- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates the problem of spatial drift induced by semantically-equivalent prompts in language-guided 3D part segmentation, and proposes GSSR, which performs graph filtering only on query-related logit residuals while preserving the query-agnostic base field. The motivation is somewhat appealing; nevertheless, the paper contains substantial flaws in several key aspects.
Critical strengths
(1)This paper achieves sota performance on the part segmentation task.
(2)This paper organizes in a good shape.
Critical weaknesses
(1)The paper claim that “observe that graph energy of paraphrase-induced logit differences adds modest held-out predictive value for soft-mask disagreement in two fusion heads.”. But, there is no evidence that this happens in the part segmentation task. Building the whole paper on the motivation that does not validate is no acceptable.
(2)The core mechanism of retaining the unfiltered base field and filtering only residuals has known precedents in graph neural networks, time-series denoising, and Transformer adaptation [1,2]. The papers’ main contribution is the observation. But the observation itself does not validate. Thus, this paper is a application rather than a research paper.
[1] Adaptive Initial Residual Connections for GNNs with Theoretical Guarantees, AAAI 2026
[2]Double-Diffusion: Balancing Speed, Accuracy, and Uncertainty inProbabilistic Forecasting for Urban Sensor Networks, Arxiv
(3)The Assumption of the paper is weird, test-independent backbone produces is separated into and . Then, the most central part of this paper comes with Eq. 6. This is ok. But, the whole part of the derivation is built on the separation. We even do not know why this separation works. Why a simple separation could produce prompt-independent base field. This is a simple assumption but rather than a real problem.
(4)The motivation centers on prompt sensitivity, yet the primary controlled target metric is standard part-segmentation mIoU, rather than prompt-robustness metrics. Prompt-robustness results only appear in the top panel of Table 3. Even in this section, the paper fails to establish a mechanistic link between residual filtering and reduced prompt sensitivity. It does not verify whether filtered components correspond to prompt-introduced noise instead of authentic boundary signals, nor does it measure whether the discrepancy field localizes at true boundaries. Consequently, the paper only demonstrates overall performance improvements but cannot explain why the gains occur, and lacks direct experimental validation supporting its core motivation.
Questions for authors
(1)This paper give the claim that even has not been validated, like “Filtering the complete logit can attenuate prompt-induced variation”, why? Does the logit really reflect the prompt-induced variation?
(2)The paper adopts normalized Dirichlet energy as a diagnostic metric without justifying why this statistic is appropriate, nor does it compare it against alternative graph-signal metrics. Meanwhile, it remains unclear whether the proposed framework is specifically tailored for part-segmentation tasks or enjoys general applicability. The idea is presented, yet its underlying rationale is not elaborated.
(3)This paper changes the symbol used in the paper through the paper. is defined as the point cloud. In the stage, it’s meaning is changed into the text promt . This leads to a very bad reading experience. And the similar happens in the whole paper, like and . The meaning of this symbols needs to be guessed. This paper, from the very beginning contains many confused symbols.
2 comments
Thank you to the authors for their reply and for the reminder regarding AC. From the authors' response, I still find the overall readability of the paper to be quite poor: logically, the motivation in the earlier sections depends on experiments presented later, which seriously undermines readability. The novelty is also incremental. Furthermore, the late reply made it difficult for the reviewer to properly reassess the overall quality of the paper. I therefore maintain my score.
Response to Reviewer zcty
Purple highlighting in the revised PDF marks the construction of the shared base (Sections 3.2–3.3) and the boundary experiment (Section 4.5).
Critical Weaknesses
W1. Evidence for the observation in 3D part segmentation. We tested the diagnostic on pointwise outputs of two trained 3D part-segmentation heads. Each seed was evaluated on 1,200 equivalent-prompt pairs from 100 held-out objects. All pairs for an object stayed in the same regression fold. Adding normalized Dirichlet energy to predictors including change magnitude and confidence increased out-of-fold R² by 0.0618 for the pooled-prompt head and 0.0579 for the token–point head (Section 3.1, Table 9). This is a modest association with soft-mask disagreement. Q2 compares alternative diagnostics.
W2. Relationship to prior residual and diffusion methods. Section 2 now discusses both suggested papers. Adaptive Initial Residual Connections preserve initial node features during graph message passing. Double-Diffusion combines a graph forecasting prior with residual refinement and uses a spectral diagnostic to guide its design. Our contribution is to test a specific placement of an established filter: after text fusion, should it act on the entire pointwise prediction or only on the update for the requested part? Equivalent-prompt pairs measure wording sensitivity, and frozen placement controls isolate the effect of retaining the shared base.
W3. Why does the decomposition produce a query-independent base? The architecture specifies two heads trained jointly for segmentation. The base head takes only point features, so its output b is identical for every prompt on a fixed object. The query head also takes text. Subtracting its output for the fixed empty reference defines the query residual (Section 3.2). The empty reference sets the residual to zero for that input and cancels when two prompts are compared. Whether the learned base contains useful boundary detail is an empirical question, tested in Section 4.5.
W4. Prompt robustness as an outcome and evidence for the mechanism. The top panel of Table 2 directly evaluates the held-out paraphrases. Across five paired training seeds, GSSR reduces soft disagreement from 3.20 to 2.25 on the 100esoft scale and the point-flip rate from 2.85% to 1.95%. Worst-prompt mIoU increases from 44.60 to 48.80 (+4.20 percentage points). Coarse mIoU is the primary endpoint for the separate segmentation evaluation.
For identical frozen fields and the same filter H, residual-only and full-logit outputs for one prompt differ by (I − H)b. This restored component has a mean boundary enrichment of 1.51. Adding it back reduces error by 2.40 percentage points near ground-truth boundaries and by 0.20 elsewhere (Appendix C.3, Table 11). This identifies useful boundary information in the shared base under the frozen comparison.
Questions for Authors
Q1. Why do logit differences measure wording sensitivity, and how can full-logit filtering attenuate it? A logit is the pointwise score before the sigmoid. We fix the object, model, and target part and change only the wording, so subtracting the two logit fields measures the change in the model’s scores under that rewording. For the full-logit output H[b + r(x)], the shared base cancels under subtraction, giving H[r(x) − r(x′)]. Residual-only filtering gives the same difference for fixed fields and H (Eqs. 9–10). The low-pass filter attenuates components that vary rapidly on the graph. Probability disagreement after the sigmoid is measured separately in Table 2.
Q2. Why use normalized Dirichlet energy, how does it compare with other metrics, and what is the scope? Normalization lets us ask how sharply a score change varies between neighboring points relative to its magnitude. Under the same object-grouped evaluation, Table 9 gives the following increments over the regression using nonspectral covariates.
Dirichlet energy has the largest point estimate in both heads, and shuffling the graph brings the increment close to zero. These results concern text-prompted 3D part segmentation with two PTv3 fusion heads.
Q3. Which symbols denote the point cloud, point attributes, and text? Section 3.1 uses X for the point cloud, pi for the coordinates of point i, and ci for its input attributes. The text prompt is x, and x+ is another wording that names the same part and shares its target mask. Section 3.2 uses aθ(F,x) for the query-head output. Appendix A.2 uses t(x) for the pooled text embedding.