually changes. Appendix A reports both cross-view disagreement and native denoising error, including the increase in the latter. Reporting both quantities makes the mechanism easier to understand and gives readers more than an aggregate image-quality table.
Critical weaknesses
-
Genuine P2P transfer is evaluated mainly with FID and KID, which do not measure whether the output preserves the specified source garment. The paired P2P result uses the unmasked target as the reference and measures self-reference reconstruction. A direct garment-fidelity evaluation is needed to judge the transfer improvement, particularly for patterns, logos and details that distribution-level metrics can miss.
-
Several image-level gains are small, such as unpaired P2P FID 9.60 to 9.37 and KID 1.31 to 1.27 on VITON-HD. The bootstrap analysis covers latent diagnostics for selected checkpoints, while the uncertainty of the main image-quality differences is not reported. This makes it difficult to judge how consistent the benefit is across evaluation samples and training runs.
-
Performance is sensitive to the strength of the coupling loss. In Table 4, increasing λ from 1 to 2 worsens several metrics and can erase the improvement over the uncoupled model. The paper does not explain clearly how λ=1 was selected or whether the same choice remains effective when the task mixture changes. That matters for using the method beyond the reported configuration.
Questions for authors
-
On genuine unpaired P2P transfer, does coupling improve garment identity and detail preservation over the matched uncoupled model? Can you provide a source-conditioned metric or a blinded pairwise assessment?
-
Can you report uncertainty for the matched image-level gains, particularly the small P2P differences? Please distinguish variation from resampling evaluation data from variation across independent training runs, where available.
-
How was the coupling weight chosen, using which validation set? Does one fixed value work across the task mixtures in the paper, or does each mixture require retuning?
6 comments
W1 + Q1: Genuine unpaired P2P garment fidelity
W1. Genuine P2P transfer is evaluated mainly with FID and KID, which do not measure whether the output preserves the specified source garment. The paired P2P result uses the unmasked target as the reference and measures self-reference reconstruction. A direct garment-fidelity evaluation is needed to judge the transfer improvement, particularly for patterns, logos and details that distribution-level metrics can miss.
Q1. On genuine unpaired P2P transfer, does coupling improve garment identity and detail preservation over the matched uncoupled model? Can you provide a source-conditioned metric or blinded pairwise assessment?
Response
Thank you for this comment. Yes, on genuine unpaired P2P transfer, symmetric coupling improves source-garment consistency over the matched uncoupled model.
We added Mask-DINO and CLIP-I for genuine unpaired P2P in Table 4(a), Lines 385–394. The metric definition and paired-bootstrap uncertainty protocol are described in Lines 397–401. Mask-DINO is the cosine similarity between DINOv2 features pooled over Sapiens-derived garment regions in the source and generated output:
| Train→eval. | Metric ↑ | w/o sym. | w/ sym. | Δ [95% CI] | n |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 512→512 | Mask-DINO | 0.8292 | 0.8382 | +0.0090 [+0.0021, +0.0158] | 2030 |
| 512→512 | CLIP-I | 0.9249 | 0.9287 | +0.0039 [+0.0012, +0.0066] | 2030 |
| 512→1024×1024 | Mask-DINO | 0.7881 | 0.8060 | +0.0179 [+0.0099, +0.0260] | 2028 |
| 512→1024×1024 | CLIP-I | 0.8994 | 0.9065 | +0.0071 [+0.0039, +0.0104] | 2028 |
All paired 95% CIs exclude zero.
Appendix Fig. C provides complementary qualitative evidence: across the displayed P2P examples, the symmetric variants more consistently preserve the source garment’s style and identity, with fewer visible garment-structure and outfit-drift artifacts.
W2 + Q2: Magnitude of the P2P gain and uncertainty
W2. Several image-level gains are small, such as unpaired P2P FID 9.60→9.37 and KID 1.31→1.27 on VITON-HD. The bootstrap analysis covers latent diagnostics for selected checkpoints, while the uncertainty of the main image-quality differences is not reported, making it difficult to judge consistency across evaluation samples and training runs.
Q2. Can you report uncertainty for the matched image-level gains, particularly the small P2P differences? Please distinguish evaluation resampling from independent training runs.
Response
Thank you for this comment. We address the magnitude of the matched P2P gain and the scope of the reported uncertainty separately below.
