- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
BiCorr proposes bidirectional correspondence supervision for video virtual try-on using a garment-conditioned video diffusion Transformer. It combines direct DINOv3 matches with validated tracking-based propagation, maps these frame-level correspondences to compressed latent tokens, and constructs Gaussian-based distributional targets. These targets supervise person-to-garment retrieval through self- and cross-attention, together with garment-to-person localization through self-attention. Correspondence estimation and auxiliary supervision are used only during training. The paper also introduces LHFSC, a paired spectral metric, and curates BiCorr-Test from existing official test splits. Evaluation includes video benchmarks, image try-on benchmarks, component ablations, and a 60-participant user study, with reported improvements in garment fidelity and video quality.
Critical strengths
-
A coherent correspondence-learning approach without additional inference-time matching or tracking. The method addresses the difficulty of translating frame-level correspondences into temporally compressed video tokens and supervises both retrieval directions. The directional ablations in Table 3 show that removing either direction worsens several generation metrics, including LPIPS, LHFSC, and unpaired VFID_R. This provides meaningful evidence that bidirectional supervision contributes beyond the generation objective alone, while keeping the additional correspondence machinery confined to training.
-
The reported improvements have quantitative and perceptual support. BiCorr performs favorably against video baselines on ViViD-S and BiCorr-Test, and the qualitative results show improved preservation of garment motifs and local structure. The user study also reports garment-detail improvements over MagicTryOn, with confidence intervals in both paired and unpaired settings. This strengthens the empirical case because it draws on established generation metrics and human judgments alongside the proposed LHFSC metric.
Critical weaknesses
-
Insufficiently controlled ablations of the central design choices. Although Table 3 and Figure 9 provide useful quantitative and visual comparisons, several ablations change multiple factors simultaneously. The direct-only and track-only variants also remove coverage-balanced query selection and alter clip sampling. The hard-target variant changes center selection, distribution shape, and support regions; singleton supports additionally make the conditional KL term degenerate. Consequently, these experiments support the complete pipeline but do not isolate the benefits of coverage balancing, Gaussian smoothing, or retaining multiple correspondence locations. Separate ablations of these factors, with clips and other settings held fixed, are needed. The mechanism also remains incompletely explained: hard targets achieve higher mode coverage and temporal coverage than Full in Table 7 despite worse generation metrics. Finally, the ablations use a 1.3B model and 20% of the training data, whereas the main results use a 14B model. A matched generation-only comparison at the main scale would strengthen attribution of the headline improvements to correspondence supervision.
-
Incomplete comparison with recent image-based virtual try-on methods. The image evaluation in Table 4 omits relevant recent methods, including Garments2Look, RefTon, and Mobile-VTON. Their inclusion would better establish the claimed competitiveness on image try-on. Since Table 2 also compares image try-on followed by animation, the authors should justify that baseline selection or extend the comparison using the same animation protocol. Such video comparisons would assess the complete image-plus-animation pipelines, so their interpretation should account for the animation stage.
-
BiCorr-Test provides limited evidence for robustness, and direct evaluation on the source benchmarks is missing. BiCorr-Test contains 150 short clips selected from the official Eevee and ViT-HD test splits: 123 from Eevee and 27 from ViT-HD. It favors clear garment details and predominantly frontal views, explicitly excluding back and strict profile views. Why not evaluate the same trained model directly on the complete official Eevee and ViT-HD test splits and report each dataset separately? The added value of BiCorr-Test as a separate benchmark contribution also needs clearer justification beyond its curation from existing test data.
-
The user study does not directly report how often participants prefer each method. Appendix A.3 provides randomized, anonymized five-point ratings and a mixed-effects analysis, which are useful evidence. However, the mean-score differences in Table 5 do not directly show how often users select BiCorr as the best output or prefer it to the strongest baseline. An explicit best-output choice or pairwise preference task, allowing ties, would provide a useful complementary assessment. At minimum, the authors could report within-trial win/tie/loss rates derived from the existing ratings, clearly distinguishing these from explicitly elicited preferences, together with confidence intervals and the number of cases and judgments per comparison. Since each trial includes BiCorr and only one to three baselines, winner rates should use matched candidate sets or account for the differing competitor sets. This would make the claimed perceptual advantage easier to assess.
