- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Multi-Anchor Latent Transduction (MALT) for out-of-distribution molecular property prediction. Instead of predicting from a query molecule alone, MALT retrieves multiple training molecules in a learned latent space and uses them as anchors for prediction. Two variants are introduced: MALT-Fusion, which combines query and anchor embeddings through attention, and MALT-Delta, which further uses anchor labels and predicted property corrections. The framework is evaluated on MoleculeNet, BOOM, and Activity Cliffs, covering different types of molecular distribution shifts. The results show improvements over several inductive and transductive baselines.
Critical strengths
-
The paper addresses an important problem in molecular property prediction. Using training molecules as references for OOD prediction is an interesting direction, especially for property extrapolation and activity cliffs.
-
The evaluation covers several OOD scenarios, including structural shifts, target-value extrapolation, low-density property regions, and activity cliffs. The experiments also use different molecular encoders, which helps assess the applicability of the framework.
Critical weaknesses
-
The methodological novelty is somewhat limited. The main components of MALT are learned molecular embeddings, nearest-neighbor retrieval, multi-head attention, and anchor-conditioned prediction. MALT-Fusion in particular looks quite similar to existing retrieval-augmented prediction frameworks. MALT-Delta extends BLT by replacing descriptor differences with latent differences and aggregating multiple anchors, which is reasonable but also relatively straightforward.
-
The paper emphasizes jointly learning the encoder, retrieval geometry, and prediction head. However, retrieval itself is non-differentiable, and the memory bank is updated periodically as the encoder changes. It is not entirely clear what new learning mechanism is introduced beyond training a retrieval-conditioned predictor with a task-specific encoder.
-
The reported results are encouraging overall, particularly under Y-split label extrapolation. However, the gains are considerably less consistent under structural OOD shifts. For example, on the MoleculeNet X-splits, MALT-Fusion with Chemprop improves BACE and ESOL but performs worse on FreeSolv and Lipophilicity. The Activity Cliffs results also show a clear dependence on the underlying encoder. The improvements for GIN are relatively large, while those for UniMol are only around 1% in OOD RMSE. This raises some questions about when the proposed method actually helps. The strong results under label extrapolation are interesting, but they do not necessarily imply equally strong generalization to unseen molecular structures. I would like to see a clearer analysis of the settings where MALT is less effective.
-
A central motivation is that conventional embedding spaces may retrieve molecules that are structurally similar but not useful for property extrapolation. The proposed solution is to learn a more property-relevant retrieval space. While the retrieval ablations support the importance of anchor selection, the paper provides relatively little direct evidence about what the learned neighbors actually represent chemically. This is particularly relevant to activity cliffs, where highly similar molecules can have very different activities. Does the learned retrieval space avoid such misleading neighbors? Are the selected anchors more consistent in their properties, or do they capture meaningful molecular transformations? Some concrete examples and quantitative analysis of anchor quality would make the main motivation more convincing.
-
The two prediction heads have different operating regimes, but the choice between them is not sufficiently clear. MALT-Fusion and MALT-Delta behave differently across the experiments. In some settings, anchor labels provide useful local priors, but in others they appear to hurt performance. As the authors described, Section 4.5 reports worse aggregate OOD MAE for MALT-Delta than MALT-Fusion with UniMol (0.506 vs. 0.469). For a new dataset, it therefore seems unclear which head should be used. The authors also mention that Figure 3 uses earlier UniMol results without the matched fine-tuned initialization, while the main discussion refers to the matched setting. However, using the same experimental setup throughout seems to make the comparison easier to interpret.
-
The presentation of the proposed architecture could be improved. For a paper introducing a new retrieval-based framework, it is a bit surprising that there is no architecture figure in the main text. The only framework illustration appears in Appendix and it mainly shows a general encoder, memory bank, retrieval module, and prediction head. It does not explain the differences between MALT-Fusion and MALT-Delta very clearly, especially the latent correction and anchor-label mechanism of MALT-Delta. Since these two heads are central to the paper, a more detailed figure in the main text would help readers understand the method.
Questions for authors
See weaknesses.