(a) Magnitude of the P2P gain
The matched P2P improvement is meaningful in the context of recent VTON studies. Our 9.60→9.37 FID (()) improvement on VITON-HD is comparable to the 0.254 unpaired-FID margin reported by DeCo-VTON (ECCV 2026) and larger than the 0.013 margin reported by CCVTON (CVPR 2026). For Voost (SIGGRAPH Asia 2025), the final model is 0.159 FID better than the second-best external method on VITON-HD (9.141→8.982), while its own w/o λ-scaling ablation differs by only 0.009 FID (8.991→8.982). RefTON (CVPR 2026) reports internal gains of 0.15 FID on VITON-HD (8.58→8.43) and 0.24 FID on DressCode (5.31→5.07). On DressCode, our 4.59→4.38 FID (()) improvement is also comparable to DeCo-VTON’s 0.170 margin. These values are provided only to contextualize the scale of FID differences commonly treated as meaningful in recent VTON studies, rather than as direct method-to-method comparisons.
The matched P2P results are:
| Method | VITON-HD FID ↓ | VITON-HD KID ×10³ ↓ | DressCode FID ↓ | DressCode KID ×10³ ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ours w/o sym. | 9.60 | 1.31 | 4.59 | 0.85 |
| Ours w/ sym. | 9.37 | 1.27 | 4.38 | 0.60 |
(b) Evaluation-sample uncertainty and independent retraining
As discussed above, the magnitude of the matched P2P gains is comparable to differences reported and treated as meaningful in recent VTON studies.
Importantly, FID and KID are distribution-level metrics computed over sets of generated and reference images, rather than per-sample measurements. Therefore, the paired per-example uncertainty analysis used for our source-conditioned metrics does not directly apply to the reported FID/KID differences.
For the new Mask-DINO and CLIP-I evaluations, each matched example yields an individual source-conditioned similarity score. This enables paired-bootstrap resampling over the same test samples, from which we report 95% confidence intervals:
| Train→eval. | Metric ↑ | w/o sym. | w/ sym. | Δ [95% CI] | n |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 512→512 | Mask-DINO | 0.8292 | 0.8382 | +0.0090 [+0.0021, +0.0158] | 2030 |
| 512→512 | CLIP-I | 0.9249 | 0.9287 | +0.0039 [+0.0012, +0.0066] | 2030 |
| 512→1024×1024 | Mask-DINO | 0.7881 | 0.8060 | +0.0179 [+0.0099, +0.0260] | 2028 |
| 512→1024×1024 | CLIP-I | 0.8994 | 0.9065 | +0.0071 [+0.0039, +0.0104] | 2028 |
All four source-conditioned gains exclude zero under paired bootstrap resampling, quantifying evaluation-sample variability.
As requested by the reviewer, and given the limited rebuttal period, we additionally performed an independent retraining with a different random seed on a different machine, using the same training code and configuration, to verify whether the observed P2P improvement reproduces under a separate training execution. On VITON-HD P2P, the independently trained uncoupled and coupled models obtain 9.79 and 9.40 FID, respectively, compared with 9.60 and 9.37 FID in the original matched run. The improvement therefore reproduces in the additional run, with coupling improving P2P FID by 0.39.
Together with the magnitude analysis above, this additional run provides further evidence that the observed P2P gain is consistent and not specific to a single training execution.
We clarified the scope of the paired-bootstrap uncertainty analysis in Lines 400–402.
Summary and Discussion Note
Thank you for your constructive feedback. In response, we added direct source-conditioned evaluation for genuine unpaired P2P, reported evaluation-sample uncertainty for the new source-conditioned metrics, added an independent retraining check, and expanded the analysis of the coupling-weight sensitivity and selection.
These additions have been incorporated into the revised manuscript.
Discussion note. All figure, table, equation, and line references in the responses below refer to the revised manuscript. Newly added or modified content is highlighted in orange in the revised manuscript, while unchanged content retains its original formatting. Because new figures and tables were inserted during revision, some pre-existing figures and tables were automatically renumbered relative to the submitted manuscript. Fig. 2 was moved from the appendix to the main paper for clearer presentation; its content was already present in the submitted manuscript.
Please find our detailed responses below.