-
The additional value of LHFSC for garment-detail evaluation is not yet sufficiently established. LHFSC compares high-frequency Fourier magnitudes while discarding phase, so spectral agreement alone does not establish that lettering or motifs have the correct spatial structure. Appendix C.4 also acknowledges that the agnostic mask may include non-garment content and that high-frequency responses can arise from folds, boundaries, or noise. Table 6 shows only small improvements over LPIPS in within-case correlation (0.847 versus 0.839) and ranking agreement (89.3% versus 88.4%), with confidence intervals for the differences spanning zero. Controlled evaluations involving incorrect lettering, displaced motifs, blur, and added noise would clarify the metric's sensitivities and blind spots. Its intended role as a complementary measure is reasonable, but the present evidence does not establish a clear additional advantage for distinguishing garment-detail quality within the same test case.
Questions for authors
My questions are incorporated into the five points in Critical Weaknesses. Please respond to them individually. Clarifications concerning the ablation controls, evaluation on the original Eevee and ViT-HD test splits, and the additional value of LHFSC could materially affect my assessment.
11 comments
Response to Reviewer 8FQU (Benchmark scope and user study)
3. BiCorr-Test scope and evaluation on the original source benchmarks (W3)
We agree that BiCorr-Test alone cannot establish robustness across viewpoints. Our main video benchmark is ViViD-S. BiCorr-Test complements it with a reproducible, detail-oriented evaluation protocol designed to assess garment-detail fidelity and overall video quality across three garment categories. Clip identities and intervals were fixed before inspecting outputs or scores. We will clarify its contribution as a curated protocol for controlled evaluation, rather than a newly collected dataset or a comprehensive robustness benchmark.
Regarding the viewpoint selection, we follow the single frontal-reference setting: back-facing and strict-profile views may expose garment regions absent from the reference image, making fine-grained evaluation of details such as logos and patterns underconstrained. CatV2TON adopts a similar protocol, filtering back-facing frames and using 64 consecutive frontal frames for ViViD-S (Chong et al., 2025).
We are evaluating the same BiCorr checkpoint, without further fine-tuning, on all 1,000 official Eevee test IDs against MagicTryOn. Following the Eevee evaluation setting, we use 49-frame clips at 624 × 832 resolution. Evaluation is ongoing, with completion expected in approximately two days. We will report the Eevee results separately. Complete evaluation on the official ViT-HD test split exceeds the remaining rebuttal budget and is planned as follow-up work.
4. Rating-derived win/tie/loss analysis of the user study (W4)
We reanalyzed the existing anonymized five-point ratings to obtain within-trial win/tie/loss (W/T/L) rates against MagicTryOn, the strongest baseline in our user study. Each comparison matches the participant, trial, case, and criterion. Higher, equal, and lower BiCorr ratings count as wins, ties, and losses, respectively. These are rating-derived comparisons, not explicit preference votes.
Table W4. Rating-derived within-trial comparisons between BiCorr and MagicTryOn. W/T/L rates are computed over matched judgments, with ties included in the denominator. All intervals are pointwise 95% CIs; pp denotes percentage points.