3 comments
W3-6
W3 — Where gains diminish. Y-split gains are strongest; structural/cliff benefits depend more on the encoder. Fusion versus query-only reductions:
| Encoder | Y MAE | X MAE | Cliffs RMSE |
|---|---|---|---|
| GIN | 19.7% | 9.1% | 14.9% |
| Chemprop | 30.1% | 2.0% | 8.6% |
| UniMol | 14.2% | 2.3% | 0.9% |
Y/X average task-relative reductions; cliffs use target medians (Tables 2/4). Chemprop-Fusion has FreeSolv/Lipo-X exceptions; UniMol's cliff gain is small. On X-splits (Table 5), Delta lowers BACE/ESOL means versus both controls and Lipo versus set attention (.490 versus .495); TabR-style remains stronger on Lipo (.455 versus .490).
Coverage analysis: Chemprop reruns (30 targets/five seeds) group queries by maximum training ECFP4 similarity. Median RMSE reductions relative to the restored query-only checkpoint remain 3.88% [1.79,6.76] at lowest coverage, rising to 14.98% [9.99,19.05] at highest coverage (95% paired target-family/seed bootstrap CIs; Table 30). RMSE uses all benchmark test queries within each tertile, including both cliff-flagged and unflagged queries.
W4 — Anchor relevance. Chemprop: 30 targets/five seeds; query labels are used only for offline scoring (Appendix I).
Retrieved anchors have smaller activity gaps than non-retrieved training molecules matched within .025 ECFP4 similarity and the same benchmark similarity category (Table 28):
| Head | Activity-gap reduction | Target wins | Supports matched |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fusion | 18.52% | 30/30 | 69.0% |
| Delta | 10.97% | 30/30 | 72.3% |
Effects apply only to matched supports. Activity-gap and cliff-rate comparisons average five seeds per target and weight all 30 targets equally. Fusion's cliff rate among matched structurally similar pairs is 4.38 percentage points lower [1.00,7.22] (95% target-bootstrap CI). This comparison is observational.
Fusion before/after training: structural matching of initial/trained supports covers 82.8%. Mean target-wise activity gaps fall 1.42% [0.85,2.05] (24/30 target means; 95% paired target-family/seed bootstrap CI). Initial geometry is task-fine-tuned; the cliff-rate change is inconclusive.
Example (Table 29): for a Cl query in CHEMBL214_Ki, fingerprints prefer an isopropyl analogue (similarity .8254; gap 1.396) over F (.8125; .097 log units). Fusion ranks F first and isopropyl 11th. The initial encoder also ranks F first: this illustrates latent versus fingerprint ordering; the separate before/after analysis measures training's added effect.
W5 — Head selection. Fusion is the conservative default. Consider descriptor-assisted Delta (Table 18) when simulated deployment shifts formed from training data support it; this policy remains unvalidated. UniMol's .469/.506 compares complete configurations (Table 2; Appendix E.5).
W6 — Presentation. We added the two-branch architecture (Figures 1/4), gradient/bank-refresh paths, and reorganized Tables 2–3. The unmatched-initialization anchor-label plot was removed; head comparisons use Table 2/Appendix E.5, with X/Y results separate.
Summary and Appreciation
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the detailed and constructive feedback. We have revised the manuscript and conducted additional experiments to address all six concerns raised in the review. We would like to briefly summarize the main revisions.
Methodological contribution (W1–W2). We clarify MALT's distinction from BLT and retrieval-conditioned prediction: a task-adapted molecular multi-anchor transductive formulation with two complementary prediction rules. The new Figure 1 illustrates both heads and the training mechanism, including non-differentiable retrieval and implicit adaptation of the encoder-induced retrieval geometry. New matched TabR-style and set-attention controls (Table 5; Appendix G) show 14.67%/13.53% mean task-relative OOD MAE reductions for Delta under label extrapolation.
Operating regimes (W3). We explicitly analyze where gains diminish, including structural shifts and strong pretrained encoders. New Activity Cliffs experiments quantify performance across analogue-coverage levels, showing positive but smaller gains when training analogues are less similar.
Anchor relevance (W4). New similarity-controlled analyses across 30 Activity Cliffs targets demonstrate 18.52%/10.97% smaller activity gaps for Fusion/Delta on matched supports, alongside cliff-rate analysis, before/after-training comparisons, and a concrete chemical example (Appendix I).
Head selection (W5). We clarify when Fusion and Delta are preferable, recommending Fusion as the conservative default while explicitly acknowledging that the proposed validation-based selection policy remains unvalidated.
Presentation (W6). We added a detailed main-text architecture figure, reorganized Tables 2–3 for clearer comparisons, and removed the earlier inconsistent head-comparison figure.
We hope these revisions address the reviewer's main concerns and make both the methodological contribution and its empirical evidence substantially clearer. We appreciate the feedback, which helped strengthen the manuscript.
