acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Reducing Coordination Failures in LLM Agent Populations via Bilevel Information Allocation

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

When multiple LLM agents act separately on a shared task, individually reasonable decisions can produce poor collective outcomes: agents may crowd the same scarce resources, duplicate effort, or leave useful alternatives unused. We ask whether these failures can be reduced without updating the acting agents, by changing only which truthful state information each agent receives. The problem is difficult because responses to information are unknown and history-dependent, evaluating an allocation requires costly agent execution, and what is useful for one agent depends on what the others see. We introduce , a Bilevel Response-guided Information Allocation framework with two alternating levels. BRIA learns how the agent population responds to joint information allocations and uses that response model to choose better allocations. The two levels form a closed loop: the learned response guides allocation, the resulting allocations change the histories subsequently reached, and randomized data from those histories are used to update the response model. Across three datasets, BRIA improves response prediction and end-to-end coordination while keeping the amount of information per agent fixed, with consistent reductions in crowd-out. Ablations support history modeling, joint allocation, and repeated response-model updates, showing that jointly optimizing truthful information allocation can improve coordination without updating the acting agents.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Large Language Models, Multi-Agent Learning, Coordination, Information Allocation, Population Modeling, Decision Making

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_XSNeOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies coordination failures in LLM-agent populations caused by agents competing for shared resources. It proposes BRIA, a bilevel information allocation framework that improves coordination by controlling which truthful information each agent receives, without modifying the acting agents. BRIA alternates between learning a history-aware population response model and optimizing joint information allocation using model-based evaluation. Experiments on three datasets demonstrate improvements in response prediction, task success, and reduced crowd-out compared to various baselines.

Critical strengths
  1. An important and practical problem. Joint information allocation is a meaningful approach to improving coordination, especially in large-scale LLM multi-agent systems where independently reasonable decisions may lead to poor collective outcomes. I believe this is a valuable research direction with practical relevance.

  2. A reasonable optimization framework. The proposed bilevel framework is well-motivated. Learning a population response model to evaluate candidate allocations can potentially reduce expensive LLM-agent executions, while alternating updates allow the model to adapt to evolving interaction histories. The experimental results provide encouraging evidence for this approach.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Insufficient clarity in the methodology. Several important components are not clearly defined or explained. For example, the allocation policy Γ\Gamma and its relationship to the learned proposal and final selector are unclear, the concrete round-level task loss is unspecified, and the prior distribution r0r_0 is insufficiently described. Section 4.1 also lacks a clear explanation of the response model architecture and its implementation. Figure 2 is overly complicated and uses terminology inconsistent with the main text. These issues make the method difficult to understand and reproduce.

  2. Insufficient experimental and implementation details. The benchmark descriptions should clarify the number of agents, their tasks, and how information allocation is constructed for each dataset. The paper also compares cooperative MARL algorithms, information selection methods, and LLM prompting methods, but their relationships to BRIA and their adaptations to this setting deserve more explanation. Additionally, although computational efficiency is an important motivation, the paper does not provide sufficient analysis of actual training and inference costs. These missing details make it difficult to fully assess the experimental comparisons and practical efficiency of the proposed method.

  3. More comprehensive evaluation of coordination failures. While the reduction in Crowd-out provides direct evidence for improved coordination, the introduction discusses broader coordination failures, including duplicated effort and underutilized resources. Additional analysis of these failure modes and population-level action distributions would better support the paper's claims. Furthermore, evaluating different population sizes would help demonstrate the scalability and practical relevance of the proposed approach.

Questions for authors

See Critical Weaknesses

Reviewer_hjhgOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

BRIA tries to reduce coordination failures by changing which truthful optional facts each agent sees. The agents and the number of facts per agent stay fixed. The method alternates between fitting a response model on allocation outcomes and training a joint allocator. At execution time, it uses the response model to score candidate allocations and chooses the one with the lowest predicted loss. Experiments with Qwen3-8B agents use environments based on Citi Bike, LaDe, and AskUbuntu. BRIA reports the best response-prediction results in Table 1 and the highest Success and lowest Crowd-out in Table 2.

Critical strengths

S1. The setup isolates an interesting coordination lever. BRIA changes the distribution of facts without changing the agents or the number of optional facts each receives. The information controls are useful: on Citi Bike, giving every agent all optional facts lowers Success from 0.441 to 0.324.

S2. The end-to-end results are promising. BRIA improves Success over the best baseline by 0.043 on Citi Bike and 0.027 on AskUbuntu, and reports lower Crowd-out on all three datasets. Joint REINFORCE is a relevant comparison because it also learns a joint allocator from realized outcomes.

Critical weaknesses

W1. I cannot tell exactly what the reported coordination gains measure. Section 5.1 lists the source datasets but provides little detail on how each becomes an allocation environment. The options, capacity, and eligibility rules, optional facts, and task loss are needed to interpret Table 2. This is especially true for AskUbuntu, where “capacity” and “service” are not self-explanatory.

The two outcome metrics also use different denominators. On LaDe, Crowd-out falls from 0.260 to 0.225 relative to Joint REINFORCE, while Success barely changes, from 0.421 to 0.422. Please report the eligible fraction and the main failure types on a common denominator. That would show what the lower Crowd-out actually changes.