| Mode | Criterion | Matched Comparisons / Cases / Participants | W/T/L Counts | Win % [95% CI] | Tie % [95% CI] | Loss % [95% CI] | Net W−L, pp [95% CI] |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paired | Garment detail | 119 / 35 / 60 | 57/48/14 | 47.9 [29.9, 65.2] | 40.3 [24.8, 57.3] | 11.8 [3.3, 23.8] | 36.1 [10.6, 58.8] |
| Paired | Overall quality | 119 / 35 / 60 | 60/44/15 | 50.4 [32.3, 67.8] | 37.0 [21.5, 54.7] | 12.6 [3.6, 25.2] | 37.8 [12.2, 60.4] |
| Paired | Temporal consistency | 119 / 35 / 60 | 46/62/11 | 38.7 [22.6, 56.0] | 52.1 [36.1, 68.3] | 9.2 [1.9, 19.6] | 29.4 [7.8, 50.8] |
| Unpaired | Garment detail | 91 / 33 / 60 | 45/32/14 | 49.5 [30.1, 68.8] | 35.2 [18.9, 52.6] | 15.4 [4.4, 29.5] | 34.1 [4.8, 60.9] |
| Unpaired | Overall quality | 91 / 33 / 60 | 45/34/12 | 49.5 [30.1, 68.4] | 37.4 [21.4, 53.9] | 13.2 [2.8, 26.8] | 36.3 [7.8, 62.4] |
| Unpaired | Temporal consistency | 91 / 33 / 60 | 33/49/9 | 36.3 [18.5, 55.7] | 53.8 [35.2, 71.7] | 9.9 [1.3, 22.4] | 26.4 [1.2, 49.5] |
Intervals use 5,000 two-way participant–case cluster bootstrap replicates, independently resampling participants and cases while retaining observed within-trial comparisons. Net-rate intervals are computed directly from bootstrap differences. BiCorr wins outnumber losses across all criteria and both protocols.
Only trials presenting both methods enter each pairwise comparison. We will also report rating-derived unique-highest, tied-highest, and non-highest frequencies separately for each exact candidate set, without pooling across sets, alongside pairwise comparisons with the remaining baselines.
5. Sensitivity, limitations, and complementary value of LHFSC (W5)
The additional LHFSC sensitivity tests and human-judgment analyses are currently underway. We expect to report the results, together with confidence intervals, in a follow-up comment within three days, before the discussion period closes.
My main concern remains unresolved. Although this is a video virtual try-on (VVT) paper, its core methodological designs are largely adapted from existing image-based VTO approaches, without sufficient video-specific innovations to explicitly address temporal consistency and video dynamics.
Response to Reviewer 8FQU (Image and video baseline comparisons)
We thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback and recognition of BiCorr's correspondence-learning framework and empirical improvements. We address the remaining concerns below with additional experiments and clarifications.
1. Controlled ablations, hard-target behavior, and attribution of generation improvements (W1)
The requested controlled ablations require additional training runs and evaluation. These experiments are currently underway, and we expect to report the results in a follow-up comment within three days, before the discussion period closes.
2. Comparison with recent image-based try-on methods and image-to-video baselines (W2)
We added Mobile-VTON and RefTon evaluations on VITON-HD and DressCode upper-body subset (DressCode-UB) under paired and unpaired settings. For RefTon, we use its inference mode without optional extra person-reference images to match the person–garment inputs available to BiCorr. Table W2-A shows that BiCorr remains competitive with methods specifically designed for image-based try-on, particularly in FID and KID, while Mobile-VTON achieves better SSIM and LPIPS.
Garments2Look introduces a multi-reference, outfit-level dataset and benchmark covering multiple garments, accessories, layering, and styling. Its task differs from our single-garment setting. We will discuss this distinction in Related Work in the revision.
Table W2-A. Image-level comparison. All images are evaluated at 1024 × 768. KID is multiplied by 103. p/u denote paired/unpaired. Bold: best; underline: second best.
For video comparisons, we originally selected CORAL as a correspondence-aware baseline and Any2AnyTryon as a general image-based try-on baseline. We extend the comparison with Mobile-VTON and RefTon on 50 shared upper-body cases, and evaluate RefTon on 150 cases across all three garment categories. Mobile-VTON is included only in the upper-body comparison, in accordance with its released upper-body evaluation protocol.
All image-based try-on methods use the same StableAnimator (SA) checkpoint and configuration (832 × 624 resolution, 64 frames, and 25 fps), whereas BiCorr generates videos directly without an additional animation stage. BiCorr achieves the best results on all seven reported video metrics in both comparisons. Table W2-B reports the three-category results; Tables 14–16 (Appendices D.2–D.3 of the revised manuscript) provide the upper-body comparison and reference-frame diagnostics. These results compare complete image-plus-animation pipelines with direct video generation. Differences therefore reflect both image try-on and animation, rather than image-model quality alone.
Table W2-B. Raw video metrics on 150 cases across three garment categories (50 per category). All image-based methods are followed by the same SA pipeline; BiCorr generates videos directly. p/u denote paired/unpaired. Bold: best; underline: second best.