References
[1] Netanyahu et al. (2023). Learning to Extrapolate: A Transductive Approach.
[2] Segal et al. (2025). Known Unknowns: Out-of-Distribution Property Prediction in Materials and Molecules.
[3] Gorishniy et al. (2024). TabR: Tabular Deep Learning Meets Nearest Neighbors.
[4] Lee et al. (2019). Set Transformer: A Framework for Attention-based Permutation-Invariant Neural Networks.
[5] Kim et al. (2019). Attentive Neural Processes. ICLR.
W1-2
W1–W2 — Contribution and learning. Thank you for asking us to clarify the contribution. MALT extends BLT-inspired molecular extrapolation to task-adapted encoder representations and jointly trained multi-anchor prediction. The issue is a representation–inference mismatch: query-only embeddings need not encode useful query–anchor relations for extrapolation. New Figure 1 shows the shared encoder and detached bank (a), label-free Fusion (b), and Delta's anchor-label-plus-correction pathway (c), including the training and bank-refresh paths.
1) Relative to BLT [2,3]. Molecular BLT [3] selects a single anchor by matching descriptor differences to training-pair differences via an argmin. Its Discussion identifies metric learning for anchor selection and graph/3D representations as future directions. MALT develops these directions by adapting pretrained molecular encoders under a multi-anchor prediction loss. BLT already learns nonlinear bilinear factors; our additional change is to adapt the coordinates used for retrieval and displacement prediction. Fusion predicts from query/support embeddings without anchor labels. Delta predicts
\delta_a=f([z_q-\bar z_a;e_{qa}])^\top g(\bar z_a).$$ The correction couples a latent-displacement/pair-feature factor with anchor context. Full Delta includes RDKit pair features. **Loss is applied to the aggregate of corrected anchor-property estimates**, rather than adding multi-anchor averaging only at inference. Table 2 also compares with BLT adapted to GIN, Chemprop and UniMol: Fusion/Delta have lower OOD means in **20/24 and 21/24** corresponding comparisons. These are complete-configuration comparisons, not matched-budget component isolations. **2) Relative to retrieval-conditioned predictors.** We agree that retrieval-conditioned training and attention are established; **our contribution is the specific molecular extrapolation formulation**, not a new retrieval or attention primitive. TabR [1] already uses label embeddings and displacement-dependent corrections. Unlike an embedding-update readout, **Delta explicitly reconstructs a target-unit estimate from each measured anchor label and an anchor-context-dependent bilinear correction, then aggregates these estimates** (Figure 1c). This is a prediction inductive bias, not an expressivity claim. Fusion uses standard attention but provides a complementary retrieved-label-free pathway (Figure 1b); fixed-neighbor label-readout controls (Table 7) and anchor interventions (Table 20) support its reliance on informative supports. **Matched retrieval-conditioned controls (Table 5; Appendix G):** | Y-split OOD MAE | BACE | ESOL | FreeSolv | Lipo | |---|---:|---:|---:|---:| | TabR-style | .811±.061 | .490±.024 | .244±.019 | .640±.046 | | Set attention | .728±.019 | .469±.042 | .256±.062 | .679±.038 | | **MALT-Delta** | **.670±.030** | **.450±.017** | **.177±.029** | **.604±.015** | Five-seed mean±SD. All arms share an MSE-trained GIN warm start, 500 MAE epochs, optimizer/schedule, access to ten training-anchor labels and 14 pair features, and trainable parameter counts within 0.1%. All use exact Euclidean top-10 retrieval, detached training-only banks refreshed each epoch and self-exclusion. Encoders adapt separately, so retrieved identities can differ. These are adapted controls, not full original-system reproductions; the separate main benchmarks use MAE fine-tuning. One training-identical ESOL OOD query per split is excluded equally across arms. **Delta improves all four Y-split means** (mean task-relative MAE reductions **14.67%/13.53%** versus TabR-style/set attention, from unrounded means). This supports the complete prediction rule under label extrapolation, not bilinearity alone; X-split exceptions are discussed in W3. **3) Non-differentiable retrieval (Figure 1; Algorithm 1).** Each training molecule is predicted from other training supports. The property loss updates the query encoder and head, **not** hard top-k indices or stored bank embeddings. Epoch-wise bank re-encoding changes support coordinates and future neighbors. Thus, **the encoder-induced retrieval geometry adapts indirectly**, without backpropagating through retrieval or introducing a new metric loss.