W2. The comparisons do not isolate the value or cost of the response model. The learned baselines share BRIA's allocation-training schedule, but it is unclear whether they receive an equivalent total interaction budget. BRIA also uses initial randomized rounds to train its response model. Were those rounds available to the baselines or counted in the budget? This matters for the claim that BRIA uses costly executions more efficiently.

A simple joint allocation heuristic, using the same public information and fact budget, would also show how much BRIA adds beyond basic allocation based on coverage or capacity.

W3. The reliability of the reported gaps is unclear. The tables give no across-seed uncertainty, and the number of final test rounds is not stated. This matters especially for LaDe's 0.001 Success advantage over Joint REINFORCE and the 0.004–0.025 Success drops in the Citi Bike ablations. Please report uncertainty for differences on matched test episodes across training seeds, and state the statistical unit; agents and rounds within an episode are dependent.

W4. The response-model tests miss the joint outcomes used to choose allocations. Table 1 evaluates agent-level predictions and average population shares. These metrics may miss errors in predicted collisions. Since BRIA uses the model to choose among candidate allocations, please compare predicted and realized loss or crowding on the allocations it actually selects.

The ablations also need clearer definitions. “w/o Joint Proposal” still uses the response model, while “w/o Outcome Scoring” removes the final reranking step. Clarifying what each variant retains and how it chooses an allocation would make Table 3 easier to interpret.

Questions for authors
  1. How are the three allocation environments constructed? Please specify their options, capacities, eligibility rules, facts, service criteria, task losses, and agent counts. For LaDe, how do the eligible fraction and failure types change across policies?
  2. Does BRIA's real-execution budget include the initial response-model data and model-selection rounds? Did the learned baselines receive those data or an equivalent interaction budget?
  3. How does BRIA compare with a non-learned coverage- or capacity-aware joint allocator under the same public information and fact budget?
  4. How stable are the main results and ablations across training seeds and matched test episodes? How well does the response model predict loss or crowding on the allocations BRIA selects?
  5. What is retained in “w/o Joint Proposal” and “w/o Outcome Scoring,” and how is an allocation chosen in the latter variant?
Reviewer_MYhjOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies coordination in fixed LLM-agent populations by allocating truthful optional facts rather than modifying the agents. BRIA learns a history-aware joint response model and uses it to score candidate information allocations. The implemented system samples 12 joint allocations, evaluates each with eight one-step model rollouts, executes the allocation with the lowest predicted loss, and periodically refits the response model using randomized interactions. Experiments on three dataset-derived tasks report improvements in response prediction, Success, and Crowd-out over retrieval, reinforcement-learning, and prompting baselines.

Critical strengths

The paper addresses a meaningful problem: individually useful information can create population-level congestion. The fixed-agent and fixed-fact-budget setup provides a clear comparison in principle. The evaluation includes a broad range of controls, uses chronological splits and matched exogenous sequences, and avoids contemporaneous teacher forcing in response prediction. The reported improvements are consistent in direction across all three datasets, and the gains on Citi Bike and AskUbuntu are potentially meaningful.

Critical weaknesses

The central weakness is that the experimental tasks are not adequately defined. Section 5.1 and Appendices G-H do not explain how the three datasets become resource-allocation environments, including agent roles, optional facts, capacities, eligibility, and transitions. The actual task loss being optimized is also unspecified, and test episode and agent-round counts are absent. Consequently, the main results cannot be interpreted or reproduced from the paper. This is a fundamental evaluation issue rather than a minor implementation omission.

The statistical evidence is insufficient. The implementation specifies seed 0, while the tables contain only point estimates despite stochastic decoding and Monte Carlo response prediction. On LaDe, Success improves by only 0.001 over Joint REINFORCE. Although Crowd-out decreases by 0.035, its denominator differs from Success and varies with eligibility, so the missing raw failure counts prevent a clear interpretation. The small ablation differences likewise do not establish the claimed “clear hierarchy.”

The method presentation exceeds the implemented algorithm. The objective concerns cumulative loss, but all experiments use one-step prediction. “Bilevel” denotes alternating model and policy fitting, while the information bottleneck and KL-regularized proposal are standard constructions. Moreover, the deployed best-of-N selector is not the KL-optimal distribution analyzed theoretically. The long-horizon and optimization claims therefore need narrowing or direct validation.

Finally, interaction and compute budgets are unclear. For LaDe, BRIA initializes from a response model trained on 600 randomized rounds before 300 adaptation rounds, whereas learned baselines are only stated to share the latter schedule. The 96 auxiliary rollouts per decision and repeated refitting are also excluded from the efficiency analysis. Thus, the claim of efficient allocation is not established.

Questions for authors

What are the precise task construction, optional facts, capacity and eligibility rules, task loss, and test-set sizes for each dataset? Are Tables 1-3 single-run results? What are the raw Success, Crowd-out, eligibility, and other failure counts? Did the learned baselines receive interaction data equivalent to BRIA's initial 600 randomized rounds, and how were total compute budgets compared? How does the one-step best-of-N implementation support the cumulative-loss objective, and what is the intended relationship between the deployed selector and the theoretical KL-optimal proposal?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.